Re: …or hearing protection
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
Choice of mallet is, I think, a very personal thing, with lots of different parameters affecting its performance. I think some of my permantne thearing damage is due to a wooden mallet striking a wooden carcase during a glue-up. Also, I've had furniture surfaces damaged due to wooden mallet blows.
While mallet durability at the extreme end of the scale may give some indication of cutting board durability, and lend support for Ellis's hunch, whether there is a significant practical difference would be a lot more difficult to determine, and would probably not be worth the effort of the testing, especially considering all the variables. My recommendation would be use what you have, be it a semi-hardening vege-oil, BLO, Watco, Waterlox, Salad Bowl Finish, or even a Poly wiping varnish. If it has a petroleum distilate carrier, make sure all odor of the carrier is gone before you use the cutting board. Hopefully, all of our noses are trained well enough to tell the difference between mineral spirits (even the "odorless" variety), naptha, and turpentene on one hand and triglycerides, EVOO, etc., on the other.