Re: Look at TOTAL COST
Jesper, Denmark
It is a well posed QUESTION, Charlie. But, as you indicate, the answer is not so simple.
All of the combustion processes to generate power put carbon into the air and contribute to the global warming problem. Once exception could be pure hydrogen, but that is way out in the future. Of these, lignite coal is worst and natural gas the least.
I'm not convinced that the energy used to produce solar panels is high in relation to their lifetime production. The solar panel industry is not subsidized, so the cost of energy to produce them must be included in their sales price. The actual purchase price of the panels themselves were less than half the cost of the installation, so figuring in transportation and profits in the distribution chain, maybe $1000 worth of energy might have been used. Further extrapolating, you might argue that this could be equal to the energy production from one year of operation. The raw material is basically silica - sand - and readily available. The production technique is similar to producing semiconductors for computers or flat screen displays. Both use some nasty organic materials and acids in the manufacture, but these are well controlled and removed or neutralized before the ventilation from the plant is released to the atmosphere.
You mention aestetics of wind turbines and their reputation for killing birds. Whether you like the looks of the wind systems is a personal thing. I submit that they are no worse than other infrastructure constructions, such as highways, factories, oil well pumps, bridges etc. etc.
Local power distribution is ugly - if on poles along the road - but this can be put undreground. Hig voltage distribution is not so easy to bury.
There are a lot of wind turbines installed here. Probably 25 or more within a 3 mile radius from my house. If birdstrikes were a major problem, one would expect to se dead birds around the mills - but that is not the case.
One aspect of using wind or solar is the fact that their production is not continuous, and typically has overproduction when the demand is lowest and underproduction when demand is high. This requires some form of storage - or at least re-distribution to where the demand is. Up to a point, it is easy to send the excess into the net and use it elsewhere, reducing the power generation need in fired power plants. However, should these methods of generating power become the major source, there is a problem.
Accounting is great. But, like statistics, it is not an exact science. Particularly not in a situation where many of the factors are not well known and subject to ideologic skewing.
But, if we don't keep asking the questions, we will not get anywhere close to the answers.