Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Fire retardant, chemistry question?

Posts

Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#1

Fire retardant, chemistry question?

Keith Newton

Some of you seem to have a lot of chemistry in your background, so help me with this, if there is a good solution.

I find a lot of rich Pine scattered around down in the woods near my cabin. I have a restaurant project coming up where I could use some which I might sculpt into fish, gators, or frogs, but without some sort of retardant, I might as well use oil soaked rags, this stuff is so flammable.

I would imagine that heating them to cook off the most volatiles would help, but not by much. Is there some solution that I might immerse it in, then pull and release a vacuum several times, that would work, or is there just too much resin in this material.

By itself, it can really have a nice look, being somewhat translucent. But I'd hate to set myself up with some liability suit down the road.

Looking like I might get to take apart, and reassemble a whole tree again, so I'm looking forward to that. OF course I'm not going to use rich pine for that.

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#2

Pine?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Do you mean "Pitch" rather than "rich" Pine?

Are your carvings small enough that you could boil them? That might work to release at least some of the pitch resin which you could, actually, save for fire starter.

Never heard of pine auto-igniting, even fatwood doesn't do that. Were it otherwise we'd have constant problems with dead trees exploding or some such.

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#3

Re: Pine?

John in NM

Rich pine is fatwood. AFAIK, it's not so much a species or variety as heartwood from the lower trunk/stump of long leaf pine that grows in warmer climates. I was once working in the mountains of Chihuahua, MX. Down there they called it Ocote. Probably a different species than what grows in the US, but same cause of pitch accumulation.

Never heard of it self igniting, but I wouldn't trust it around a lit cigarette :D Stuff burns like it's soaked in diesel fuel.

Back to the OP.... I don't think it would work well with stabilizing resin if that's what you're thinking. Too much pitch in the wood. You could just as well use some white pine and stabilize that as try to pull enough of the pitch out of the fatwood to make it work with the resin process. Some of the stabilizers might have tried it before though, you could call one and ask (I've used K&G Finishing a couple times for maple burl, they seem to know their stuff).

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#4

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

Bob Lang

There are fire retardant chemicals used to treat wood in commercial applications, or at least there were 25-30 years ago when I came across it. We had to send stuff out where it was essentially pressure-treated with a fire retardant. Don't know the details beyond it wasn't cheap and it took 6 weeks. There might be something that could be applied topically, but that would limit your finish options. I would consult with who ever enforces the local code, they could tell you what, if anything is required in your neighborhood.

Bob Lang

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#5

Is this really a concern

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Can you ignite a carved fish easier than a styrofoam cup? Many plastics split out stuff as flammable as xylene when heated and a restaurant would have lots of this stuff. Hold a match under a piece of urethane upholstery foam and see how it ignites compared to a carved fish. Indeed the burning booth cushion could ignite the carved fish, but that would be a minor contribution to the conflagration.

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#6

Well, Yea, I may be wigging for no good reason..

Keith Newton

I have had several burls sitting around the shop for too long now that I have had thoughts of turning thin, thinking how they might look under a bright spot, but then balked at the thought of someone getting it to use as a candle lantern, or something stupid like that.

This stuff is flammable enough that one match laid on top of a solid surface will likely spread like on spilled kerosene or diesel. Otherwise, I like the way it looks, and the thought of carving some swamp critter emerging from a weathered gnarly hunk of wood, would work into this space nicely, and I would enjoy doing it. I just wish I didn't have this anxiety about it.

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#7

Re: Well, Yea, I may be wigging for no good reason

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Sodium silcate can be used to treat wood to be fire risistant. Its been a while since I read about it so I don't remember the details of the process or it's effectiveness.

Robin

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#8

Thanks Robin

Keith Newton

That looks like it has good possibilities, and worth a try, if I can find a source for a small amount.

I'll bet that is what was used on some 3ply veneer that i got second-hand from a Jet interior fabrication plant here. On high humidity days it would draw a lot of moisture from the air, and get totally saturated with moisture.

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#9

If you want to make it hygroscopic.....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

If you want to make it hygroscopic and absorb alot of moisture, I'd be inclined to treat it with a solution of calcium chloride. It's commonly used on gravel roads to keep the dust down. The Calcium chloride solution is sprayed on and it sucks the moisture out of the air and binds the dust to the aggregate, almost making it hard like concrete.

If you can't find generic calcium chloride, look for Ball Pickle Crisp in the canning aisles. It's food grade calcium chloride.

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#10

Re: Thanks Robin

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I bought some abut 10 years ago to play around with post cure treatment on some concrete countertops. I bought a 1 gallon container from a local ceramics supply shop for a very reasonable price.

Robin

Re: Fire retardant, chemistry question?

#11

some misconceptions here

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are numerous ways to make something fire retardant. For example in a carpet the backing is loaded with mineral material to soak up heat from ignition. Nylon or wool can be chosen as a fiber because they char and do not readily make volatile fuel. Acrylic is a difficult choice because it readily makes volatile fuel like the pine.

What works in a particular situation depends on where the flammability problem is attacked. As I understand the case at hand the problem is that a modest amount of heat generates a volatile fuel. In such a case making the wood (cellulose) less flammable will have no practical effect. The only way to affect this case is to mess with the flame chemistry that is burning the volatile fuel. I don't vision any practical treatment that will make the pine less prone to making fuel. There are phosphorus and bromine compounds that mess with the flame but it will take an expert in this area to recommend the chemical, likely available in 55 gallon drums or tank cars, and how to apply it.

Bottom line, this will be a difficult problem to solve, if it indeed is a practical problem. Encourage the local bowl turners to display their pine bowls and vases and if the place burns down blame the turners.