Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Is MDF wood good enough

Posts

Is MDF wood good enough

#1

Is MDF wood good enough

Raj

Hi mates,

I am looking for furniture for my new house(Wardrobes, beds, tables)

I went to one local shop in Birmingham. The furniture looks nice and competetive price. I asked what wood they use. They said that they use MDF.

I am searching online whether MDF is good or not. I found confusing answers.

Suddenly I found this site and I felt lucky and hope I get an answer.

The local weather is cold. So we use heating in the rooms during winter.

So, shall I go ahead with furniture made with MDF wood or not?

As it is for my own house and we will not buy furniture every few years.

Please reply.

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#2

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

Barry Irby

MDF stands for Medium Density Fiberboard. Generally its sheets of wood fiber glued and pressed together. Sheets dome in many thicknesses starting at about 1/8" or 3mm up to 3/4" or 18 mm. Actually its available thicker than that and it can be laminated. Its also available in lighter of heavier densities and with various face materials laminated onto it Like melamine in white or wood grain and there are water proof versions.

I don't think I am overstating it by saying it is generally associated with cheaper mass produced furniture. The grade of it used in furniture seems to break easily and is difficult to nearly impossible to fix well once damaged. I recently repaired some for my son who is in the Army. He bought it as almost disposable furniture because he moves frequently. It was a self fulling prophesy. He was dreading the movers damaging his cheap furniture and they pretty much destroyed it. He threw some of it away. I don't think there will be any MDF antiques.

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#3

Ellis Walentine

Not for me

Ellis Walentine

MDF isn't technically wood, it's more like dense cardboard. That said, MDF has its place in furnituremaking, as it is a preferred substrate for some high-end veneered furniture. But, the MDF junk they sell at the big discount stores is not worth investing in. Most of it has sharp edges, cheap veneers, poor hardware and terrible aesthetics. It is susceptible to contact with moisture. It is often assembled with knockdown connectors that make it weak and wobbly. Shelves and table leaves have relatively little resistance to deflection under load, which means that bookshelves will sag unacceptably. It is price-point furniture with every possible corner cut, and it will not last.

Need I go on? Save up for something nice made of solid wood.

Ellis Walentine, Host

WoodCentral

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#4

consider used furniture

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First, MDF is not wood.

Used furniture will likely be well made because it has survived long enough to become used furniture fit for resale. Even if minor repair or refinishing needs to be done the used furniture may still be significantly less expensive than new furniture.

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#5

Re: consider used furniture

Larry in NW Ohio

I think Bill has the right idea. Look around for good used furniture. Go to garage sales, second hand stores, good will and such places. Some of these places have very good furniture, you just need to catch the right place. Good Luck Larry

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#6

Kneale Brownson

Used SOLID WOOD furniture


Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#7

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

William Duffield

There are very good reasons that those who build quality furniture from real hardwoods often refer to this stuff as "Termite barf." Don't be fooled by the pictures of wood that they print on the surface (or even 1/64" thin veneer they glue on). Carefully check the edges. If you can't see the grain, run away from it.

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#8

Re: consider used furniture

Bill Howatt

Yes, but be careful if you want a complete refinishing or reupholstering and have to have the work done. It can get very expensive.

How well furniture stands up depends on your circumstances and what the piece is. Some people are just a lot more careful than others and if you have young children then the risk of damage is a lot higher. Certainly solid wood is best but I have some veneered particle-board bedroom furniture that is 25-35 years old and it is just fine. Particle-board furniture is not considered the best but I guess now MDF is the new low-end.

Bill

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#9

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

Depending in the store often timesthe prices a furniture store charges are really close to what you would have to pay if you commissioned a custom furniture maker. You may want to do a few google searches for terms like studio furniture makers, custom furniture, and local furniture maker.

By buying directly from the maker you cut out the 100% markup that the charges and instead get that applied to the quietly and craftsmanship of a Lockhart made piece of furniture.

It is common for custom makers to guarantee their joinery for life. try and get that at a furniture store.

Robin

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#10

Custom furniture makers by you must work cheap

Dick Coers

because I would never sell a solid wood piece of furniture for close to what people are paying for furniture in a store. The last sentence from the OP says he doesn't want to buy furniture every few years. Don't buy MDF furinture if that is a consideration. Especially with kids! MDF furniture is throw away stuff that will only look good for a couple of years and not hold up well for more than a few more than that. Almost all bedroom furniture in the mass markets used to be made in Viet Nam. I don't know if that is still the case or it moved to China, but it's made for the throw away society.

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#11

Re: Custom furniture makers by you must work cheap

Bill Howatt

The throw-away society is what most younger people are these days. They don't really have any interest in keeping something for 100 years and plan to change it on the next interior decorating update.

Just watch home TV shows and listen to how many times your hear, "we'll do something about that out-dated furniture....".

Bill

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#12

contrarian opinion coming right up

Howard in Toronto

Raj - the short answer is - IT DEPENDS.

In certain applications, it's excellent stuff.

If the furniture is properly engineered for MDF's characteristics, it can last a loooooong time, even under heavy use.

Cut corners and everyone's comments here are valid.

So what does that mean to you? Certain furniture like bookcases and cabinets can be just fine. Beds? Not so fine.

The trick is to identify how it's put together.

Screws? Nails? Walk away.

Housed joints? Glue? Worth a closer look.

I've made dining room cabinets. What seems like millions of bookcases. Desks. And end tables.

All of them with the same simple joints - rabbets, dadoes grooves and nothing more than glue. Shelves as long as 8 feet. And 10 years later, still no sag because I accounted for both tensile strength and beam strength.

So the trick is to figure out if certain pieces might work for you. If not, consider yourself lucky that you got this much info from the very knowledgeable practitioners here.

Look at it this way, the money you save on the MDF furniture (IF it's engineered as I described) you can go a little higher on other furniture made of solid wood.

I hope this helped.

Howard

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

#13

Re: Is MDF wood good enough

John Lucas

I'm not a fan of MDF furniture Sure I have quite a few pieces because they are cheap and I don't have money to spend on good furniture. I do buy a lot of flea mkt furniture and fix it up.

MDF simply doesn't hold up. The corners chip easily, it won't hold anyweight without sagging and if you ever get it wet, fogetaboutit.

That being said I have several sets of bookshelf kind of cabinets that only hold light weight stuff. They don't look bad and will do until I can afford to build my own out of good wood, or find a proper replacement at a yard sale.