Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Resawing blade choice question

Posts

Resawing blade choice question

#1

Resawing blade choice question

DLCinSTL

Recently this forum had a link to a video of a “Bandsaw Clinic” by Alex Snodgrass, a Carter rep. So far, I have tried his approach to set-up and I am impressed. Within that video he responded to an inaudible question from a spectator with, “thicker wood, half-inch, three teeth per inch”, which I surmise to be his recommendation for a resaw blade. In the past I have used a half-inch, three teeth per inch “Wood Slicer” resaw blade from Highland Woodworking. It performed well, but is now dull, so I am considering replacing it with another Wood Slicer blade.

However, back in 2004, a gentleman named Bob Dodge referred to a book by the late Jim Cummins titled, "Power Saws, and Planers". In it, he said, “Basically the article identifies the fact that smaller band saws can't properly tension a wider blade to the 25,000 psi tension the blade manufacturers recommend. He (Jim) therefore recommends using a 1/4", .025 thick, bi-metal blade, with 6 tooth hook profile, for everything, including re-sawing, as that size CAN be properly tensioned. The results were part of a year-long study by two engineers at Lenox blades, on how band saw blades cut.”

Jim asserted that regular blades anneal at 400 degrees. They get soft, and dull very quickly. The saw operator then tends to apply more pressure to complete the cut. This generates more heat and friction, compounding the dulling of the blade. That in turn, causes blade distortion and drift. Bi-metal, on the other hand, anneals at 1200 degrees, and stays sharp much longer, reducing heat distortion, and eliminating drift.

Why 6 tooth? He said that Jim stated that the 4 tooth blade cut so aggressively, as to tend to overfeed. He chose the 6 tooth blade for the better finish of the cut, as well as speed.

My question is: Is there anyone out there that uses such a method for resawing larger stock, i.e., six inches thick or more, and gets the same or better results than with a half-inch, three teeth per inch resaw blade?

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#2

blade wandering

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

you get blade wandering when the gullets fill up with sawdust and clearance is lost. The information provided at the Lenox saw seminar is at odds with this narrow 6 tpi blade claim.

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#3

The single most confusing variable....

Dick Coers

is the speed that you move the wood through the blade. Done properly, with any blade, and you will not see any sawdust in the kerf when you are done sawing. As Bill said, it's because you let the gullets pull out the dust without over filling them. Lots of talk about guides, super blades, carbide tipped blades, blade tension, the list goes on and on. But the one thing you can't tell someone on the internet is correct feed speed. I took three slices from a 7/8" thick piece of curly soft maple, 12" wide, without any top guides at all. My bandsaw could not saw that wide, so I took off the top guides and really cut slowly. Blade was a 1/2" wide, but I can't remember the manufacturer. I made that room screen, 25 years ago. I'm not a fan of the Wood Slicer, seems to dull too quickly for me. I use a local guy who buys reels of stock and makes them.

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#4

Re: Resawing blade choice question

Larry in NW Ohio

DCL If you would be interested, I started to get my bandsaw blades from a place called SuperCutBandsaw at www.supercutbandsaw.com. I really like them even better than the Wood Slicer, and that is the only place I get them anymore. They have alot of their blades carbide coated on the teeth, and of course they last much longer and the prices are almost the same price or less expensive. I think there are a couple people on this site that have tried them and liked them. I`m in no way in with them, just like the blades. Larry

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#5

Re: Resawing blade choice question

John in NM

I think that book was a collection of FWW articles, I suspect that the info you're referring to was in one of those articles.

I'm wondering though, if you have gotten good results out of a 1/2" blade, then why would you need to follow this advice using a 1/4" blade? Good results from a 1/2" blade would indicate to me that you are having no trouble getting it tight enough.

I have had that aggressive feed problem now and then, but usually with a dull blade that is being pushed too hard. I've usually attributed it to the blade oscillating and thus cutting a much bigger kerf (and much rougher). Seems counter intuitive that a bigger kerf would cut faster - until you consider that the limiting factor is chip clearing - that wider kerf gives all the dust somewhere to go.

Getting such small saw blades to 25,000 psi shouldn't be that much trouble - it only requires a few hundred pounds from the tensioning mechanism of the saw (assuming I've done the math correctly of course :D )

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#6

Re: Resawing blade choice question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I understand the theory and all that stuff, but I get really good results from a Lenox Trimaster, carbide tipped 1/2" 3 tpi blade. It's fairly stiff but I get adequate tension from my 14" Delta with stock springs (I've been thinking about putting on some stiffer ones, though). It's not a super smooth cut, though and is going to require some clean-up. If you're concerned about price, the Trimaster is fairly costly, but it can be resharpened. I have it because of one heckuva good deal.

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#7

Thanks for your input

DLCinSTL

I appreciate your responses. All of you gentlemen are confirming what I have always understood. That is why I was inquiring as to if anyone actually used the 1/4” bi-metal blade method.

I rarely ever need a resaw blade. It’s just handy to have one when needed.

I can't complain about the Wood Slicer blade, as it is approx. 10-years old. I think what “did it in” was when I ripped some old, used, eight-foot pressure treated landscape timbers. I cut off the rounded sides to make them square. It was when I saw sparks flying that I suspected I just might need a new blade.

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#8

Re: Resawing blade choice question

del schisler

i use blades from this company SUPPER SAW CUT here is the link, their is no price's listed so you have to call the co. for price, i use their blades and they will stay sharp, i have used the blades from highland but they dull very quick, the blades from supper saw cut co will last a long time, Bill also use them i use 1/2" and 4 tpi , i have used lenox blades i didn't like them, i know lot's of people use their blades , i had blades brake, i know they will weld them for free, but i have not had blades from the supper saw cut com. fail . oh well here is the link

http://www.supercutbandsaw.com/

Re: Resawing blade choice question

#9

Re: Resawing blade supper saw cut company

del schisler

i posted the same for the supper saw cut co. i have very good luck also