Funny, I wrote an article, too
Ellis Walentine
... for CWB, back in 2000. Here is the text of the article minus the chart and photos. It's old information but still pretty current....
CWB Tests
BISCUIT JOINERS
We sort out the differences between 10 leading models.
by Ellis Walentine
Biscuit joinery is an vital operation in many custom and production woodworking shops. It is one of the simplest methods for making strong, accurate joints in wood and man-made materials, by cutting crescent-shaped slots in mating pieces and gluing the pieces together with oval-shaped, compressed wood "biscuits" in the slots. The dedicated portable power tool that cuts the grooves is called a biscuit joiner.
Since Lamello invented the first portable biscuit joiner in 1955, these tools—also known as "plate joiners"—have become immensely popular among professional and amateur woodworkers everywhere. Originally designed for fast, accurate plywood case construction, biscuit joiners also offer unique alternatives to traditional joinery methods in many furniture and millwork applications. When combined with shop-made fixtures that locate the joiner in relation to the workpiece, the biscuit joiner becomes a versatile production tool for frames, doors, coopered assemblies and other specialized tasks.
For this test, our team of editors and experienced woodworkers compared the performance of eight leading corded biscuit joiners, along with the new cordless model from DeWalt and a scaled-down, mini-biscuit model from Ryobi that can be handy for very small or narrow work. Our ratings appear with the tool specifications in the chart on pages XX-XX.
What's Important?
At first glance, most biscuit joiners appear to be quite similar to each other. The models we tested (with the exception of the Ryobi models) have an angle-grinder-style motor, equipped with a 4-in.-dia. blade. The motor slides forward and backward in a base assembly that has a vertical fence at the business end. This fence keeps the blade perpendicular to the edge or face of the workpiece. A multi-position turret stop on the base limits the plunge depth for various sized biscuits.
But, that's where the similarity ends. Manufacturers have adopted very different approaches to many key aspects of biscuit joiner design. The most striking differences we found among our test models were in the fences; but we also found significant differences in ergonomics, "fit and finish" and switch operation. We chose these four factors as our primary rating criteria. (See chart.) Other factors, such as blade-changing, accuracy and dust collection also figured into our ratings.
Fences
For the simplest and most common biscuit joining task—making right-angle butt joints in 3/4-inch stock using the base of the tool as a reference (see photos, DIRECTION) —all biscuit joiners function very much alike. Because their blades are centered approximately 3/8 inch above the base, no auxiliary fences or adjustments are necessary for this operation.
For other types of cuts, most biscuit joiners have ingenious, and sometimes elaborate, fence systems to accommodate different angles and heights of cut.
Height adjustment is critical for slotting material of different thicknesses and for cutting multiple slots across the width of an edge. We found two fundamentally different approaches to height adjustment in our test models.
On half of our test tools—the Porter-Cable, the Ryobi JM80, the two DeWalt models and the Craftsman—you move the entire fence up and down to set the height. Of these five models, we lliked the DeWalt-style fences (including the Craftsman, which is made by DeWalt) the best. Their independent double rack-and-pinion mechanisms keep the fence parallel to the blade and are easy to use. The Porter-Cable has two nicely machined rods to guide the vertical travel; but it relies on the same locking knobs for both the pivot and height adjustment, and it doesn’t have detents for common angles, so you tend to lose the angle setting when you need to change heights. Also, you have to turn a fine-pitched screw to raise and lower the fence—a tedious operation. Similarly, changing angle and height adjustments on the Ryobi felt like a three-handed operation.
The rest of our standard-sized test models—the Lamellos, the Makita and the Freud—had detachable perpendicular guides that can be moved up and down on the fence to adjust the height. The Makita, with its self-aligning, single rack-and-pinion mechanism, was the easiest of these to use. The two Lamello models and the Freud required you to hold one side of the detachable guide against the dovetail way while tightening the locking lever, and the Freud’s guide was a bit fussy to install. The Lamellos had a nifty feature: an 1/8-inch plastic shim plate that snaps easily onto the detachable fence, so you can quickly alternate between appropriate blade heights for 3/4-inch and 1/2-inch material without readjusting the fence itself.
Another thoughtful and extremely useful height-adjustment not directly related to the fence was the height-adjustment knob on the Lamello Top 20. This made it possible to adjust the blade height on-the-fly, independent of fence settings, with repeatability of 1/4000 inch.
Angle adjustment is important for slotting mitered edges. The fences on our test models all pivoted on quadrant-style hinges, allowing you to reference the fence on the inside face of the board, with the contact surface of the base against the miter. (See photo, DIRECTION.) Most of the fences pivoted from 0 (upright, perpendicular to the base) to 90 (straight forward, parallel to the base), but the fences on the Porter-Cable 557 and the Ryobi JM80 tilted further, to 135, allowing them to reference on the outside face of miters up to 45. The other joiners had a small 45 notch in either the pivoting fence or the detachable guide for this purpose. (See photos, DIRECTION.)
For slotting miters, we preferred fences with built-in height adjustments over those with detachable guides, because they allow you to place the slot anywhere on the miter. The detachable-guide models all placed the slot too far from the inside edge of the miter, making it impossible, for example, to join 1/2-inch material to 3/4-in material with the inside corners aligned, without cutting all the way through the 1/2-inch material. We were able to correct for this on the Lamello models by using the plastic shim plate on the fence and settling for #10 biscuits. On square-edged stock, the Lamellos and the Freud provided the widest range of height adjustment. (See chart.)
When we sorted out all these fence functions and interactions, it was clear that none of the fence systems covered all the possibilities perfectly. We gave high marks to the DeWalt fences (including the Craftsman) because of their superior adjustability, and to the Lamello fences for their large range of depth adjustments and their ease of use in the most common biscuit-joining situations. (See photos, DIRECTION.)
We downrated the Makita and Freud models because they didn't allow us to reference off the inside faces of mitered boards with any degree of adjustability. We also downrated the Ryobi JM80's fence because it was so awkward to adjust. The Porter-Cable's fence was versatile and thoughtfully designed, but it didn't have detents for common angle settings, and the height-adjustment screw was tedious to use.
Ergonomics
In overall user-friendliness, we didn't find any earth-shaking differences between our test models; most earned ratings in the good-to-excellent range. The Ryobi models scored slightly lower because of their high center of gravity, the result of their direct-drive motors. We also downrated the new battery-powered DeWalt 932 because it was much heavier than other models and felt off-balance, especially in the vertical operating position.
Fit and finish
This is a measure of quality craftsmanship, as evidenced by machine tolerances, surface finishes and smoothness of operation. The two Swiss-made Lamello models won top honors in this category, followed by the Porter-Cable, which costs considerably less. The rest of our test models scored in the fair-to-good range in this category.
Switches
All of our test tools rated at least fair in the switch department, but there were a couple standouts—the DeWalt 682 and the Porter-Cable—which we found very accessible and easy-to-use. Of these two, we preferred the Porter-Cable because of its conveniently located lock-on button; it takes two hands to lock the DeWalt's switch in the "on" position. We found the Freud's rocker switch counterintuitive and a bit awkward; you have to pull it backwards to activate it. The Lamello Top 20 had the only safety trigger of the group, which we appreciated; unprotected trigger switches are very easy to activate accidentally.
Other decision factors.
Besides our four main rating criteria, we also noted several other factors that could sway your purchasing decision:
Accuracy. Biscuit slots need to be straight— that is, parallel to the base or fence of the tool, not tilted left or right. If they aren’t, the discrepancy is doubled when the two parts of the joint are brought together. The result is that biscuits fit too tightly if at all, and create built-in tension in the joint itself, which can lead to twisted or misaligned parts.
When we measured some test slots (see photo, DIRECTION), we found that four models—the two Lamellos, the Makita and the Porter-Cable—were dead-on, or nearly so. (See chart.) We liked the Makita’s unique linear-bearing slide mechanism to insure accuracy.
We were disappointed with the DeWalt models, the Craftsman and particularly the Freud which was out of parallel by over .025 inch. This may have been a quality control issue; accuracy may vary from tool to tool. But, if your biscuit joiner doesn’t cut parallel, we suggest swapping it for one that does.
Blade changing. At one time or another, you'll probably have to change the blade on your biscuit joiner, but not often enough to make this a primary rating factor. That said, all our test models rated very good to excellent in this category except for the Ryobi models and the Freud, which we rated as poor because of the complicated and tool-intensive process of unhooking and hooking the return spring. (See photos, DIRECTION)
We liked the Porter-Cable's easy-to-remove baseplate, which makes it a snap to install the auxiliary 2-inch blade for cutting FF biscuit slots. It’s also very quick and easy to remove the base housings of the Lamello models by simply backing off a knob on the base.
Noise. All the joiners in our test were too loud to use for extended periods without hearing protection—85 dBA is the maximum sound pressure allowed by workplace laws for continuous exposure—but some were much louder than others. (See chart.) The quietest were the Lamello models, the Porter-Cable and the battery-powered DeWalt, all in the 96 dBA range
Safety. All biscuit joiners are potentially dangerous, and you need to be very careful when handling them. As a general rule, never place your fingers near the blade opening and make sure the power cord is disconnected before changing settings or blades. Models with trigger or paddle switches are more worrisome than those with barrel-mounted rocker switches, because you tend to depress the trigger every time you pick up the tool.
The Lamello Top 20 had the most safety features, including a lockout trigger and a clutch mechanism that cuts out when you encounter an obstacle in the work. The clutch also keeps the tool from bogging down under load.
The one model that we felt posed the greatest safety concerns was the DeWalt 932 cordless model. Since there is no cord, it's easy to forget that this tool is powered all the time, unless you've removed the battery. We'd like to see a safety lockout switch on future editions of this tool.
Dust collection. Biscuit joiners generate a surprising amount of dust, so dust collection can be a desirable feature, although many pros don’t bother with it. All of our test models came with dust bag attachments, and all could be connected to a shop vac for dust collection.
A vacuum hose is the most effective dust collection solution, but it can be cumbersome. Dust bags are far more convenient, and all performed quite well in our test though they filled up quickly. Once the bag fills, chips can get wedged in the passages in the base, requiring a cleanout.
We found some other problems with three of the dust bag arrangements. The plastic mounting ports for the Lamello disposable paper dust bags interfered with our hands as we tried to operate the tools. Lamello acknowledged this and said that most production workers don’t bother with the bags. If they need to keep dust to a minimum, they use a vacuum hookup.
We also found that the Ryobi JM80's dust bag fit too loosely into the dust port and dragged on the bench when attached. The Ryobi DBJ50 didn't offer dust collection.
Recommendations
This test proved that not all biscuit joiners are created equal, but they are unequal in different ways. While all of our test models performed basic slotting operations well, we found substantial differences in their extended abilities, their user-friendliness and their features. And though we've ranked the tools based on calculated overall scores, we advise you to base your buying decision on specific features that you need for your kind of work.
At the top of the overall rankings, the Lamello Top 20 is hard to beat on any score. Its rock-solid construction, smooth operation and overall ease of use weighed heavily in this top rating. We also gave it extra credit for its blade-height adjustment knob, which offers you 3/16-inch of fine-tuning ability on the fly, and for its handy snap-on shim for switching quickly between 1/2-inch and 3/4-inch stock thickness. The Top 20's only drawback, besides its $629 street price, is that its simple pivoting fence is less adept at miter joining than the DeWalt, Porter-Cable and Craftsman models. Still, when I asked a group of professional cabinetmakers what they looked for in a biscuit joiner, their answer was, "the name Lamello on the side." Clearly, this is a production-minded tool that has gained a loyal following among cabinetmakers. On the other hand, you could buy three DeWalt 682s for the same price and have enough left over to buy your first thousand biscuits.
The DeWalt 682 and the Porter-Cable 557 also rated very highly, but for somewhat different reasons. We found the DeWalt's fence easier to use, but the Porter-Cable's was more versatile. The DeWalt was more compact and less expensive; but the Porter-Cable was a more refined machine, with some bonus features that may appeal to some woodworkers, such as its fence-mounted handle and its ability to cut FF-sized slots with the interchangeable 2-inch blade.
The Lamello Classic C2 and the Craftsman 27730 rounded out the list of top performers. The Classic C2 is a stripped-down version of the Top 20 without the blade-height knob, or the deluxe wooden case, or the expensive scoring blade, or the powder-coated finish. The C2 weighs almost a pound less than the Top 20 but is not as comfortable to use because of its thick barrel and stiff rocker switch. The Craftsman, made by DeWalt, scored highly for all the same reasons. But we found its knob less comfortable to use than the bail-type handle on the DeWalt, and we didn't like its switch or lock-on button as well as the DeWalt's.
If you’re looking for a solid, budget-minded tool that gets the job done, the Freud JS102 is definitely worth a look, but check the parallelism of a test slot before you keep it. A similar model, the Makita 3901, rated slightly higher but cost $35 more.
The Ryobi models were comfortable to use, but disappointing in most other respects. The mini-biscuit model, the DBJ50, could be a handy tool for occasional small work and face frames, but we didn’t consider it a production tool.
Ellis