Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

Posts

Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#1

Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

Derek Arita

I'm finally running down to my last Phillips head screws and I'm looking to switch heads. I originally wanted to go with square drives, but on a recent trip to HD, the hardware guy recommended Star drives as the next big thing...so I went for it and purchased a few boxes. Now I'm thinking I made a mistake and should have stuck with the Squares. What do you think?

By the way, the reason I'm switching is because I'm tired of having to constantly replace phillips bits in my drivers. I've had limited experience with Square drives, but have been impressed with the positive hold of bit to head.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#2

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I use only Torx-headed screws, not that I have anything against the square-drive ones. I stopped using drywall screws for anything other than drywall many years ago.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#3

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

Barry Irby

I developed a sincere dislike of the deck screws at Home Depot because they were so dull that it took a lot of pressure to get them started. They would sit on the surface and spin and then the drill would flip out and the bit stab me in the finger. Been stabbed too many times to like the screws. It may be from that that I don't like the star drive screws. I found them to be very touchy about the fit of the bit and if the coating on the screws tended to clog the holes the bits fit even more poorly.

I like the square drive screws better, but my experience is mostly with the ones for the Kreg system. You can load the screw onto the bit and then tip the bit into any position, even straight down and with a little care, they don't fall off.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#4

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

Larry in NW Ohio

I`m changing to the torx also, Sometimes I have trouble with the square head stripping out, especially when you have to kind of put the screw in when you can`t see to well to keep the drill straight with the screw. I have yet to strip a torx. Larry

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#5

Torx (star)

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

They're about as industrial looking as you can get, so I wouldn't use them in an exposed location on fine furniture, but they're what I use for utility screws. Better hold than square, and the bits last longer.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#6

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

John McGaw

I basically use whatever I have on hand that suits the application -- anything from machined brass and bronze straight-slot screws to coated star-drive deck screws. I find that having a well-fitted tip is as important as the style -- it is one of those Goldilocks situations where the fit needs to be 'just right' if it is going to work. Star-drive seems to give me more problems than square drive when it comes down to having the screw stay on the driver but I put that down as much to me using high-quality square driver bits from McFeely's or Kreg and cheap throw-away bits that always seem to be included with boxes of star-drive screws as to the style. I really hate regular Phillips head screws drywall screws when used (for drywall only!) with a dimpler bit -- they just never seem to work properly no matter what I do.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#7

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

waroland

Someone here where I am volunteering,Lake Yale Baptist Conference Center, had a box of what I call a combo head, phillips and square. I have used these in the past with a square bit and they work okay, but he had a bit that was a combo like the screw and it worked great. I have not looked for this bit yet, but I will the next time I need screws.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#8

Robertson

Bill Howatt

Unfortunately, the fine Cdn Robertson screw head gets some bad press because of inferior screws, typically cheap Chinese ones. Also, the Robertson head looks square but it is actually tapered towards the bottom and really means that you should use the proper screwdriver/head combination for best results.

Anyway, I use them even if the screws are non-tapered square drive. Phillips sometimes but I never buy a slotted wood-screw and if I get some from any source I immediately throw them into the garbage.

Years ago a friend went to NY state to do some contract work. Some American's on the site were looking at his tools and making fun of his square Robertson screwdriver. So he said, "Can you do this?". He put a screw on the driver, held it horizontally, walked several feet to an exposed 2x4 and drove it in with no trouble. End of the joking.

Bill

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#9

It the driver not the screw

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

They all work well with an impact driver. It is the secret to successful screw driving with any head configuration.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#10

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I like the square drive screws and usually get them from McFeelys. I've used Torx and like them too, but prefer the square drive.

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#11

Paul Kramer

A little historical data

Paul Kramer

Derek,

I like others try to avoid Phillips screws but I will use them with a magnetic bit and an impact driver. Keep in mind that the Phillips head was designed for FORD so that relatively unskilled workers could drive the screws without over tightening or breaking while assembling autos. The idea was that the driver would cam out of the screw prior to one of these undesirable outcomes. Robertson was designed to not cam out. I must add that in my experience poorly made screws and drivers make them unpleasant in use. So, I am a big booster of McFeely's (I have no financial interest). I have used a smattering of Torx and I too think they are too industrial looking. When screws are meant to show I like simple slotted screws.

Paul

Re: Screwed With Screws...Which Do You Use?

#12

Re: A little historical data

TomD

Lee Valley sells the Robertson bits, the actual original bits, and for stuff around the shop they are perfectly good. That way you at least have the half the equation right. If you want to burn deck screws in, maybe something disposable would be better All the different styles have pros and cons. The permutations are endless, so I am not looking to add any new choices.