Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A rumination on finishing

Posts

A rumination on finishing

#1

Clint Searl

A rumination on finishing

Clint Searl

One of the more enduring finishing beliefs is that BLO and tung oil “soak” into wood. I’ve been more than a little skeptical about that idea, so I conducted an experiment to see if and just how much BLO and raw tung oil penetrate different woods. I puddled each oil on samples of the flat grain of white ash, red oak, cherry, and hard maple. After a half hour, I wiped the oils off; and after another hour, re-applied and wiped the oils. After another hour I sliced the samples to reveal the edge profile that would show the oils’ effects. The open grained oak showed the most penetration at about one millimeter, followed by cherry at around a half millimeter. The white ash showed little if any penetration, and the hard maple showed no penetration at all. Between the two oils, the tung oil seemed to be absorbed more, which may? be accounted for by the difference in molecular weights: 900 for BLO and 250 for tung oil. Because both oils are drying oils, exposure to oxygen begins the polymerization process that impedes the penetration of subsequent coats, which only serve to microscopically thicken the layer of dried oil on top of the wood. I did not check end grain absorption.

As to whether thinning a finish will increase penetration, it's my opinion that although the reducer may soak into the wood, the molecules of the drying oil or resin that make up the body of the finish will only penetrate a few wood cells deep, if at all,where they will cure and present a barrier to any further penetration. Subsequent applications, thinned or not, will simply add to the film already started.

Commentary invited.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#2

craigd

Re: A rumination on finishing

craigd

If you want liquid in the wood, you need to add it via the end grain. Dresdner or Flexner has a photo in one of their books of a block of wood with one end grain side sitting in puddle of linseed oil (not "boiled") and the oil has risen to wet the top of the block. Old wooden plane makers would sometimes close the bottom of a plane and fill it with oil, wait for it to soak in and repeat. If you do vacuum infusing and track before/after weights, it can be pretty surprising how much liquid gets into the wood.

Gases are different; ammonia, given enough time, can penetrate an inch or more.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: A rumination on finishing

Moses Yoder

What type of microscope and measuring instruments did you use to examine and measure the penetration?

Re: A rumination on finishing

#4

comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"One of the more enduring finishing beliefs is that BLO and tung oil “soak” into wood".........Wood is not a homogeneous material. I have no doubt that these oils will wick by capillary action into the relatively large open spaces in a wood like oak. These oils will not penetrate the crystalline cellulose regions. And then there is every thing in between. To actually diffuse through the wood the diffusing molecule , oil in this case, must be small enough (these molecules are small enough, barely) and they must be soluble in the wood. I am not thinking these oily tryglycerides are very soluble in either cellulose or lignin. Bottom line, I would speculate the oil will readily wick into large pores, wick slowly into the smaller pores and not diffuse through either the dense cellulose or lignin at any appreciable rate. A penetration of a fraction of a mm seems about right.

accounted for by the difference in molecular weights: 900 for BLO and 250 for tung oil.......I suspect not right ck Tung oil. I presume it is a triglyceride and they all weigh about the same amount

"Because both oils are drying oils, exposure to oxygen begins the polymerization process that impedes the penetration of subsequent coats".......correct. These oils will diffuse at glacial speed, or less, through a cured layer.

"As to whether thinning a finish will increase penetration, it's my opinion that although the reducer may soak into the wood, the molecules of the drying oil or resin that make up the body of the finish will only penetrate a few wood cells deep"......the lower viscosity will speed wicking in pores.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#5

Re: A rumination on finishing

John McGaw

If you want real penetration a bit of force is probably called for and the more viscous the finish the more force will be needed. Take a piece of wood, immerse it in the finish, draw a 25" of Hg vacuum over the entire thing, wait a few minutes (until any bubbling stops) and then slowly drop the vacuum to atmospheric pressure. Then you will have penetration. Of course this is totally impractical for furniture but it is standard practice for bits of wood such a knife scales and pistol grips and can allow finish, often a catalyzed resin, to reach pretty much every pore in even dense woods.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#6

Clint Searl

Ruler and eyeball


Re: A rumination on finishing

#7

Clint Searl

Re: comments

Clint Searl

I couldn't find any reference that cited other than 250 for tung oil. I had speculated that both would be closer.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#8

Clint Searl

Re: A rumination on finishing

Clint Searl

I'm skeptical. My understanding of both the physical and chemical structure of wood is intuitive at best, but my speculation is that the BLO and tung oil molecules are too big to squeeze through the interstitial spaces of the wood, and crossing cell walls does not occur.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#9

wicking and diffusion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Transport through a channel/pore depends on viscosity and ability of the stuff to wet, or not, the pore wall. The size of the molecule is irrelevant for a wicking channel is a huge pipe relative to a molecule size.

Diffusion occurs on the molecule scale. To diffuse the stuff must dissolve in the matrix it is diffusing in. The distance something moves in a given time is greatly, greatly and more greatly dependent on the molecular weight of the stuff diffusing. At room temperature the rate at which oil molecules would diffuse through the solid portions of wood, if indeed oil is soluble in these portions, would be extremely small.

You are right about the barrier the cured film would make. A film will be a continuous layer. To get through it the oil would need to dissolve in it, and then diffuse as molecules through the film.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#10

I used to think similarly...

John in NM

Until I was making some color samples - maple with ferric acetate, followed by various other treatments, and all finished with some oil. BLO being the traditional oil over a musket stock, that is what I used, and thinned according to Stephen's instructions - 50% thinner (turpentine in this case, because I like the smell) for the first application, only 25% for following applications.

Soaked right through the 3/32" or so thick samples.

Thinking this was due to sloppy application perhaps getting oil on the backs too, I later tried it again, puddling oil on a thin piece but taking care to keep it from the edges. Still soaked through.

I never have tested if the results are the same with thick wood as thin. However, based on some experience with cutting up 1960's German army surplus rifle stocks, I would expect reasonably deep penetration of oil if the oil is thinned significantly (half at least), and the oil has sufficient time to penetrate before forming a film. With raw linseed or traditionally boiled linseed, the drying time is slooooow, so this does not present much of a problem.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#11

Tried it once...

John in NM

Results were basically nil extra penetration with BLO. But it was unthinned. I suspect you'd see better results with thinned oil and a vacuum. Maybe I'll try it next week, just for fun.

Most of the bubbling is the liquid boiling at ambient temp - happens under low pressure. If it stops after a short while, you have a leak in your chamber.

I mostly use this stuff for casting resins and silicones. The few times I've needed to stabilize burls or something, it's been cheaper to send it out to a pro, the heat cure resins they use are pretty different from the two part stuff I use for casting parts.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#12

Clint Searl

So...

Clint Searl

It appears that there's general agreement that un-thinned drying oils hardly extend past the surface of wood. But does thinning the oil carry it substantially farther or is it just the thinner soaking/wicking in?

Re: A rumination on finishing

#13

JL

Re: So...

JL

Some thoughts - not that they are that applicable to furniture.

The higher the molecular weight of a molecule - the larger it will be. Smaller molecules will diffuse through pores, openings or whatnot easier than larger molecules. At the same time - like molecules tend to "clump" together - that is one reason why cell membranes hold together. If an oil is thinned - it isn't going to be as viscous and there is a greater chance for a single molecule to wend its way into the wood.

Heat and pressure can help with the diffusion into the wood. I often heat a thinned oil mixture when finishing. I also warm a piece of furniture before finishing w/ oil or an oil mixture (radiant heaters work well for this). I don't really know how you would apply pressure to a piece of furniture. Maybe if you sealed it in a larger container w/ finish and pressurized the finish :D . Obviously impractical.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: So...

Moses Yoder

You can make all the assumptions you want; there are no laws against assuming things, even if those things are wrong. The only issue would be if they end up harming someone which is not likely in this case. A film finish like conversion varnish or laquer or polyurethane is generally agreed does not penetrate the wood, it simply adheres to it. Now you are saying an oil finish like linseed oil or Danish oil does not penetrate the surface either and simply adheres to the wood. I think you are wrong about that. In order to prove you wrong I would have to become a scientist which I have no desire to do. The other option would be just to argue about, both of us with our ignorant assumptions. I recently learned that it is not worth it to argue about something you have no desire to put forth the effort to prove.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#15

reread diffusion vs wicking.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

........or diffusion vs capillary action in more scientific terms. Viscosity and surface tension are the only liquid composition variables that affect transport along a pore . The size of the molecule is irrelevant unless it is big enough to be a polymer and thereby affect viscosity.

Pressure will have an important effect on overcoming the resistance to flow in the pore/capillary. If pressure is used to drive material into the pores the rate of penetration, v, is given by the equation

v = P K/nL where P is the pressure applied, K is a constant that has to do with the geometry of the pore, L is the length of the pore and n is the viscosity of the liquid.

Bottom line: less viscous stuff will penetrate faster. Bigger pores will suck up stuff greatly faster than small pores. Pressure will drive stuff to the core, eventually.

Molecular diffusion is a whole different transport mechanism. To a first approximation it will be governed by Fick's Law

rate of transport = D times C, where C is the difference in concentration between one side of the matrix stuff is diffusing through and the other, and D is the diffusion coefficient of what is diffusing. D gets small real quick when the molecular size gets larger. C is the concentration of the diffusing species dissolved(that is molecularly dispersed and no longer liquid oil) in surface layer of the matrix, in our case wood. In the case of oil and wood C will be so small and D so astronomically tiny at room temperature that we can safely conclude that diffusion of oil molecules will not penetrate oil into wood more than a few atoms deep in days, or weeks.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#16

Actual data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These past few days I was oiling up a wood handle I made for a whisk that had a broken handle . The results were typical of what "oilers" observe when oiling wood.

Step 1 add oil and let it sit for an hour or two, then wipe

Step 2 next day the surface looks dry, I suppose because the oil on the surface has penetrated. Add more oil.

Step 3 after 2-3 days the surface looks dry, I suppose because the oil on the surface has penetrated. Add more oil.

Step 4 after a week the surface looks dry, I suppose because the oil on the surface has penetrated. Add more oil.

Step5 after a month the surface looks dry, I suppose because the oil on the surface has penetrated. Add more oil. (step 5 is anticipated for this handle based on prior experience.

It appears to me that the wood takes up the oil, slowly. But, the process slows down over time, I believe because the oil in the wood cures and provides an effective barrier to further penetration.

There is no doubt that a molecule 1/5 the size of linseed oil can be driven to the center of a 1" board is minutes at elevated temperature and pressure. There is a commercial practice that does it and you can buy this deck product at some Lowes.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#17

Re: Actual data

Barry Irby

Bill this reminds me of something I learned a long time ago when I was a kid. To finish a walnut gunstock with linseed oil you apply "a coat an hour for a day, a coat a day for a week, a coat a week for a month, a coat a month for a year and a coat a year for life." I was fairly far into this when I loaned my gun to my cousin. He did not like the blotchy appearance so he sloped on a coat of varnish. Thanks a lot.

I am very interested in your explanations of the various mechanisms of wicking and diffusion. I look at these things all the time on Home Inspections. Particularly related to wet crawl spaces. Thanks for taking the time. I am trying to get a grip on such terms as Adhesion and Cohesion. Interesting to me that water vapor is a DRY gas. It can diffuse through building materials without wetting them.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#18

bulk vs molecular properties

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If we start with a bunch of Lego blocks spread about on the floor and then fasten them together into some structure it will be obvious that the properties of the assembled Legos(say a house) will be different from the scattered blocks.

And so it is with molecules. Widely separated from one another, for example water vapor, individual molecules have vastly different properties than when they are assembled.

Assemble a bunch of water molecules together so they stick to one another a bit and you get water. In the liquid water the oxygen of each water molecule is loosely stuck to the hydrogen atoms of several other water molecules. The result is that every water molecule is loosely attached to every other water molecule. Hooked together this way the assembly of water molecules can so things that one molecule (Lego block) can't, like dissolve salt. Conversely, individual water molecules because they are tiny can do things that water can't, like diffuse through wood, drywall and even a coating of varnish.

Cool the liquid water and the sticking together gets more tight and ice forms. It is like locking the Legos together to make one stuck together block of Legos. In this state one can not push a stick through the assembled mass of Legos, for example. Clearly this stuck together block of Legos has greatly different properties than when they were widely scattered on the floor.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#19

Lots of good info, a few missing items

Michael Dresdner

Interesting thread.

Several entries noted that if the molecule is small enough, it will penetrate any hole that is big enough. That is correct, but there are other factors that can come into play. One is that wood is, oddly enough, both hyrdrophilic and lipophilic, the latter meaning it will "help" oil penetrate to some degree because it has components that will favorably "attract" it (for lack of a more accurate and less clear term). Another is Brownian motion; the warmer a liquid is, the more active the molecules are, and that, too, can help penetration, as several entries noted.

While thinning oil does not change its molecular weight (the size of the molecule) it can separate molecules so there is less aggregation, and correspondingly less stearic hindrance, thus it has an easier time penetrating. However, there is also a down side to this; thinning means less oil will penetrate (since a percentage of what goes into the wood is solvent) and once the solvent evaporates, the oil will more quickly start to polymerize, thus forming a barrier to further penetration.

For that reason, if you want maximum oil penetration, warm the wood, the oil, or both, and used pure unthinned oil, but instead of wiping it on, soak the entire part for as long as is reasonable. I typically soak parts at least overnight, and sometimes 24 hours (as in the case of maple). The wood must be completely immersed, and in an atmosphere free of oxygen, so no polymerization takes place and you will get the maximum penetration. Putting on a "coat" and letting it dry before adding another coat is counterproductive to penetration.

As for molecular weights, I don't know where those numbers came from but both linseed and tung oil are mixtures of a number of different triglycerides, each of which is a different weight. Thus, the numbers bandied about are average molecular weights. Smaller components of the oils will still move more easily. As for the averages, both oils are in the same general ball park. The number usually used is around 750, (when you buy it as a formulator, it is sold not as a molecular weight but as a range of molecular weights) but even taking tung oil from a different tree will change the average molecular weight. Still, we are talking about numbers small enough to penetrate most woods. It is worth mentioning that since we are not processing our own cold pressed oils, the processing of what we buy can also alter both the average molecular weight and the rheology (willingness to flow easily vs. resistance to flow.)

And yes, different woods have different penetration rates, because they are more or less dense, with smaller or larger pores. Thus, the type of wood has even more impact than the type of oil. Try applying oil to poplar vs. boxwood and you will see what I mean.

Others mentioned pressure or vacuum, and yes, both will help penetration by driving or drawing out moisture and air and allowing, in this case, oil, to replace it more easily.

Finally, this whole thread raises an interesting question. What is the advantage of a finish that penetrates deeper, when the main use of a finish is to help shed dirt and water, and to improve the appearance? Sometimes deeper is not necessarily better. Certainly, protection increases not with deeper penetration, but with more surface build, if protection is your main objective. As for appearance, beyond a certain depth, we simply can't see a difference. Again, this is not to suggest there are not reasons for wanting oil impregnated more; I'm sure there are. It's just that there's a lot to be said for understanding what your objectives are in each stage/step of the finishing process so you can know what you need to seek, and what you don't.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#20

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Michael

Ellis Walentine

This surely adds a lot to my understanding of the subject. I appreciate your weighing in.

Ellis

Re: A rumination on finishing

#21

I Gotta Ask ...

Joe Burke

Describe the "parts" you might soak over night as well as what sort of container ... how much oil ... etc.

I suppose I could just ask for a "for instance".

Re: A rumination on finishing

#22

Examples? Sure!

Michael Dresdner

Small parts are fairly easy. I recently did a belt buckle, an espresso tamper, several bracelets, napkin rings, and other parts of that size and ilk -- one at a time, of course, except for the bracelet, napkin ring, scarf ring "stack" which nest and go into one bag. I take a zip lock plastic bag large enough for the parts, put the part(s) in, pour in some oil, squeeze out the excess air, then seal the bag. Whatever oil is not absorbed you pour out of the bag and use again, so there is virtually no waste. For kitchen tool handles, where the metal part is already attached, I find a jar about the right diameter, pop the part in, fill with oil, shove plastic wrap on the top surface, soak, and again, re-use whatever is not absorbed. For larger items, like cutting boards, I'll use either larger garbage bags, or put the board in a tray and cover it, laying a sheet of plastic directly onto the oil surface, again, to prevent a surface crust from forming. Where it is impossible to avoid an air space, blow Bloxygen into it to remove the oxygen. I've used things like cardboard trays (make them any size and shape you need) lined with plastic garbage bags, to keep the oil where you want it and use only enough oil to coat, and not gallons more.

On those rare cases when things can't be immersed, but I still want a deep oil penetration, I go the labor intensive route; simply stand there and keep flooding the surface of the wood with oil until it stops showing dry spots. It takes a surprisingly long time; even maple, which stops quickly, can take more than a half an hour.

However, it is rare that I use oil to penetrate on large pieces. For the most part, I only use penetration on kitchen items that will be washed repeatedly. Items that are not washed, but are handled a lot (pens, letter openers, etc.) don't need as much penetration; each time you handle the item, the sebaceous oil from your hands adds to the build of the finish. Take a look at old "unfinished" stairwell handrails and you will see what I mean.

On furniture, I generally want a surface finish, and the only thing I'll use oil for is appearance (popping the grain.) To do that, you don't need very much penetration. Simply flood the piece and keep re-wetting it for about 15 minutes, then wipe it off. That's enough for grain popping, and once the oil is dry and cured (usually about one to two days for boiled linseed oil) you can continue with whatever top coat finish you've chosen.

Does that help?

Re: A rumination on finishing

#23

Makes Sense ...

Joe Burke

I tend to be myopic ... or maybe have tunnel vision ... at times. It's been so long since I built anything that didn't need a truck to deliver, or install, that something like a napkin ring or bracelet didn't cross my mind. Also, I've been spraying so long I've sorta forgotten about using oil at all. Once in a while to pop grain as you said.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#24

Clint Searl

Re: Examples? Sure!

Clint Searl

"On furniture, I generally want a surface finish, and the only thing I'll use oil for is appearance (popping the grain.)"

Which raises the question of whether an oil, BLO in particular, emphasizes the grain any more than anything else that "wets" the wood; or if it's the attendant yellow cast that highlights the light and dark differently.

I recall reference to an FWW article which I think debunked the "popping" power of BLO.

Re: A rumination on finishing

#25

BLO and grain popping

Michael Dresdner

There are two components to emphasizing figured grain, or popping the grain.

First, you need something that will impregnate the wood and act as a lens, adding clarity the wood fiber. Think about what happens when you put oil (any oil) on a brown paper bag, then hold it up to the light. It makes the paper more translucent. The same happens with oil and wood; the upshot is that the wood appears to have more depth. This is because light actually goes a bit deeper before being reflected because we have made the very top of the surface more translucent and less opaque. Naturally, this can be done with either clear or colored materials.

The second component of popping the grain is contrast. By adding color to the end grain of figured wood, it makes it contrast more with the flat grain. Thus, something that adds a bit of color, like BLO, will make the figure even more obvious.

BLO does both jobs simultaneously, and that is why it is so popular as a grain popper.

I don't know what FW article you are referring to, but do realize that not everything in print (or online, for that matter) is correct. This is not to impugn whomever the writer was either; I quit one magazine abruptly when an editor changed the content of what I had written to coincide with what he believed, so somewhere out there is some blatantly incorrect information published under my name. It, along with misinformation from "whispering down the lane" is what we writers must constantly contend with.