I've got a 3/4" copper supply line to the hot water heater, with a small leak at a 3/4" sweated coupling that I'm sure will develop into a catastrophe at some point. On one side of the coupling is about an 18" section of pipe (other end of 18" is sweated to 90° elbow), the other side of the leaking coupling is long 3/4" pipe back to the water supply.
Option 1: Cut the coupling out of the long side, replace the coupling and the 18" section with sweated copper.
Option 2: Cut out the coupling and install SharkBite Push-to-Fit Slip Coupling.
Option 2 is very appealing but I'm so old that threaded iron or sweated copper is all I've come to be comfortable with.
They work great - so much quicker than getting out the torch and solder. And if necessary they're removable - just ask for the removal tool (less than $1) when you buy your sharkbite .
I've used probably a dozen over the years and never had a failure of any kind but you shouldn't use them where you need the pipe to be rigid. There is a bit of play in the joint and the pipe can spin in the fitting.
My neighbor, a plumber, says they're supposed to be guaranteed for 25 years but he'd be a bit leary of using them behind a closed-up wall.......although I have with no failures.
Yes they work. I have had good luck with them. Be sure the end of the pipe is clean, free of solder and corrosion. Might even clean it with fine sandpaper or steel wool.
They also make flexible lines that are threaded on one end to screw into the tank and a Shark Bite on the other end. They come in different lengths. I would try to "keep it simple" and use as few fittings as possible. If you screw it into the tank, use pipe dope or Teflon tape. Some of the borgs carry Shark Bite and the others carry Gator Bite. Can't tell the difference in performance.
These fittings are not designed to withstand mechanical strain. So, if your connection requires flexing a pipe or leaning hard on the water heater to close the connection, Don't. Figure out an arrangement to allow the pressing together of the fittings without leaving them under a strain.
I was amazed that they work. After a long belly crawl, I was under the old home place with just 12" to 15" clearance to work under floor joist. First couple of attempts it had a small leak. I was cussing and saying things like, "I knew this was to good to be true". Finally got the pipe ends in perfect alignment and "snap"....job done, no leaks.
The inventor probably owns his own island somewhere and he deserves it.
I hope the thieves that tried to steal the plumbing caught pneumonia.
You are right, If you don't seat them properly, they will leak.
Pay close attention to the instructions and put a mark on the pipes as recommended to be sure you have pushed it all the way in. In difficult locations it is harder than it seems, but when they seat they work and the difference is night and day.
Your question is very timely. I have some plumbing work to do as well and have been looking at the SharkBite push fit fittings for use with copper and PEX pipes. From what I understand, this stuff has been around for a few years and it seems like people's skepticism is beginning to fade.
About a year and a half ago I was in Lowe's searching for a ball valve to replace the standard shut-off valve to my water heater. I explained to the clerk, who seemed knowledgeable, what I was doing. Knowing I would need a new elbow fitting he recommended this new fangled thing that just slipped onto the pipe. I was skeptical but a fellow standing behind us spoke up and said they worked for him.
Took it home with the little plastic thing to remove it if needed and put it on. I bet I stood there after turning the water supply back on and waited quite a while before walking away. Even then, I later returned from time to time checking for a leak. The darned thing is still working and I think they're the coolest thing since sliced bread.
I was a licensed contractor plumber for a several years (side job), I really can't comment on the "Shark Bite" connectors as I have never used them. (I did retire from contracting about 15 years ago.) I do however trust the brass ferrule type connectors, as I have used them in Water, Air and Hydraulic connections without any failure. When used properly (not overtightened) I have never seen any failure with these connections even under high pressure and in my opinion they are as easy to use as any other type on the market.
Normally I would just solder a threaded fitting on in your application then add a flex copper water heater connection kit. However if you lack the tools, or experience to install a soldered fitting (or it is in a place where a torch would be dangerous), I would certainly install a ferrule fitting. These should be installed on a "clean" pipe- sand to remove any corrosion etc. Hand tighten the fitting then wrench tighten 1/2 to 3/4 rotation. Pressurize the system and check for leaks, if you see any seepage, just tighten a 1/4 turn at a time and check until it seals. The ferrule fittings are as solid as the pipe, and will not rotate nor flex at all.
The reason I recommend a "kit" with the flex lines installed is that replacing the water heater later is a snap, as they will accommodate variations in height and spacing between pipes in later heaters.