Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distance
David Hay Denver
One way to do it would be to just change the unit of measure. Instead of using 3-4-5 inches, use feet, yards or some arbitrary unit. What I mean for the last one is to pick some arbitrary measurement and use that as a single "unit". For example, you could pick a unit length of 4-ft and then the measurements would be 12-16-20 (3*4 - 4*4 - 5*4).
David
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
I remember working through the Pythagorean Theorem in geometry class in high school, and as we got to the end of it, being totally blown away by the genius of Pythagoras and how he must have figured out how to generalize from the well known 3:4:5 ratio to the rule we all study now. I'm sure Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein were just as amazed when they saw the proof for the first time, but they had a lot more smarts than I have and were much better able to apply the enlightenment to their own discoveries.
It's not too late to learn how to do math. It will certainly help with your furniture design, even if you onlylimit yourself to proportions of whole numbers.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
Works with any lengths, decimal or even fractional. Ratios where all three sides are whole numbers are just conveniently tidy cases of the broader concept.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
I use various means for checking for square but never used this one. How are you using it (the application or need)? It would seem to me that the errors in measuring three distances would result in a greater angular error than say using a square.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
Generally it is used for big stuff, rooms for example. When I was in the cabinet business we used it to check conditions in the room whenever we had to turn a corner. It's also handy if you don't have (or don't trust) your square or if you are beyond its capacity. You do have to be careful measuring, as you always do, but 1/32" measurement error if you're using feet isn't that significant. I've also set up trammel points and swung arcs to generate a large square (table saw sled) using this method.
If they focused on the useful things in high school geometry a lot more people would pay attention.
Bob Lang
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
That was the kind of answer I was looking for. It just didn't seem to have much application in squaring a piece of furniture or anything else small, but I wanted to be sure I was not overlooking something.
I too use a trammel to lay out saw sled fences. A trammel and/or divider can be used for all sorts of layout tasks based on geometric principals.
Will Neptune is a genius at employing geometric principals in furniture building. I have pestered him a time or two to write a book, or at least an article on some of his geometric time saving tricks. The one for making a domed lid for a trunk, for example, is an exceptional time saver. Maybe you can induce him to publish some of his insights in a PW article.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
5 12 13 also works and is useful when constructing building and roofs.
Bill, I have used it often building things like a room addition. For example, lets say you wanted to add a room onto your house that is 20 feet wide and projects out 15 feet. You measure the 20 foot width across the house, then you measure fifteen feet out from one mark and pull a 25 foot diagonal from the other one, and that's the corner. Then you can do the same for the other corner. Then you can recheck it to see if your rectangle is 20 x 15 and both diagonals are 25 feet.
Lets say you want to install kitchen cabinets in an inside corner, but you doubt the corner is square. From the corner measure out four feet one way and three feet the other. If the diagonal between the two marks is five feet, the corner is square or ninety degrees. (This assumes you made your marks level with each other and the walls are straight.) If the diagonal is less than five feet the corner is less than ninety degrees or "closed" and if it is more than five feet it more than ninety degrees or "open". I'm sure modern calculators or some sort of trig chart could tell you the exact number of degrees, but I have never tried to figure it out. If it is close, its about all you can expect and you can fudge for a 1/4" or so. This is what sanding flanges are for. In the real world, corners are never square and floors are never level. At least where I live.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
Look up the Golden Rectangle as it applies to furniture and while you are at it look up the Fibonacci Series. Astounding stuff, if that's the kind of stuff that astounds you.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
I have found no use for these design features in building furniture. The rectangle never results in a practical shape for anything I have ever built. I regret wasting time trying to use it in design.
The various series have been suggested for sizing things like drawers. Good luck with that suggestion. The resulting drawers will range from impractically small to impractically larger if there are many of them.
A more practical and widely used drawer sizing scheme is to increase the drawer size by the divider thickness. This scheme enables easy layout with two dividers, one set to the smallest drawer height and the second to the divider thickness. The resulting rank of drawers will remain in a practical range.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
There are lots of good explanations out there on the Internet. That one was just the first one I found that seemed to be well presented and easy to understand. You could try Googling "pythagorean theorem proof" or even "3:4:5". I'm kinda reluctant to provide the latter search parameter, because Goggle isn't very good at punctuation, but you should be able to sort it out.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
It even works for irrational and transcendental numbers. But when Pythagoreas invented (or discovered) his proof, it's not clear that he had yet grasped the concept of irrational numbers. I'm sure neither he nor his followers understood the concept of transcendental numbers, as they would have been inconsistent with their belief system. Even Leonardo DaVinci, almost two millennia later, was still struggling with the squaring of the circle, because he didn't understand that pi is transcendental.
The reason 3:4:5 was important in antiquity is that it can be laid out with dividers, and no measuring numbers or units or scales (or Platinum bars hidden away at NIST ) at all.
For more enlightenment on what can be done with furniture design using just dividers and straight edge and whole number ratios, George Walker and Jim Tolpin's book, By Hand and Eye, is a very interesting text. It's published byLost Art Press.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
I think it is interesting, but I never use it in furniture.
I am interested in what William has to say, mostly out of curiosity. I had forgotten that transcendental number even existed. I have wondered if we (humans) invented mathematics or discovered it. I suspect that it was already there and we just finally noticed it.
I wonder how Pii was derived? Been meaning to look it up? Did we measure the circumference and diameter and divide, or is there another more accurate way?
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
𝜋 (pi) is the ratio of circumference to diameter of a circle, there are a number of ways to calculate it as it shows up in a number of different places/calculations (eg if you want to know the area in a circle).
To me, the cool thing about these numbers is that Ma Nature uses them again and again: for example, the Nautilus shell is a Fibonacci series, as are many growing ferns as they unfold. Fern leaves are Mandelbrot sets, as are some coast lines. I think these numbers are so ingrained in us we don't notice them even as we use them.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
I agree, Bill. the Golden Mean (or rectangle) when applied to furniture results in some unappealing and useless proportions. I think it has to do with scale. It's perfectly wrong for furniture. It's nice for architecture and nautilus shells.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances
The link worked fine just now although Firefox's built-in PDF display didn't like it and I had to look at it in a different viewer. It is definitely there though. Trying to work through any of the math gave me a headache just like I used to get in calculus class, though.
Re: puzzled about 3-4-5 method and longer distances