Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

A trip to the lumber yard

Posts

A trip to the lumber yard

#1

A trip to the lumber yard

Yonak

The following is a re-enactment :

I called my sales representative this morning inquiring about a pickup truckload of 8/4 maple, rough sawn, no extras. He said they didn't have any unsurfaced but he'd give me the surfaced to 1- 13/16" at the same price as the rough sawn : $4.34 net. I wanted to make sure the price was net so he fiddled with his calculator and told me the total would be $1519 for 350 bf. That satisfied me.

Later in the day I showed up at the lumber dealer. The boards hadn't been set out for me ; I had to get it out of the retail area, so I took the opportunity to choose 30 boards with such dimensions that it would produce the best yield for my purposes. I loaded 341 bf into my truck.

The guy took The Trickulator, you know, that stick with the numbers written on it that he hooks on the side of the board, gets a pained expression on his face, then adds the figures in his head, to tally the load. At the end he proudly announced, "three eighty-six."

"Three eighty-six," I said. "How did you figure that ?" If I were a neophyte, a weekend warrior, and didn't know how to figure board feet I would have just gone straight to the cashier and been rooked.

The manager came over and re-tallyed. He came up with a figure about half way in between us.

"Look," I said, "it's so easy. All the boards are the same length. There are six levels." I measured all the way across each level and wrote down the numbers in inches, making sure to round up to the next whole number, added all six numbers, divided by 12 to get feet, multiplied by 2 (8/4), multiplied by 10' long and, voila : 341 bf.

The manager looked disgusted, scribbled out the 386 on the tally sheet, wrote 341 and handed it back to me. I took it to the cashier. She fiddled with her calculator and said, "$1920.24"

"Huh ?"

She said, "341 bf plus 18% is 402, times $4.34. plus 12¢ for surfacing, plus 7% tax. $1920.24. How will you be paying ?"

"First of all, if you look at my account, I'm tax exempt. Also, what's the 18% ?

"Shrinkage." she said.

"I was quoted net on the phone. He also said there would be no surfacing charge."

She called over the manager, who called the guy I spoke with. After slamming down the phone, the manager said, "I'm gonna lose money on this."

I said, "Why don't you just always quote the out-the-door price on the phone and you wouldn't have this problem ?"

"That's not the way it's done," he said.

I know that's not the way it's done. Doing it this way he can tell the unaware buyer a cheaper amount than what he intends to charge. Then, when the buyer has loaded the lumber, he can spring the real charge on him. Most buyers will just pay rather than unloading their truck. Doesn't he know the buyer will just trust him less next time ?

Now, I realize the cashier may not have known what the salesperson and I discussed on the phone, even though the order was clipped to the tally sheet in front of her but, if I hadn't been paying attention, I could have paid $655 more than I should have.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#2

An error in your method

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. You only round up if the value is over 0.5. If less you round down. (NHLA rule)

2. Measuring a stack of lumber by measuring the width of layers always overestimates the amount. Those cracks between boards add up across a 42 or 48 " wide layer. As a rule of thumb I would figure a stack measured this way overestimate the amount 10-15%, if it was piled tight.

So, you may have only gotten less than 341 bdft in fact. You can be certain that at 4.35/bdft the yard was not loosing money on the sale.

Measuring a small quantity of 8/4 lumber with a lumber stick is a problem. Rounding errors will cancel out on 1000 bdft. They could be significant (but not more than +/- a few bdft) either way, on 300 bdft. Two people measuring 300 bdft of lumber with a stick should differ no more than 2 or 3 bdft. if they were applying the stick properly.

Conclusion: this business does not know how to measure lumber or they are crooks.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#3

Re: An error in your method

John McGaw

"Conclusion: this business does not know how to measure lumber or they are crooks. "

Couldn't they be both?

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#4

Re: An error in your method

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Yes, they could be both, and Bill's statment does not rule that out. If he said "Either they are crooks or they don't know how to measure lumber," then that might more strongly imply an exclusive choice.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#5

no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

good crooks would know how to manipulate a measurement to their advantage. To do so would involved some knowledge of measuring lumber.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#6

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

Larry in NW Ohio

There is a lesson to be learned here. When you call to get a price on something to buy, especially if there is something special about it, always, always get the name of the person you talked to, and write it down, and ask him if he is going to be around when you come to pick it up, and when you go to pick it up make sure you talk to him if at all possible. If this is done then there will be less chance of a misunderstanding. Larry

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#7

Re: no

John McGaw

That doesn't rule out their being incompetent crooks.

I recently finished up a large room project with the installation of carpet. A nice hard-wearing commercial carpet would do and HD had one that would have suited perfectly so I paid them (that should have been the first warning sign) to come out and measure up. Somehow their numbers didn't smell right so I did my own careful measurement allowing for stock widths and seaming allowances and waste and came up with a number around 5 yards less than HD claimed. I tried to contact them and get an explanation but all I ever got was people who claimed that their estimator couldn't make that sort of mistake. I then had two local suppliers do the same measurements and their numbers came out virtually identical to mine. From that I gleaned that HD's guy was incompetent or thievery was involved and they weren't competent to cover the discrepancy. Or possibly both.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#8

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

Dick Coers

Here is a good explanation from Gene Wengert, famous for his technical knowledge on professional woodworking sites.

From Gene Wengert, forum technical advisor:

First, the practice of adding for shrinkage is illegal in all 50 states. Contact your Weights and Measure Commission (or similar outfit that measures the accuracy of fuel pumps, etc.).

Basically, you must sell the footage you have. (It would be like buying gasoline and having to pay for spillage and evaporation, so one gallon would be actually less.) "Adding back" went to district court and was declared illegal, as well as being against the written law. Further, the NHLA is against such practice. Further, the wood shrinks about 6%, but some people will add 8%. The legitimate people will give you both numbers; this is so you can compare the legitimate folks with the others.

From the NHLA book "On July 21, 1977...” sales of hardwood lumber measured after kiln drying shall be quoted, invoiced, and delivered on the basis of net board footage, with no addition of footage for kiln drying shrinkage'." I would be very surprised is a large company like GP is adding anything, let alone 15%. Their legal department would be on top of such a practice and prevent it.

One additional thought, the term kiln dried has no specific meaning when used for hardwoods. Always specify the moisture content that you want. Note that the lack of moisture content specification in the rules means that moisture content is not a reason to return or reject lumber based on the NHLA Sales Code.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#9

Thank you

Yonak

Wow ! Thank you very much, Dick. This is very useful information.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#10

"One additional thought...

Tom

the term kiln dried has no specific meaning when used for hardwoods." Of course he is referring to shrinkage rates. But seems otherwise true. No surprise there. At least air drying is a consistent process.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#11

Re: "One additional thought...

Dick Coers

What Gene is saying about the term kiln dried, is that the words do not mean a specific measurement. Kiln dried to 6%-8% gets you kiln dried lumber to those numbers. Without the number attached, it just means it went through a kiln. Air dying without a number means just as little. It just means it sat outside and dried some. Air dried to 15% means something.

My favorite selling pitch lately. Eggs that are labeled, from cage free, grain fed chickens. It doesn't mean that the chickens aren't stacked like cord wood in a giant building, it just means there aren't bars on the windows like a cage. The grain fed is not natural either. Chickens seem really happy to scratch around and eat bugs with the seeds.

Re: A trip to the lumber yard

#12

Re: "One additional thought...

paul in AZ

My favorite or pet peeve lately is "natural" as applied to foods.

The word has no legal or rational meaning but customers seem to think that it is synonymous with organic. Not the least bit true.

Pure marketing BS.