Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

router kickback

Posts

router kickback

#1

router kickback

Charles Yawn

This happened when I was routing the piece with a template attached underneath using a flush cut bit. Somehow, the bit grabbed to work and snatched it out of my hands. Only the work piece was damaged; me and the template (3/4" MDF) were not injured. The only thing I can figure is that I tried to cut to far, started cutting against the grain, and the soft wood had large tearout's that the router bit grabbed. There were wood chips all over the router table and workshop. Charles


Re: router kickback

#2

Two suggestions

Keith Newton

You make no mention of a starting pin. For shaped parts, this allows you to use leverage to your advantage, as you rock around as you start into the cut, while feeding forward.

The other thing, is that you have two options, bearing over, and bearing under. Each will give the option of opposite rotation, so all can be cut down-slope of the grain. However, I'm not fond of using a bearing-under bit on a table router, unless you had the extra bit shrouded somehow. I would much rather have the router in my hands, and the work secured to the bench. This may require some creative fixtures on small parts.

Re: router kickback

#3

Re: thank you!

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Keith: I never thought about the fact that a combination of top-bearing and bottom-bearing router bits allow down hill cutting for all portions of the piece.

I have only rarely had similar issues, but when I have had them, they were vexing. Your insight solves it (not the fixturing or work holding issues, but at least the routing/cutting issues).

Henry

Re: router kickback

#4

Seems like I've seen...

John in NM

A flush trim bit with both a top and bottom bearing. Then assuming the template/work assembly could be flipped over and used either template up or template down, reversing the cut direction would be fairly simple.

I've had similar problems to this with one particular template rout I do often. My operation is really scary as hell, and sometimes I wonder that I do it at all. I've had excellent results about 75% of the time, minor problems 20% or so, and a total disaster the remaining 5%. I finally tried an inexpensive spindle sander as an alternative, and it works well and while not as fast as the router, the lack of disasters offsets that. Now if there were only a way to use it as consistently as a router template :D

Re: router kickback

#5

Re: Two suggestions

Charles Yawn

Keith, good suggestions.

I did have a starting pin mounted, but when the incident happened, I think the work piece was not bearing on the pin along with the router bit.

Also, I was using a two-bearing router bit. I believe I cut past where I should have stopped and flipped the work. In defense, it was swirly-grained wood and a little difficult to see the grain direction! :)

Charles

Re: router kickback

#6

First Thoughts

Joe Burke

And none of them are revolutionary. They're just things I've decided over the years.

If I'm flush trimming something like that I'd try and remove as much waste as possible to leave the smallest amount to flush trim away as possible. Have the router bit work as little as possible. I wouldn't trim and remove more than 1/8" were I trimming that, and 1/16" would be better. For me anyway.

If the bit isn't new or almost new that's particularly important. I've got more than one trimming bit, and I try and keep the sharpest, least used one, in reserve for important jobs. Once it's dull I'll rotate it out of the sharp loop and get a couple more. As an aside ... once one sees some MDF it's usually out of the "sharp" loop.

I don't know what type of bit you were using, but if what I need to flush trim is solid lumber and important, I'll spring for a solid carbide spiral bit with bearings. Short of that the other bits I keep have that slight shear angle as opposed to being simply straight cut.

Using a double bearing bit and being able to flip the job to follow the grain as needed would be great. I've never owned a double bearing bit. If I get a job that calls for one I'll have to hunt one up.

Again, nothing here is revolutionary. Maybe something will apply?

Re: router kickback

#7

Re: router kickback

BrianMonumentCO

You did not state the type of wood. It looks a bit like maple.

Three observations;

1. should always use the starter pin gives much better control

2. feed rate is really important to keep at a minimum when broaching squirrelly grain.

3. I agree with another poster who stated that he tries to trim off only 1/16 of an inch or so.

Re: router kickback

#8

Solution

Bill Howatt

Mail the piece to the guys that do router-work on DIY TV shows. They always seem to be able to zip around a piece, trim and plunge as easy and slick as you can get.

When I try it..... well, your piece looks familiar. :)

I did describe my problem to a router-whiz at a woodshow, he said sharp bits and very light cuts especially if you can't flip the piece - not surprising, I guess.

Bill

Re: router kickback

#9

Re: thank you!

Jerry Roberts

I learned one thing from the kickback I had several months ago.Never,never, never route anything freehand. Always use a starter pin or fence. I thought I had lost some fingers but didn't. Man, that hurt!

Re: router kickback

#10

another option

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

What you are seeing is fairly common when trying to route all the way around a piece of wood with curves. There are places where you will encounter reverse grain that will either lift or shatter when the cutting edge of the bit hits it. The type of damage shown in your photo can potentially destroy not only the work piece, but can also damage routers and bits.

A good way to prevent this type of damage is to read your wood and be aware of where the grain will be difficult if not impossible to route. You can use the top/bottom guide bearing bits suggested or you can selectively climb cut the potential problem areas and conventional cut the remaining areas.

Climb cutting requires that you have a very firm grip on the piece being routed to prevent self feeding and that you take very light cuts. You can add layers of painters tape to your template that can be pealed off a few at a time to create light cuts.

Lee

Re: router kickback

#11

Don't take such a big bite...

Dick Coers

You are trying to remove a lot of material there. When I pattern cut like that I take my time on the bandsaw and then remove about a 1/16" on the router. Much safer and a whole lot easier. I also prefer to use larger diameter router bits when I can. The 1 1/4" diameter pattern bits work ten times easier than the 1/2" diameter.

Re: router kickback

#12

Re: Seems like I've seen...

Barry Irby

I think I have seen sanding drums with a guide bearing on them. Like a router bit with a guide bearing. Might be useful for very difficult grain.

Otherwise you have gotten good advice.

Re: router kickback

#13

Bob

Re: router kickback

Bob

Probably the quilted wood?

Higher speed and lighter cuts would work.

Re: router kickback

#14

Re: Two suggestions

Keith Newton

Charles, you said you were using a double bearing bit, so I'll assume it was a over an under, instead of two on the end together. Also, you said you have a starting pin, but wasn't riding it at the moment of the grab.

As the name implies, it really is just for safe starting. Whenever I'm using one, I don't just pivot the work around it, letting the bit go straight in, but rather pivot around while moving forward. Then it is a good idea to go ahead and pivot away from the pin. For some reason, when I find I'm riding it, I tend to get away from the bearing unexpectedly, and need to make another pass.

I try not to say never or always, so I'll just say you won't catch me climb-cutting on a table router. I would much rather be holding the router where my hands are well away from the cutter.

I suspect you accidentally backed up, which led to the grab.

You didn't reveal what router and table you have, but it would be wise to check to make sure after this, that everything is still tight and straight.

Re: router kickback

#15

I agree with Dick

John Lucas

I made 25 hand mirrors with just the router about 25 years ago. Trying to take too big of a bite will do that. Also take care to feed into the rotation of the bit. If you have a thick area to remove do it a little at a time using lighter pressure to sneak up on it.

I now make 99% of mirrors on the Lathe so no longer have that problem but I still remember those days.

Re: router kickback

#16

Re: router kickback

Larry in nw ohio

Charles I agree with Dick, especially using a large bit. I have a 1 1/4" bit I use for making patterns and duplicutes. I think they make it much easier to use. Be Careful. Larry

Re: router kickback

#17

Re: Don't take such a big bite...

Templatetom

My answer to this type of process is to use the router in the plung mode with the aid of template guides This of course will require the production of a simple Template to begin with

You can see many of my templates in us by logging on to youtube and look for routing with tom O'Donnell