Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Mission Style Design Question

Posts

Mission Style Design Question

#1

Mission Style Design Question

AZ in Colorado Springs

Happy New Year everyone

I'm building a mission style entry hall table and accompanying mirror for my daughter. She sent a link to a photo on the web, and I drew my own sketch after we discussed the dimensions.

My question is simple --what is the right treatment for the edges of the legs, rails & stiles, aprons, and table top? Rounded over with an 1/8" or 1/4" roundover bit? Or just eased a bit with sandpaper? How 'sharp' should these edges on the table be?

Thanks

Andy

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#2

Re: Mission Style Design Question

Keith Newton

I would go with the 1/8 or less, depending on it's exposure, and hardness of wood.

Then, outside corners which may be prone to being bumped, I sand to a more rounded / hip friendly shape.

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#3

Re: Mission Style Design Question

john Veerkamp

The mission dinning suit I grew up with had about a 1/8 round over on all edges. It was Q sawn oak in with the fumed dark color.

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#4

Re: Mission Style Design Question

roger lance

Andy.....I don't believe that there is a set rule.....you do want to round over somewhat if for no other reason than finish doesn't do well on sharp edges and sharp edges don't feel good to the hand.....so I'd start with the smallest round over bit I had.....you being the maker, decide if you like it.....go to a larger round over bit if you decide you want more.....I'd also consider a beading bit for the bottom of aprons....gives a nice look.

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#5

Re: Mission Style Design Question

Bob Lang

Original pieces vary from next to nothing to a 1/8" +/- roundover or chamfer. To my eye less is more and I like to break the edge with sandpaper or give it a slight bevel with a block plane. It also looks better if there is some variation; places that are regularly touched or where there is a risk of damage get a bit more taken off the edge.

Bob Lang

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#6

Re: Mission Style Design Question

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I grew up in a house full of monterey mission furniture. The edges have about a 1/16" radius with it much more rounded on all the potter edges, particularly the corners. Monterey mission is a bit different from some of the other stuff. It was made from alder distressed and finished with a very very dark oil and rubbed with rottten stone . The objective was to make it look like it was 200 years old when it left the factory.

Robin

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#7

I agree with Bob Lang

Howard in Toronto

It's always looked that edges have been just broken with sandpaper.

Nothing says you can't use your own taste or needs - like if there are little kids at home etc.

Howard

Re: Mission Style Design Question

#8

Re: I agree with Bob Lang

William Duffield

Yup, Bob is definitely the expert on this style of furniture.

Note, however, that Greene and Greene (on which subject Bob is also expert) is sometimes lumped in with "mission" by interior decorators who don't know any better. If the table is G&G, then the round overs should be larger radius, and the radius actually increases as you get closer to the end of each edge and corner. These radii are usually very specific to the particular piece of furniture, or at least the particular room it was designed for.