Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

Posts

Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#1

Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I've been looking into spray finishing. I ordered Jeff Jewitt's book Spray Finishing Made Simple. Nice book, comes with a DVD too.

I think I have all of his books now and still can't get a good finish to save my life... :)

In his book, he says your compressor needs to produce "7-8 cfm or more at 40 psi" (page 18).

So with the enthusiasm of Ralphie with his Official Red Ryder Carbine-Action Two-Hundred-Shot Range Model Air Rifle on Christmas morning, I ran out (to the garage) and looked at my old trusty compressor. It's a piece of junk my dad gave me years ago. It's rated at 4.4 cfm @40 psi. It operated a nail gun ok, but not a spray gun I guess. Sigh.

So I decided to go to that dreaded orange box to have a look at what one would cost. I had no idea (still need to look at Lowes) what one would cost. I've never really looked at them. I didn't know HD even sold (Husky) spray guns. I suspect they aren't very good. But I have no idea.

So I looked at the specs on all the models they had there. Some oil and some oil less. Various size tanks:

Dewalt 5.1 cfm @40 psi - $250

Dewalt 6.3 cfm @40 psi - $350

Rigid 6.0 cfm @40psi - $300

Rigid 6.5 @40 psi - $440

Husky 6.8 cfm @40 psi - $300

Husky 13.4 @40 psi - $490

Pretty pricey. For me anyway.

Only one even meets the 7-8 cfm requirement and it's nearly $500. Yikes. I wonder if I could buy that for my daughter's wedding gift and she would keep it at my house... I'm guessing that won't fly.

Guess I'll stick to brushes and Viva paper towels for a while.

Of course, I do need to look at Lowes yet. Lowes is way better than the local HD's. At least here anyway.

Is it true my piddly 4.4 cfm won't operate a spray gun? I think he implies you can get away with a small gravity fed detail gun and thin finishes. Probably not what I would really want though.

:)

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#2

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

Dick Coers

Your compressor might handle you spraying a jewelry box. But if you try to spray a bookcase, you will run out of air. While shopping, don't forget to add a really good filter system for the compressed air. It needs to be mounted some distance from the compressor so the air can cool and let you filter out the water. Probably consider another $100+ for that. I would shop at a local farm store before shopping at a BORG for an air compressor.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#3

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun *LINK*

walta

There are several HVLP systems on the market that do not need a compressor. They use a turbine and the whole system cost less than a big compressor. I have not used any of the sprayers. This link is just more or less random example.

http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2083184/33566/Earlex-Spray-Station-HV5500-HVLP.aspx

Walta


woodcraft.com

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#4

a better solution

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your compressor will run a conventional gun just fine. Given all the advantages of a conventional gun, why are you stuck on HVLP? There are gobs of them on Ebay for less than $100.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#5

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

Ken Krawford

Why not buy the Dewalt for $250 and gang it together with your existing unit? I don't know if this works in real life but theoretically that would give you 9.5 cfm.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#6

Daughter getting married

Dustmaker Mike

when is the party? I am sure we could get a few folks from the Mountains of Cleveland to show up heck I might even put on a clean pair of jeans.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#7

Re: a better solution

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I guess I am confused by terminology then. And/or this book I bought is about HVLP only?

From what I've read there are two basic types of gun - turbine and compressor based. With compressor based, air comes from the compressor at high pressure, its decompressed at the gun and is called a high pressure low volume conversion gun.

Bill, you mentioned in a previous post about the "professional DeVilbiss gun JGA 502, 30 or 42 cap and 3M PPS cup". Is this considered to be HVLP? If not, then what type of gun is it?

Would I be ok with my compressor and one of those guns from ebay?

Sorry to be the village idiot, but this is all new to me.

Thanks.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#8

Serious?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Clean jeans are required? Crap.

:\

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#9

Explanation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are three approaches with some minor variations in each. HVLP with turbine, HVLP running off high volume air compressor, conventional which uses a modest amount of 35 psi air. Few have any reason to go the HVLP route for it has several disadvantages compared to its only advantage of generating some less over spray (that not none, its less).

And/or this book I bought is about HVLP only? ....Might be, HVLP is trendy and lots being said about it.

From what I've read there are two basic types of gun - turbine and compressor based. ......no, 3 types, see above.

Bill, you mentioned in a previous post about the "professional DeVilbiss gun JGA 502, 30 or 42 cap and 3M PPS cup". Is this considered to be HVLP? ....no. If not, then what type of gun is it?...."conventioal"

Would I be ok with my compressor and one of those guns from ebay?..... yes, after gaining some experience. A mentor for an hour would be worth a lot.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#10

A couple of suggestions

Howard in Toronto

There is some good advice here about ignoring HVLP and buying a conventional spray gun.

Just remember that the spray is stronger. Cover your other machines and surfaces and maybe hang up rolled film to create a sort of contained booth.

You'd need to do that with HVLP too. Just not as far away inside your shop!

Another suggestion is the HVLP turbine that Rockler stocks. Buy it with the different needle sizes so you can spray more finishes without having to thin too much.

People that own it are uniformly positive about it.

A step up from that is the Earlex equipment. A step up again is a brand like FUJI 2-stage units.

And you can always replace the compressor if you think you'll use the compressor for spraying plus other tasks too. Pricey, and puts you in the territory of the FUJI gear but has some pluses too.

Howard

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#11

"its decompressed at the gun"?

Dick Coers

"its decompressed"

From diving into too deep of water? Sorry, couldn't help myself, just sitting here giggling.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#12

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

don stephan

Jeff Jewitt is never going to try to sell you something you don't want or need. Even if he doesn't carry conventional spray guns, you might ask his opinion as to conventional, HVLP, and turbine. You might also post your query on the finishing forum on Homestead Finishing. I can't advise as to the differences between HVLP and conventional. I purchased HVLP years ago for reduced overspray and material consumption, and have always been happy with HVLP.

It is possible to buy some additonal spray time with a small compressor by adding a storage tank between the compressor and spray gun. For years I used a nail gun compressor with an HVLP gun by having a storage tank. I sprayed some fairly large pieces this way, but of course the compressor was running a lot.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

^Good advice here.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The air delivery ratings on compressors are sustained air delivery based on the duty cycle of the compressor. I have a 50% duty cycle compressor that is a dual "hot dog" style, but have sprayed plenty of things with it.

The key is that duty cycle--typically it's based on one hour. So my compressor, for example, can run continuously for a half hour, but then needs to cool for half an hour before it can run again. That means that if I'm spraying something that causes the compressor to run almost constantly, I have about 30 minutes of spray time, maybe a little more, before I'm risking compressor damage/overheating. Add in an auxiliary tank, and that time can be somewhat extended (but probably only by a few minutes--once the storage pressure drops to the spray pressure, the compressor will run continuously until you stop spraying, provided the compressor can maintain that air delivery. If it can't, you'll notice a drop in atomization and pattern width from your spray gun (more importantly, you'll HEAR it--I judge my spray patterns, HVLP or airless, by sound also).

So the base question is, will your compressor's raw air delivery, plus air storage, factored by duty cycle, last the length of time it takes to spray a coat of finish on your project?

Jason

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#14

Jeff Jewitt's book

Jerry Gibbs

"Spray Finishing Made Simple" discusses conventional high pressure guns. Your local experts will be the auto body supply people. You might check with them. Jerry

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#15

Mr Tindall is correct

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

The HVLP craze started due to a couple of issues 1) The High Volume Low Pressure system does have less "bounce back" - This does reduce the amount of "wasted finish", including solvents. Industries like the Automotive builders and other high volume users have to contend with the EPA, OSHA and a host of other regulatory issues. So when they can reduce solvent and paint usage it can reduce their overall cost significantly. While the cost of solvent paint saved may run into the hundreds a day, the cost to remove all the vapors and paint from the air may be in the thousands per day. I am sure the EPA monitors the air both inside the work area's and at the exhaust area(s). I'm sure any industry in California have far worse regulations. So the HVLP has benefits for those industries.

However in my opinion there is absolutely no benefit to the average hobby user. The conventional spray gun is far easier to learn to use, costs far less for the equivalent equipment capable of spraying multiple finishes and viscosities, and in every case I have seen produces a better finish. The conventional system allows you to spray a far wider viscosity range well (unless you have an expensive turbine type HVLP system - then they are similar).

I have a large compressor and good Binks conventional spray guns. I do have two or three cheap HVLP conversion guns - they work (just ok), but the only time I have used them is when I sprayed in a deep "hole", like deep shelves or a chest. Then the reduced bounce back did let me see what I am doing somewhat better. I can reduce the bounce back of the conventional system by reducing the spray pressure but then need to thin the finish and apply more coats. I don't use the HVLP at all on 90%+ of my projects.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#16

That HVLP craze has been going for 20+ years

Dick Coers

And basing your recommendation and experiences on cheap HVLP kinda skews your results wouldn't you say? I've been using Binks HVLP for all those 20+ years. I'll never go back to conventional. I've never been a fan (get it?) of turbine units, but I only used one many years ago.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#17

Starting to sink in

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for all the replies. It's starting to sink in for me.

So, if I find a DeVilbiss JGA 502 used on eBay:

1.) It will be considered a 'conventional' spray gun.

2.) my old compressor should handle it - small jobs.

3.) I can expect a lot of overspray compared to an HVLP gun

3.a.) Based on 3 above, my neighbors won't like me.

4.) I will need to put a filter at the gun

5.) I'll need to practice a lot - maybe with water and cardboard

6.) What else?

So far I havent' found any on eBay. There are a couple listed now, but they look incomplete or really really used.

What do I need to look for when/if getting one used off eBay?

Thanks.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#18

reply, can someone provide Joe some Binks gun mode

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Thanks for all the replies. It's starting to sink in for me.

So, if I find a DeVilbiss JGA 502 used on eBay:....Will someone provide a Binks gun number? I think there are other JGA mooels that will be equivalent, as well an the equivalent Binks models.

1.) It will be considered a 'conventional' spray gun. ....yes

2.) my old compressor should handle it - small jobs....any job they don't take much air

3.) I can expect a lot of overspray compared to an HVLP gun...I have seen figures like 50% lost from conventional and 35% for HVLP

3.a.) Based on 3 above, my neighbors won't like me.....the won't notice 50' away

4.) I will need to put a filter at the gun....the filter can be at the compressor if the line is not miles long. For years I sprayed with no filter.

5.) I'll need to practice a lot - maybe with water and cardboard ....yes

6.) What else? ..every woodworking/ cabinet shop will spray. Find someone that will give you an hours lesson. Stop by and I will do it free.

So

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#19

Re: That HVLP craze has been going for 20+ years

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Dick, I have no issues with what you say, I have not used expensive HVLP units, nor do I intend to experiment with them as I am 100% satisfied with the tools and methods I currently have and used.

I think I sprayed my first car in 1957, been using conventional units since. Where I worked as an Engineer, I purchased and used expensive "Airless" units (another story) and we had 30 or 40 conventional air spray heads on automatic spray lines - all worked for many years perfectly.

To each their own, if you prefer HVLP and have used it - great.

I do stand by my statements above that for almost all hobbyist's the conventional units cost less, are easier to learn and do a superior finish in the hands of most hobbyists'.

I grant you they do waste more finish, but in my experience, the cost of the finish I loose will never equal the equipment cost differences. The convenience, ease of use and versatility of the conventional units are really hard to beat.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#20

Re: I have a Binks model 7

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I picked up a Binks model 7 in great shape at an auction for about $25 as I remember. The gun did not have a cup on it, so I had a cheap HF gun that I scavenged for that, installed it and have used the gun for several years. I would not pay the price for a new one but sure do like the one I have. The parts and tips are readily available for this model. I can't remember the other Binks gun I have, also bought it at an auction dirt cheap, it works well but I usually use the model 7.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#21

suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Find a store that sells spray equipment, find someone at store with a gray beard and ask what models of "classic" Binks and DeVilbiss guns work with furniture lacquer. Or if you find a good looking gun on Ebay call DeVilbiss and ask if it will work. Or asking at a cabinet shop might work too.

The cap will be important. A #30 is typically used.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#22

One more important consideration

David Yoho

I'm late to this topic but have been reading along since it began. Joe, I hope you know if you decide to go the conventional route, which will produce more overspray, that another thing you must think about is setting up proper exhaust to get those fumes out of your indoor space. Also use proper filtration mask to keep your lungs safe.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#23

I would not go there

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I cannot imagine spaying indoors. The effort to assemble the necessary stuff to prevent fire, explosion, and long term health effects is too daunting to implement for the person that might spray a few times a year. I would reccommned that if you can't spray on the driveway, forget it.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#24

Go Half Way

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Spray in the garage where you can get good circulation and full air change using just a couple of cheapo 20" box fans (1 in, 1 out). Just remember to move the car out of range of the overspray, SWMBO will be pissed if you "glaze" her ride, and you'll still need a mask.

Re: Compressor and HVLP conversion gun

#25

Re: Go Half Way

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It will be months before the windshield returns to normal.....now how do I know that?