Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Posts

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#27

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I'm skeptical...

Jesper, Denmark

The move to leaner oil concentrtions was a result of many years of experience.Generally, a 50:1 gas:oil mixture provides plenty of lubrication, the rest just ends up in blue smoke.

The piston rings in most engines - from simple two strokes to highly developed gas and diesel engines are cast iron.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#28

Re: I'm skeptical...

John in NM

I could see that manufacturers might conclude that it doesn't much matter why an engine needs a rebuild or replacement -- rapid wear from too little oil or damage from carbon build up from too much. Either way there is engine damage. Add in government mandated emissions standards and they would quickly go to higher ratios as "better".

I've also read that synthetic 2 cycle oil is what really made the change - but that is just anecdotal. Timing of the change seems a little early, but not out of the question.

One thing I'd not thought of until you replied -- 50:1 vs. 40:1.... I forgot that 40:1 is the extreme condition recommendation, and that 50:1 is "normal". Conditions here are pretty much "extreme" all the time - thin dry air does not cool the engine well. I could easily understand that down near sea level in humid air, excess oil would be considered a nuisance rather than a benefit.

All that said, I'm still going to stick to lots of oil in my old saw :D I don't even like the new ones!

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#29

Re: I don't believe the additive claims *LINK*

Bill Howatt

Bill,

Here is a discussion of how it works. I don't have sufficient knowledge to support or refute the claims but it is interesting.

(Other) Bill


Ethanol Treatment Discussion

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#30

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: 30:1 vs 50:1 mixes

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Heavier oil/gas (30:1~40:1) mixes are also a slightly higher viscosity than 50:1.

A potential problem with this - particularly in high performance engines (Motocross motorcycles, for example) - is that the higher viscosity mixture going through the carburetor tends to flow less fuel and more air, which is leaner than intended.

An overly lean mixture can lead to overheating, or (worse) a burnt piston.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#31

It's very slight...

John in NM

By volume (US oz & gallons):

50:1 is 2% oil (2.56 oz per gallon)

40:1 is 2.5% oil (3.2 oz per gallon)

30:1 is 3.3% oil (4.27 oz per gallon)

16:1 is 6.25% oil (8 oz per gallon)

I don't believe even the difference between 2% oil and 6% oil will be noticeable as a change in viscosity. In theory a small carb adjustment may be necessary.

I'm not sure I buy the leaning out the fuel/air mix argument in practice, based on two things - the very small amount of gasoline displaced by the oil, and secondly the apparent assumption that the oil does not burn at all. It does - that's why there is smoke and often excess carbon :D

Now adding more oil to the fuel will require leaning the fuel air mixture to prevent carbon build up - the opposite of what that conventional wisdom dictates. Ironically, I bet that the oxygenated fuels (with added ethanol) burn lower oil mix ratio (as in more oil) fuels cleaner due to a bit more available oxygen. I'll never get the repair shops to admit that ethanol has any benefit though :D

If I were halfway good at chemistry, I'd come up with an experiment! :D

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#32

Neat article...

John in NM

Explained a number of things clearly, especially the short shelf life - gasoline degrades from oxygen exposure, and alcohol adds oxygen to the mix - that is why it reduces emissions as well - CO2 rather than CO and it changes the hydrocarbons formed during combustion.

I wonder what effect the stabilizer has on the emission reducing role of alcohol in gasoline?

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#34

risky speculation, multiviscosity oil

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Especially if someone (Jim) has actual data. Some things can have a huge affect on viscosity, like viscosity equals concentration to the 5th power. Not suggesting oil is in this league but the effect may well not be linear with concentration. The bottom line is that in going from 3% to 3.5% could significantly increase viscosity. After all, the tiny amount of viscosity additive that dissolves at higher oil temperature is enough to increase the oil from 5 "weight" to 30. BTW, that is how multiviscosity oils work. Stuff dissolves at higher temperature which increases the viscosity. (different mechanism for synthetic oil).

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#35

Ok, that makes sense

John in NM

I've little doubt you understand it much better than do I!

However, I remain doubtful, having handled and spilled mixes from 40:1 to 16:1, there is little difference in casual observation of the fluid. Really though, the definitive answer would come from the guy who designs the carburetors - he would know without a doubt :D If the viscosity does change appreciably, that would be the only way I could see the more oil = leaner fuel mix notion having any merit.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#36

how about engine deposits

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My engine fixer, not that I have ever needed a chain saw fixed in 40 years, claims that the synthetic oil does not make deposits in the cylinder as much as regular oil. Stihl provides several years of additional warranty if you use their synthetic oil. Maybe more oil would lead to more deposits. In any case I have yet to have a piston wear failure on a saw and I follow manufacturers recommendations.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#37

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Philip Duffy

Buy and use, 80 octane AVGAs! Not another problem, ever. Philip

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#38

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Kurt

Good luck finding 80 octane at most airports. In fact there are STCs(Supplemental Type Certificates) to run premium no-ethanol car gas in old low compression aircraft engines that find too much lead (spark plug fouling) in even 100LL avgas. Expect all leaded aviation fuels to go away in the next few years.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#39

Synthetic really does change things...

John in NM

I've been reading up a bit on synthetic oils, in part due to this discussion, and I'm tempted to dump all my mixed gas in the truck and start over with some synthetic. For all I know, the oil I'm using is synthetic, I never even looked :D

A good hand with carb tuning should be able to adjust it to the point where there will be no deposits even at low mix ratios. I believe the trick to that is excess oxygen, but without a carb engineer to talk to, that is just seat of the pants reasoning. The lean mix required is also going to raise the operating temp somewhat - and that may negate any benefit from a lower premix oil ratio. I kind of wonder if that is part of what is behind the high modern ratios - except that the manufacturers do recommend lowering the ratio in hot weather conditions - to 40:1 rather than 50:1.

You know, if it weren't for EPA meddling, I wouldn't even question it :D