Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

Posts

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#26

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well, Dad was at Hemlock from '92 to '00 or so, I think. He may have gone back to the corporate HQ a couple years before '00 (I think that's when he retired), but if you visited there during that time, I suppose there's a chance you met him.

I think I finally may have convinced him that silicone caulk is wholly inappropriate for some applications...

Jason

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#27

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Howard Norman

Jason, I probable made my last trip to Hemlock about 92. I retired in 94. I may have met your father, who knows.

Since I was a customer most of my contact was with marketing and general management but I did have contact with operational people at times. Where did your Dad fit into the organization? When I think of DC I think of Duane Townley. Duane and I go back to when he joined DC as a measurement guy and was marketing manager when I retired. Unfortunately I have lost contact with Duane over the last ten years. Hope that he is OK.

Howard

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#28

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

He would have been the #2 guy at the plant, whatever title that garnered. I think it basically meant he was in charge of operations, starting there in about August or September of '92. Even if you didn't run into him, it's a small world!

Jason

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#29

Look at TOTAL COST

charlie belden

Evaluating the cost effectiveness of alternative energy sorces one must consider the actual TOTAL COST of alternatives.

Coal is probably the "cheapest" energy source - if you only look at PART of the ACTUAL COST - the cost to extract, transport and burn. If you include the additional ACTUAL COST - negative health impacts of particulates on lungs, mercury going into the food chain, ecoloogical impacts of tearing off the tops of mountains and dumpinng the overburden into rivers, creeks and streams, cost to safely dispose of fly ash, etc. AND the cost of the loss of a coal miner's life . . .

Oil - factor in the cost of 911, wars we've fought in the middle east, the cost of the navy to secure the shipping lanes - the costs of spills, the oil company subsidies, etc.

Nucear power? It only took Three Mile Island to kill its future. Add the Nakashima distaster. Then there's the What Do You Do With All The Nuclear Waste costs.

Natural gas? Looks real promising - IF - fracking doesn't pollute the underground aquifers that supply clean water to the middle third of the country. THAT is a big IF. If you think the demand for energy and its cost is an issue - consider what happens to the cost of water if it becomes scarce. I can live without coal, oil, nantural gas and nuclear generated electricity. Water? Go without water for a week and you're dead.

The energy to produce solar panels is high and so the cost of solar is high - now. That will come down over time.

WIND on the other hand looks promising and aside from birds being hit and killed, seems to have the least impact on the environment. There are aesthetic issues with windpower, but nowhere neer the visual impact of electrical transmission lines.

The major obstacle to our energy future is not power generation. The obstacle is power transmission - something we're just now starting to focus on - for strategic reasons.

Accounting is great for evaluation the cost effectiveness of alternative energy sources. BUT - you have to account for ALL, or at least all of the MAJOR, costs.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#30

Re: Look at TOTAL COST

Mark Nowicki

Ok, where should we consider it?

Should we add a few hundred trillion dollars to the initial investment of $20K, or should we add the trillions

to the savings realized in year 10?

In either case I don't think Jesper should be stuck with the entire cost or enjoy the entire benefit.

Mark

( feeling guilty that I might have caused 9/11 because I have a power line connected to my house)

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#31

And by that logic...

John in NM

We would need to consider some of the true costs involved with solar as well as conventional energy. Many of the "costs" associated with other forms of energy also apply to alternative energy production. Many of the assumptions about product lifespan and viability of recycling are just that, assumptions.

Much of the trouble is that politics is involved on all sides, and typical of all politics, there is a vested interest in hiding costs, obtaining subsidies and favors, and generally muddying the waters to the point where it comes down to the voters simply believing whatever their flavor of politico says.

I have a feeling though, if we could clear all the muddy water, get rid of all the subsidies, and just compare a few numbers, fossil fuels would still come out cheaper than the alternatives.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#32

Re: And by that logic...

R Payne

I listen to NPR on occasion and they have interview various folks who've tried to put all the numbers into the equation.

For wind the numbers tend to range from around 0.8 to 1.1 X coal. Solar generally is worst at 0.9 to 2.5 X coal (I never have figured out what such a big range on that one, I guess assumptions are being made about total environmental impact).

If burning fossil fuels is a major factor in the current global warming (and the current science says it is), then alternatives are much cheaper in the long run.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#33

Thanks Charlie, well put

Dick Coers

Nothing is a simple equation these days, but if we do nothing because it is cheaper now, we just kick the can down the street and expect our kids and grandkids to take care of it. My parents did it, but I do as much as I can now so I start to change the cycle. A new fact is emerging about the air quality we are making now. Asthma is dramatically increasing, with more and more children carrying inhalers all the time. I know people that bought up cheap light bulbs because they didn't want to be forced into energy saving bulbs. Incredible that folks are so short sighted.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#34

Re: And by that logic...

Brian from Monument

On the flip side of the fossil fuel equation, if the science is right and fossil fuel burning and not a natural planet tendency towards ice ages and warmer times alternating, then we are already past the point at which turning off fossil fuel plants would stop the cycle. That means that any changes made now are useless.

Yet some may sleep better at night, but we still need electric power and there only so many ways to generate it efficiently, and since this administration and morons in Nevada can't allow the nuclear waste to travel to yucca for permanent storage, this country is in for a nuclear catastrophe that will make Fukishima, chernobyl and three mile island look like picnics.

Coal, oil, nuclear, natural gas, propane, solar, and wind in no particular order are the major ones that come to mind. Nuclear, solar and wind have no major CO2 problems.

If every house had solar panels and wind turbines, we might not need as many power plants as we have now.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#35

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Look at TOTAL COST

Jesper, Denmark

It is a well posed QUESTION, Charlie. But, as you indicate, the answer is not so simple.

All of the combustion processes to generate power put carbon into the air and contribute to the global warming problem. Once exception could be pure hydrogen, but that is way out in the future. Of these, lignite coal is worst and natural gas the least.

I'm not convinced that the energy used to produce solar panels is high in relation to their lifetime production. The solar panel industry is not subsidized, so the cost of energy to produce them must be included in their sales price. The actual purchase price of the panels themselves were less than half the cost of the installation, so figuring in transportation and profits in the distribution chain, maybe $1000 worth of energy might have been used. Further extrapolating, you might argue that this could be equal to the energy production from one year of operation. The raw material is basically silica - sand - and readily available. The production technique is similar to producing semiconductors for computers or flat screen displays. Both use some nasty organic materials and acids in the manufacture, but these are well controlled and removed or neutralized before the ventilation from the plant is released to the atmosphere.

You mention aestetics of wind turbines and their reputation for killing birds. Whether you like the looks of the wind systems is a personal thing. I submit that they are no worse than other infrastructure constructions, such as highways, factories, oil well pumps, bridges etc. etc.

Local power distribution is ugly - if on poles along the road - but this can be put undreground. Hig voltage distribution is not so easy to bury.

There are a lot of wind turbines installed here. Probably 25 or more within a 3 mile radius from my house. If birdstrikes were a major problem, one would expect to se dead birds around the mills - but that is not the case.

One aspect of using wind or solar is the fact that their production is not continuous, and typically has overproduction when the demand is lowest and underproduction when demand is high. This requires some form of storage - or at least re-distribution to where the demand is. Up to a point, it is easy to send the excess into the net and use it elsewhere, reducing the power generation need in fired power plants. However, should these methods of generating power become the major source, there is a problem.

Accounting is great. But, like statistics, it is not an exact science. Particularly not in a situation where many of the factors are not well known and subject to ideologic skewing.

But, if we don't keep asking the questions, we will not get anywhere close to the answers.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#36

Nakashima distaster

GolfSteve in Calgary

I never thought Nakashima's work was a disaster - I kind of like that natural look in furniture :-)

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#37

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Hydrogen

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Hydrogen is only a means of storing/transferring power, not a source. Since hydrogen does not occur naturally on Earth in elemental form, it must be produced. And, there is no way to produce hydrogen that is not a net loss of energy--that's not just about efficiencies, either, it's about the chemistry of all the compounds from which hydrogen could be readily freed.

All humans exhale carbon dioxide, too. Are we to be regulated?

Jason

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#38

Population is the issue

Merle

IMO. I don't think we would have had this thread if the earth's population were, oh, say a billion people, but 7+ billion (and increasing by 1.1% per year) people are straining all of the earth's systems and resources. One article suggests the total carrying capacity of the earth is between 9-10 billion people. Think how much fun we will be having in 30 years when there are global shortages of everything except people.

http://www.geohive.com/earth/population_now.aspx

http://www.livescience.com/16493-people-planet-earth-support.html

Happy Saturday morning!

P.S. I commend Jesper for the investment he made and the savings he has/will enjoy that he described in his initial post starting this thread.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#39

That is precisely the problem...

John in NM

Is it 0.9x or 2.5x? Why the huge range? How many assumptions are involved in those figures? Would anyone outside of government actually attempt to base policy on such vague guesses as these?

For alternative energy to be realistically viable, it would have to be so obviously effective and convenient that people lined right up to acquire systems to produce it. That they do not demonstrates to me that it is not realistically viable at the present time, and for me, that ends the discussion.

Now if people, the world over, were as enthusiastic about getting little wind turbines as they are about getting cell phones, we wouldn't be having this discussion. It is simply going to take a revolutionary innovation of that magnitude to make wind or solar viable energy sources.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#40

Re: That is precisely the problem...

R Payne

Alternative energies are so un-viable that Germany gets around a quarter of it's energy needs that way. With plans to be entirely off fossil fuels and using renewables by 2050.

The rest of the world is passing us by as we sit here complaining what they are doing isn't viable.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#41

Not complaining at all...

John in NM

I call it viewing the world as it is rather than as I wish it were :D

Take away subsidies and tax incentives (like with cell phones - well, mostly) and in all likely hood Germany's plans would go no where.

I'll believe alternative energy is viable when companies are building the infrastructure simply to make sales - like they do with cell phones, all over the world.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#42

Re: Not complaining at all...

R Payne

Just don't forget to take away the billions oil companies get (more than alternative energies).

There has to be a certain demand for anything to sell, right now (at least in the U.S.) oil company lobbyists work hard to keep fossil fuels looking attractive which skews the apparent demand.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#43

Sure, sure...

John in NM

The demand for petroleum products has everything to do with lobbying :\

Give me a break! Demand for fossil fuel products is driven by their being cheap and convenient. Easy to store, easy to transport, with a very high power density compared to any other source. That is why they are popular.

Remove all the subsidies and tax breaks for all energy sources and I think you would find that fossil fuels remain cheap and popular relative to alternative sources.

I do not advocate for government subsidies or favoritism for any industry, so that does not enter into it. Remove them all and let the market choose is fine by me -- I'm willing to bet I know what that choice will be, based on the rationale I explained earlier.

I have nothing against solar or wind power - they just remain impractical for the bulk of current applications. Wishing it were otherwise doesn't make it so.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#44

Re: Sure, sure...

R Payne

I didn't say lobbying has everything to do with the cost of petrol. But the lobbying keeps billions of tax money in the U.S. going to support fossil fuels.

I agree, get rid of all subsidies (fossil fuels, alternative energies, food, wool, honey - everything). Of course prices will go up. A lot.

Solar, wind, geothermal, hydro all of these have problems. Some are still more expensive than coal/gas. Some are not. Those that aren't also aren't being developed. Conspiracy theorist claim this is because the fossil fuel industry lobbies congress to make it difficult for them to get going. I think it is more ignorance on the part of the average consumer, the guy who just doesn't want to search for the truth, who just is comfortable where he is and doesn't want anything to upset his comfort. Well that comfort isn't going to last much longer, the options are to start changing now while it's relatively easy even if it is a bit more costly or be forced to change later when it'll be much more expensive and probably harder.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#45

Its not laziness...

John in NM

The average consumer does not pursue alternatives because they are not cheap and convenient. I do not know of any alternative energy that is cheaper than coal, cheaper than oil. It's easy enough to claim that ignorance is borne of laziness or some conspiracy, but more often the reason is that untenable ideas to not generate excitement outside of the political arena.

History does not agree with you that change is more expensive and probably harder. Change comes when it is cheaper and easier than continuing the older way. One day oil and coal will likely become too expensive to extract - but no one can predict when that time will come with any certainty.

Attempting to induce change artificially is a fools errand, just as attempting to artificially maintain a truly unsustainable status quo is a fools errand.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#46

Re: Its not laziness...

R Payne

Change does not always come when it becomes easy. Sea level is rising and rising more each year. It won't be cheap or easy to find room for the billion or so people who will lose homes when the sea claims that coastline.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#47

First of all... *LINK*

John in NM

Time to put up some referencing :D You are starting to make wild and unsubstantiated claims, and have even gone so far as to mention conspiracy theorists as implicit support. Lets see some references.

Contrary to your assertion earlier that "current science" says there is a warming trend tied to CO2 emission, there is ample research that calls this warming trend itself into question, and also casts a skeptical eye on presumed correlation between CO2 emission and this questionable warming trend.

The blog post in the link below contains a great summary of recent headlines, data charts, and research that contradict the politically correct narrative of global warming.


http://wattsupwiththat.com/2013/08/10/what-the-year-of-living-dangerously-at-nearly-400-ppm-of-co2-in-earths-atmosphere-looks-like/

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#50

And back to "current science" *LINK*

John in NM

"Current science" actually tends to take no position on whether any warming trends are anthropogenic or not -- and it shouldn't. The assignation of such "blame" is the stuff of bias and should be beneath scientific research. That the rate of impartiality is as low as 66% is actually quite disappointing - this influence of research by the press and policy makers is a large part of the reason I tend to be so skeptical when confronted with the alleged certainty of global warming in popular culture.


http://www.staatvanhetklimaat.nl/2013/05/17/cooks-survey-not-only-meaningless-but-also-misleading/