Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

Posts

Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#1

Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I find myself headed toward another compromise from woodworking purity, into a realm about which I know little.

We're remodeling a room in the house that has an alcove that will hold a natural-gas radiant heater - looks like a woodstove, doesn't involve schlepping wood in and ash out. It's tiled up four feet, and will have a painted frame-and-panel mantel-like trim a foot wide, wrapping around the back and sides of the alcove. The design scheme is Arts and Craftsy, so the frame and panel will be simple, square edges on 6/4 (1-3/8" actual) poplar frame members about 2" wide, flat panels of Masonite (the amount of recess to be determined in the course of the build). The whole thing painted white. There's plenty of structural meat behind the wall for me to fasten to, so, once this thing's in place, it will have no life purpose besides sitting there looking pretty.

I'm thinking about breaking down and using pocket screws for the assembly, something I've been avoiding for years. Because of my denial about this construction system, I know little about the fine details.

First, is what I've described workable with pocket screws? Kreg says it is, but there's sometimes a difference between the manufacturer's beliefs and field realities. Are there fine details I should know about this joinery technique, not obvious from the tools and manual?

Second, I'm considering the Kreg "JigMaster," which has a jig into which you clamp your board, with various adjustments, and a DeStaCo type clamp to hold the piece; and then a Vise-Grip with big faces on the clamping jaws to align the pieces being joined; plus other bits and pieces. This seems like enough for the job at hand and for what I can contemplate for future jobs.

I'd appreciate the thoughts of this brain trust.


Thinking about this jig

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#2

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

John McGaw

That looks to be identical to the kit that I bought and I can highly recommend it. Sure, it isn't 'pure' but sometimes purity comes at too big a cost (I'm speaking as the guy who at one time refused to use plywood in furniture). The method works, it is flexible in application but rigid in structure, it is strong, it is invisible. Sure, you could use bridle joints or M&T for what you describe but what would it gain you beyond an incredible sense of relief that the job was finally behind you?

I've made a TV stand, a wine rack, and a concealed-compartment nightstand using the Kreg and don't consider any of them to be less good because of it.

If the 'purity' thing still bothers you just remember that every woodworking technique was new at one time and there were probably old timers looking down upon those who used the new ways. "Mortises? We didn't need mortises in my day -- we were real men then..."


Perspective from Four Yorkshiremen

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#3

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Merle

Bill, not to discourage you if you want the complete set, but you could probably do fine with this smaller kit.

http://www.amazon.com/Kreg-R3-Pocket-Hole-System/dp/B000J43A7W/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1382049746&sr=8-2&keywords=kreg+jig

The process is quite simple; I was even able to figure it out. There are fine thread screws for softwood and course thread for hardwoods.

Regarding your purist concerns, didn't Norm use pocket screws on a few projects?

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#4

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Gary Smyth

I have the big Kreg jig. Early on I too wondered about it, even though I watched TOH and New Yankee etc. For me this is practical, this ain’t fine woodworking. I needed some cabinets and covered storage in the laundry and garage, a frame, plywood, mouldings mostly. All connections should be over ½” to ½”. Under that is not recommended. I have to say I’m surprised and pleased. Once you figure the dimensions and read the directions to get the correct size screws the frame is fast and easy. Of course you are looking at the holes (I do not plug the holes unless they are in a door that opens) and I still get a twinge if I see them, but truth is once they are sheathed with a skin and not in plain view you forget and your neighbors won't know about the frame and you can spend more productive time on the appearance. Also you can use lumberyard lumber with no further dressing which will save much time if only building a frame which is to be covered. If no one is going to view the innards, buy the jig. I did buy an extra drill, square drive bits, and additional screws. Kreg offers an assortment in a plastic box and I bought two to have enough selection until I knew what was what and had to order more if I ran into a big project. Ebay and Amazon were my friend for screws. You will use more screws than you think you will however. 1 ¼” for ¾ to ¾, 1 ½ screws for 1” to 1” and 2 1/2” screws if using 2 x 4s as a frame. All of this is in the directions. I also use Jorgenson wood hand screw clamps to hold the pieces when screwing stuff together as the pocket hole wood has a tendency to want to move at the last instant. I do use and find workable the Kreg clamp when drilling. The hand screws work far better for me as assembly holding clamps than the Kreg stuff. Slower going but nothing slips. Other than that, a 23Ga pin nailer was a great help when dressing it up on the outside. The only cautions are that there is a slight learning curve the first time out, and I find the prices fixed with few discounts. Hope this helps.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#5

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Joe shelton

Bill, I had an earlier version of that kit, and after using it rather extensively I gave it away because of the "purity" motivation.

Now I'm awfully tempted by the new jig that has the toggle on the side you work from.

My results with it were very good after setting it up, and assemblies were certainly sturdy.

I like the right angle clamp (I think that's the name) which goes into a pocket.

One thing I never did was to glue in the plugs to hide the pockets. If you try that, let us know what you think...

Joe

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#6

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Barry Irby

I agree with all of the above. I have on that is so old it all metal construction, not the plastic one of today.

I agree that it is not fine wood working, but for some things, Its Great. Stronger than I thought it would be also. A fairly powerful drill is nice, but not too big and a little impact driver is great for the screws.

One caution. Those screws are hardened. Don't forget and saw through one. That blade will never be any good again. (I threw mine away) You can saw through a biscuit (another frowned upon option) but not one of these screws.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#7

I bought the Harbor Freight...

Tom Dunlap

...jig and I'm happy with it. The guides are metal and replaceable.

The whole fixture is aluminum extrusions.

Without doing a side by side comparison or reading many reviews I can't say how it compares to the Kreg. From looking at the Kreg in the store it sure seems like this model of HF is a great value.

It sure makes joining wood easier. The joining turns out better than I have ever been able to build. The speed is amazing too!

Wait for the 20% off coupon from HF.

Tom

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#8

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Earl

I think thats wrong I think the coarse goes with the soft and the fine goes with the hard Earl

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#9

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill, I have a former BIL who runs a high-end cabinet shop, putting in hundred thousand dollar installations in million-dollar homes. He uses pocket screws all over the place. He showed me his setup, darn near automated, and the speed at which he produced face frames was simply astounding.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#10

HF discount coupon *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

15% off saves a little :D


HF discount coupon

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#11

Biscuits vs. screws

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks for all the good information so far.

Barry's comment about being able to saw through biscuits reminded me that I own a biscuit cutter (a Craftsman-badged DeWalt), $20 in good shape at a yard sale, that I used just once on a quick, sloppily-done project. Biscuits might also get the job done here.

What are the tradeoffs of biscuits vs. screws?

Later edit: I realized that the slot even for #0 biscuits is too wide for 2" stock; and, since I haven't decided on how deeply the panels will be recessed, I don't want to risk the slots showing. So, I'm off to buy a Kreg jig.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#12

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

Dave Bair

I used pocket screws to create the face frames for my kitchen cabinets. The frames are very sturdy and the holes are not visible unless you stick your head deep into the cabinet. The only problem I ever had was keeping the 2 pieces being joined flush with each other. The screw side likes to slide by the other as the final few turns are applied. I ended up clamping the 2 pieces to the bench top to avoid the problem.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#13

Re: Biscuits vs. screws

Barry Irby

I have a Porter Cable plate joiner/biscuit cutter. It comes with a smaller cutter and you can get "FF" biscuits for Face Frames. I don't think any of the other machines will work for this.

I think Kreg screws will be faster and perhaps stronger. With the biscuits you have to glue and assemble and clamp. Kreg screws are sort of one and done. The Vice Grip like clamps are very handy. Learn to put the bigger plate on the face side and the smaller one on the back. The smaller one may leave an imprint.

Also, the Kreg screw are washer head screws. They have a significant flat shoulder under the head. That causes them to put the joint tight. Do not try to substitute counter sunk screws. They will burst the frame.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#14

Right angle clamp

Tom Dunlap

For years I had one locking c-clamp that didn't have swivel pads on the jaws. It rarely got used for welding or any other clamping.

Along comes my pocket hole jig and I see the custom Kreg tool. Hmm...about five minutes of work with my angle grinder and that lone c-clamp now has a job to do.

Mine was free but the HF three pack is cheap and adequate for the job. I doubt that I'd buy the HF locking c-clamps for welding since I always clamp harder.

Google "locking c clamp" and you'll find Irwin, the good ones, with non-swivel jaws for under $10.

I'm going to weld on larger pads to one of my swivel jaw c-clamps for pocket screwing.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#15

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions

david in indy

I took a class at Marc Adams from Gary Striegler about interior trim. He used pocket screws extensively. We built fireplace mantels, dooors, transom windows, etc.

The big advantage is speed. Even when you are using glue in the joint, once the screw is in you can move on to the next step without clamping or waiting for the glue to dry. Can't do that with biscuits.

Gary made the point that much interior trim work has a limited life and so it made sense to save the dovetails and mortise and tenons for the pieces that don't.

Re: Pocket hole screws; Kreg jig; questions *LINK*

#16

Right you are

Merle

Earl, just me showing off my ignorance once again. :)