Re: The real story
Tom in Toronto
Barry, The main advantages to slabs are that they involve less cutting. When I did my beech a few years ago, I did a mostly 2-2.5 inch, and one 4 inch for a bench top, it was only 7 feet long, and about 16" wide though. The longer I am at this, I find the following:
- I rarely loose any wood, so long as I handle the pith properly, etc...
- I never need it before I dry it. I mean I often need it the day of the cut, that is why I want a load of beech, or cherry, but by the time a few months slide by it is long forgotten. SO time to dry is largely a non-issue. The beech was weird, it dried in less than a year, in the 4 inch slab. The majority of the water was out by then.
- Even now that I am in my fifties, and with my helpers all being at best 100 pounds, I don't have any trouble moving the boards, which are rarely more that 7 feet long. Really big pieces would be another mater, but just like moving machinery. In the woods one can normally skid slabs on rollers, or sawdust, or a trail of other smaller boards.
- I never worry about how much my mill takes, so it is a 1/16 more than a bandmill that cost 5-10 times as much, and isn't portable. My trees are all free or firewood prices, and they normally come from: Trees that the arbourist would get, and are destined for the chipper; trees that are blow downs; cleaning out a sugar bush; or being managed for firewood.
- I am getting dead straight cuts with my mill, and I can process pretty much any shape, at any angle to that shape. Try that with some of the other machines. I also take a pretty much unlimited width. I only use my 36" bar, gets me maybe 28 inches, but I could cut 8' with minor changes. Try that with a portable bandsaw.
I would normally cut less than 3, but 2 or 2.5 work for me, it depends on the scale of the work. I mostly flat saw, so wider boards give me gargantuan pieces, less cutting, better yield; material to quarter for stiles; the already mentioned fat legs. Less stickering.
As I say, most of this work is prospective, I don't really know what it will exactly be used for. I have never regretted the big piece. So for instance when I did the beech. I was sorta thinking "hollows and rounds; big bench planes; bench parts. But not long afterwards they cleared a place on "Old Orchard road". By the time I got there all that was left was some short pieces of maple. I cut them at 4-5 inches, partly anticipating neighbours would protest, which they did (moreso the guys who had been there all day, but I was nearest the road). The pieces are sorta oddball, so I am thinking perfect legs for the bench. So the beech I cut for that is now freed up, If I had cut it specifically right away, I would be in a lock. And all that could change again with the next tree to fall