Re: Insulation is a myth... Any thermal engineers
Tom
I did the insulate, drywall, and cleats approach, and it is nice. It adds to resale, because people are always saying how nice it looks, and imagining getting all my tools out, and their pool tables in.
It is cold though. Mostly because I underheat it. But pals who have OSB or ply walls and spray paint them white, still have nice looking places, and the walls are stronger, and the heating required is less.
Of course insulation isn't a myth, but if you have thermal breaks, that pull cold in, and then you have a cold material attached to them. So say you had metal studs and metal walls, the isulation is only so much use. OK, only an issue if you are in a cold place.
I have a variety of windows, some of which are thermally efficient, others of which are not. The best of them are good enough not to put plastic over. But I do the rest with plastic film. I notice that whatever the effect of the argon, etc... The glass is always cold to the touch, due to thermal mass, and conduction. The plastic sheet is always "warm" to the touch. So I am spending more time considering, not just insulation but also the basic friendliness of materials.
All that said. I remember when Norm and crew did that huge mansion in the Boston area some years back, and the guy wanted a posh, millionaire's workshop... To my surprise they did the walls in OSB and spray painted, that was their couldn't be beat millionaire's place. So on the practicality of wall materials, they considered the OSB a win. One reason being the routine tears drywall takes. If as with my place you have the full level 5 finish, or better, a lot of the little pouches a place takes from lumber are not that super easy to fix. I would prefer to find something other than OSB, which offgasses a little too much for me.