Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Advice sought...

Posts

Advice sought...

#1

Advice sought...

Stuart Hough

This should be the year I "finish" the gara...er...shop. I have looked at two approaches to the job. One is to insulate, drywall and paint the walls. I would be using French cleats run the length of each wall to hang cabinets and tool stations, giving me the flexibility to move them as needed when/if I reconfigure the layout. The other is to use panels, such as T1-11, after insulating, to cover the studs and allow me to place cabinets and such anywhere I please, regardless of studs. The drywall approach means a lot of work with taping and joint compound, then priming and painting, but less cost, while the panels mean less work and time, but significantly more cost. Which would you choose, or do you suggest a different approach? Thanks in advance for the responses.

Re: Advice sought...

#2

Re: Advice sought...

Dick Coers

I'm an OSB guy with exposed screws. It lets me pull a panel if I want to run more wire and other options. Taped and mud on drywall would just be "too fancy" for me!

Re: Advice sought...

#3

Re: Advice sought...

Jim Toews

Be sure to check local building codes! Unless your shop is free-standing, you may have to use sheetrock on all walls shared with your house as a fire barrier. In my area all walls within 8 feet of the house have to be sheetrocked as well. I am in the process of getting bids to add a garage and convert the existing garage (plus an 8 foot extension!) into a climate controlled shop and had requested 3/4" plywood walls; the contractor told me about the above code issues, as well as others. I'll have to go with sheetrock and a French cleat system. Be that as it may, be sure to check your local codes!!

Re: Advice sought...

#4

Re: Advice sought...

Stuart Hough

Jim, I have a detached garage, at least 20 feet between the nearest corners of the garage and house. I asked some local guys who do contracting, and they said I would only be required to do sheetrock if I was running a production shop for hire, but I know that rules change quickly, along with interpretations. Thanks for the reply!

Re: Advice sought...

#5

The best of both worlds...

RobCarr

... 5/8" drywall over 1/2" plywood - gives you the impact resistance of plywood, the ability to hang anything anywhere without blocking and the neat appearance of finished plaster walls. Another advantage is when putting up the drywall sheets you don't have to worry about ending the drywall joints on a half stud since you have plywood backing.

Re: Advice sought...

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Advice sought...

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have pine boards running horizontally floor to ceiling in my shop. I love being able to attach anything anywhere I want. I have the advantage of living in a white pine forest though and boards are cheap and plentiful. In your instance I would go with the wood. Sheetrock is for looks,it is otherwise useless. Also you will always have to be careful not to bump into it. If you will be mostly working on small things,don't intend on hanging stuff from your walls and you want brighter walls,go with the sheetrock otherwise,wood.---Jack

Re: Advice sought...

#7

Re: Advice sought...

Jerry Gibbs

I wanted good light reflection. I used drywall, but didn't bother with taping, since I am a lousy at taping. I then painted with white semi-gloss. I can unscrew a drywall panel if needed. I learned this when I covered an electrical box and couldn't figure out my continuity problem. Jerry

Re: Advice sought...

#8

Useless???

David Yoho

Sheetrock is for looks,it is otherwise useless.

Doesn't it provide some level of fireproofing, which would be important in a workshop?

Re: Advice sought...

#9

Re: Advice sought...

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

My shop is a barn away from the house. I used beadboard for the walls over the insulation. I guess it is a plywood of some kind. The cheap stuff from the big box stores is definitely plywood. The nice stuff from the lumber supply place--not sure what it is. I DO know it is hard as a rock and I HAVE to use screws. It laughs at nails. To cover the ceiling insulation I used sheets of luan. It was cheaper and much lighter to ask my friends to help lift up and install.

Re: Advice sought...

#10

Re: Advice sought...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I used cheap sheets of luan for my walls. It was inexpensive and easy, and actually looks good.

As for insulation, I used blown-in celulose. Glad I did, I use the furnace much less and in summer last year I turned on the AC only twice.

T.

Re: Advice sought...

#11

Re: Advice sought...

Barry Irby

Good thoughts here. Check your local code, but I think its only required to install drywall if it is attached to the house. It might be interesting to search out what would be required if it were a shop and not a garage.

I agree with the insulation. Really improves the comfort and cuts the noise transmission to the house.

I can tape drywall with the best of them, but the pro's would be finished and fishing before I got the first coat on. If I were dry-walling, I would put half inch OSB under it and tape and paint the drywall. I would also map out the studs and keep the plan for future reference.

As far as fire goes, the paper face on drywall will burn and provide enough heat and smoke to kill you if you are present. Ordinary drywall collapses after the paper is gone. Fire rated rock has fiberglass reinforcing the core and it stays in place better longer.

Re: Advice sought...

#12

Re: Advice sought...

Tony - Memphis

My shop is drywalled/insulated/etc. I guess it is pretty subjective. I haven't ahd any issues hanging anything. I really like the nice finished look of drywall. I've never cared much for pywood or chipboard walls. Insulation was a must for me. I've even added some outlets and such and that wasn't a big deal either. Had to do one patch to run a circuit - no biggie. I guess the other thing is how you use your shop - I'm not a hanger. I don't like the look of things hanging all over the place. Anyway, I did the sheetrock thing and don't regret it after 16 years.

Oh, let me also qualify my statements and point out that I did not install the sheetrock. Wouldn't made a difference though. Other than it wouldn't look as good, well, maybe.

Tony

Re: Advice sought...

#13

Re: Advice sought...

David Hay

My current shop has drywall. My previous shop had plywood/beadply for the walls. I definitely liked the convenience of being able to hang anything anywhere. With my current shop, I have to think a bit more carefully about where I want to put things.

I am looking at installing some kind of french cleat system, spaced about every foot vertically to allow me to hang stuff just about anywhere I want and even rearrange things, should I find a better way to organize things.

David

Re: Advice sought...

#14

Jack Guzman from Maine

I stand corrected


Re: Advice sought...

#15

I prefer drywall...

John in NM

But then I'm a pretty good taper...

When we were finishing the inside of my shop, I needed about another sheet and a half to finish out a closet. Being 2 hours from anywhere that sells drywall, and having some surplus OSB on hand, I used it instead, and not liking the look of it, every time I had some surplus mud I applied it to the OSB to smooth out the awful chipboard look.

Sanded smooth and painted, I'm surprised how good it looks :D

Re: Advice sought...

#16

Re: Advice sought...

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Stuart,

If it was my shop I would hang drywall and just do a quick coat of mud/tape and roll on some white latex. I did my shop in this manner.I did each wall as it's own project.I had already ran my wiring and such before I began the wall finish project.

Drywall is cheap,I hung my sheets vertical so I only had one seam running floor to ceiling,no horizontal or butt joints to deal with.

T1-11 is nice but to get to a thickness that could support potentially heavy cabinets it would be cost prohibitive and I'd still want to be sure and hit studs with my screws anyhow.

Re: Advice sought...

#17

Re: I really like drywall

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

When I built my shop, I elected to use drywall for several reasons. First it is economical, second it is far more fire resistant than wood paneling of any type, and third it is very easy to repair perfectly when (not if) you ram a long board or damage it some other way. I was very adamant about installing enough outlets in the shop, I installed one on every other stud (16" on center studs) and tossed in a few extra here and there, also installed about 10 ~ 220V outlets in areas for dust collector, compressor, and other spots easy to reach with extensions. All my equipment sans Powermatic lathe is on mobile bases so made up #10 extensions for all the 220V equipment (most of my equipment is wired for 220V). I painted the ceiling white, and the walls a "Smoke Grey", which is a light grey with a bluish tinge. Works well for lighting. I have hung cabinets around almost all the shop, using french cleats.

I built my shop about 8 ~ 9 years ago and would do it the same way today!

Re: Advice sought...

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Drywall "upgrades"...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

If you really want to go all-out with drywall, there are a couple more things you can do:

1. Hang OSB or plywood on the studs, then hang 1/4" drywall and finish it.

2. Get high-density drywall. It's much heavier and less prone to damage (I suspect it would also cut noise transmission).

3. As someone else said, use fire-rated drywall (not sure if the high-density drywall is rated or not, but I suspect it is).

4. Don't fasten the drywall near the corners (within 12-18" or so). Use clips to attach the pieces on each side of the corner, but let the corner float--this will reduce cracking due to movement of the framing. (A large Chicago builder took this approach years ago and reduced the average cost of callbacks from $1500/house to $150/house as a result.)

Jason

Re: Advice sought...

#19

Thanks to all!

Stuart Hough

I appreciate all your responses. Looks like the best way to go is fire-rated sheet-rock over 1/2" ply or OSB. Will be about half the cost of T1-11 in the end, and be as "flexible" and look nice, too! All the advice reminds me why I'm proud to be a part of this great community!

Re: Advice sought...

#20

Re: Insulation is a myth...  Any thermal engineers

Tom

I did the insulate, drywall, and cleats approach, and it is nice. It adds to resale, because people are always saying how nice it looks, and imagining getting all my tools out, and their pool tables in.

It is cold though. Mostly because I underheat it. But pals who have OSB or ply walls and spray paint them white, still have nice looking places, and the walls are stronger, and the heating required is less.

Of course insulation isn't a myth, but if you have thermal breaks, that pull cold in, and then you have a cold material attached to them. So say you had metal studs and metal walls, the isulation is only so much use. OK, only an issue if you are in a cold place.

I have a variety of windows, some of which are thermally efficient, others of which are not. The best of them are good enough not to put plastic over. But I do the rest with plastic film. I notice that whatever the effect of the argon, etc... The glass is always cold to the touch, due to thermal mass, and conduction. The plastic sheet is always "warm" to the touch. So I am spending more time considering, not just insulation but also the basic friendliness of materials.

All that said. I remember when Norm and crew did that huge mansion in the Boston area some years back, and the guy wanted a posh, millionaire's workshop... To my surprise they did the walls in OSB and spray painted, that was their couldn't be beat millionaire's place. So on the practicality of wall materials, they considered the OSB a win. One reason being the routine tears drywall takes. If as with my place you have the full level 5 finish, or better, a lot of the little pouches a place takes from lumber are not that super easy to fix. I would prefer to find something other than OSB, which offgasses a little too much for me.

Re: Advice sought...

#21

Re: Insulation is a myth...  Any thermal engineers

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I would have to disagree about insulation, my shop is 30' X 30' with 10' ceiling downstairs and a room upstairs with kneewalls 30' X 10' wide X 8'+ high. I built my shop using 2X6 walls on 16" centers. The entire shop is heavily insulated. I have a high efficiency furnace (sealed combustion chamber with plastic intake and exhaust piping from/to outside air) installed in the upstairs room with a central air unit. Here in central Indiana, the winters are fairly rough, my heating costs to maintain the shop at about 65 deg. all the time except when in use - (then 70 ~75 deg) is, best I can estimate about $50 ~ 75 month and air conditioning less than $40/month. I maintain the heat and air to prevent condensation on my tools and I also store some materials that shouldn't freeze. I designed the shop myself, so pre- purchased good quality, somewhat odd sized thermopane windows and insulated doors at a "surplus" outlet at quite low cost and designed the shop around them.

Re: Advice sought...

#22

Re: Insulation is a myth...  Any thermal engineers

Tom

I did say it actually wasn't a myth, the point I was getting at is that the other materials are just as important, thermal breaks can break the insulation plan, and in the context of this discussion I think drywall is a less ideal thermal break wise than wood, but that could be wrong. There are ways to separate the inner walls for better sound and heat, but bad materials are just bad. The climate in my shop has really got terrible since I bought the metal working tools, they just suck heat out, which is ok when the summer comes, but not good for the time I am in there.

Your shop sounds great. I was all for super insulating my shop, but I kept being told it didn't make a difference. I have super insulated my bedroom, and it didn't seem to make a difference. What the engineers say is that 1.5 inches of continuous foam insulation on a wall is all it takes, you are getting almost all you can get at that point. But with thermal breaks and leaks, you won't get there. This comes around to another issue related to wall material which is that having done drywall, and trim, I now don't feel like upgrading anything, it is so much work to redo all that, that I feel stuck with what I have. If I hadn't put all that work in, I would probably go in there, and take my walls to 6 inches by putting in 2 inches of foam. So for a technical space it might make more sense to make like a machine so one can get under the hood.

Re: Advice sought...

#23

Re: Insulation is a myth...  Any thermal engineers

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Well, you may be right about drywall and thermal break. What I did when building was to encapsulate my walls as follows: I installed 1/2" OSB on the outside of my studs, then used house wrap - then Vinyl siding, the house wrap allows moisture to escape. I then installed 6" roll insulation between the studs, then covered the entire walls with fairly heavy plastic, taping all joints to insure a continuous seal. then installed the 5/8 reinforced drywall. When I installed the thermopane windows, I sealed the plastic to the windows, insuring no air leaks. I purchased custom trusses for the roof, built so that the center of the trusses provided a 10" wide open room the length of the 30' X 30' shop. After installing the trusses, I nailed a 3/4 ~ 1" square (cutoffs from a local lumber distributor) against the roof sheeting against each side of each truss, then tacked in 3/4" foam. This allowed air movement from my ventilated eave to the roof peak, where "cobra vent" was installed. I covered the upstairs walls with OSB, then blew in cellulose insulation, filling the entire cavity solid. The upstairs room ceiling was then insulated with 6" insulation and covered with 2" blue Styrofoam, followed with 3/16 plywood. I did install my heating / cooling trunk and piping in the upstairs floor prior to insulating to insure they are also well insulated to prevent condensation and heat loss. After about 8 years or so, don't know of anything I would change.

Re: Advice sought...

#24

They're the same... *LINK*

John in NM

The values for drywall and plywood (assumed to be similar to OSB) are very close - 0.17 vs 0.13 W/(m*K)

I think you mean to say thermal bridge - a thermal break is any insulating material. A thermal bridge is something like steel studs in a wall, or the glass in your window.


Thermal conductivities of materials

Re: Advice sought...

#25

Is thermal conductivity the reason...

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

a tile floor feels colder than a wood floor? I have always wondered.