Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Spring Joints-useful or not?

Posts

Spring Joints-useful or not?

#1

Spring Joints-useful or not?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A letter about “spring joints” in the recent Popular Woodworking got me to thinking more about this often discussed and, in my experience, seldom used joint. There was an error in the editor’s response that could be significant in considering this joint in one’s work. To quote, “the ends of the board contract more quickly and to a greater degree than the center of the board”. Half this statement is true under one condition and the other is not true.

A nice piece of work out of VA Tech showed that under drying conditions the rate of water transport along the length of a board is times greater than through the faces of the board. The tree’s plumbing is designed to move water up the trunk more so than radially, so this result should not be surprising. As a result, a board, or fireplace log, will lose water out its ends at a much greater rate than through its edges, or bark in the case of the log. Were this not the case a 10” fireplace long would take years to dry in a stack. However, the equilibrium moisture content, defined as the moisture content of the wood after equilibration at some specified temperature and humidity, will be the same throughout the board. Hence, left to establish equilibrium, the ends of the board, as well as the middle, will contract equally in a drying situation. The correct statement would read; under drying conditions a glued up and unfinished panel will lose moisture out the panel ends faster than through the faces, until the wood reaches its equilibrium moisture content for the conditions it is exposed to. In this drying situation the ends of the panel will initially shrink faster than the middle. This situation will initially stress the glue joints at the panel ends as the panel dries, but not after the panel has reached equilibrium.

I once demonstrated this fact while sanding a walnut panel outside in the hot sun. The dark panel became surprisingly hot, the ends began to rapidly loose water and the ends of the joints failed. That said, do spring joints provide a sufficient benefit to bother learning to make them and use them? I think not and here is why.

It is a fact that the furniture industry successfully glues millions of panels without the aid of spring joints. Furthermore, I have never seen a commercial shop employ them. I think there are good reasons to explain these successes.

If we are using kiln dried wood dried to the common specification of 7% a panel is more likely to expand than shrink as it equilibrates to its typical surroundings. This situation renders the sprung joint moot.

Once the panel is finished now we have to consider the rate of moisture loss or gain through the finish. If this rate is slower than the rate water moves along the length of the board then the difference in rate at which water moves along the length of the board vs across the board becomes irrelevant. The overall rate will be determined by the rate through the finish, which will be the same on the ends as in the middle. I have never seen data for moisture transport through finish but I expect it to be much slower than through the wood. Maybe someone will find data for the rate of water transport in various finishes and report it here.

Wood is plastic, that is, its molecules will move around to relieve stress applied to the wood. Hence, we would expect that the compression provide by the sprung joint would relax and become less over time.

In 1720 all panels were made from air dried (more or less) wood. The number of busted panels I have seen in antiques suggests wood was often dried less than more. The edge joints were prepared with hand planes by persons that could reliably plane an edge. It would have been a trivial task to plane a spring joint into the edge. Furthermore, in examining inventories of these ancient shops they did not seem to have extensive clamp collections. The spring joint was trivial to add, it lessened the need for clamps and it compensated for less than optimally dried wood as the panel further dried. Makes a lot of sense to the 1720 shop or a modern shop emulating this way of working.

Learning to build quality furniture is difficult. There are so many things to learn. It doesn't help the student of this goal to become sidetracked by some technique that is unnecessary, or provides marginal value. Is the spring joint technique worth learning and employing in a modern shop using modern lumber? Probably not. There are certainly many other things to learn that will yield a greater benefit.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#2

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

roger lance

This subject is one of those in woodworking that never made a lot of sense to me unless you were getting failure of joints in panels at the ends....and people were not reporting such problems. Yet it is a technique that continues to be taught/advocated.....most recently, I saw a video in which Tommy MacDonald, a graduate of The North Bennett Street School, demonstrated spring joints for panel construction. I think you are probably correct in that the reason for using spring joints was a valid method for the type of conditions of the past....but in current times, IMHO, the need for spring joints is questionable.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#3

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

John in NM

I find them useful, and trivially easy to do.

Joint on the machine so that the joint is straight. Then a few swipes with a hand plane on each side and you have the sprung joint.

I can't explain why edge joints fail, but I've seen an awful lot of them do so, from factory furniture to high end stuff. Never had one of mine fail, but then I've only had 20 odd years doing it, most of the failed stuff I've seen was older than that. The two cases I can think of that were much younger, it is likely that the jointer was not cutting straight, knowing the capabilities of the shop in each case.

The worst failures I've seen were from actual liquid exposure - table leaves stored in the basement for example - not from moisture. One of the young failures I've seen was most certainly from contraction of amateurly seasoned wood in a table top. In a case where you are using professionally dried wood with a properly tuned jointer, for a captured panel in furniture, it is probably excessive to worry about springing the joint. Do it if you do everything that way, or don't do it if you don't and have no reason to make an exception.

I've not looked at as many antiques as you have, maybe edge joint failures are as common as with factory furniture and either get repaired or repurposed, or just tossed out. Maybe they just didn't fail though (I'm assuming most antiques had sprung edge joints, since hand planing a straight line is not as easy as machine jointing it). I'm not sure we can ever answer that with finality.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#4

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

Sgian Dubh

"The overall rate will be determined by the rate through the finish, which will be the same on the ends as in the middle."

I'm not convinced that your logic is good there Bill. I can see the logic you are applying, but the vapour pressure either side of the finish at the end grain will surely always be greater than either side of the finish in the long grain areas won't it? If that's the case then it follows that water adsorption and desorption will generally be more volatile at the end grain than the long grain areas. This in turn will lead to greater expansion and contraction of the last few inches of a board, or edged joined panel, although less volatile than if there's no finish at all on the wood.

Things may be different in the US with regards to normal edge jointing practice, but here in the UK we still teach sprung joinery as the standard basic edge joint. They can be difficult to do by hand if you haven't developed good hand skills, but once those skills are developed they should be reasonably easy to achieve ... I've forgotten how many edge joints I've sprung by hand over the years, but they're even easier to achieve if the edges have already been straightened on a surface planer (jointer). Certainly in my experience a sprung joint requiring (in theory) only pressure at the centre point to pull the boards up is better than a joint where the two edges are convex requiring pressure at either end to pull the joint tight. Joints of the latter form I find almost always fail.

There's a bit of discussion I put together on this subject at the following link, and I've no plans to change it. Slainte.

http://www.richardjonesfurniture.com/Articles/panel-glue-ups/panel-glue-ups.html

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#5

But, but...

Dave Bair

it's just so cool to put only one clamp in the middle of the panel and see the entire joint close up with just a turn to tighten the clamp. I have to admit that I also add clamps on the ends after the middle one is tight just to be safe and square.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#6

vapor transport, more than you ever wanted to know

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To a first approximation, the rate of molecule transport through a polymer film, in this case finish, is governed by Fick's Law, R = D dc/dx,

where R is the rate of transport measured in amount of stuff per unit of time (say grams per day or any similar unit), D is the diffusion coefficient of the diffusing molecule and dC/dx is the differential concentration gradient across the film. If one were to plot the concentration of stuff in the film as a function of distance across the film, dC/dX is the slope of this plot(to a first approximation).

In words, that rate at which stuff diffuses through a film depends on how fast the diffusing molecule moves in the film (D), and the concentration of the diffusing species on each side of the film. These concentrations in turn depend on the solubility of this stuff in the film (in this case water) and the concentration of this stuff next to the film on each side of it.

(It takes months for carbon dioxide molecules to diffuse through the sides of a soda bottle and make it go flat. It takes years for enough water to move through the walls of a gallon bottle of Titebond to make it thicken noticeably. If water moves this slow through a finish film the rate at which a finished panel equilibrates in response to changes in house humidity is so slow as to be unimportant in stressing joinery. It is a good question to know the answer to and I can only speculate)

The diffusion coefficient of water in the solid portions of wood vs finish may not be hugely different. However, wood has another means of getting water to the inside surface of the finish. It can diffuse there through the open pores of the wood and this rate will be many orders of magnitude faster than diffusion in the solid portions of the wood.

It matters not how fast the molecule can move in the polymer film if its solubility in the film is poor. It can’t move through the film until it dissolves in the film. The solubility of water in wood is something like 30%. The solubility of water in finish will be about 1/10 this amount. The bottom line is that the much higher solubility of water in wood and higher diffusion rate in the vapor space of the wood pores will mean the overall rate of getting water molecules to the polymer film is probably greater than the rate at which water can continue to diffuse through the finish film.

Now the “probably” results from the fact that I don’t know absolute values for D or dC/dX. Additionally, the polymer film is 0.010” thick and the diffusion distance in the wood is 0.375” (half the board thickness). If solubility was the same in wood and polymer dC/dX would be 0.375/ 0.010 steeper in the film. All else being equal (which it isn’t) would result in the thin film being able to transport 37 times more water molecules per unit of time than the wood.

In conclusion: One the one hand the finish film is thinner than the diffusion distance in the wood. But the water solubility and sum of the various diffusion coefficients in the wood are greater, maybe much greater. Temperature will have a huge, and probably not a proportionally equal, effect on diffusion coefficient and solubility in wood vs finish.

Which factors become most important? I don’t know.

Analogy- Suppose we have a crowd of people moving from field A 100 yards wide, across a parking lot 100 yard wide and into another field B infinitely wide. We place a restriction that the concentration of people per square ft. in the parking lot must remain at 1/10 the concentration in field A and B. Even if they can walk at the same speed in the fields and parking lot(diffusion coefficient is the same) the constriction of lower concentration in the parking lot will mean that we can move people to the edge of the parking lot faster than through it. As a result people will be coming to and leaving the boundary of Field A and the parking lot waiting for a vacancy in the parking lot to enter. Keep in mind that we cannot concentrate people at the Filed A boundary to exceed 10X the concentration in the parking lot. If more arrive they have to diffuse back into rest of Filed A.

Make the parking lot 10 feet wide and it will now have little effect on how fast people can move from A to B. Make them walk much slower in the parking lot and even the 10 foot lot will jam up people at the edge forcening them to diffuse back into the interior of Lot A.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#7

clamp pressure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well, this sets off yet another debate, except in this case we have data.

It is essential for best joint strength to squeeze out all the "excess" glue from a joint. The glue companies tell us that something over 100 psi on a Titebond type joint is best. Good luck achieving that recommendation with one clamp. (BTW, the sometimes statement of "starving" a joint with too much pressure is baloney with Titebond. )

Then there is the issue of joint alignment. I just finished two 4 foot length joints. I used a clamp every 16 inches. The procedure was to begin in the center, coaxing the joint flush and then working my way down the length,raising or lowering one of the boards to align the edges while tightening the clamps. Can't get there with one clamp or three.

The furniture factories use clamps every 16"or thereabouts. I figure they have the resources to have researched what is best.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#8

my point exactly

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"They can be difficult to do by hand if you haven't developed good hand skills, but once those skills are developed they should be reasonably easy to achieve" .

Now where in the list of essential stuff to master to make a piece of furniture does one put this item? It is easy to add it to a formal program syllabus for it dovetails with other skills required. But where in an armature's self taught list does it belong in their goal to build something to hold their socks?

I could not agree more that if you have the skill and tools, no harm to use it, in spite of the fact the furniture industry has found no need using KD lumber. It is in the category of it can't hurt if done right. It is easy to do for the already skilled and a challenge for the process oriented personalities to master. And there isn't hard data to show it is useless in every occasion. So if you can, and want to, why not.

But suppose you don' t have the skills or tools to do a spring joint. Should it stop you from successfully making panels from KD wood to go into furniture and cabinetry? I think not.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#9

Re: clamp pressure

John in NM

I use many clamps as well. Alignment is not a problem with a sprung joint, you just don't smash down the middle one right off. Snug is fine. Get them all snug and the joint flush and then tighten away.

This doesn't really seem like the same discussion to me, it's not really relevant to whether springing is useful or not.

If you have a well tuned jointer and get perfectly straight joints, then don't spring if you don't wish to.

I would speculate that the tradition of springing has a lot to do with the difficulty of getting perfectly straight and square edges using an 18" or 24" plane. The advantage of springing in such a context is that there is a range of acceptable concavity, right up to perfectly straight. If you are shooting for un-sprung, the range of acceptable joint geometry gets far tighter.

Considering how many guys I've seen fighting with their jointer to get a perfect edge, I tend to think that springing is still a good skill to have.

Given the number of 50-60 year old solid wood factory tables I've seen with failed joints, I'm a bit more skeptical of the production techniques than you are. The I suspect that a factory's goal is about a 40 year life span. Not that they set out to hit that mark, but more that if a problem turns up after 5 years, they are likely to want to correct it. Probably not so after 30-40 years.

I suspect that you would like your work to last longer than that, as do most of us who build for reasons other than sales.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#10

Re: my point exactly

Sgian Dubh

"Now where in the list of essential stuff to master to make a piece of furniture does one put this item?"

For the professional craft furniture maker it's a basic or elementary skill. For the amateur woodworker I suppose it depends upon the work they do.

I think you are also assuming that everyone in the "furniture industry" work to the same standards and use the same practices. They don't. Sprung joints are common enough in the furniture industry, although they are not universal. I have been in this industry for a long time, and it's rare I don't use a sprung joint in an edge glued panel assembly. The reason for it is because I've found it works and seldom fails, whereas unsprung joints (especially if the edges to be joined are convex or wavey) almost always fail sooner or later. Slainte.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#11

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

don stephan

Perhaps it's not common, but I've seen showroom furniture with cracks, and new chairs are commonly developing loose glue joints in a short time, so I don't think the furniture industry as a whole is aspiring to a very high quality level.

It's rare that my jointer plane will take a continuous shaving of an edge straight off my PM long bed jointer, more often two or three passes are required before I get a continuous shaving. So I would expect edge gluing boards right off the jointer to have a less than ideal glue joint. Granted, might be good enough for factory work, I'm sure they plan a certain percentage of pieces to be returned within warranty period for failures. In fact, I would expect if they have no failures they would want to reduce quality slightly for a production cost savings.

There are lots of woodworkers who don't thoroughly brush the glue on both surfaces of a joint; who don't allow lumber to acclimate in the workshop for a week before using; who don't allow boards to adjust after initial flattening and straightening; who don't use rift grain for table legs; and so on. As long as they understand the tradeoff, I think that's fine.

When I started using a jointer plane and springing edges before glueup I found the glue lines to be less noticeable, which I think makes a more attractive result. And the extra time in the project is not significant.

As long as our homes and workplaces have forced air heating and cooling, wood in furniture will undergo seasonal movement. In one rustic table I made decades ago, splits in the ends open up every winter and close the rest of the year, but they never extend far into the table. I can only conclude that the ends of the top are expanding and contracting faster than the interior.

I still make tradeoffs in my work, but not on glue lines. Just my opinion.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#12

We agree on one point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

We will agree that a joint made under tension at its ends is not good and must be avoided. However, anyone can quickly learn to make adequately mated joints with a power jointer and get on with making stuff successfully.

I will continue to advocate that learning to make a spring joint is not essential for long lasting panel construction.

However, I am not saying it is a useless skill to eventually learn. A slight convex edge in a long board can be difficult to straighten on a jointer. I have come to appreciate that hand planing the middle of the board in such a situation and then rejointing on the jointer can be the quickest way out of this problem. Or, if one has become sufficiently skilled at planing edges to keep them orthogonal the trip back to the jointer is not necessary.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#13

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

Paul Leuba

I agree that the ends of panels appear to expand and contract more than their interior. This, I believe, is particularly true in panels captured in door frames, for example, where often the very edge of the panel does not receive the "film finish" Bill referred to in his comments above. This differential in finish at the end grain of the panels vs. the interior would contribute to unequal expansion and contraction of their ends.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#14

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

To my knowledge I have never had a panel failure. I don't often use "spring joints", but would never assemble a panel that required end clamping to close the joint. I don't see how any panel would / should not have a good "film finish" on the ends. I always finish my panels before assembly, otherwise a "finish line" would appear on the panels as they shrink during low humidity conditions. I'm probably not as adept at using a joining plane as I should be, I am however meticulous about the setup of my joiner and it does produce a flat, gap free joint when boards are placed together on the workbench prior to glue-up (or I would re-join them). I also have almost all the wood I use well acclimated in my shop before use. My shop is heated and has AC, and is kept between 65 and 75 deg F year around. Most of the wood I use had been in upstairs shop storage for at least a few months - some years.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#15

Re: Wrong, wrong, wrong...

Tom

"(It takes months for carbon dioxide molecules to diffuse through the sides of a soda bottle and make it go flat. It takes years for enough water to move through the walls of a gallon bottle of Titebond to make it thicken noticeably. If water moves this slow through a finish film the rate at which a finished panel equilibrates in response to changes in house humidity is so slow as to be unimportant in stressing joinery. It is a good question to know the answer to and I can only speculate)"

This is a common test for epoxies which are very resistant to moisture flow, given the so called 100% solids. Wood moves around when finished relatively easily. How much is easily seen for your species and finish by making a hydrometer out of 0/90 wood. It does not take long, and often happens overnight with weather changes.

That said, the whole sprung joint thing doesn't make much sense to me. A few points I hope I am not repeating (I read whole thread...)

- Who exactly says they must be used? Normally books are written by non-doers, or other people who are repeating stuff written by earlier non-doers. I am not saying nobody said so, but what is the record this is a universal practice from an earlier time. I get somewhat tired of these massive exercises to use modern science in the service of dispelling straw men.

- Who says the reason they must be used is because of the drying out thing, for one thing, central heating wasn't in the the houses I knew in the UK until the 80s if at all. Just how much variability have people in all times and places felt. If sprung joints killed rot and woodworm they might have been onto something.

- When did they stop using hide glue and rubbed joints with dead straight interfaces and no clamps.

- Other reasons for springing boards are lower clamp use. Need fewer clamps. Rubbed joints are out, the crap in bottles is in, and we now need a lot of gear to hold the joints together.

- And a very useful reason is to go to the trouble to spring joints is that this is how you make them straight in the first place, hollow to a stop, then back out the ends, the only way you know you didn't back them out too far, is if you leave a little bite in them. This can be done blindfolded in a blackened room.

- Who says the problem is dealing with long term moisture change, maybe it is dealing with short term change that occurs when you bark off a board at unheated workshop temp, then glue two wet, (now to be interior) faces together, then sell them to someone in a somewhat drier house.

Most of this crap starts when some busy body asks someone whose only reason for doing stuff is because that was how he was taught, and he just makes something up, and it unfortunately gets printed. Or someone asks someone who doesn't want to tell what he knows, and he makes something up. Well maybe.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#16

Re: my point exactly

Tom

Spring joints are easily done by machine, and it is my preferred approach to jointing wood on a jointer. Many newbies who shoot bananas at their jointers are surprised to find they get a banana back.

Not all furniture is made from KD lumber.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#17

Ellis Walentine

Nobody has mentioned...

Ellis Walentine

... the importance of perfectly sharpened and aligned jointer knives. Even slightly dulled knives burnish and scallop the wood fibers, making them more resistant to glue. I think there is an argument for using a hand plane to tune up a jointed edge, whether or not you create a sprung joint in the bargain.

Ellis

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#18

test results coming soon

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Franklin Glue Guide warns against scalloped edges and "dull" knives. They do not suggest that perfectly sharp knives are required.

I don't think that one can afflict any mechanical damage on a wood surface that would keep glue from sticking (more on that later). However, I can imagine that severe "burnishing" could lead to a weakened wood fiber structure near the surface, which in turn would weaken the joint.

Virginia Tech is a center of adhesives research and I found myself with an opportunity to ask one of their scientists whether wood glues work by adhesion or mechanical interlocking of the wood through penetration of glue into its porous structure. "Can't say" was the reply. Wood is so porous on the scale of glue penetration that one can not separate these factors, I was told.

However, glue does not have to penetrate wood pores to stick wood together. All the adhesive has to do is wet the surface and adhesion will do the sticking. For example, water sticks two perfectly flat pieces of glass together. If water had any shear strength one would never get the glass apart. Metal and Formica are similarly stuck with out the aid of mechanical factors. When we tested cyanoacrylate adhesives on metal the surfaces were polished optically flat. Given the composition of glue and cellulose there is little doubt the glue will wet the wood and provide adhesion.

When I install a new set of knives in the jointer I begin with the fence all the way to the right. As that section gets dull from edge jointing I move the fence progressively to the left. When I get a bit past the center I change knives. I sometimes take the time to move the fence back to the right for the first edge pass on rough lumber.

I am about half way across the jointer and the knives are noticeably dull on the right side. I'll joint two edges over there and do a test gluing, then look for wood failure when I break the joint, comparing it to a joint made with unused knife edge.

Why beat on this horse? Panel gluing is fundamental to almost any woodworking. It has to be mastered to make many things. If we make this step unnecessarily complicated it is going to slow down students of woodworking on their climb up the furniture building learning curve. Imply that one needs to learn the difficult task of planing an edge with a hand plane and some are going to take up basket weaving instead.

I just did an inventory of 184 edge joints I could fine that I had done around the house(I've done hundreds more located various places). These joints span 40+ years of wood working and none involved a hand plane. (It was not till recently that I even owned a hand plane that could have been used and sooner still that I had acquired the skill to attempt hand planing an edge. I still find getting a uniform shaving the length of a board daunting. Think of the requirement, keeping the plane angle oriented to the precision of less than 0.001" across a 7/8" edge.

Of these 184 joints one has failed at its end. It is located on the vertical of a bookcase 7' tall. The joint sits 1inch from a hot air register and it shows a crack about 3" up from the floor that is obvious, but not opened enough to show a gap. Would hand planing these surfaces or "springing" this long and limber joint prevented this crack. Don't know. But my advice remains the same. Don't let the inability to hand plane an edge slow you down in the quest to build stuff. It is a skill you can work on later if you feel the need.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#19

Re: aspect ratio

Tom

"Why beat on this horse? Panel gluing is fundamental to almost any woodworking. It has to be mastered to make many things. If we make this step unnecessarily complicated it is going to slow down students of woodworking on their climb up the furniture building learning curve. Imply that one needs to learn the difficult task of planing an edge with a hand plane and some are going to take up basket weaving instead."

There are a number of flaws in this analysis:

1) you don't have to master edge jointing to get her done;

2) who says hand planing an edge is complicated, compared to ownership and maintenance of a jointer, it would be tight. If you have both tools, the hand jointing of the post jointed edge is trivial.

3) Some people are discouraged from doing stuff that requires skills, other people are drawn to it, so it would move them along, not hold them back.

4) you can spring edges off a power jointer, so false dilemma.

5) Sharpening and all that can be tricky, but theoretically and actually there are disposable blade planes, though not in broad use. These tend to have square blade presentation that is ideal for jointing.

6) the run of the mill non-neander probably doesn't even know this issue exists.

"I just did an inventory of 184 edge joints I could fine that I had done around the house(I've done hundreds more located various places). These joints span 40+ years of wood working and none involved a hand plane.

It is again a mistake in you analysis to assume a joint can only be sprung with a hand plane.

"(It was not till recently that I even owned a hand plane that could have been used and sooner still that I had acquired the skill to attempt hand planing an edge. I still find getting a uniform shaving the length of a board daunting."

This is not necessary, or how I would spring a joint. Full length shavings would be possibly only one stroke in the whole process, and would be at that point where they were the only thing that could happen, raising the possibility that you don't know what you are doing, though I suppose this proves the difficulty point, at least for you.

"Think of the requirement, keeping the plane angle oriented to the precision of less than 0.001" across a 7/8" edge."

This is not difficult. There are a fair number of ways of goofing the jointer, it is not an automatic tool, no mater how comfy you may be with it. The condition of the board edge can cause misalignment, and crumbs, not to mention sucking the whole arm in. Among the halt and the lame, I have seen as many who do not want to get close the howling tool, as those who are scared of the plane.

"Of these 184 joints one has failed at its end. It is located on the vertical of a bookcase 7' tall. The joint sits 1inch from a hot air register and it shows a crack about 3" up from the floor that is obvious, but not opened enough to show a gap. Would hand planing these surfaces or "springing" this long and limber joint prevented this crack. Don't know. But my advice remains the same. Don't let the inability to hand plane an edge slow you down in the quest to build stuff. It is a skill you can work on later if you feel the need."

+1ish, other than the hand plane being necessary, and all the earlier stuff that was mentioned on splitting in a higher post.

HOWEVER, one very important point is to understand aspect ratio and springing, there are many joints that should not be or can't be sprung. One has to know this, it has to do with stiffness of low aspect ration panels. I sure don't spring guitar plates, other than transitionally on the way to the straight edge I need. This does tend to undermine the idea that spring is necessary, though I don't know who said that in the first place, and what the evidence for the idea is given the fact it obviously doesn't include rubbed joints, and other items you need to answer. You may overall be contributing to, not rebutting the myth. What about the whole mode a shooting board thing.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#20

Re: test results coming soon

Sgian Dubh

Bill, as long as you are having success with your edge jointing technique, that's really all that matters. The fact is that you must be doing it well otherwise you would see failure on a regular basis. In my practice I make a sprung joint almost every time, and this is usually done after straightening the joining edges on the surface planer (jointer). If the edges come off the jointer already sprung I don't touch them again, but if they're not I tweak them with a hand plane until they are sprung.

People may have a misconception about what I mean by "sprung". It doesn't mean there's a big gap in the middle that needs significant force to pull the joint together. One description I use to convey the correct amount of spring is to say the force needed to close a sprung joint should be no more than that required to suspend a large book between fingers and thumb, i.e., spine uppermost, e.g., a book that weighs somewhere between 4 and 5 lbs.

For short boards up to about 2 or three feet long this would mean a gap perhaps the thickness of a piece or two of standard writing paper.

I find it interesting that you seem to consider mastering the skill to hand plane a sprung joint difficult and perhaps off putting for students or learners. Whilst the task isn't so simple as falling off a log it is, as far as professional woodworkers are generally concerned, an elementary or basic skill because it follows on from the elementary or basic skills of being able to tune, sharpen, set and use a hand plane. Whilst excellent woodworking can be achieved without much recourse to hand tools nowadays, a truly skilled woodworker (at professional level anyway, and for hand tool aficionados at the amateur end, plus other categories of woodworker I may have omitted) can always work wood skilfully, albeit more slowly, when there's no electricity to run any machines. Slainte.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#21

Re: test results coming soon

Tom

"For short boards up to about 2 or three feet long this would mean a gap perhaps the thickness of a piece or two of standard writing paper"

This only applies to a given width of board, at some point the boards become essentially rigid. clamping even a small crack will cause excess deformation, or remove too much glue.

"I find it interesting that you seem to consider mastering the skill to hand plane a sprung joint difficult and perhaps off putting for students or learners. Whilst the task isn't so simple as falling off a log it is, as far as professional woodworkers are generally concerned, an elementary or basic skill because it follows on from the elementary or basic skills of being able to tune, sharpen, set and use a hand plane."

I agree it is easy. It wasn't easy for me to learn, but we had bad information. Today there is a lot of info out there so it really isn't hard to learn. Though Bill may never have met an industrial pro who owned a hand plane, but then there is a lot of bad work being produced out there. It would actually be interesting to know where the real woodworkers exist today. Most of then, not in the US/NA.

Re: Spring Joints-useful or not?

#22

Re: test results coming soon

Sgian Dubh

"This only applies to a given width of board, at some point the boards become essentially rigid. clamping even a small crack will cause excess deformation, or remove too much glue."

True, but it's rare to come across a board so wide that a bit of gentle clamping can't close a small gap of about 100 - 125μm (~5 thou). And, of course, the longer the board the more easily it can be caused to flex under load, i.e., clamping two edges together to form a panel. The spring created is appropriate to the joint length: a longer joint can take a greater spring. So, from my practical perspective and experience, your point is specious for something like ±99.5% of all the sprung joint panel assemblies I've put together in my working life. Slainte.