Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Question on large wood slabs

Posts

Question on large wood slabs

#1

Question on large wood slabs

Barry Irby

Keith Newton posted a link to a WoodWeb video of a mill a guy had made to slab large logs. (Its in Weekend accomplishments.) Shows a chainsaw mill on a swing arm sawing large logs into three inch thick slabs.

I have a couple of oak slabs I had sawn about a year ago and I have my eye on a huge maple tree that I might have slabbed if its solid. I was wondering why three inches thick? Is this to allow for the eventual flattening of the slab? The video mentioned some of the slabs weighed 800 pounds. I assume they will dry and weigh much less, but its still a huge heavy piece of wood. Three inches seems too thick to me for the end product, but too thin to resaw and a waste of birds eye maple. My slabs are about 2 1/2" thick and I am hoping to end up with 1 3/4.

Any experience out there with slabs?

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#2

define "slab"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

At the mill a slab was the waste piece resulting from the first cut off a log(and subsequent cuts with bark on one side). It does not seem this piece of wood is what someone is cutting for some useful purpose.?.

Even in the best case the wood is only going to loose about 40% of its green weight.

800 pounds is about 160 bd ft of green lumber. At 3" thick that would be about 50 surface square feet. That is one ginormous slab. I saw a Bubinga plank that big once.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#3

Re: Question on large wood slabs

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Have to agree with Bill, depends on your definition of "slab". I have found several uses for thick lumber in shorter lengths (3 ~ 4 foot), and dependent on what you want as far as finished length, you should not have the thickness loss you describe from rough sawn to finished.

I have some Walnut (air dried) that is about 4" thick X 12 / 18" wide X 3'+ long that I have had for a few years. My intent is to make benches from those. I have also used some "thick" material for table legs etc. I did have some thick oak lumber I purchased from a local mill, it was kiln dried, but the dryer did a poor job and I found several splits in the interior of the material, rendering it unusable for my purposes. I should have returned the lumber but I had stored it for a few months before trying to use it and the value was only about $50 ~ $75 so I just took my losses.

If you don't intend to utilize any of the material you are cutting in finished thick sections there is no advantage (and a lot of detriments in handling, drying and storing) thick sections. I certainly would not think of trying to store and dry 4" or thicker sections in my shop at full length unless I had a specific purpose for that thickness. My equipment would handle it, but I sure couldn't do anything with it alone!

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#4

Re: Question on large wood slabs

Yonak

Issues of handling, re-sawing and drying aside, a chain saw just takes out so much material, sawing into 1" boards would waste a lot of that birds eye maple.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#5

kerf waste

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The head saw in a typical circle saw mill has a 1/4" kerf; band mill 3/16".

Accuracy is another matter. While well sawed lumber from a band mill can often be cleaned up with a 1/16" planer pass I would think it grand if the chain saw cut didn't wander more than 1/2" on a 12' cut.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#6

Barry should have provided a link, *LINK*

Keith Newton

These slabs are not the kind of material traditional makers have a need for. George Nakashima, blazed a wide path for using this type of material, as well as a bunch of West coasters who had access to huge redwood stumps washing out of the mountains.

The first post under the photos has a link to a video of it running.


http://www.woodweb.com/cgi-bin/forums/sawdry.pl?read=754042

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#7

Re: Question on large wood slabs

David Yoho

I watched the video of that guy with the chainsaw mill. Quite impressive but I wondered if he had a stop on it when it reached the point in the arc when the blade exited the wood. Looked like it could swing into him where he was standing.

I'm sure there are woodworkers out there that would require slabs the size he was cutting from time to time. However, they would be near impossible to handle in a one man shop unless they were shortened. He says to ship any of his stuff using UPS he has to cut long stock in half to meet their size restrictions. A piece 3" thick by 8 to 10 inches wide by 3 to 5 ft. long would still be heavy as heck.

There are certain parts for furniture building that are better cut from thick stock. I just don't think the average person will have a need for something that thick. For those interested in cutting their own veneer, I would expect they would have the appropriate setup to handle and cut stuff of that weight and size.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#8

I saw "thick" stock

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sometimes I have sawed a log into 10/4 planks. Indeed they are heavy. They are then resawed on my shop band saw and book matched for case sides. It makes for an attractive gain match where the side of a piece is expected to show.


Re: Question on large wood slabs

#9

Thick

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've been doing some stuff that needs heavy (4") leg stock that can't be done "layered." I shopped around for 4x4 walnut and quickly found that nobody cuts or carries it except at organ transplant prices.

So I clue my arborist buds, snag six 11-14"x 9' walnut take-downs, and run the stuff over to my Woodmizer guy across the river.

Two days later I go back and pick up my trailer with several hundred lineal feet of pretty 4x4 walnut stock. Cost? $100 plus some gas. Sealed, stacked and stickered in my shop, I've now go a stash of prime walnut stock that has reached EMT. Nothing not to like.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#10

Re: I saw "thick" stock

Barry Irby

I was thinking Nakashima-ish type uses. Did not make myself clear about what a slab was in this context. Did not want to post the link because Keith had posted it first and felt like I was poaching it.

I agree with Bill about resawing and book matching, but I could not figure out what a typical amateur wood worker would do with a huge live edge plank three inches thick. A three foot by eight foot piece might make a wonderful table top, but why would you start with a piece three inches thick?

I would like to have a bigger better bandsaw to allow for easier resawing. (sniff)

Bill is right about the sawing. I have pieces done on an excellent band mill and can clean up the faces with about a 1/16" pass on both sides. The same people did some chain-mill work for me and I think its going to take about a half inch to clean some of it up.

And I agree with David about that saw In Keith's post. I would not want to stand where he was. I was looking for a door behind him and hoping he had a safety cut off or dead man's switch. Better yet, he should move the controls outside the arc of the saw.

My question is that if you wanted to make some Nakashima style slabs, how thick would you make them? How thick were his?

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#11

Re: Question on large wood slabs

Keith Newton

Yea David, viewing that video does induce a bit of anxiety, but it was a slowmo, so not as bad as it looked. In the background, you can see another sawmill, with log and lumber handling equipment. Just because he has the wherewithal to build it, doesn't mean that there will be a market for slabbed "catheads".

But then again, who ever would have thought there would be a market for 3" square fur dice, yet there is probably some guy somewhere driving a big caddy around smoking a big cigar worth multi millions from that marketing idea. ha

I think the most expensive board I ever bought cost ~ $3000, but it was figured Bubinga. Twould be funny if he was able to sell those slabs over in Congo for what we pay for exotics here.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#12

EMT?

Keith Newton

So Mark, you have to call a Paramedic when you use it? ha

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#13

It's about proportion and design of the piece

Dick Coers

A natural edge slab that is 3' wide and 10' long, would look out of scale to be 1 1/2" thick. At 2 1/2"+ thick, the scale is good and it looks proportional. At 3"+, you can flatten both sides after drying. At less than 3" thick, you can likely only flatten one side and maintain the thickness. Attached is my friend James, completing a bubinga slab table. It was right at 2" thick with the top flattened. He only cleaned up the bottom where the legs met it. To me it was a little thin, but it was purchased and you work with what you have!


Re: Question on large wood slabs

#14

That mill has a variable speed power feed

Dick Coers

He has another video on his Facebook page that shows many details of the construction of the mill. He drives it from an electronic variable speed and chain drive. He was never in danger unless he walked over to it and walked into the chain.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#15

couple of things I would have done different

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I never had much luck drying 4 x 4's and keeping them straight. I cut planks to the thickness I want and cut the square stock out after it dries. That way I only have to worry about movement in one direction.

I would not have attempted to get 4x4's from an 11" log. One side will be at or near the center of the log where the wood is not stable and the other will be near or into the sap wood. However, if it worked for you I can't argue against success. Just a caution to others that you may not be lucky. Walnut wood from near the center of a log almost always shatters when it dries. The sap wood usually shrinks more, generating bows and crooks in lumber with sap on one side.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#16

Exactly!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

They may be nice and dry, but a 9' section of 4x4 walnut will make you a candidate for surgical intervention in a heartbeat.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#17

To Be Honest

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I had a couple that "moved a bit" but for my use it will make no difference because a) I can cut lengths that minimize the drying defect, b) I like to include some sap wood and other "defects", and c) by the time I finish the funky stuff is in the dust collector anyway.

Here, the legs are milled from 4x4 to 3-3/4 tapered to 2" to make the Tori gate leg set


For a 2" thick walnut slab top


Re: Question on large wood slabs

#18

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Here is one of my 4x4 stacks drying in the shop


My meter reads to a depth of 1" so I remain conservative about the EMC issue. A nice sound knot actually provides a good clue as to core moisture since knot provides a route for core water to wick to the outside. When the reading in the knot remains stable, it's pretty safe to proceed on the basis of full dry. Stuff in the pic has been "dry" for more than 12 months, I do, however, leave the stack stickered until used.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#19

Re: The real story

Tom in Toronto

Barry, The main advantages to slabs are that they involve less cutting. When I did my beech a few years ago, I did a mostly 2-2.5 inch, and one 4 inch for a bench top, it was only 7 feet long, and about 16" wide though. The longer I am at this, I find the following:

- I rarely loose any wood, so long as I handle the pith properly, etc...

- I never need it before I dry it. I mean I often need it the day of the cut, that is why I want a load of beech, or cherry, but by the time a few months slide by it is long forgotten. SO time to dry is largely a non-issue. The beech was weird, it dried in less than a year, in the 4 inch slab. The majority of the water was out by then.

- Even now that I am in my fifties, and with my helpers all being at best 100 pounds, I don't have any trouble moving the boards, which are rarely more that 7 feet long. Really big pieces would be another mater, but just like moving machinery. In the woods one can normally skid slabs on rollers, or sawdust, or a trail of other smaller boards.

- I never worry about how much my mill takes, so it is a 1/16 more than a bandmill that cost 5-10 times as much, and isn't portable. My trees are all free or firewood prices, and they normally come from: Trees that the arbourist would get, and are destined for the chipper; trees that are blow downs; cleaning out a sugar bush; or being managed for firewood.

- I am getting dead straight cuts with my mill, and I can process pretty much any shape, at any angle to that shape. Try that with some of the other machines. I also take a pretty much unlimited width. I only use my 36" bar, gets me maybe 28 inches, but I could cut 8' with minor changes. Try that with a portable bandsaw.

I would normally cut less than 3, but 2 or 2.5 work for me, it depends on the scale of the work. I mostly flat saw, so wider boards give me gargantuan pieces, less cutting, better yield; material to quarter for stiles; the already mentioned fat legs. Less stickering.

As I say, most of this work is prospective, I don't really know what it will exactly be used for. I have never regretted the big piece. So for instance when I did the beech. I was sorta thinking "hollows and rounds; big bench planes; bench parts. But not long afterwards they cleared a place on "Old Orchard road". By the time I got there all that was left was some short pieces of maple. I cut them at 4-5 inches, partly anticipating neighbours would protest, which they did (moreso the guys who had been there all day, but I was nearest the road). The pieces are sorta oddball, so I am thinking perfect legs for the bench. So the beech I cut for that is now freed up, If I had cut it specifically right away, I would be in a lock. And all that could change again with the next tree to fall

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#20

Your Mill?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Alaska? Other?

Chain? Granberg?

Pic(s)?

8)

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#21

Logs to Lumber-slabs *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

Brian milled some logs for me a few years ago. He's quite an efficient sawyer. My goal was to have as much of the oak quarter sawn. He milled the wood close to quarter sawn without the waste or time involved in true quarter sawn. I've been happy with how the wood turned out.

Here's some of his slabs:


Logs to Lumber

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#22

$20/bdft for elm!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Who buys this stuff? For those kind of prices any mill in my area would be delighted to saw lumber like that..... and probably deliver it.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#23

Re: Question on large wood slabs

Logs To Lumber

Hey guys. This is Brian from Logs To Lumber with the chainsaw slabber.

I can try to answer a couple of your questions I read here.

I built the slabber because I was tired of pushing a 084 breathing the exhaust and being right on top of the bar as it cut.

The saw cuts smoother than my woodmizer. Her4e are pics of the 54" maple I just cut.

https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.553157801437396.1073741865.329602620459583&type=1

Anything wider than say 30" I cut at 3" thick. Sometimes wide slabs cup so you have to remove about 1/2" so you end up with 2 1/2" which looks right. Anything thinner and you end up with to thin a wide slab.

These are cut as live edge slabs. I sell the 3" thick slabs all the time and ship all of the US so there is a market.

If you watch the real time video you can see it cuts very slow. I designed the saw to take up to a 40 HP electric motor but only run a 7 1/2 now. The chain speed is only 2000 FPM. 404 pitch chain usually runs 6-8000 FPM. The bar gets warm at most which I like, also when things go wrong, a lot of HP makes it worse.

This video linc below shows the chain drive up close. Its a DC drive. I use Woodlandpro 404 43rp full comp chain. I use the full chain for the first few sharpenings and them cut off every other two teeth with a hand held 4" grinder. I can remove the 16' loop and sharpen it on my Silva sharpener, remount and start cutting in 30 minutes. The bar is 8' long and custom built by Pacific Trail in Oregon. I can mill a 60" - 9 foot log, or a 48" 12 foot log. The bigger the log, the shorter because its cutting on an arc. When not in use I run the saw up and over against the wall so its out of the way.

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?v=525196140900229

I usually handle 200-800 pound wet slabs all the time. I slide them off the log 90 deg to my bobcat.

The nice thing about my saw is I cut inside with no exhaust, or noise. it's not that fast but I use it once every few months. I have about 7 grand into the saw.

I use a pressure pot to provide oil at 12 PSI to 4 points on the bar, usually just use two.

Another link to a pic of the mill below.

https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=331274966959015&set=a.329617233791455.79612.329602620459583&type=1&theater

Brian

Logs to Lumber

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#24

Re: PS

Keith Newton

Hey Mark, That looks like a fine way to handle a walnut tree to me. However, next time, I would suggest that you start your stack higher off the floor, and use some thicker stickers / spacers. It wouldn't hurt to have a fan circulating some air through that stack, if it has a wall behind it.

Walnut is pretty forgiving though, but I'll bet the wood on the bottom toward the middle is still pretty wet.

Re: Question on large wood slabs

#25

Hey Brian, Thanks for checking in here and

Keith Newton

Sharing more with us. That is quite a piece of equipment you have there. My hat is off to you. Did you do all the machining yourself, or do you have a good friend with a machine shop?

I thought that looked about like a 7.5 motor, and wondering if more wouldn't be more efficient? Also, I was wondering why you chose this pivot crane situation, rather than a gantry type that could travel down a longer log. It seems to me that when I'm free-hand ripping, I get a faster cut by leading with the motor by about 15º, probably about like when you start into the cut. Do you maintain the same feed rate from start to finish?

It is great that the bar only gets warm. Where do most of your big logs come from? Are they from timber stands, or from old home places, cemeteries, and city parks? In my neck of the woods, nobody lets their timber get that large in the woods.

So,,,,,,,, If someone showed up with a 39" diameter Walnut, which is actually about 30" x 48" oval, do you saw on shares?