Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

Posts

The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#1

The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

William Duffield

They've created another dysfunctional tool, at an absurd price.

http://www.woodpeck.com/ottpaoliniplanergauge.html

You might find something exquisite from John Economaki worth paying for and waiting for, but this bauble is really questionable.

You probably already have the tool you should be using to do this job, not to mention a lot of other essential shop functions. For example there is this one, at about half the price, and you can have it in hand next week, and not next March.

http://store.harryepstein.com/cp/Squares/7104-4R.html

Mine is nearly as accurate as my Starretts, and is easier to read than most of them, because the blade has a satin finish. The blade is hardened, so unlike the melamine surface of the pecker tool, it should last for a century or two and still be readable and accurate.

Many years ago, I bought one of the cheap aluminum versions of the planer gauge, but I never use it, because it has no real uses. It sits unused it the same nook I dropped it into in my tool chest when I got it.

Remember, you are probably running each of your pieces of stock through your planer multiple times, and you need to check each board each time it comes out of the planer, to decide whether it has been reduced to the required thickness, and also how much you need to crank down the planer head for the next pass. If the board is too thick, it doesn't fit, but you can't tell how much more needs to be removed. The bigger problem is remembering the target thickness, and consistently finding the right gap in the tool.

With a double square, you "set and forget". Offer the square up to the stock as it comes off the planer, and you can feel the amount that needs to come off with the tip of your thumb, so you don't even need to blow the dust off your glasses to read the measurement. The 4" double square is continuously variable, so you can easily set it to the nearest 64th of an inch, from 3" down to the thinnest piece of wood you can feed throught your planer. If you're counting, that's 192 different settings, not a paltry 13.

But wait, there's more. There are all the other uses for the double square, from marking tenon shoulders to checking jointer fence squareness, table saw blade squareness, and bandsaw table squareness, to router bit height to Forstner bit depth, scribing a line parallel to an existing face, and the list of real functions goes on. If you need metric as well as imperial, just get another blade. You don't have to pay for another whole square. Note that Dominos also come in thicknesses of 4, 5, 6 and 8 mm., all less than the 9 mm. minimum gap provided by the Paolini. "Recommended" stock thicknesses for Dominos (3x tenon thickness, FWIW) also include 30, 36 and 40 mm., all beyond the limits of the Paolini.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#2

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

Ralph Lipeles

This tool is obviously aimed toward visually impaired woodworkers or those that cannot read a scale.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#3

As a card carrying peckerhead,

Joe shelton

and self-appointed spokesman for the clan, I say you've mistakenly applied the sobriquet.

They have an elegant solution to a problem that doesn't exist. Just call them dilettantes.

And thanks for that link to a cheap, good tool.

Joe

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#4

William - thanks for that link

Howard in Toronto

As for the PeckerHeads, if you can make a living answering a question no-one asked............

It'd be interesting to find out how many people eventually twig to the fact they could just use dial calipers or anything else they probably already own.

Howard

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#5

Re: Richard Heads, Inc.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

A. I plane all the stock I need for a given project at the same time.

B. I use a digital micrometer to check my thickness

C. I have absolutely no use for such a plastic fantastic hoogee.

You sure this didn't come from American Handyman?

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#6

Thickness planer aids

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have run thousands of bdft through a planer and never discovered a need for a tool such as this one. A caliper, on the other hand, stayed close by.

There are two situations in thickness planing that require a thickness measurement and one that doesn't.

Case 1. Planing rough stock for a project. I never plane rough stock for a project to a target thickness. I plane till it gets cleaned up and quit there. No measurement required. The way I build stuff, taking measurements off the project as it evolves, makes planing to a target, say 13/16", irrelevant. Doesn't matter if in fact it is really 27/64. We rarely planed customer lumber to any specific thickness. 4/4 came out about 13/16" but rarely exactly 13/16"

Case 2 If your machine won't hog off 1/4" if it encounters a thick end it may be useful to know the starting thickness of stock so the bed can be set so as to not stall the machine.

Case 3 For fitting something it can be required to hit some exact thickness. In this case an initial measurement is essential, which when coupled to the knowledge of how much lumber gets removed per turn of the handle will enable one to hit a target to a small fraction of an inch.

The pricey tool disparaged by Mr. Duffiled isn't useful for any of these common tasks. A caliper, on the other hand, is perfect for the task.

The square described is so handy it stays in my apron pocket or on the bench but I don't prefer it to a caliper at the planer. It is likely the most used tool in the shop when I am building stuff. If you don't own one consider a purchase. Mine is from Lee Valley and it is a quality tool.

There was the day I left the caliper on the board as it fed into the planer. It was not a happy outcome. I kept the carnage by the machine as a reminder to not do that again.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#7

probably what inspired it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The end of some lumber rules have notches to gauge 4/4,5/4 etc lumber thickness and they look like that tool. In theory one can slip the rule over the edge of the board and determine what thickness grade it belongs in. I have never seen a lumber grader use this feature.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#8

Lumber Grader

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I used to buy wood from an old guy in my area. His name was Simpson Agin, but everyone called him "Simmy". He sawed and air-dried every stick of the 200,000+ bf in his barns, and would impart his knowledge of how to cut and dry any given species of wood for free.

You could pick up any board in the place and Simmy could tell you the exact amount of board feet in that piece from 12 feet away. He'd then hand you a rule and grader's stick and challenge you to prove him wrong.

Boards weren't marked.

He was never (NEVER) wrong.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#9

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

Thomas S Stockton

"Looks like something Handyman club of america"©2013 Mark Mandell, would make of plastic and send out with their sales info and stickers.

Tom

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#10

Stealing

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

my lines!

:D :D

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#11

Re: Stealing

Thomas S Stockton

Guilty as charged totally missed that

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#12

Re: Sss'alRite

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I learned to share at an early age

:D :D

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#13

That was my first thought too...

John in NM

The Handyman Club or whatever it is must be updating their free gifts.

I can't figure out why they think it's worth $30... sell the same for 5 or 10 and they'd sell an awful lot more of them, and the volume would probably make up for the smaller margin.

Maybe I should be one of those highly paid marketing execs :D

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#14

Inexpensive and accurate enough *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

One of these works well enough most of the time. If I need higher accuracy I use one of several micrometers.


Accurate to 1/32"

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Interesting.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The packaging in the link you shared claims 1/16" accuracy, you said 1/32", and I see markings at 1/32" spacing--which can be eyeballed to as many as 10 increments (according to what I learned about measurement in chemistry and physics classes many, many years ago). Personally, I would probably not go beyond dividing the markings by 4, which would be 1/128" accuracy, or better than 0.01", which is good enough for the vast majority of woodworking in my book.

Jason

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#16

$11.59 at Woodcraft

Ray Newman

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2007281/4443/Thickness-Gauge.aspx

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#17

Re: $11.59 at Woodcraft

William Duffield

I've used that Woodcraft caliper, and it works. I've also used dial calipers and vernier calipers. They work, too. I've never put one through my planer, like Bill did. :( I've also used outside calipers that you have to set from a separate ruler.

Do yourself a favor, if you have a small double square or even a combination square, try it out and see if it meets your needs for this application, before purchasing a new tool, or even before subjecting a fragile, expensive tool to the rigors of measuring large hunks of rough sawn lumber.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#18

Re: $11.59 at Woodcraft

Ray Newman

I posted that in case anyone was looking for an even cheaper version.

I utilize a 4" adjustable square that to measure board thickness coming off the planer.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#19

Re: $11.59 at Woodcraft

William Duffield

I hope you don't think I was complaining about that particular calipers, or any calipers. Like a square, with calipers, you can look up your target thickness and "set and forget". That can be important when one's short term memory, like mine, is "going the way of the dodo bird."

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#20

Kneale Brownson

Re: William - thanks for that link

Kneale Brownson

Who needs tools? A flat surface and you can match up lumber thicknesses with your fingertips.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#21

Fingertips - that's how I do it, too

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't measure much of anything anyway, unless it comes to plywood. Angles, square, that's worth paying attention to, but not dimensions. I just go by looks.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#22

Where this approach fails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In planing, or thickness sanding, suppose board 1 is thicker than the target board 2. This situation is most common in my shop. How to proceed?

I submit that the best way to proceed is to know how much thicker board 1 is than board 2, then set the planer to take off the difference. This need requires some means of measuring thickness. If a precise match is required a precise measuring device is required (a caliper). Any rule (I may use the edge of a tape measure) works when less precision is required.

I agree that in the case where one simply wants to know if two boards are the same that putting them together and feeling is quick and sufficiently precise.

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#23

Re: $11.59 at Woodcraft

Ray Newman

W'm. no, did not take it as a criticism. I just posted it because some of the Craft are looking for economical gifts for the fast approaching holiday season

Re: The Peckerheads Have Done It Again

#24

Re: Where this approach fails

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I do this by process of elimination and the last pass through the planer makes them identical regardless of the measurement.