Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

explosion proof fan

Posts

explosion proof fan

#1

explosion proof fan

gfriend

Looking for new or used explosion proof fan for small paint booth. Where would I look?

Re: explosion proof fan

#2

Re: explosion proof fan

Joe Burke

I bought mine from an auto body supplier. It's been long enough ago that I no longer get their catalogs and I don't even remember the name. I'll have to recommend a search for auto body suppliers. Explosion proof fans are standard fare for those folks.

Re: explosion proof fan

#3

Re: explosion proof fan

Dick Coers

I'm in the camp that any fan will work. I've never seen a fan spark during startup or running. So unless your insurance man is the one calling for it, get a fan that is belt drive and the motor is not in the air stream. Keep the switch at least 4' from the booth. An explosion proof fan would really take an entire system. Explosion proof "conduit", junction boxes, and switches. I designed explosion proof electrical systems for turbine gas compressors in the day. An explosion proof system is really designed to contain an explosion inside the system (like if a spark from the switch lit off the gas in the switch box) and keep it from carrying into the atmosphere around the system. So it's heavy wall everything, and machined aluminum junction boxes. All that spells EXPENSIVE!

Re: explosion proof fan

#4

Re: explosion proof fan

John McGaw

Go to ebay and look for 'paint booth exhaust'. Prices are higher than I, personally, could tolerate but they do exist there.

Re: explosion proof fan

#5

Re: explosion proof fan

Larry in NW Ohio

You might also try a surplus store. I use to buy a few things from one, but right know do not know the name, if I come across I`ll post it. Larry

Re: explosion proof fan

#6

Re: explosion proof fan

Barry Irby

I agree with the "Any fan will do Version", but if you really want or need one you might look for an industrial tool salvage reseller. There is one locally (Richmond, VA) that sells most anything they reclaim out of sold off plants. No telling what they have.

Re: explosion proof fan

#7

PS, if you buy a used one...

Barry Irby

make sure it has a single phase motor.

Re: explosion proof fan

#8

Re: explosion proof fan

Paul Woolson

When I needed one I started pricing them which very quickly turned my thoughts to "what else will work?"

I was able to salvage a squirrel cage furnace fan and mounted it in my exhaust. Then I mounted the motor for it a good 5' away and use those twist link belts to make an extra long one. Once I got it set up I built an encasement around the motor where the only openings were two small slots for the belt. It is POSSIBLE for fumes to get in there? Yeah, probably. But it's 5' away from where I am spraying, pretty much entirely enclosed, and the air is violently being pulled out of the duct work. I'm pretty confident that nothing will happen.

Re: explosion proof fan

#9

Re: explosion proof fan

frank

Grainger

Re: explosion proof fan

#10

Any fan school

john Veerkamp

To explode the vapors need to reach a critical volume. If you turn your fan on a few seconds before starting spraying I can't believe that there would be sufficient concentration. There are lots and lots of home made spray booths with various types of ordinary fans that have been operating for years with no problems.

Re: explosion proof fan

#11

On The Cheap

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A plastic-bladed 20" box fan ($19 at Wally's World, etm) will do quite nicely since the motor is brushless so the only source of sparking in the airstream is the switch. You can move the switch outside of the enclosure with a bit of rewiring if you like, but unless you operate the switch, that shouldn't spark anyway. Put a 24" cheapo spun-glass furnace filter over the intake to catch most of the finish solids in the vapor while allowing the solvents to pass through. I've used this set-up for years in the take-down booth I built. Start your fan and get the air moving before you start applying finish so the vapor concentration never gets very high. For best results, put a couple of filters over air intakes on the opposite side of the booth to keep dust out of your finish film.

Just a note, if you're applying waterborne finishes, this whole thing is unneeded except to control over-spray.

Re: explosion proof fan

#12

Re: On The Cheap

Larry in NW Ohio

One thing about explosion proof fan or most anything elsenthat is explosion proof is the motor. The motor needs to be TEFC, in words it means totally enclosed fan cooled. Larry

Re: explosion proof fan

#13

The risk factor

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is a fact that many finishers use an ordinary fan for exhausting their spray booth. The underlying principal is that the concentration of the solvent that will incapacitate you from toxic effects is far greater than the lower explosive limit of the solvent. The nose will be relied upon to avoid too high a concentration in the spray area, that is, if it does not smell too bad it will be ok.

I do not question the observed fact that home made spray booths don't explode often, or maybe ever, under "ordinary" conditions. Personally I fear volatile solvents used in confined spaces. Unexpected events such as a spill can lead to localized concentrations that reach the explosive limit, about 1% for many of the solvents used in spray finishes. These vapors are dense and they will "flow". They may flow to an ignition source. For me the risk is too great to rely on a home made design.

Re: explosion proof fan

#14

Correct OSHA Answer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

For an industrial location absolutely true, with the unit totally made from non-ferrous alloys. They run about the price of a reasonably good table saw, and are guaranteed for use in explosive atmospheres. Total overkill for a home shop finishing booth where the most that will be dealt with is some lacquer thinner, alcohol, or mineral spirits that, with a little airflow (let alone the 1000 CFM that a 19" box fan will move) won't ever reach the concentrations needed to ignite.

Now, if "gfriend" is opening a commercial, shop he/she had best make plans on spending real money on this finishing room, and it'll take way more than a fancy bronze fan to meet the building and fire codes.

Re: explosion proof fan

#15

Re: explosion proof fan

Howard Acheson

Just so you know the options, if you mount your fan blowing into the paint booth you do not need an explosion proof face. The fan will blow the fresh air over the motor therefor the explosive gases are not blown over the spark producing motor components.

Re: explosion proof fan

#16

Some data

GolfSteve in Calgary

I use the fan from a 1.5 hp general international dust collector (scavenged from a model 10-105) as ventilation for my "spray booth". The fan is rated for 1100 cfm, but I assume it delivers less than that. It has a TEFC motor and the motor is out of the air stream.

All of the values below are from memory! When I built the spray booth I did some calculations:

I spray with a SATA miniJet IV. This is a small touchup gun. Spraying lacquer thinner with the largest nozzle I recall that I could spray max. 100 mL/min. At one point I did some lower explosive limit (LEL) calculations and determined it would be impossible to reach 100% of LEL by mixing 100 mL/min of solvent with approx. 800 cfm of air. But if the air is not ventilated outside the shop, then solvent can accumulate! And if you don't get perfect mixing, you can reach LEL in localized areas.

On that basis I proceeded.

During my last spray job I brought home an LEL meter to do some tests. If I sprayed lacquer thinner at maximum rate directly into the exhaust fan inlet, the air exiting the fan read 5% of LEL. For some reason 20% sticks into my mind, so perhaps I was able to get a reading as high as 20% in some circumstance. 20% is pretty high and if I consistently got 20% then I would not use this set-up.

I put the meter just upwind of the job and did some spraying. The meter read 0%. When I sprayed I clipped the meter onto me and onto the wings of the booth. At all times it read zero unless I put the meter directly into the fan exhaust. I exhaust the air outside, so solvent does not accumulate in the shop. I also only spray very small jobs, so I only spray for about 1 minute, then I usually open and close the garage door to get a good ventilation cycle, and then have to wait an hour before the next coat.

Remember, I'm using a small touchup gun. If you have a larger gun you will spray more solvent and reach a higher % of LEL. If you reach 100%, then you have an explosive atmosphere that can be ignited.

I'm also using a fan with relatively low air flow. The direct axial fans often have much larger air flows than the type of fan I'm using. Clogged filters (like seen in the picture below) also drastically reduce airflow. I punched a hole in the filter because I didn't have a replacement filter that day.

Anyway, I recommend using an explosion proof fan even though I don't. Someday when I build a better spray both I will spend the approx. $500 for a proper fan and motor. The above test showed that what I was doing was not hazardous on that particular day, but some type of incident such as clogged filters, or an unusually large solvent flow, or changing to a larger gun, or spraying an unusually large job, etc., without thinking about the consequences could result in a different answer.

A guy blew himself up in my hometown a couple of years ago. He was spraying a car in his garage. Because a car is a large job, I assume he was spraying for a while with inadequate ventilation and improper equipment. He's dead.