Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

Posts

Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#1

Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

David Hay Denver

I'm starting to think about a dust collection system for my shop. Specifically, I'm thinking about a cyclone dust collector.

In order to reduce the noise level, I'm considering putting the cyclone in the attic and the dust bin in the shop. This would mean having about 6-8 feet between the top of the dust bin and the bottom of the cyclone. Is this something even worth thinking about? Any reason this wouldn't work?

Thanks!

David

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: It'll work fine.


Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#3

JL

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

JL

As Jesper said, it will work fine.

I am presuming the majority of your DC ducting will be in the attic. The usual caveats - minimize the number of bends, use larger mains, etc.

I made a major mistake w/ my ducting. I used duct tape. I should have used the foil duct tape. It makes a BIG difference.

One other advantage with your desired setup. You can put the dust bin on casters.

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#4

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

Randy Johnson

There might be some point where diminishing returns enters the picture, but from what I’ve learned, mostly the hard way, the more distance between the bottom of the cyclone and the dust bin the better.

The only caveat I would offer beyond what has already been said about the ducting, is making sure the motor doesn’t overheat during the summer months when the attic is something over 100 degrees.

Many is the time I've wished I'd planned ahead and rasied mine three or four feet.

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#5

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

Barry Irby

I don't have a cyclone, so I can't answer your question from experience. I have the other system. From that experience I can tell you that getting the unit out of the shop will be good. (Mine is in an outdoor closet and the noise reduction is substantial and very beneficial.) Try using rubber pads or some other sort of sound/vibration isolators.

Also, do whatever you can to make it easy to change the bag or drum to remove the debris. Its a chore and anything that makes it quicker and easier will be highly thought of later. You will want some sort of easy to see indicator when the drum is full. I don't have that and I have to walk outside tot eh closet to check it occasionally. Several time I failed to catch it and have found the debris all the way up into the upper bag. Its a mess to clean up. (Sort of defeats the purpose of collecting it in the first place.) I want a dust remover, not collector. I need to go empty mine now.

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#6

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

I did that with mine (I'll try to take a picture within the next few days, if there's enough light when I'm home before the weekend; otherwise I'll do it then). I wish I had put most of the ducting up there, too, but that would have meant many more holes in the floor/ceiling between the 2 floors and that was a pain to do for the intake and output.

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#7

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

walta

Please consider that if your cyclone puts its exhaust into the attic may create 2 problems.

1 You are likely to depressurize your shop any fuel burning appliances may back draft. Where air could be drown down the flue and spill the combustion fumes into the building. CO poisoning and fire are real possibility.

2 If your shop is heated or cool your systems will not likely to be large enough condition the volume of air you be exhausting. If the equipment is large enough it will use a lot of fuel.

Be sure to return the air to the shop and even then small leaks could pose a big problem if you have appliances. Gas water heaters are very susceptible to back drafting.

Walta

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#8

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

Randy Johnson

Okay, this is a little off the subject. But not much.

I work for a natural gas supplier, and as one might expect, part of the job is investigating gas leaks. Quite often the source of the smell someone thinks is natural gas will turn out to be something else.

Several months ago one of the other guys went on a leak call where the smell was determined to be exhaust from a water heater that was not vented well. The vent was long and at best level, with a little sag along the way making it slightly downhill. The homeowner was told that moving the water heater closer to the chimney would probably correct the problem.

Fast forward a couple weeks.

I was on standby when the same homeowner called and said that he had moved his water heater but was still smelling gas. Once again, the problem was exhaust. But here is where it gets interesting. On removing the vent from the chimney to check for blockage in the chimney itself, I was immediately hit in the face with a back draft that couldn’t have been stronger if a fan was mounted on top of the chimney. In the end, that was sorta the problem. The water heater was in the basement, but, with the basement door open as it normally was in that house……The (recently installed) whole house fan was powerful enough to pull air down the chimney along with pulling it through windows.

I doubt that many of you have a cyclone THAT powerful, but it does illustrate the point of exhausting inside air to the outside instead of keeping it all inside via a filter.

In the case of the original poster, I did not read his question as saying he was venting outside. He was only placing most or all of the unit in the attic. The filters could still be in the shop itself.

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#9

Walta and Randy Have Good points

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector I find back drafting situations fairly often. We don't know if you have a fired appliance of any sort in your house and/or in your shop. We are not sure your shop is part of your house. But, back drafting can be a serious problem. It has become even more complicated as appliances and devices get more efficient and put less heat out the flue/vent. Many devices have draft fans and that complicates things further. I won't go on and on about it, but take the possibility seriously.

It also matters whether you turn the DC on and off with each operation or just let it run and open and close blast gates.

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#10

Re: Walta and Randy Have Good points

Pete in Holland MI

Mounting the blower in the wood attic will excite the whole house with any motor / fan noise & vibration. Push your blower into a wood wall to see what I mean. Keeping it on concrete floor minimizes that.

Pete

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#11

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

David Hay

This is a good point. I hadn't considered how the exhaust air would make its way back into the shop. I imagine that I could either figure out some way to enclose the filters and pipe the air back into the shop or extends the exhaust piping such that the filters were in the shop.

I should have mentioned that this is a detached shop. I also don't have any gas fired appliances out there (yet). I imagine I'll be installing some kind of heating system (probably electric) at some point, so I'm definitely thinking about returning the air back to the shop.

The other concern I have is whether condensation might be a problem. I live in a pretty dry climate (Colorado), but I would imagine that pulling warm air into a cold attic could cause moisture to build up inside the cyclone and any ductwork that is up there.

Definitely some things to think through, but it sounds like it might be easier to find space in the shop for the dust collector and devise a way to enclose it with some kind of sound insulating cabinet/closet.

Thanks!

David

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#12

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question *LINK*

Hank Knight

David,

Sorry I'm late to the party.

I put my cyclone in my small basement shop and built a sound buffering enclosure around it based on Jameel Abraham's enclosure on the Clear Vue web site. (See link below). It works great and takes up very little room - an important consideration in my small shop. It doesn't "silence" the cyclone, but it dampens the sound down to a very tolerable level. My shop is in our basement, directly below I our family room, and I get no noise complaints from my wife. Check out the Clear Vue Gallery. It has dozens I of photo albums of various installations, many of which have some great I ideas.


Clear Vue Installations

Re: Cyclone and Dust Bin Question

#13

It may not even be necessary...

Grant in Iowa

I can tell you that my Oneida Dust Gorilla (an early production version of what is now their 2HP Super dust gorilla) isn't really very loud.

The cyclone is mounted to the wall and I plumbed my system with 6 and 7" snap-lock piping from Oneida. All of this ducting was carefully sealed by applying silicone sealant with an acid brush to each joint. On its own, it really isn't very loud. The noise it does produce is more of a low rumbling sound and is not at all objectionable. I would suspect that the low frequency of this sound would be difficult to muffle, and might better be damped by affixing it to concrete in some way. One can easily carry on a conversation in the room when only it is running. The majority of the rumbling sound mine produces is emanating from the cartridge filter on its output. One could simply install the system with that filter behind a panel to reduce what noise it produces.

That said, once you turn on a TS, planer or jointer, THEY are much louder due to the air being pulled over their rotating head. Presumably this is due to sort of an air raid siren effect.

Point being if you don't already have your cyclone, you might find that it isn't really as loud as you might surmise, and therefore not an issue.

An interesting side note is that the air output of the unit is noticeably warmer than the surrounding air. The motor is NOT in this airflow path. Apparently friction caused by the cyclone and twists and turns heats the air. I'm sure compression and decompression also factor in. The energy the motor supplies goes somewhere, and a great deal of it becomes heat. For this reason, you might consider incorporating the ability to duct it outside in warmer weather via a damper or two.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa