Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Posts

Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#1

Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Barry Irby

May son and I have a number of small gas powered tools including two Stihl chainsaws, a Echo backpack blower, Echo String Trimmer and an Echo rotor Tiller. the tiller is the culprit in this story. Its one of the small ones about a foot wide and weighs about twenty pounds. Similar to a Mantis. Bought it new about a year ago and used it for a few minutes twice. It was so hard to start we took it back to the dealer immediately and then again about two months later when we tried using it the second time. Apparently we waited too long for whatever the "guarantee' period is. (Keep in mind that we use the other tools on an infrequent basis and keep gas around with Stabil in it and buy higher grade gas for them. Any suspicious gas gets thrown away.) The dealer is giving us the old Ethanol song and dance. "There's nothing we can do, we are all victims of the evil oil industry and the Greenie Weenie's that force us to use Ethanol to save the planet." It separates, it attracts water, it destroys the plastic parts and tubing, it causes.....

So, we took the tiller back for the third time basically complaining its a lemon and asking for a replacement. They fixed it. We went back to get it six weeks later. (We were in no hurry, did not need it, and the dealer is about twenty miles away.) Paid $82 for the fix. Guess what? After standing there for about ten or twenty minutes minutes, they admitted that Heh, heh, heh, it won't start. They worked on it for anther twenty minutes and got it running. They said it was our fault because we left it with them for six weeks and the ethanol gas they had it it was only good for a month. They had dumped out the gas and put in some fresh (ethanol) gas.

Their solution was to sell us a 2 quart bottle of gas with the oil already mixed and without ethanol. $7, $14 a gallon. They explained that was not very expensive because "you don't really run it a lot".

My answer is Bullsh*t! Ethanol has been here a long time, is not going away, and is getting "worse" because the trend is to go to E-85. They need to live in the real world and make the machines to operate on the gas that is commonly available.

Any suggestions?

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#2

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

John Veerkamp

Duh. What makes Echo dealer think they can control the rest of the world. I have a 25 year old Stihl 028. I use regular gas and never had a problem with it starting unless I forget to keep the air filter clean. If Stihl can do it so can the others. Sounds like a cop out for cheap products.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re:It's not the ethanol.....

Jesper, Denmark

Like John, I too have an about 25 year old Stihl 028 Woodboss - which works fine on the standard E90 gasoline we get here.

The blaming of the ethanol is just a ploy to blame something YOU cannot check and cover up a sh**ty piece of equipment or their own ignorance.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#4

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

A gas station in our area sells non-ethanol gas for a premium price. However it is way short of $14/gal. It is an Exxon product. This is a rural area with lots of wood sawing, tree pruning, wood splitters, tillers, etc.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#5

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

John in NM

It sounds like low compression. If you have a gauge I'd check that first. I have a chainsaw that is just above 100psi and it's really hard to start. Over 120 is normal. That or maybe faulty ignition.

That tiller does sound like a lemon, most of the new stuff I've tried starts on the first pull. Perhaps the manufacturer would make it right?

But the bottom line is that shop sucks - quit going there!

1. They do not stand by their products

2. They do not care if they piss off the customer with a bunch of horsepucky about bad gas and "out of warranty"

3. They do not know how to troubleshoot your engine. If it's a 2 cycle, they are stupid simple.

They suck, find a new shop.

Yesterday I stopped in at my regular shop to get a chain shortened - no charge. The guy knows me even though I only stop in twice a year or so. I have little doubt that he could fix any problem I bring in - or honestly tell me its not worth fixing.

I'd look for a chainsaw forum, someone will probably be able to recommend a good repair shop. I was going to give you a link to the one I like, but the site seems to have been hijacked by some kind of e-cig scam.

I also use steel jerry cans. But then I can get away with that out in the middle of nowhere, in CA or similar states you have to buy the new fangled ones with the non-venting, spillomatic nozzle. My theory is that plastic cans breath enough that the fuel doesn't keep. Could be BS too :D

Back when I was a kid with a motor boat and fuel lasted forever, it was stored in steel cans and there was no ethanol in it. I could use the gas from the previous summer without bugging my dad to go get some new gas. I think this question of gas not lasting more than a month is at least half moron excuses from shops that don't want to fix tools - they want to sell you a new one.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#6

I am highly(unfortunate) experienced inthis matter

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have dealt with 2 cycle engines for some time and learned that every time you take one to be repaired you will get a lecture that even a lost gas cap is caused by "ethanol in the gas". Indeed, at some time in the past there could have been seals that were affected by the ethanol but this excuse is way overused in justifying why your broken machine will not be repaired under warranty, or failed in the first place.

To head off this line of attack for some time I have only used ethanol-free gas, stored in an air impermeable container(not plastic) and synthetic oil. This line of defense heads off lots of conversation at the repair shop. Maybe for this reason, or not, I have never had a carburetor problem on a chain saw or string trimmer, both of which I use a lot.

I bought a Mantis 2 years ago. Carburetor promptly failed. Learned that carburetors are not warranted at the dealer. Paid plenty to get it cleaned. Within days it failed again and I returned it to Mantix for a full refund. Obvious to me was that even with fresh ethanol-free gas and synthetic oil some seal was dissolving and making black crap that plugged the carburetor jet. Then.....learned a while back on Internet that Mantis had carburetor issues at this time. Of course they would not own up to this fact when I was having carburetor problems with the machine.

Fast forward to the next year. I bought a Stihl tiller ( I call it my power hoe). It looked like it was the reliable string trimmer engine fastened to a tiller. Hence, it should be as reliable as my Stihl string trimmers. WRONG on both counts. The carburetor failed (stuck open) within days. Returned it for warranty repair. This back and forth went on for 1 1/2 years. I made several calls to Stihl. Tried several repair shops. Nobody would admit that damn carburetor was screwed up and needed replacing and not at my expense. I did notice that there were other tillers in these shops all with carburetor problems. In fact one shop has a 5 gallon bucket full of spent carburetors headed to the metal recycle yard.

Finally the shop I bought it at got tired of my returning it for carburetor cleaning ( it was festooned with all the repair tags I purposely left on it) and they replaced the carburetor. End of problems and only after 1 1/2 years.

Then I learned that Stihl had bought their carburetor supplier about the time my machine was made because of quality problems with the supplier.

Bottom line- there is something about these small tillers that the carburetors they use are not as reliable as those used on professional chain saws and trimmers. Either avoid buying them, or

1. use only "fresh ethanol- free gas

2.use synthetic oil

3.never leave gas in machine when done

4. pray a lot and tithe the church

and MAYBE one or more of the above will leave you with a trouble free 2-cycle tiller.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#8

you are correct about plastic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

gas will last forever if kept free of oxygen and sunlight. Duh, its been in the ground for a million years. Indeed, plastic is permeable to oxygen. You can indirectly confirm this fact by storing a plastic container of soda for a year and noting that it has become flat. In this case the carbon dioxide has left through the walls. You don't see beer in plastic because oxygen permeates the plastic and ruins the taste. A billion dollars has been spent trying to overcome this limitation with no economically viable success.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#9

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

Bill Howatt

I believe Sta-bil makes an additive to neutralize the corrosive and other bad effects of ethanol.

The whole ethanol thing in fuel is a load of crappola and has done nothing but driven up food prices, provided less energy than is required to make it, clogged carburetors etc. Paint it green and they will buy it!

Bill

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#10

I don't believe the additive claims

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are(at least) two problems with ethanol and neither can be fixed with an additive.

1. It is corrosive. Ethanol is mixed at the distribution center because it can not be piped from the refinery do to pipe corrosion. This property can be lessened but not eliminated by an additive. Don't know if the additive has anticorrosion chemicals in it or if they are effective.

2. It dissolves stuff gas won't. The solvent properties of the mixture are substantially different from pure gasoline, a hydrocarbon. Hence, things like gaskets and seals designed for a pure hydrocarbon solvent can be swelled, or otherwise attacked by the blend. Again, this property will not eliminated by adding a smidgen of any additive. But, seals and gaskets designed to survive the blend will not be affected. Age of engine will determine this risk.

The additive is mainly an antioxidant which may prevent polymerizing the gasoline into goo that can clog and/ or stick carburetor parts.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#11

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

BrianMonumentCO

something like 18 years ago when I moved from NH to Colorado, I brought my Mitsbubishi Eclipse. One day I had to drive up to Denver from Colorado Springs for a hour long meeting. When I came out my car wouldn't start. I had never had that problem before. Turns out that it was the ethanol mixed fuel. I talked to the mitsubishi dealer and they told me that I would have to leave my only vehicle with them for several days so they could retune the engine to work with this crap fuel. The problem only happened when the vehicle had run for a while and then sat for an hour. Sitting for a night it would start in the morning.

Bad fuel done for environmental reasons is still bad fuel.

It infuriated me that vehicles are not able to handle.

Yet I bought a Ford exploder er explorer and it started all the time. No problems but it was tuned for both the altitude and bad fuel.

By the way here in colorado bad fuel is sold only during the winter.

At least it was when I moved out here.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#12

Find a marina.

Ray - Middletown, IN

Most will have 90 octane, ethanol free, with Stabil added. Boat owners found eroded fuel lines to be an expensive proposition. I found one that is only about $.40 a gallon more, well worth it.

Ray

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#13

Or and airport for that matter...

John McGaw

If you really want high-purity no-ethanol low-lead gasoline of known and well-controlled characteristics then you can't go wrong with a Jerry can of 100LL AVGAS. Friends in Alaska used to use it for their racing snowmobiles.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#14

Will aviation gas.....

Barry Irby

last longer if I put Stabil in it and use a metal can, If I can find one? I am not aware of another source for no ethanol gas locally, but there is an airport about ten miles away. Just a matter of rounding up a can and then finding the actual Pump.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#15

ethanol-free gas stations-common here

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Gas stations that sell ethanol-free gas are common in E.TN. Are they not common elsewhere?

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#16

Re: Will aviation gas.....

John McGaw

I don't like to add anything to fuel so I don't have any expertise there. I know that, in Alaska, it was not uncommon for people in the bush to buy their AVGAS by the 55-gallon drum and have it barged or flown into their strips and to keep until it was used up, possibly years later. My friends who raced snowmobiles usually bought their fuel by the 5-gallon can at the local general aviation airport and used it up pretty quickly. I'd think that any non-reactive vapor-tight container should keep AVGAS or other pure petrochemical fuel usable for a long time and to me that suggests a good metal can.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#17

The main thing is the steel can

John in NM

Has to seal well enough that you can keep it in doors with no gas odor. More and more I think the ethanol thing is a red herring, get a good can and it won't matter if there's alcohol in the gas. That has been working for me, and there is no source of pure gas anywhere locally.

If you can find one, I like 10 liter military wine cans (they're French of course :D ). Stay away from the new made ones that outfits like Sportsmans Guide sell, they are thin and poorly stamped and will start leaking inside a year. Heavy steel and deep stampings are necessary to keep the can from flexing under pressure/vacuum as the gas/vapor changes volume with changing temperature. Thin cans with flat stampings flex and start leaking at the creases where flexing stops at corners.

I like the 10 L cans because I don't use enough fuel to keep 20 L mixed. If you have a decent surplus store locally, check there first - shipping is a killer on bulky stuff like jerry cans.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#18

Not around here...

John in NM

I've yet to see one here, though I bet the local saw shop would know if there was any available. Logging isn't much of an industry here like in your neck of the woods.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#19

While we're on the subject...

John in NM

It amazes me how little 2 cycle oil gets mixed into the gas these days, per the engine manufacturer's instructions. 40:1 mix seems standard, yet my 1974 chainsaw manual recommends 16:1!

I have to wonder whether the improved air quality is worth the waste of energy and resources of the much shorter engine life using such lean oil mixtures.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#20

There was nothing wrong with gas and diesel....

basil

....so government had to fix it.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#21

Wasn't The Fuel

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

But the air and the low price of corn, that's a different story . . .

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#22

I'm told...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...that, at least with the pro tools, better construction requires less oil. My Stihl weed frightener only requires 50:1.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#23

Re: ethanol-free gas stations-common here

Howard Norman

I don't know of a gas station around Prescott, AZ that sells ethanol-free gasoline.

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#24

I'm skeptical...

John in NM

But I've no proof of the matter. Just seems like running a car with a quart in the crankcase instead of 4 or 5.

My neighbor wears out a chainsaw in a couple years, gets it rebuilt and wears it out again. I'm still running one as old as I am and just now need to rebuild it (if only I could do the same for my knees and back!) My old saw has the same chromed cylinder and steel (or whatever) rings that new saws do.

But it is in the manufacturer's interest to go along with the charade - they get to sell more new tools!

Re: Ethanol/Gas Question/Rant

#25

you are probably too close to CA

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

These are typical gas stations except they have prominent signs saying things like "no cheap ethanol gas sold here". I know of three in tiny Gate City, VA and there are several more in Kingsport, TN. The price is usually 20 cents higher but the extra mileage at least partially compensates for the price. Daughter has no trouble getting ethanol-free gas in Greenville, SC either.