Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

Posts

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#26

The last time I used it, was 12-16-20

Keith Newton

I was adding a wing, off the back of the cabin I've been helping my cousin with down next to our cabin. We are in the flood-plain of a river, so they are up 8' on legs.

Due to the downward sloping grade, and needing my new + crossing ridges of the roof, using some inside existing walls to carry the rafters, I just put up the band joist by eye on temporary legs, then measured out, and squared this way. When I later tore the back wall out, and could measure the diagonals, they were within 1/4", which was plent close for sheet goods to stay on the layout.

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#27

Re: The last time I used it, was 12-16-20

Barry Irby

Many years ago somebody sold me a building lot that already had a foundation on it. There was some story about somebody buying the lot and putting in the foundation and then failing to make the payments on the lot so the developer took it back. They gave me a discount on the lot and did not try to charge me for the foundation, explaining it was a "freebe". It was about the same size as the house I wanted to build. Close enough. Unfortunately it did not occur to me to pull the diagonals. As we tried to install the plywood on the roof we discovered the diagonals were off by a foot! I had a framing crew do the house and they just ignored the problems on the floor and trimmed everything to fit. It was a nightmare on the roof, but we were stuck with it at that point and soldered on, somewhat drunkenly. We avoided any floor covering with a pattern. Sold the house. No one noticed. There was a tiny defect in the drywall at the light switches at the front door and they were so fixated on that they never noticed their house was a foot out of square.

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#28

Reminds me...

Tony - Memphis

In 9th grade geometry, we got a bonus if we could figure out the height of the flag pole in front of the school using a protractor. A few of us figured it out....but not me (I had figured out girls by then!).

Tony

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#29

Pythagorean triples

charlie belden

Here's a link to a bunch more

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_right_triangles

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#30

Re: Same here

Tom

But I assume the fault is mine. They really did extensively use this stuff in the day, a designer would have book after book laying out the practical uses of geometry. I once ran into a guy who had a whole large artist's book full of drawing relating the GT to the classical guitar outline.

One of the wood mags suggested a fairly recent book, though I don't believe it is still published, I got mine from the library. It was a well written and entertaining introduction to architectural, and design proportions - Anyone know the one I mean - It starts out describing, like, a New England street and a modernist post office building with zero ornamentation.

At the end of the day, my failure to take much interest in classical furniture is in part because I don't understand this stuff, and don't want to do the furniture equivalent of setting out to write the great English novel, yet handing in a result in Pig Latin. I did find a good book, mentioned above, to point out the errors of my ways, but not an easy book to introduce me to the subject. The math isn't the problem, it is just a tremendously involved subject.

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#31

Re: how is it used?

Tom

People seem to like using it for setting up the crossed lines for a foundation. I think it works there because you don't just cut four pieces of wood to length then measure diagonals, you need to start with string. So they get three guys to hook their tapes together to check the first corner, then move on. If they had something solid to work with they could use the diagonals.

Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances

#32

Re: Pythagorean triples

BrianMonumentCO

I am always concerned about the accuracy of any measurement where the angle between the longest side and the hypotenuse is small. The angle is 36.8689 degrees. The 5,12,13 has a 22.6199 degrees. So I prefer the 3,4,5 right triangle it is so easy to remember and use.

The 5,12,13 triangle is fine for roofs where the right angle is not really critical. The relationship between rise (5) and run (12) appears more important. The numbers suggest the lengths of boards but not 5,12 and 13.

Of course in furniture making only the 3,4 and 5 appear truly useful......at least to me.

But math specifically trigonometry and geometry are so much fun.