Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

Posts

OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#1

Jesper, Denmark

OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Jesper, Denmark

A year ago, I had a 5.3 kW photovoltiac array installed. The intention was to take advantage of the current (sic) arrrangemnt, where the power company accepts the excess power from the system at the same rate as their supply rate - so in effect "stores" your excess power for future use.

The system has functioned without any flaws and has generated 4.5 MWh in the first year. The cunsumption in that same year has been 4.1 MWh, so an excess of 0.4 MWh.

The electric meter is linked to the power company via data transfer over the power wires and you can access the readings on an hourly basis on their website. This has been very helpful in analyzing consumption and allowed optimizing of the house consumption. All the house lighting has more or less been replaced with LED bulbs (from IKEA). The largest consumer is lighting in the shop, where a total of 965 watt type T5 fluorescent tubes are installed. They were originally on only two wal lswitches, so in effect, all had to be on to work in the shop.

This has now been changed, so there are four switches, so the light only needs to be on where you actually work. This has reduced the peak daily consumption from about 18 kWh to 8kWh.

Economically, the annual cost of power has been reduced to the fixed distribution fee of around $300 from the previous $1700 - before any tax write-offs. The pay-back of the $20,000 investment is around 8 years, counting the tax write-off.

Conclusion: Zero CO2 electric power and a reasonable economic return.

MWh= megawatthours=1000 kWh.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#2

vastly different economics..

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Government regulations, or the lack thereof, can skew the economic situation to any result. Here in the land of less government, Tennessee, my electric cost is $0.10/KWH and we use, for our all electric home, about 1MWH per month, for an average yearly bill of less than $1500. My son in law spends that much for his phone-internet service. Decorating my house with Chinese solar cells is not practical or desirable, nor will it make any measurable effect on my economics or the world's CO2 production.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#3

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Tony - Memphis

Wow, that's pretty cool. Thanks for sharing. I'd love to install some panels on my home. Our roof is oriented just right for it. For now, however, I just can't justify the expense. Not sure we'll stay put long enough for ROI (power is "cheap" here, relative to toehr regions) and we've already lost a lot of value on our house. I looked at a solar collector (more DIY friendly), but the ROI was even longer, and there were other issues. If we build again, I will definitely go solar.

Sharp produces solar panels right here in Memphis.

Tony

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#4

Re: vastly different economics..

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Bill, you echo my sentiments exactly. It is kind of like buying a new car that is more fuel efficient or an "electric hybrid". The statistics are vastly skewed by the "Green movement". I drive a 1996 GMC full size custom van. I don't put a lot of miles on the van, bought it right and probably will have it for another 4 to 6 years (it now has about 88K miles and is well maintained). When you factor in the cost of manufacturing a new vehicle in energy use, I am far more "Green" then most of the people driving hybrids. The electrical issue is another aspect I have investigated - without government kickbacks (which is really OUR money) there is no economic return with small scale (individual homes) solar or wind power. In reality there is probably a net loss in CO2 emission when the energy costs involved in the manufacture of the panels and associated equipment vs purchasing the power from an efficient utility company. If I want to go "green" I will plant a few more trees - if I could my yard would be prairie grass and wildflowers! I really don't like a golf course yard - Think of the energy savings in all countries if we just stopped cutting lawns and let the plants convert CO2 to Oxygen :>).

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#5

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Brian from Monument

Here in Colorado near Colorado Springs, the USAFA has installed a large array of photovoltaics.

It appears to be near 2 acres in size. I don't know how many panels. Nor the power generation.

I hope they publish a report on its power generation for the public to see.

Another use of photovoltaics is on motorhomes and trailers.

Here the value is good as it reduces the need to run the generator.

Still photovoltaics are NOT the complete solution.

I am still searching for a vertical wind turbine that would work for power generation.

As here in Colorado we either have sun, wind or fire. (We do have earth.)

Big problem with all these power generation methods is that you really should have a substantial battery bank to store the energy when you generate so you can use it later when YOU need it.

The heck with a few bucks of savings. Power outages happen all the time.

Some are longer than others but if your system does have storage capability you lose out.

Those that attempt to live off the grid need both photovoltaics, wind. But they must have batteries.

And a bunch too. And also an inverter if they ever want to use anything but 6v, 12v, or 24v DC power.

IE you gotta have an inverter to get to 110 AC.

My 2 cents worth. Or on this subject perhaps a milliamps worth.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#6

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Mark Nowicki

Initial investment = 20,000 whatever

saving year 1 = 1400

assuming the savings will grow 10% per year, and the 300 fixed delivery fee remains unchanged (in Fantasyland savings usually grow and costs remain the same)

yr2 - 1540

yr3 - 1694

yr4 - 1863

yr5 - 2050

yr6 - 2255

yr7 - 2480

yr8 - 2728

Total savings 16010

Initial investment 20000

Your conclusion would have gotten me an F in my Introduction to Finance class.

Mark

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#7

It is a bad investment regardless...


Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#8

Re: vastly different economics..

R Payne

Don't forget to factor in the current government subsidies to the fossil fuel industry. Without that (which is your tax money) your cost of electric would be (and is if you figure your taxes) higher than it is.

Each side tends to present the statistics that show its side in the best light.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#9

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Howard Norman

I think that many people that install photovoltaic systems do it because it makes them "feel good because they are helping the environment". And that is a legitimate reaction and decision for certain people.

I spent a 40 year career in producing polycrystalline and single crystal Silicon which is the bedrock of the photovoltaic industry. I would estimate that half of that time was devoted to "how can we do this better and cheaper" for photocells. I have now been retired for almost 20 years and we haven't solved the problems yet.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#10

Re: vastly different economics..

Mark Nowicki

Which current government subsidies you have in mind?

Mark

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#11

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Mark Nowicki

How people choose to spend their money is none of my business, and I don't really care how it makes them feel.

I probably would care if I was one of the Danish taxpayers that had to make up the tax difference.

My post meant to address the "reasonable economic return" only.

Mark

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#12

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Howard Norman

O well, it makes for interesting discussions anyway. I live in an area where there are isolated private lands and the Feds won't let you cross their lands for electricity. A very good case can be made for photovoltaics in that situation.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Jesper, Denmark

Mark,

You did not get the complete accounting story. The little diffierenece is this " counting the tax write-off".

I did not include these figures, a this was not intended as a for or against discusion, and the taxing here vs. US is vastly different. Annual write-off of 25% and a marginal tax rate of around 60% changes the picture.

The system makes sense economically and environmentally in my situation.

My only other comment to the discussion is that long term, it is not sustainable that a very small percentage of the World population use a large percentage of the Worlds energy and generate an equal proportion of the CO2.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#14

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Mark Nowicki

Jesper

If investing 20K to loose 4K just to get back 25% of something after giving away 60% of everything works for you, that's fine.

Mark

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#16

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Stuart Johnson

How do your numbers work if you figure in years 9 - 20? The investment is paid off plus has a useful residual value.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#17

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Chuck in Mtl.

What is the life span of these cells? After the 8 year payback will the still be providing power?

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#18

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Chuck in Mtl.

In some countries where electricity is expensive then an installation of supplementary systems makes sense. And the tax writeoff helps to justify the cost. In countries where power is relatively cheap then its not worth it. But IMHO if everyone helped to reduce greenhouse gases then the net result is significant.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#19

Re: OT: Forgot cost of 20K money

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Sorry but the other issue not covered is that if you "borrow" $20,000 for the (tongue in cheek) 8 years, that cost has not been factored in, even if you figure it by paying cash - you lose the interest you would be drawing. Not trying to disparage your investment, it is obviously pleasing you and probably is profitable in your situation - but the government (other people) are subsidizing the actual cost. - Also there is no costs factored in as far as repairs, this can occur due to storm damage, or just aging. Those costs are factored in by the utility company when you pay for your power from them. This may be a great deal for you (and makes you "feel good" - but would not be a viable investment here in the US - except for those applications where Utilities do not deliver power.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#20

"opportunity cost"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Even if you already have the $1 to invest, the new investment must be discounted according to the alternative use for this $1. If the $1 could be invested in say a bond(or pick what ever alternative), and the return was $0.01 per year, the investment must be compared to the $1.01 received as the alternative. So, if the new investment returned $0.01 per year the investments are equivalent in dollar return and the choice would be determined by risk or what ever other criteria was of importance to the investor. The "return" of selling the bond, and making the new investment to yield $1.01, would be zero.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#21

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Keith Newton

Jesper, that sounds great to me. After eight years, you'll be living free of one of the expenses the rest of us will be stuck with for life.

I was just wondering though. Here, at least once a decade, we seem to have a big snow or ice storm, which takes out a lot of the power lines, leaving lots of homes without power for weeks due to trees falling across the lines. I would imagine you get plenty of snow there, do you have a good way to clear it, or do you just leave it?

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#22

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Jesper, Denmark

Typically, not so much snow, and typically not too low temperatures, so a bit of sun and the black slippery surface cause the snow to slide off. They are on a roof with 45° slope.

After a 1999 freak hurricane, more or less all powerlines less than 10 kV are underground, so snow and icing conditions do not cause power outages.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#23

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Howard, I'm curious as to what company(ies) employed you for that 40 years. My father was also involved his entire career with a silicon manufacturer (initials of the company are D.C.).

The other item I don't see mentioned here is that while PV panels may reduce CO2 emissions, I think there would be some very ugly unintended consequences if their use were widespread. The elemental ingredients in PV panels is a laundry list of some of the worst, particularly heavy metals. That's an as-yet-undetermined future cost.

Don't get me wrong, I'd love to see cheap PV panels available--I could put a few hundred watts worth to use for various things both at home and as a contractor.

Jason

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#24

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The elemental ingredients in PV panels is a laundry list of some of the worst"

An easy technical problem to manage. While lead dioxide paint pigment and cadmium plated screws spread across the land are impossible to manage anything in solar panels will be easy to capture and recycle, as needed.

Some company has convinced our county schools to install solar panels. Curious that they are being installed in the least technically savvy county so I am a bit skeptical that they make economic sense. Neighbors complained about one school installation (looks? I don't know) and got it moved at a significant cost. Objection to looks could be a problem to more wide spread installation.

Re: OT: Photovoltiac 1 year update....

#25

Re: OT: Photovoltiac  1 year update....

Howard Norman

Jason, I have been at Hemlock many times over the years. Thirty nine of the years in my career were spent at Motorola in Phoenix and a couple of years as a self employed consultant after that.

Howard