Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Electrical question

Posts

Electrical question

#1

Electrical question

Larry in nw ohio

I`m doing some wiring for my SIL, I`m not the best at this, but can do the simplest like he has. The thing that set me back was that when he hung the switch box, he put it upside down, if there is such a thing. Does it really matter if the main is at the bottom. I don`t really see what would be wrong with it, but like I said I`m not the best. I just never saw it like that, but I don`t know why not. But I know there is a why not reason. Thank You Larry

Re: Electrical question

#2

JL

Re: Electrical question

JL

By switch box, do you mean the circuit breaker box?

By convention - if not regulation - the main breaker is at the top of the box.

The box - if it has numbers stamped on it - would have the numbers upside down and in the wrong place. Lower numbers should be at the top.

Re: Electrical question

#3

Re: Electrical question

John Veerkamp

Electricity doesn't care! some building inspectors might. I've seem them installed sideways due to space considerations. If the main feed came in low there would be a good reason to put the box above the feed "upside down".

Re: Electrical question

#4

Re: Electrical question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's good, when roughing in, to have a habit for where you put your line (incoming power) and load (outgoing); makes things easier at hookup time. But it's not hard to test, if you're not sure, and there's no particular requirement for where a line enters the box, as far as I know, as long as it's properly secured.

On complex boxes, like the three-switch box I installed in the current remodel in my house, I'll take a Sharpie and label the box where each wire enters, so I can tell later. Similarly, I actually went to the trouble to label the various conduits for the data- and low-voltage-wire boxes I put on the TV wall, so I could, and a future owner could, tell where they went.

Re: Electrical question

#5

Re: Electrical question

Barry Irby

There is no reason it can't be Upside down. At least nothing in the Code demands it be right side up.

The convention of putting the main at the top came from the days of Knife switches. The reason to feed from the top down was that if the switch fell down, it would open the circuit, turning it off. (Gravity has not failed yet and it relentless) If the switch fed from the bottom and the handle fell down, it would turn the power ON, a more dangerous situation. (think Gene Wilder in the Young Frankenstein movie, it this case we don't want it alive.)

Breakers are not sensitive to position, so it does not matter. (All the rest of it about maintaining conventions and patterns and having the numbers right side up are still good thoughts. Keep it simple.)

Re: Electrical question

#6

Labeling

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I label the outlet/switch covers on the back with the circuit breaker number that controls that device. It only takes a few seconds and makes it easy to get the right breaker the first time. I wish code would demand that it be done. Labeling the box doesn't help if you don't know what the person doing the installation thought the device was going to be or what room it was going to be.

Lee

Re: Electrical question

#7

Bob

More than one way to do it

Bob

Your fine, I prefer that when the light is off the sw. is down. Some inspectors are anal about the ground wire being on the bottom but nothing in the code says you must do it that way.

Re: Electrical question

#8

Re: More than one way to do it

Brad Chenoweth

I remember watching "Holmes on Homes", they always installed the panel sideways, but they never mentioned why? Maybe it's a Canadian thing? At least I always thought the show was Canadian.

Re: Electrical question

#9

Re: More than one way to do it

Bill Howatt

Yes, he's Canadian.

I don't think we install panels sideways in new construction where there is ample room.

I had a 100A panel with something like 16 or 20 breakers replaced with a 40 breaker 200A panel. It was installed sideways. I can't recall if there was a vertical space issue since the panel including main breaker area was longer but I think the main reason was that by putting it horizontal more of the original wiring would reach without extending.

Bill