Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Posts

Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#1

JL

Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

JL

I'm not sure of the correct terminology.

The "modesty panel" in question is in front of the church pews and separates the pews from the aisle in front of the pews.

Anyway - it wobbles. It is secured to the floor by angle brackets. Needless to say, everyone grabs onto the panels and heaves themselves up. Currently the angle brackets are on the order of 3-4".

Can't really have diagonals on the angle brackets as the diagonals would be a trip hazard. I could possibly incorporate a "flying buttress" or three - but that would probably also interfere.

Any other suggestions?

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#2

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Angle brackets are not a good support. What really needs to be done is to remove the panels, bore a 1/2" to 3/4" hole into the floor and insert a length of steel rod into the floor and up into or adjacent to the vertical posts of the panel. These rods will give you some strength to resist the pulling forces of people standing up with the help of the panel.

Lee

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#3

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Barry Irby

Lee has a good idea if the floor is concrete or if you have floor joists to SECURELY attach the rods to.

If these are 4x4 posts, Home Depot used to have and may still have an anchoring system that involved some very sturdy angles that you screwed into the floor and posts and then some base (as in baseboard) came with it that you installed around the post to conceal the angles.

You could also make a home made version of the same thing, on steroids. Have some steel angle iron cut into pieces an 1 1/2" or so long and put one on the outer side and and other on the inner side. Have the metal fabricator punch or drill holes in them for screws and screw them to the floor and posts. 3" by 4" angle brackets should help, but the angles have to be sturdy enough to resist bending.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#4

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Dick Coers

I don't think a 1/2" steel rod will add much at all to resist the bending. Seems like the steel will flex pretty easily. I think you need the buttress support. To eliminate tripping, you can box them in so that front wall will now be a 8" to 12" thick instead of the few inches you have now. You need triangular braces if you really want to resist racking.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#5

JL

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

JL

I wonder. If I make a buttress for each end and combine them with your steel rods. I can get to the floor. The sanctuary is above a basement with a suspended ceiling.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#6

Kneale Brownson

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Kneale Brownson

Something like: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hP8-_5Hx5yw

I've done something similar with four pieces of angle drilled for both the post and the supporting structure.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#7

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

BrianMonumentCO

If you think of this panel as a stair railing since it seems to be being used as one,

then the only solution, I see is to attach the vertical post to the floor joists as you would a yule post (hope I spelled that correctly).

If you needed to add cross pieces to permit bolting in 2 directions that wouldn't be the worst thing.

But then again it would necessitate a hole through the floor the size of your post.

I would not use a 1/2 steel rod. I would go with solid wood, like laminated oak.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#8

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

john Veerkamp

To strengthen angle brackets you could weld in fillets.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#9

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Joseph Mulherin, sr

JL, the unit Kneal said to see on YouTube would do the trick. I would band saw the ABS unit in half, install 2x4s in them under the pew and screw where it is needed for the panel, then screw the "modesty panel" to the 2x4

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#10

What is the floor made of? *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

I am thinking newell post hardware, assuming you can get them anchored in to floor joists or blocking under the flooring.

If the floor is concrete, you can hammer drill in anchors that will interface with this type of newell post hardware.

Depending on the panel design, you should be able to install this type of hardware wherever the posts are.

Another approach could be to add cross panels of the same height as the modesty panels between each section. These cross panels, since they would be as high as the panels would not present a tripping hazard. I would think a heavily built cross panel 10" in width would be strong enough to resist lateral movement, especially if there is a newell post bolt/ anchor in each leg. An added benefit, assuming adequate space, is that the area in front of the panel could accommodate wheel chairs.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

P.S. Here's a link to many images of newell post hardware in its various incarnations:


Google results for newell post hardware

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#11

Confucious say....

Grant in Iowa

Confucious say:

Man who pass gas in church sit in pew.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#12

Different approach to same problem.

Keith Newton

JL, about two years ago, I did some church alterations similar to this. I had to remove the communion rail for ceramic tile, then put it back. It had been very wobbly for a long time with it's old anchoring system on a wood floor, and adding tile wasn't going to help that.

What I did, was set it up in place with a few fasteners, but with shims under holding it up about 1/8~ 3/16". I had already used masking tape to outline the footprint on the floor, and along the bottom edge of the unit. Then with a big caulking gun, I shot into the space as much silicone, or polyurethane as it would take.

By the next morning, I was really surprised by how strong that full length bond had become. Having a fat joint builds in a bit of flex to handle shock loads, far better than a thin joint, and especially mechanical fasteners. After you flood the joint, finger it off, lots of paper towels, then peel the masking tape, and make sure not to do it on an evening where there may be a prayer meeting or people using the space while it is wet.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#13

From the bottom

Yonak

If you can remove the ceiling tiles in the basement area beneath the Sanctuary and get to right part of the floor, you could screw as many lag bolts as necessary into the bottom of the panel. Additional braces (large washers or plates) between the heads of the lag bolts and the bottom of the floor would add support also.

The newel post idea sounds excellent, as well. Maybe they wouldn't have to actually go through the floor to be secure. It seems like it could be sufficiently bolstered by three long lag bolts secured by a hearty brace beneath attached to joists.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#14

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

AZ in Colorado Springs

I would think the "steel rods" would provide assistance only if you could secure them into the ends of the modesty panel -- perhaps using epoxy to secure threaded rod in the bores -- then inserting the other end of the threaded rod through the floor and securing it from below with flat washers, lock washers, and a nut. Maybe that's what Lee intended, but it wasn't clear to me. Might have to include a "caul" below the floor to spread the load depending on the rigidity of the floor material.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#15

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

Joe shelton

First, the Newell post approach is a good one, if feasible. If not, then you need brackets "fore and aft", opposing the thrust as much as possible. Be sure you maximize your anchoring devices and screws. There is a great variety of expansion bolt or anchor options. Lag screws are better than wood screws, of course. Artful wooden brackets can hide the strong hardware beneath. All this is speculation, not knowing what your surface is, nor the substrate...

Joe

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#16

JL

Oak flooring over subfloor

JL

The floor/ceiling joists are "truss" like and stretch across the width of the church. They are parallel to the modesty panel. There are two sheets of plywood over the joists. It appears that the plywood is 3/4".

So - we'd have two thicknesses of plywood and the thickness of the oak flooring (~1/2") - so about 2" overall.

Re: Wobbly "modesty panel" - how to deal with it?

#17

Re: Oak flooring over subfloor

psenn

This is the strongest system I have ever used. installed 6 years ago on my deck and no movement of the railing to this day.

http://www.ideasfordeckdesigns.com/titanpostanchor.php

http://www.titanbuildingproductscrm.com/index.php/product-training/titan-post-anchor