"crowd editing" cutting board finishes
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
This is an experiment for participation.
Possibly more than any other topic, the question of how to finish a cutting board comes up on this Forum. It gets tedious for all (presumably) typing the same answers several time a year. The solution is the WoodCentral Articles section. Here topics of general interest are posted. Persons posting a new question can simply be pointed to the article. So, we need a good article on cutting board finish and Ellis has asked that I wrote it up. He will use his considerable talent as an editor to edit the final Article. Here is your chance to make your thoughts on the topic preserved in an Article.
If you want to add or change something send me an email with the information
The Article is in two parts. First there is a summary of common finishes. Following, is a discussion, simplified but not misleading, of the chemistry involved.
Finish for functional cutting boards and butcher block counter tops
Cutting boards and counter tops can be finished to help preserve them and make them more easily cleaned, or they can be finished to achieve and maintain some appearance. This article focuses on preserving a cutting board to make it long lasting and easy to clean without regard to appearance.
The main reason to add some sort of protective coating to a cutting board is to repel food from entering the wood pores and make cleaning it easier. This treatment must coat and partially fill the wood pores and be resistant to washing, yet it must be easy to maintain and restore. There are 4 common treatments:
1. Mineral Oil The wood is soaked in mineral oil, USP or food grade, available from the drug store. Some heat the oil while others heat the wood to aid penetration. The treatment is quick, cheap and it looks good for items to be sold. The board may feel oily after treatment and oil may bleed out of the wood for some time. This treatment is the least durable.
2. Mineral Oil and Wax Paraffin wax is dissolved in hot mineral oil and the resulting solution applied to the board. The mineral oil aids penetration of the wax. This treatment is durable but more involved.
3. Walnut Oil The wood is treated as it would be with linseed oil. Wipe it on. Wipe the excess off. Walnut oil is a drying oil. It cures after oxygen exposure to a protective film like linseed oil. (see chemistry section for details)
4. Cooking/Vegetable Oil This controversial treatment is both handy and durable. It is applied like the walnut oil. Wipe it on, then wipe the excess off. Repeat when the board appears “dry”. These oils are more viscous than mineral oil, and depending on the plant source they can cure more or less quickly to become even more viscous or even a durable film. They stick to the wood better than mineral oil. Every kitchen has some on hand to be reapplied as needed.
This treatment is controversial because some object that a cooking oil treatment will become “rancid”. This claim is irrelevant for a board that is going to be used to knead bread, cut up meats and similar activities involving food that contains fats and oils. In use, the board is going to pick up some amount of vegetable oil and animal fat which will simply add to the cooking oil previously applied to the board. Upon close inspection a used wood cutting board is going to smell like a used cutting board no matter the pretreatment. If the faint odor of a used wood cutting board is unacceptable it would be better to use a plastic cutting board and run it through the dishwasher.
The chemistry that occurs to make these odors is identical to the curing of linseed oil and walnut oil and no harmful products are generated. The odors result from the same volatile organic acids and related compounds that provide flavor and odor to fermented and cultured products like cheese and bread.
In summary, cooking oil provides a handy means of treating a cutting board with a reasonably durable protective film.
The Chemistry of cutting board treatments
This chemistry section provides more details about the chemistry of fats and oils and how it compares to the mineral oil treatment.
Mineral oil and Paraffin wax are products of refining petroleum. They belong to a class of chemicals called “hydrocarbons”. Cooking oil, vegetable oil, walnut oil and fats belong to a class of chemicals called triglycerides. These chemicals are used by plants and animals to store energy. Animals store triglycerides that we call “fat” to get the animal through “hard times”. Plants store triglycerides that we call “oils” in their seeds to provide energy for germination.
Hydrocarbons are composed of just carbon and hydrogen. In general, for each carbon atom in the molecule there are two hydrogen atoms, that is, the ratio of carbon atoms to hydrogen atoms is 1:2, except at the ends of the molecule, a detail we can ignore for this discussion. The simplest and smallest hydrocarbon is methane. A molecule of methane has one carbon, ethane (2 carbons), propane (3 carbons), butane(4 carbons). Naptha is a mixture of hydrocarbon molecules that are made up from 5 to 7 carbons, Mineral spirits is a mixture of 7-12 carbon containing molecules, mineral oil is a mixture of molecules that contain about 15 to 20 carbons, paraffin wax is a mixture containing more than 20 carbon atoms per molecule and poly(ethylene) molecules contain 50,000 carbons, more or less. As the hydrocarbon molecule contains more carbon and hydrogen the material becomes less volatile starting at methane which is a gas, mineral spirits which is a liquid, paraffin wax which is a solid and finally poly(ethylene), a special class of solids with special properties that we call a polymer.
Hydrocarbons are not affected by exposure to air or moderate heat. When mineral oil or paraffin wax is added to a cutting board it remains unaltered over time. These materials are essentially tasteless and odorless and they will remain colorless, unlike the plant oils.
Plant oils and animal fats are natural products chemists call triglycerides. The name is derived from the fact that the triglyceride molecule contains three (tri) organic acid molecules attached to a glycerin molecule (glyceride). The organic acids are made up of carbon and hydrogen just like hydrocarbons but they also have carbon, hydrogen and oxygen at one end of the molecule that makes them acidic. We are familiar with many organic acids- formic(1 carbon), acetic(2 carbons), butyric acid (4 carbons), stearic acid (18 carbons). The acids in triglycerides typically contain 16 and/or 18 carbon atoms. These acids are collectively referred to as “fatty acids”.
The acids that make triglycerides usually have some carbon atoms that are deficient in hydrogen, that is the ratio of carbon atoms to hydrogen atoms in a fatty acid is typically less than 1:2, unlike like the case for a hydrocarbon.. These “deficient” carbon atoms will react with oxygen when exposed to air. When they react with oxygen one of two things can happen. The site where the oxygen has reacted can cleave off a piece of the fatty acid. The piece that cleaves off will become a smaller acid or related molecule. These smaller acids have a strong and characteristic smell that can be detected in tiny concentrations. These same acids are made by bacteria during fermentation and “culturing” and result in the characteristic odor of many cheeses, buttermilk, bread, etc. When these odors are associated with fats and oils that have reacted with oxygen we say the oil has become rancid.
After reacting with oxygen, instead of breaking off a piece of the fatty acid molecule to make a smelly acid, the triglyceride molecule can attach to another triglyceride molecule. The resulting molecule is twice as large, less volatile and more viscous.
The various fats and oils differ from one another in how many of their carbon atoms are deficient in hydrogen and therefore are more or less prone to react with oxygen. If there are a lot of deficiencies like in the case of linseed oil, or walnut oil, there will be a greater probability of one triglyceride molecule adding on to another. After exposure to oxygen for some time lots of triglyceride molecules will have added to one another to make a giant molecule we call a polymer. Polymers are tough and rubbery and make a good coating. We refer to this chemistry of adding together triglyceride molecules to make a tough film as “curing” or “drying” the oil. Chemists call it “polymerization and crosslinking”. In addition to curing/drying, the oil will also be splitting off smaller volatile acids that give these films their characteristic odor, especially in a confined space.
Oils like olive oil and saffron oil have fewer carbon atoms deficient in hydrogen. They can’t react enough to make a tough film. They don’t even react enough to generate many smaller stinky acids. In between are the oils like soy and corn. They will react with oxygen to generate smaller acids and they will react with one another to make big molecules. But they don’t react (cure) enough, or in a short enough time, to be as good as linseed oil or walnut oil for furniture finishing. Never-the-less they cure enough to stick well to a cutting broad.
The fats and oils that accumulate with use, as well as the accepted walnut oil (or anything else with organic oil in its name- linseed, Tung, etc., experience identical reaction with oxygen to generate the same volatile products as adding some oil from the cooking oil bottle. So, for a cutting board that gets used it will smell the same whether it gets freshened up with oil from the cooking oil bottle or not.





