Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Veneer slicing questions

Posts

Veneer slicing questions

#1

Veneer slicing questions

Barry Irby

Using a band saw to cut veneer comes up here fairly often. I personally struggle with my bandsaw to get it tuned up to the point I can cut veneer and then it seems that within minutes I need to change the blade to something I can hack on bowl blanks with. Several people here own Woodmizer type mills and many of us have access to them. I am wondering why there is not a simialar device for slicing veneer on a small scale. Preferably something that slices it the way its done one a large scale, IE. with a knife that does not waste any wood with a kerf. Wouldn't it be great to be able to slice your prized piece of wood into the maximum amount of veneer, reliably.

Why does no such machine exist for us to buy? Or why is there no such service to send our wood to? Seems like a lost opportunity?

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#2

You need to find one of these

Mark Hennebury

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPdn-JxUEUc

The machine to slice veneers is a pretty powerful machine with a very long knife and the would has been soaked prior to cutting then has to be dried. I dont know how you could get a machine capable of slicing veneers cheep enough for personal use, so you would have to find someone that had a production slicing operation that wouldnt mind do a small custom job.

The slicers are pretty small and comparatively cheap compared to other methods of making veneers, but still way out of reach of a small woodshop. Once you add in a serious high precision knife grinder, a roundabout feed system to recirculate the lumber and the feedthrough driers, they get seriously expensive

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#3

Actually...

McKay

Mikita used to make one. I do not believe that you could ever find one now. I am sure that it was 30 years ago. I am sure keeping the blades able to cut cleanly was difficult. The blade was on a skew and about 12 " long.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#4

That was a supersurfacer

mark hennebury

Makita, Hitachi, Ryobi, Marunak, Shinx etc.. all made and still make supersurfacers.


Supersurfacers will not make veneers only very thin shavings around a couple of thou thick. Supersurfacers are designed for finishing solid wood.

Veneer slicer like the one in the video made by Marunaka are for veneers some can make thick veneers up to an incredible 13mm thick!


"A world patented machine whose available slicing thickness is up to 13mm.(though varies according to the type of wood to be sliced)Employment of a heat-proof roller table reduces slicing resistance,which promises an excellent finish of veneers to be sliced. Finished products can be fit for wide range of application such as flooring,furniture and etc.Proud of remarkably high yield rate in comparison with that of sawing."

a variety of machines cut lumber from 135mm (approx 5 1/2" wide) up to 500mm wide ( approx 20" wide )

I have lots of info on supersurfacers on my website if you are interested in finding out more about them; http://www.solidwoodmachinery.com/supersurfacers.htm

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#5

William Falberg

Re: Veneer slicing questions

William Falberg

I just recently applied for a Utility Patent titled Veneer Resaw that incorporates the tabletop and unique fencing into a integrated system with enough accuracy to cut wooden potato chips.If I can find a manufacturer to license it it could be on the market next year at a reasonablre price. I'm set up to make them myself but I don't have the money to invest in speculative ventures right now. My cost would be in the neighborhood of $7500. I'll try to post a link to the video of my prototype if I can get YouTube to host it. It's apparently an invalid format for WC.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#7

Does anyone have a Bandsaw.....

Barry Irby

They leave set up for cutting veneer? It seems to me I need two bandsaws. One for resawing and veneer and one for everything else. Or, is the problem that I have a Delta 14" saw and its not really suitable for resawing or cutting veneer?

Can you guys that have larger heavier duty machines switch back and forth with ease? I find the bandsaw to be frustrating. Blade life can be measured in minutes and feet while on my TS blades last months and thousand of feet. I admit I am leery of trying a carbide tips bandsaw blade because I assume I would ruin it in short order. Can't afford to play with a $100 bandsaw blade. OTOH, my $120 TS blade turned out to be an excellent investment and improvement to the saw.

I wish there were a local shop I could take my prized board to and have them turn it into the max amount of veneer at anything near a reasonable price.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#8

Two saws? yes.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


When I bought my used Delta 20" I thought I would be selling my 14" saw. I quickly came to the conclusion that I would keep the 14" saw set up with a 1/4" blade and use the big saw with a 1" blade for resawing. The cheap blade shown (about $12 for this saw) leaves a cut almost smooth enough to use for the glue side of veneer. My friends carbide blade leaves a cut that requires no refinement before applying the glue.

A 20" Delta can be bought for $500 to $1000 depending on condition and your luck.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#9

What is involved in veneer manufacturer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Step 1 The logs are cooked in a tank of hot water for many hours for a specific time and temperature for the specific species. This process softens the wood to enable it to be sliced.

Step 2 The log, or part of a log,is securely fastened to a rigid mounting. If veneer 1/40" is being sliced then the log and knife must be held to something much less than 1/40" tolerances. Stop and think about that requirement for a log weighing a ton or more and a knife 12' long.

Step 3 The log is passed by the knife or visa versa to yield a slice of veneer. The log or knife is advanced exactly 1/40" to repeat the process.

Step 4 The veneer slice is sucked flat against a porous belt that passes the veneer through an oven to dry it and fix its now flat shape.

Don't try this at home!

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#10

Re: Does anyone have a Bandsaw.....

David Yoho

Barry, like Bill, I have two saws. When I bought my MM16, I thought I'd get rid of my 14" Delta, but after looking at having to change the 1-inch carbide Lenox blade back and forth so much on the MM, I decided to keep the Delta.

I thought the cost of the Lenox Trimaster was crazy but after using it I found it to be a real game changer in the finished result.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#11

Re: What is involved in veneer manufacturer

Larry in NW Ohio

Barry If you want a Carbide Bandsaw blade, there is a company out in Idaho that has blades that "Impregnate carbide" on the teeth of the blade some how. I have one and I think it does as good if not better than the Woodslicer. I have an old Craftsman bandsaw that around 30+ years old and I can slice 5 1/2" Walnut or Oak on it with no problem. I will not get blades any place else. Another guy, Del, that posts here really likes them also, and one time I think he also said that he thought that they were just about the same price as any place else. I do not have any affiliation with them at all, just a satisfied customer. You can go to www.supercutbandsaw.com Good luck Larry

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#12

Re: What is involved in veneer manufacturer

jcousins

i too ended up with 2 bandsaws. found that the mm16 was way too much trouble to change out the blades for other smaller jobs and then re-setting it for resawing - so it now stays set up with a 1" laguna resaw king and have an older 14" delta bs for everything else. this setup works well in my shop.

jerry

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#13

horizontal resaw

Tom

You can get an hr from Grizzly tools. That is what guitar makers use to cut up the 1/8 in wood they use and they are reliable.

The are probably some great machines out there since the veneer biz collapsed in the NW, after th spotted owl thing.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#14

Re: Veneer slicing questions

Keith Newton

William, you really ought to bump the motor HP up, along with the blade speed, to make that saw faster. That would sure make it more appealing I think.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#15

William Falberg

Re: Veneer slicing questions

William Falberg

There's no sense adding horsepower when the frame won't support a wide-enough blade to USE more HP. Most saws today are grossly disproportionate in that sense. The frame problem was solved and dealt with in my lastest patent application. It's an asymmetrical I-beam configuration and significantly heavier than the welded cross-braced tubing of our standard Titan but more efficient for hign tension blades . It took a while to figure out how and that prototype showed me exactly where to add the "beef" and then it took a while longer to figure out HOW to add it. That was 6 years ago. It may be another year to built the second prototype. Who knows what I'll learn from that. Meanwhile, I'm confident the new patent pending frame design will support 1" blades.

THEN , when I'm really leaning on it, I'll see if the motor will bog down. If it does, I'll consider going to 1-1/2 Hp or two HP. I know now already that the frictionless tensioning doesn't demand as much power to push 1/2" blades. I just don't believe in throwing brute force at a tool if it's not necessary . I want something that you can throw in the back of a P/U truck and drag around the shop but still rip 18" deep hardwood like a raped ape. I'm more into Formula One racing bandsaws that actually cut clean and straight consistently at a price we can all afford. That takes time and experimentation. The effects of frictionless tensioning are astounding. Wait 'til you see what happens when that innovation hits the market. It's another game -changer; like the lever-action tensioners and the balanced portable BS. I still can't believe we're using the same designs they started with in the 19th century. Somebody's been asleep at the wheel in BS manufactureland. For an entire century. Talk about astounding !!

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#16

I have one in the basement

Dick Coers

and it is not for slicing veneer. It makes shavings, not veneer.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#17

Radical Design question

Barry Irby

William, If the saw you are designing is primarily for resawing or totally for slicing veneer why have a cantilevered of "C" shaped frame at all? You could mount 14" wheels on a vertical beam and till have a 5 or 6" throat. Depending on the mounting technique, may more. Is anyone really going to want to resaw something larger than a 12 by 12?

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#18

Two bandsaws......

Barry Irby

I realized years ago that the answer for me would be to have two bandsaws. One with about a twelve inch resaw capacity with a couple of horses and an excellent blade, left tuned up for veneer and the other with about a 3/8 bowl blank type blade. Buying a good used saw could probably solve this problem for $1000 and certainly under $3000, even for a new one. I just can justify it. Don't have the spare cash, the shop is crammed full and too small, running out of electric circuits and not enough demand.

Oh, but we can daydream. Every tool I have added has been a joy. I had a jointer for 30 years before I got a lunch box planer. Amazing not to have to drive over to a friends shop to dress stuff. Bandsaw added another dimension. And who knew a Performax would be so useful? I have reached the point that I have to open the garage doors to rip anything over five feet long. Several years ago I decided to add on and double the size of my shop, but I let several friends talk me out of it. Wish I had better friends.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#19

Re: Does anyone have a Bandsaw.....

William Duffield

I also have two bandsaws. ONe is a 10" with a Carter stabilizer, for cutting curves. The other is a 18" Steel City, with 12" of resaw depth. I use two different blades in it: one for cutting bowl blanks and the other for resawing thin stock and veneer. This arrangement works for the types of work I do most often, but wouldn't be optimum for everyone. Maybe I need a third bandsaw? :) But there wouldn't be room for it in my shop.

My "enlightenment" came a few years ago when I went to Penn's Landing to take a course in lofting. They were building a large wooden sail boat at the time. Their shop had four or five bandsaws, including a ship's saw. They had carried one of the smaller ones on board and set it up on deck. I'm almost sure they had it set up on some sort of platform inside the hull well before the decks were installed. It saved them a lot of time, since they didn't have to climb up and down the gangplanks every time they needed to cut something.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#20

William Falberg

Re: Radical Design question

William Falberg

"Is anyone really going to want to resaw something larger than a 12 by 12?"

Certainly. Wood comes from trees . The majority of trees are much larger than 12"x12". Another answer would be: timberframers do it every day. I'm talking about turning logs into timber and timber into veneer using the same basic saw principle: a continuous band of steel with teeth traveling around two or more wheels ..................etc. in patent language. When I use the term bandsaw that's what I'm refering to; not Delta, Minimax, Jet, or Ryobi. Research the old books on bandsaws; you'll find that bandsaws from the 19th century look pretty much the same as they do today. My interpretation of the term includes a saw that can cut ANYTHING including metal (if you add some water and slow it down) The beauty of it that you can change the blades to accomodate your workpiece. And yes, my Resaw will be set up to cut aluminum, too. Once you go to all the expense of building a blade transport system you might as well give it some space to maneuver, a means to guide your cuts, and enough power to not bog down -it's only a couple dollars more.The big tool companies know all this but they'd rather sell you a bunch of specialized saws; there's more profit in that. I don't recall ever saying the Veneer Resaw was a dedicated one-trick pony.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#21

You seem to have read something into my suggestion

Keith Newton

I didn't say anything about changing the band size up to 1".

I don't even know what size motor you have on your saw, but lets just say it is one HP, with a 2" drive pulley. Now, without changing anything else except the motor and pulley, lets make it a two HP, with a 4" pulley. The blade speed should be double, but the force on each tooth would be the same., while you get to double your feed rate.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#22

William Falberg

Re: You seem to have read something into my sugges

William Falberg

Faster blade speeds always tend to over-heat my blades and dull them in a matter of minutes. I immediately thought of wider blades in my response to get fewer teeth per inch and put more feed pressure on the teeth with more gullet capacity to remove sawdust. It might work with carbide-tipped blades, though. I don't know. I never ran a carbide blade at 80 MPH. My blades usually, (as in the video shown) run at 40-45 MPH with 3/4-1HP motors. The few experiments I ran with high-speed pulley ratios ended in smoke and ruins so I stopped experimenting. I should have thoght more about the blade's role and gone on to try carbide blades. It's expensive to blow them up just for the sake of science; considering I ain't making any money out of it. That's a good project for you; double your blade speed and rip a few Doug Fir timbers. Tell us how it all worked out.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#23

Re: Does anyone have a Bandsaw.....

Rob Sandow

Yes. When I bought the Laguna 16" saw 15 years ago, I thought it would be the last band saw I ever needed. Then I realized that switching it over from resaw/veneer mode to scrolling mode and back again was really a time suck. But I also didn't want to take up floor space with a 2nd band saw. So I bought a 12" Delta benchtop model that sits on a shelf until needed, and the Laguna has a Lenox TriMaster in it full time.

Re: Veneer slicing questions

#24

I have 3, but like to buy my veneers..

Keith Newton

A 1/4" blade lives on my 18" Lobo, for tight curves, or whatever.

A 1/2" 2 or 3 tpi lives on the 36" Defiance. It is considered a high-speed, so can fly through most standard shop cutting, up to 16" thick. But then if I wanted to cut veneers from logs or lumber, the Woodmizer LT15 is more suitable for that. I made a melamine sub-bed to fit on it, which incorporated a power-feeder, for sawing dry lumber, which worked fine, but I haven't used it in so long, I probably couldn't find it now.

If I were sawing veneers from a log, that is easy to just be careful as I change the depth each pass. This isn't done much though, since drying something that thin, is going to have the same handling time stacking and sticking as for 1" lumber. Although I keep thinking that I need to rig a heavy-duty clothesline across the parking lot, to just hang some thin bending plys from. They would probably be dry in one or two days of hot Summer weather, and could then be stacked dead after that. If they are going to be bent around a form, any cupping,bow, crook or twist would be taken out by bending around a form in the stack.

I stopped by an old homeplace yesterday to check on some trees that I heard the owner wanted taken down. There were two walnut trees, and one pretty nice cherry free for the taking. Also, a big white oak out front that I would like some pieces of, but I'd hate to cut down only to find it was hollow. Of course if it isn't, there could be several hundred feet of QS WO lumber, not to mention some highly figured turning blanks.

There is another one out back in front of the old barn, that is just gorgeous. I could probably have it too, but I wouldn't' be able to sleep nights after that if I took it down in good health. Now, if it blew down in a storm, I'd be all over it.