Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

Posts

OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#1

OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

Keith Newton

Man oh man, what a comeback. We were down 1 - 8, but managed to win the next 8 straight. That took an amazing coordination of effort to balance the forces of those sails over such a small platform speeding through the water.

And how nice is was for me to be able to watch it all on my phone.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#2

With you.  Watched every minute.

Gary Smyth

In it from the beginning. Over 50mph SAILING above the surface on foils. America retains the America’s Cup - one of, no, THE great comeback in the history of the races. Final total of best of 17 series was America 9, New Zealand 8. (And U.S. was docked two additional races for violating rules before the finals) However, Oracle, which represents San Francisco’s Golden Gate Yacht Club and the United States, competed with just one American — Rome Kirby — on its 11-man crew. Most were new Zealanders hired for their skills. Team New Zealand stayed home bred. Nine starting crew members are New Zealanders; the other two are Australians with strong New Zealand connections. The cup was won onshore by superb engineers, money, and mostly New Zealand crew - no matter who won. Good to all.

.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#3

America's Cup.....

roger lance

Only got to watch the first race a few weeks ago in which team USA got smoked.....absolutely SMOKED!! They did not appear to be at all competitive with NZ. It was very exciting to watch these cats race at speeds exceeding 50 mph.....flying hulls.....WOW!! That's some comeback.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#4

Re: America's Cup.....

Kevin French

Yes roger, that is some win, it's hugh. That's even better then Sox-NYY '04 series, although I'll most likely remember that one longer.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#5

Re: America's Cup.....

iew

I hated every minute of it. I was even in SF one day and got to watch a few minutes. This is not your Father's Americas Cup. I want them to go back to monohulls with sleek lines that look like sailboats. Heck, even compete with J 30's. Todays AC is more like Star wars.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#6

Did you get the smart phone app?

Keith Newton

Being able to pull out my iPhone, and watch it live was so,,,,,,, Dick Tracy I thought.

I wish they would require that the majority of the teams had to be from the country being represented.

If I recall correctly, the winner gets to set the design parameters and location for the next race. This one was so exclusive, that there were very few competitors. Not everybody has the loose change to be able to spend $300,000,000 for their campaign as Ellison did for this one.

Even though it is terribly expensive, I like how these races keep pushing development of all aspects of sailing. The hardware, rigging, and spars have gotten incredibly lighter and stronger. I'm pretty sure that the racing on this level pushes lots of that development.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#7

I'm with you on this one.

paul in AZ

This crop of boats has as little relevance to sailing as the unlimited drag racers have to automobiles. They are fragile unseaworthy electronic video game marvels doing short sprints. It was a US victory in terms of money and engineering but only one man of the US' crew is American.

Even the old aluminum monohulls were borderline seaworthy. I got aboard one of them once and the skin was thin as a beer can but at least some of the technology did trickle into sailboats as we know them.

Having raced all manner of class and handicap boats for 40 odd years I watched some of the races but aside from awe at the speeds found little of interest.

I was hoping the Kiwis won so maybe they could choose to inject some sanity into the cup format.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#8

Sorry to read the above.

Gary Smyth

I’ll admit that the monohulls look nice. But remember that even those boats hung giant weighted dagger boards (half the height of the mast) with foils below the keel. Watching them through a race was like the difference of drying times between shellac to enamel. High end racing will not be the same as before, a new bar is set -- wooden ships vs. ironclads. Times and sailing have changed. A true sea change

Now that Ellison has made his point, perhaps he will agree to amend the rules to allow more nationalities to participate and play a larger part in the next America’s Cup. They have at least four years to make changes. Perhaps a strict percentage of products and design from a representative country, or at least syndicate staff and crews made up of people from the country that they represent. America’s Cup has always been about the really, really, well to do competing against one another. Not right or wrong but fact. Truth be known as the races went on I cared less about who won (well, maybe a little) than what was going on. These boats flew and the old fashioned spinnakers were gone.

If you didn’t see this, the TV coverage was spectacular – especially the real time data and graphics and cameras, from on board, to companion boats, and helicopters. The Olympics coverage should only hope to be as good. It was something. This is one time I’ll look forward to the book.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#9

Not smart phone owner but I did

Gary Smyth

search out the biggest high definition screen I could find.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#10

Re: Sorry to read the above.

paul in AZ

This discussion will no doubt go on forever. My guess is that the video game mentality will prevail. Extending that thought, is the next step to get rid of crews and sail them remotely with joy sticks from shore? It could be done.

Previous Cup boats had technologic advances that did trickle down into the boats of every day sailors.

I'm hard pressed to think of any of the technology from these boats that will make it's way into recreational or offshore racing boats.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#11

Ellison under investor attack

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Wall Street Journal, Thursday September 16. Just to the left of the picture of Ellison, celebrating on the boat he bought, was the headline "Investors are growing more dissatisfied with CEO Ellison' pay, possibly leading to showdown." I thought it an interesting juxtaposition of stories. It was reported that there was one American in the crew.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#12

Oh, I don't know about that.

Keith Newton

Your remark, "Previous Cup boats had technologic advances that did trickle down into the boats of every day sailors.

I'm hard pressed to think of any of the technology from these boats that will make it's way into recreational or offshore racing boats."

If we ever learn what the Oracle crew figured out that gained them that speed, will probably end up enlightening a lot of hungry minds.

Even on monohulls, I would imagine there will be some keel changes, or maybe articulating blades that provide a bit of change in orientation of lift. In watching these boats, it staggers my imagination to comprehend how they keep the bow up considering the tremendous power up a mast of that height.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#13

Re: Sorry to read the above.

Paul Vander Woude

Quote from Paul in AZ: "Extending that thought, is the next step to get rid of crews and sail them remotely with joy sticks from shore? It could be done."

Well it is done, and has been for years, in model sailboat racing. Scaling it up shouldn't be that technologically difficult. I have a vintage Marblehead class RC sailboat that I built about 25 years ago sitting on my fireplace mantle at home. Something like this:

http://www.theamya.org/boats/marblehead/

More realistically, computerized sail-by-wire systems might be the next step in the evolution. I have to think that with the system, it could be much faster and more accurate than a helmsman in responding to wind changes.

I loved the old America's cup boats, and love the newest ones as well. It's fun and exciting to see them pushing the technological envelope on these new sailboats, even if they aren't as beautiful and stately as the old boats. There is a place for both, just like in car races- you have the Indy Car races with the latest technology, and you can go to vintage car races to see the old cars race.

As to appling the new technology to the sailing public, how about a hobie-cat sized boat with a tall wing sail and hydrofoils? Could be pretty extreme!

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#14

Hobie had a hydrofoil 10 years ago

Keith Newton

Back before I quit racing about 10 years ago, someone showed up out at the club with one. I don't think he could get up on it except on a reach though.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#15

Re: Sorry to read the above. *LINK*

William Duffield

I think the trickle-down has been occurring right along, and will continue. Here is a half-century-old McCutcheon Shelly plywood hull Classic Moth, with an even older sail design, flying just last weekend. See the youTube Video llink at the bottom of this post. Joe also designs, builds and sails Modern Moths with foils. He's a public school teacher, and his development budget is miniscule, especially when compared with the salary of the highest paid CEO in the U.S.

More info, including Joe's report on its first flight, can be found on his blog.

http://madmothist.blogspot.com/2013/09/the-worlds-oldest-foiling-moth.html

I used to have one just like it. :)


I don't think Joe's was in any better shape than mine was at the time he began it's restoration.


Classic Moth with Foil

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#16

Re: Hobie

Gary Smyth

Keith, not many know of Hobie. Back about 1963 I was swept up in the surfing craze. At that time I worked on the Wildwood NJ Beach Patrol and I spent every dime I made (and was going to make) that summer for a Hobie surf board. Hobie Alter remains one of my heroes even today. By 1965 Alter expanded his designs and produced the Hobie 14, a small fiberglass and tube catamaran. I sold my board and added more for ½ of a 14 (about $400) that I never sailed as my partner ground and punctured the bottom of one of the hulls on the stony lake Erie shore showing off the very first time out. I remember though that at that time one of the things that Hobie (reportedly) said was that he made his cats based in the early ocean cats of Polynesia. Hundreds, if not a thousand of years earlier than the monohulls of Europe the cat was the mode of blue water transport. Fast, reliable, seaworthy, they met all conditions of the South Pacific and Indian Ocean waters. I’m not choosing one hull over another as an aesthetic item. But because the Isle if Wight race choose the European style ship to race – before it was called “America’s Cup” should not automatically eliminate the catamaran as a legitimate racing boat. They are merely an extension of what came long before.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#17

Re: Hobie had a hydrofoil 10 years ago

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

i was talking to my dad this morning and this very topic came up. my dad used to race A class out of fleet three in long beach and one of his friends was the guy that put foils on a Hobie 16. It was part of his masters or doctorate thesis. my dad thinks he sold the patent to Yamaha.

Robin

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#18

That is interesting, I have a friend,

Keith Newton

Who is an eye surgeon, that was also a sailor, that invest a million in a hydrofoil sailboat back in the early 90ies. The inventor/ maker wanted to develop it for the market. He was trying to set some Atlantic crossing record, if I recall right, but it didn't make it, so I'm sure he lost a bundle. He later married a good friend whom I grew up with. Wish I would have remembered that, and invited myself over to watch some of this with him.

Back when I was racing regularly, I was down in the Florida Keys getting ready to go out for a club race in Bullseye's. A young couple showed up at the docks of the club. My partner could tell they were sailors, and ask if they wanted to go out. They declined, then later I ran into them again as a full moon was rising out on a jetty by the inlet. They called out to me as they approached how we did in the races. We had won both, congrats etc, Where you from? Newport RI. OH great place, we sailed out of there in Oct of 98, right behind Hurricane Mitch for Bermuda. Four days and 9 hrs in a Swan 42 I said, which probably would have been a great time for that course if it had been a race. ha ha, Which was the perfect setup for his wife to ask. "Honey, What was the time on your last trip out to Bermuda?" 18 HOURS, was his casual answer! My jaw dropped to the max.

Wow, What were you on? Playstation. What was that like, I ask? Well, you start out in full foul weather gear with helmet and face mask, but the heat from working fogs the mask, so it gets tossed. Then for the rest of the trip, it is like getting shot repeatedly in the face with a paint-ball gun. She said his face was so swollen that his eyes were just slits, and bleeding cracked lips. Not fun, but and experience.

We won the national championship in the Bullseyes that year, and got to go to the Champion of Champions down in Huston. We were 150# overweight for the boats, so had no delusions of winning anything, but had a blast just being on the starting line with another 16 - 20 other dingy fleet national champions.

The starting line is probably the most exciting moment in most races, especially if it is crowded with great sailors, but then crowded mark roundings and tight finishes are up there too.

I'd like to see an A Cup Regatta with about 50 nations showing up with these boats on one starting line together. That would definitely be a Darwin survival of the fittest event. Maybe Ellison will set the design parameters down to 36' length multi-hull, foils, wing mast, citizen of home country crew requirement for the next event. Then lets have it somewhere that the winds are fluky where you have to play the shifts up and down every leg. AHRRRRRrrrr

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#19

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

Howard Acheson

>>>> And how nice is was for me to be able to watch it all on my phone.

If that's how you watched it, you lost most of spectacle of the racing. Watching it on a good, hi-def large screen TV was spectacular. The venue was spectacular and so were the boats. But the winner was the graphics and the fact that the racing was staged to allow the greatest visibility for the spectators.

Sure, they are not the type of boats we can go out and buy but then, Formula I cars are not found in many suburban garages either.

I sailed on a couple of Amrica's Cup 12 meters years ago and they were exciting boats too. But there were few spectator craft and even less on-water coverage.

I hope teams can find the funding to put on another event like this. IMO, it was the most spectacular sporting even ever shown on TV.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#20

another view

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Given all the enthusiasm here I recorded and watched it. No doubt those that sail were excited by it all for they had a clue what was going on. I didn't have a clue what was going on. The terms used by the announcers had no meaning to me, the strategy was not explained, the technical aspects of what all the cranking of what ever it was they were cranking remained a mystery. For all the graphics little effort was devoted to explaining this race to those that have never sailed. I was reminded of the situation where someone sees a hockey game for the first time and is left bewildered.

I was disappointed that the boat was not shown in detail and its parts explained. That alone might have captured my interest.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#21

Re: America's Cup.....

roger lance

I'm very impressed by the number of sailors that are on this forum.....it appears that woodworking and sailing might have some common appeal for many here. I've gone to YouTube to watch videos of this America's Cup and older videos of past Cups featuring 12 Meters with Stars and Strips and Dennis Conner. IMHO, this year's races with these cats was far more interesting/exciting.....and the venue was also great....seeing San Francisco in the background as opposed to open ocean is way more interesting.....40+ knots vs 12+ knots is no contest....and flying BOTH hulls at the same time had to have a real element of danger/instability.....these cats do dig in and flip. The America's Cup has always been a venue of the ultra rich....and will continue to be.....but it has become far more entertaining than in prior series. Perhaps the announcers could do a more detailed explanation of whats going on and why for non-sailors but this was an impressive display of sailing at the highest level.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#22

Re: Ellison under investor attack

Tom

He seems like a killer... But, the whole Blackberry thing occurred after one of the founders blew his brains out in a quest to bring a second hockey team to Southern Ontario...

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#23

Re: another view

Tom

These days I watch TV with my netbook, or tablet (each costing 150). I am sure you can find any info you want on there. But like you (though in my case a lifelong boat guy) I have little idea what is going on. I don't care for match racing, though it is a real art. The boats do interest me.

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#24

Re: I'm with you on this one.

Tom

"This crop of boats has as little relevance to sailing as the unlimited drag racers have to automobiles. They are fragile unseaworthy electronic video game marvels doing short sprints. It was a US victory in terms of money and engineering but only one man of the US' crew is American."

I doubt they are fragile any more. And that is a potential condition of most race boats, though obviously the sails are single purpose. I remember one of the recent cups had equally matched monos in the run up, and the whole bow pulled off in a race. This change over to a new style in the racing has occurred at the same time as the move to carbon in structures. And that is a material that can create huge toughness, but normally starts off with spectacular failures.

The whole multihull thing is really eating up a lot of stuff that was typically mono territory and the America's cup was slow to join that party. Multis have been winning offshore races for half a century (as I am sure we all know). The practical outflow of that has been huge strides in acceptance in tradition circles, with most people with the coin preferring multis for cruising etc...

Foils are another mater. There was an American in the 60s or 70 who built a backyard foiler trimaran and crossed the Pacific, Williwaw. But the technology to build the current crop of foils has been long in coming. Remember the craze for hydrofoil passenger ferries in the 70s? But we are there, and as a non-racing guy, I am out of touch, but stunned to discover the number of old dingy classes that have succumbed to the foil craze and are now foiling classes.

As a watcher of the cruising side of this, I think the next big step, and we are pretty much there, is the solar powered trimaran/hybrid. We have reached a point where people will be able to motor everywhere is small backyard boats, and this has huge ramifications. I think this could be a next big thing, since it is possible to do more with less that way, and it might hold back development in other areas, since most people prefer motors. The early records were snagged by people with the billions, Ilan Voyage, etc... But Yanmar endeavour was done for classic car money, and from some early Connors era multi tech. Now, as I say, we are at the point where solar may be able to do this kind of thing.

Even the old aluminum monohulls were borderline seaworthy. I got aboard one of them once and the skin was thin as a beer can but at least some of the technology did trickle into sailboats as we know them.

"Having raced all manner of class and handicap boats for 40 odd years I watched some of the races but aside from awe at the speeds found little of interest."

It probably pays more to have a background in iceboat racing where foilers are concerned. :)

"I was hoping the Kiwis won so maybe they could choose to inject some sanity into the cup format. "

Big multi scene. These boats are basically scaled up versions of Little America's Cup boats, though most of the classy places where people dress as sailors are still pretty conventional. But the Little America's cup racing which was multi doinated in the US, and was lost to the lands down under a long time ago, which I guess is part of the reason they are so good at it. It is now pretty international.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkWkJ7V0DxY

Re: OT, YAAAAH, Team Oracle USA,won the CUP

#25

Re: Oh, I don't know about that.

Tom

"In watching these boats, it staggers my imagination to comprehend how they keep the bow up considering the tremendous power up a mast of that height. "

Those are scary things. But the big difference with multis is that crashing and flipping aside, they convert the energy into speed. Monos convert energy into heeling which causes them to depower, which is in a sense handy, if not for racing. Heeling converts into weather helm, because the drag moves outboard of the foils (conventional sense of foils as in sailing is "a foil in the air, and a foil in the water". Even if the boat is some wooden galleon.)

With foilers, you even get rid of the capsize concern to some extent. As the speeds increase, the boat uses the water to increase it's hook into the water, and also to eventually rise out of the water thereby allowing a further conversion to speed. A conventional multi heels more and more until it goes over, and that can be a pretty low heel if it is beyond the size where the weight of a few guys is determinative. But with foils the foil under the leeward side creates a counter force. Or something.