Spring Joints-useful or not?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
A letter about “spring joints” in the recent Popular Woodworking got me to thinking more about this often discussed and, in my experience, seldom used joint. There was an error in the editor’s response that could be significant in considering this joint in one’s work. To quote, “the ends of the board contract more quickly and to a greater degree than the center of the board”. Half this statement is true under one condition and the other is not true.
A nice piece of work out of VA Tech showed that under drying conditions the rate of water transport along the length of a board is times greater than through the faces of the board. The tree’s plumbing is designed to move water up the trunk more so than radially, so this result should not be surprising. As a result, a board, or fireplace log, will lose water out its ends at a much greater rate than through its edges, or bark in the case of the log. Were this not the case a 10” fireplace long would take years to dry in a stack. However, the equilibrium moisture content, defined as the moisture content of the wood after equilibration at some specified temperature and humidity, will be the same throughout the board. Hence, left to establish equilibrium, the ends of the board, as well as the middle, will contract equally in a drying situation. The correct statement would read; under drying conditions a glued up and unfinished panel will lose moisture out the panel ends faster than through the faces, until the wood reaches its equilibrium moisture content for the conditions it is exposed to. In this drying situation the ends of the panel will initially shrink faster than the middle. This situation will initially stress the glue joints at the panel ends as the panel dries, but not after the panel has reached equilibrium.
I once demonstrated this fact while sanding a walnut panel outside in the hot sun. The dark panel became surprisingly hot, the ends began to rapidly loose water and the ends of the joints failed. That said, do spring joints provide a sufficient benefit to bother learning to make them and use them? I think not and here is why.
It is a fact that the furniture industry successfully glues millions of panels without the aid of spring joints. Furthermore, I have never seen a commercial shop employ them. I think there are good reasons to explain these successes.
If we are using kiln dried wood dried to the common specification of 7% a panel is more likely to expand than shrink as it equilibrates to its typical surroundings. This situation renders the sprung joint moot.
Once the panel is finished now we have to consider the rate of moisture loss or gain through the finish. If this rate is slower than the rate water moves along the length of the board then the difference in rate at which water moves along the length of the board vs across the board becomes irrelevant. The overall rate will be determined by the rate through the finish, which will be the same on the ends as in the middle. I have never seen data for moisture transport through finish but I expect it to be much slower than through the wood. Maybe someone will find data for the rate of water transport in various finishes and report it here.
Wood is plastic, that is, its molecules will move around to relieve stress applied to the wood. Hence, we would expect that the compression provide by the sprung joint would relax and become less over time.
In 1720 all panels were made from air dried (more or less) wood. The number of busted panels I have seen in antiques suggests wood was often dried less than more. The edge joints were prepared with hand planes by persons that could reliably plane an edge. It would have been a trivial task to plane a spring joint into the edge. Furthermore, in examining inventories of these ancient shops they did not seem to have extensive clamp collections. The spring joint was trivial to add, it lessened the need for clamps and it compensated for less than optimally dried wood as the panel further dried. Makes a lot of sense to the 1720 shop or a modern shop emulating this way of working.
Learning to build quality furniture is difficult. There are so many things to learn. It doesn't help the student of this goal to become sidetracked by some technique that is unnecessary, or provides marginal value. Is the spring joint technique worth learning and employing in a modern shop using modern lumber? Probably not. There are certainly many other things to learn that will yield a greater benefit.



