Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Soft Maple

Posts

Soft Maple

#1

Soft Maple

Yonak

There is a soft maple that some call "ambrosia" maple, some call, "appalachian" maple. It could be a somewhat darker color than standard maple, brown to gray, sometimes quite dark, and/or features brown and gray flags that often have insect holes. Apparently this wood is prized by some. I find it less so because I have to fill in all the holes and my customer doesn't like all the coloring.

My preferred choice is a whiter soft maple that looks a lot like hard maple. My question is : is the ambrosia maple a different species of maple or regular soft maple that grows in different conditions, such as wetter ground, than the white soft maple ?

The reason I ask is that when I look for soft maple lumber, how do I ask the sawyer which maple is it, keeping in mind that he may only have the logs to look at or, possibly, he cut it down so he has seen the leaves, shape of the tree and growing conditions ?

It's possible that this ambrosia maple only grows in the South and the white soft maple grows only in the North. This I don't know.

Re: Soft Maple

#2

Re: Soft Maple - ambrosia beetle

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

I'm no expert - but I believe that ambrosia refers to the Ambrosia beetle that burrows (hence the tunnels), and lays it's eggs. Coloration is due to some interaction with fungus - recently discussed here or on the Turning board.

So it is not a maple species - rather maple that has been attacked by a specific bug that creates those wonderful stripes of color. I like it most in small quantities - like box tops.

Henry

Re: Soft Maple

#3

Soft Maple equals red maple

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When you are talking about commercial lumber soft maple is red maple. Logs are easily distinguished from any other maple. However, a small saw mill might call anything that was not hard maple (red, silver, box elder etc) "soft maple". Of the maples that are soft, only the red maple is a species of commercial interest.

I have seen red maple as far south a Florida. But even here in TN it doesn't grow well enough to be an important timber species at lower elevation. It is a common timber species in the northern states.

Re: Soft Maple

#4

Re:  Soft Maple equals red maple

Yonak

Bill, is there a way to tell if a log has been affected before milling it ? Thanks.

Re: Soft Maple

#5

Re:  Soft Maple equals red maple or sliver maple

Tom Dunlap

Red=Acer rubrum

Silver=Acer saccarinum

Both have been called 'Soft' maple.

Red maple has the widest growth range of any hardwood tree. It grows almost anywhere in North America.

Many horticulture/arboculture tree research stations use Red Maple as their stock 'lab rat' species since it's so widely grown.

Tom

Re: Soft Maple

#6

maybe

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is very little soft maple sawed in my area and of what there is I have never seen any with the beetle holes. The turners say that the local box elder has some similar infestation that makes red holes in the wood. Again, I don't know anything about it.

To get to your question, it is likely that an experienced log buyer can spot this damage. Anyone could spot it if there happened to be a red hole at the end of the log where it could be seen on the fresh sawed surface.

I don't know anything about this damage. It certainly is not common where red maple grows well into marketable timber. There is a shop in Berea KY that makes furniture from infested lumber. I haven't asked for details but they seem to have some local source of damaged logs. Don't know if infestations are a local affair, or something stressed trees are subject to, or trees growing in mild climate. Just don't know. The only time I have ever seen it is in the shop in Berea; never at an area saw mill. Maybe loggers can spot it and leave the logs in the woods, which is why I don't see it at mills.

Of course buying graded lumber rather than logs will eliminate the problem.By NHLA grading standards a heavily infested board would grade as pallet lumber.

Re: Soft Maple

#7

A couple of quick pictures....

Barry Irby

Here is a picture of the end of a cut off from a blank or half log of maple. Don't know exactly what species it is, but it is soft maple and it came from a yard tree about a block form my house in near Richmond VA. As you can see, the ambrosia staining is very obvious. I spotted it in the firewood pile as I drove by on the street. The staining appears to be more intense low in the tree and disappears higher up, so the first ten or fifteen feet are affected and the rest of it is not. I posted a question about the distribution of the staining on the Turning Forum.


That blank is about 14" across. (I need to speak to my son about that "ear" he left.)

This is a bowl I turned out of it.


Obviously, as far as the staining goes, it has its place, and you either like it or you don't.

Re: Soft Maple

#8

Re: A couple of quick pictures....

Larry in nw ohio

Barry In my opinion, I like it. Looks good. Larry

Re: Soft Maple

#9

Re: maybe

Yonak

Thanks for your thoughts, Bill. I'll continue to research this question and post any pertinent information here.

It may be considered a defect but it apparently is prized around these parts as the lumber yards charge a premium price for it.

Re: Soft Maple

#10

Agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The person in Berea makes some stunning tables from this stuff. It is all in the style of what is made from it. It either compliments the style or .....not.

Re: Soft Maple

#11

Re: A couple of quick pictures....source

Tom Dunlap

if that sort of discoloration is confined to the lower trunk there are two very likely sources.

First...tapping for sap. Every time the cambium is wounded there is decay. The sap won't flow in that area until new, unwounded wood grows. This can take many years. Over the years the tap holes are rotated around the trunk which leads to that sort of decay pattern.

Another possibility is wounding from trunk injections for the health of the tree. Insecticide, fungicide...etc. All wounding.

Tom

Re: Soft Maple

#12

Re: Soft Maple

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Ambrosia maple is my favorite wood to turn. I mostly turn it into things that are not bothered by the holes. The white or cream color slowly turns to brown, then grey/blue. The longer the beetles are there, the darker it gets. At some point, based on personal choices, it becomes ugly! We usually don't bother once the grey starts. It is quite common here in the mountains of Western North Carolina. The first piece we turned was a tapered slab about 5 ft long that we turned into fifty Christmas ornaments that sold for $20/$25. I would take a truckload if I could find it. Sawmills in this area high grade their maple and sell it to turners at a premium. Once the wood is dried, the staining stops. Plain red maple sells here for about $2/bd ft. Ambrosia boards 4/4 sells for $4.50/bd foot. I have paid as much as $10/$12 bd ft for 10/4 Ambrosia kiln dried with almost white wood. I can get eighteen ornaments out of a sq ft of 10/4 maple. So at ~$1.33 blank cost it is not a bad deal.

Re: Soft Maple

#13

you are right HENRY  ambrosia beetle does it 


Re: Soft Maple

#14

Bill or anyone interested.

Barry Irby

Bill, I have the cut off ends of the short logs I am turning bowls from. There are corners left that would make a number of ornament blanks. I am thinking of making a few ornaments myself. Would you like to have the rest of it? They are green as grass right now, but drying. Tell me what size you want and I will cut them down and send them to you for the cost of the shipping. I hate to throw stuff away.

Re: Soft Maple

#15

Re: A couple of quick pictures & more info

Barry Irby

I just went and looked at the bark on the maple. There appear to be holes in the bark that correspond to the stains. These may be the entrance tunnels left by the beetles. These were I-phone pictures and not the best. I could try to take a pic of the holes, but I have my doubts.

Re: Soft Maple

#16

Sapsuckers!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is another source of holes and stain in maple and that is sapsuckers. These pesky things make a ring, or several rings, of holes around the tree, usually well off the ground. There are so few red maple where I live that I don't recall if red maple is attacked but it is not uncommon in the hard maple where I live.