I like being done and buying drawer pulls meant I was essentially done because I was unable to vision a wood pull. Then you provided an idea that was at first rejected but one that won't go away. Now if I can figure out how to do the shaping in the recalcitrant Blackwood.
I don't know what I'd use for standoffs--maybe some brass pipe. I'd probably do the handle shaping out of slightly oversize square stock on the drum or oscillating spindle sander.
The stand offs will be cylinders of blackwood turned on the lathe. I'll try the shaping, something I am not good at, except you just kindled a shaping idea that will involve the router and a jig.
You and your %$!!@#! labor causing ideas. The desk already has 97 parts and 80 joints; what's a few more. I still have plenty of time to work on it before squirrel season provides distraction.
Shop I used to work for made lots of square knobs like this, but without the stand off. Just a 1/4" dowel glued into the knob blank then freehand shaping using the drum end of a big belt sander, knob held with a handle made of scrap wood.
The drum provides the curve, the upper corner of the knob blank provides one index and the size of the scrap handle the other, grind to fit between them. Last step was to dome the end slightly.
Once shaped, the dowel was cut to about 3/8" sticking out and glued into a matching hole on the drawer or door.
Usually only took a few practice knobs to get a new guy able to do those by eye.
Ash can ebonise well-in a rust and vinegar solution-or dye stain etc-The ash would be far easier to shape than the Balckwood and still tie things together-Unless you are adverse to the staining idea I suppose...
BTW Great form and execution of the rest of the desk.
You don't need to finish this before squirrel seas
Keith Newton
You could just take a knife along and whittle them while you sit and wait. If you work fast, the squirrels would hear you, and just think it was another gnawing on a Hickorynut then come to join you.
I tried some pull shapes with stand-offs. These are small drawers and it is going to require a small pull to look good. The pulls I came up with that stood off from the drawer face became frail as I shrunk their dimensions to blend with the not very tall drawer. It will be a solid pull or metal and I am leaning to black bronze metal for durability. But I have not given up on wood yet.
How about tapering the solid wood pull? If they're small drawers, they won't be heavily loaded or hard to open, so small tapered wood pulls would provide adequate gripping without the problem of a standoff piece.
I've already suggested no pulls. The drawer fronts are small with plenty of visual interest in them already. I think, from your description of work you've done so far, it sounds like you could easily end up with something that adds clutter. But if I really was stuck on the idea of adding a pull of some sort it would be small so that only an index finger, or possibly the index finger plus thumb could grip it, be very dark, probably grey or black, and probably mounted along the top edge- certainly nowhere near the middle of the drawer front: a small black tongue hanging out comes to mind.
Still, no pulls on the front is what I think I'd go for so those existing attractive lines aren't visually compromised. Slainte.
Bill that turned out great. Try 800 or 1200 automotive sanding disks with oil I am told it works well, maybe try it on the underside to see if its what your looking for. Again great job.
I agree with Paul. Your approach to the stretchers is ingenious. If it were mine, I think I would try to echo the shape of the central portion of the stretchers in the handles, maybe with ebony filling the empty space between the stretchers.
The dovetailed upper stretcher and double tenoned lower stretcher are typical joinery for Federal period and Shaker small tables. But, I'm curious about the reason for two dovetails in the top of your front leg. Usually the side apron is joined to the leg with mortise and tenon. That way, less material is removed from the top of the leg, adding strength to the dovetail.
When additional strength is needed, at the expense of more effort, the upper drawer blade is widened, stepped for the difference in length between the legs and the between the side aprons, and another tail is cut into the longer extension of the stretcher, to match a socket in the side apron. Here's a rough sketch. Laying out and executing these joints is pretty exacting work.
The side of the desk is in essence a frame with a curly ash panel. What you drew would work for a Federal Table with a single board for the side but it won't for this side.
The issue becomes how to attach what is the top of the frame for the panel to the leg. I don't see any reasonable alternative but a dovetail. The panel part of the side is indeed M&T into the leg (and top and bottom frame piece) with a shallow tenon so as to not whittle away too much leg. The joinery is demanding in that the shoulders of all three parts must exactly meet the leg on both ends. You can see that I missed by a few thousandths of an inch on the panel shoulders on this end, but many won't notice.
This isn't the weak link anyway. The weak link is the attachment of the drawer blades, or whatever we call them now days. To strengthen the desk for forces acting in this area I added the novel stretcher that porvides support to the front legs , yet stays out of the way of one's legs while sitting at the desk.
Now, I understand, and I agree with everything you did.
Regarding the little gaps at the end of the panel tenons (an interesting solution to a difficult problem), I hate it when that happens. I saw the gaps on the first photo that you posted above, but like you, I decided they wouldn't be noticed. They looked kind of familiar, but I didn't really understand how or why they got there. There is a way to avoid them, but it's really fussy.
For those following along, usually, one avoids them by cutting haunched tenons, because that way you don't have to flip the board on its edge in your sled, and take the risk that it didn't register exactly the same as when you cut the shoulders along the face. Instead, you trim the ends of the tenons, both cheeks and shoulders, on the bandsaw.
However, Bill and I both realize that haunched tenons won't work for this case, because the extended mortise needed to accept them would compromise both the dovetail in the upper rail and the double tenon in the lower rail. Here's the fussy part: You cut the front and back shoulders on the tablesaw (or however you usually do it), but cut the ends of the tenon the same way you would a haunched tenon, but cut the haunch only about a sixteenth high. Then you clamp the panel on end in your shoulder vise, and take a chisel that is wider than the tenon, but narrower than the panel, and pare off the haunch, undercutting it, but not touching the front edge of the shoulder. It won't show and it won't keep the joint from closing up.
I do this frequently with small drawers that have bottoms accessible from underneath. Glue a small strip of something that you can catch with fingertips to the bottom side of the drawer. Set it far enough back that the drawer front will clear the front rail when pulled.