Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Stain before glue up

Posts

Stain before glue up

#1

Stain before glue up

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

The desk I am currently making out of Walnut is going to be stained using a General Finish oil based stain (similar to what Bill Tindall has posted about using on walnut).

I am thinking about staining it before glue up. I know of course if you 'finish' before glue-up, not to get finish on the glue areas.

What about stain though? I wouldn't put it on the tenons of course, but what about tenon shoulders and so on.

Does the oil based stain affect adhesion?

I'm guessing the answer is yes... :)

Thanks.

Re: Stain before glue up

#2

Re: Stain before glue up

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Good guess. It will "resist" the glue.

When finishing parts before glue-up (like spindles, etm) I use blue tape to mask off the tenon, I then do the full finish routine, allow to dry, then peel off the tape when ready for glue-up. While I rarely use stain, the same routine applies.

Since the shoulders of the tenons are end-grain, stain or finish on that tiny surface will make no difference in the strength of the joint.

BTW, pre-finishing spindles etm. allows you to simply wipe off any glue squeeze with ease.

Re: Stain before glue up

#3

Yes

John in NM

Stain will inhibit adhesion, just like an oil finish.

I used to wrap tape around tenons to keep the shop's finishers from getting oily fingerprints all over the glue surfaces.

I wouldn't worry too much about tenon shoulders, they aren't crucial for adhesion.

Re: Stain before glue up

#4

Why?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is no reason to stain before glue up, except panels that are framed, which might shrink and reveal an unstained edge.

Stain is oil. Glue is water. Water...oil....I think you know the answer to that question.

Re: Stain before glue up

#5

A Different View

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Having done a number of hi-count spindle pieces


I'll differ as to reasons for pre-finishing. The example, comprised of 88 spindles could not have been properly finished if I had glued it up ahead of time. Granted I say "properly" in the context of an application of oil, then shellac, then a waterborne lacquer top coat.

Could I have oiled it after gluing? Sure.

Could I have sprayed it with shellac to get a smooth, even coating in the 1" gaps between the spindles? Seriously doubt it.

Could I have done likewise with the wb lacquer? Not a chance.

Could I have wiped/brushed on some varnish and called it a day? Sure, but I don't like varnish.

Re: Stain before glue up

#6

stain vs prefinish

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Had the question been about prefinishing I would have suspected some situation like you illustrated. But the question involved just staining. I presumed the piece was to be top coated after assembly and the staining concern was not access.

That's one awesome desk.

Re: Stain before glue up

#7

Thanks, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It's a couch :D


Commissioned during Memsahib's "Cherry Mission" decorating phase.

Re: Stain before glue up

#8

Ooops

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Even with my glasses I imagined the flowers were sitting on a desk top with leather insert on the top and a chair behind it. The design would make an awesome desk.

Re: Stain before glue up

#9

Followup/ hijack: drawers

Grant in Iowa

I have decided for my methods and skills that staining and in some cases finishing works best for my building methods and skills.

What about dovetailed drawers? I am speaking here about flush drawers without separate fronts. Where does one stop staining, finishing, etc? I always finish the top edge of the drawer front, but struggle with deciding where to stop finishing the sides... is it at the face of the drawer?, at the dovetail? the entire drawer side?

My most recent projects have had finished drawer sides just because... Where do YOU stop?

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Stain before glue up

#10

Answser to Why?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

My answer to your question of 'Why?' is that I don't have an answer.

Honestly, of all the things I've made over the years, I have never used stain. Well, maybe once or twice early on years ago. I normally don't like to stain, but my daughter wants this to be 'darker'.

I just thought it would be a little easier to stain prior to glue up.

When I'm ready, I'll glue it up, then stain it, then varnish of some flavor.

Thanks.

Re: Stain before glue up

#11

staining dovetail drawers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For "fine cabientry" which is to say when I am trying to do my best, the drawer front is usually a dark wood like walnut, cherry or mahogany and the drawer side is poplar. I want the contrast for the dovetail so I stain the pin ends with an artist brush and leave the tails "white". I then shellac the entire drawer to keep if "fresh" looking . Unfinished drawers acquire a dead looking oxidized surface over time.

Re: Stain before glue up

#12

Wanted to add..

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

that another reason I am trying stain is to even out some of the lighter sap wood. On some scrap pieces (yeah, I'm actually testing first...) the stain is evening out the lighter parts pretty well.

Joe

Re: Stain before glue up

#13

staining for beginers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The secret to attractive staining is perfect sanding. The last sanding step should be by hand in good light, watching for any dull places that indicate torn grain that is catching sanding dust. If the surface is catching dust it will catch stain particles and looks "blotchy" or dirty.




I apply stain with a "rubber" (as in rubbing not a stretchy polymer) like shellac. The rubber is a wad of tee shirt wrapped in a cover of some more durable cloth. Wet (not make soggy) the rubber with stain and apply by rubbing. Pressure squeezes stain from the interior reservoir of stain soaked in the wad of cotton. Rub it on until the color is right and then quickly wipe any excess off with the clean rag. You will not (should not) likely use more than 20 ml of stain to do a desk with this technique.

In the second picture the back has been stained and the drawer in front has not yet been stained.

Re: Stain before glue up

#14

Re: Followup/ hijack: drawers

Sgian Dubh

If you mark the shoulder line of the dovetails all across the width of the drawer side with a deeply scored line using a cutting gauge, with care you can run your dye or stain and polish up to the scored line leaving a neat end of the finish along the drawer side. Some people object to the practice of scoring dovetail shoulder lines this way, with a typical objection being that it looks unsightly... and surprisingly to me sometimes objectors declare the practice is somehow "unprofessional", even though, in my experience, the vast majority of professionals seem to have been scoring the shoulder line deeply for hundreds of years! Most objectors prefer to only score the line in the gaps between either the tails or the pins so that it isn't visible at the roots of the tails and pins after the joint is assembled. I find the absence of a scored line visually a little unusual. I don't think it's wrong, but it does mean the joint is a little slower to execute this way, and it also makes taking finish around the corner of a drawer front to a sharp ending more challenging. Slainte.

Re: Stain before glue up

#15

Couple questions - thoughts...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Bill for the additional info.

I am wondering though, you mention "The last sanding step should be by hand in good light". Lately I have been using hand planes more and more and not sanding. Do you ever go from plane to finish, or do you always use sand paper last? I like the look and feel of the planed surface; assuming of course no tear out and so on.

Regarding the rubber, I am familiar with its use from using shellac. I hadn't considered using one for stain. I was going to brush it on and wipe off excess. I will give this method a try on scrap.

Thanks.

Re: Stain before glue up

#16

pre-finished drawers.....

roger lance

Grant....I like to pre-finish....use tape on the pins for protection and finish the inside of the drawer fronts as well.....




Re: Stain before glue up

#17

Staining planed surfaces

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never been able to successfully stain a planed surface with a pigment stain. They are too porous and drink up stain to yield an overly dark effect that will probably be blotchy from imperfect sanding. I can not overemphasize the importance of a perfectly prepared surface for the success of a pigment stain. For walnut, end with 180 or 220 and there must not be any dull places. The walnut must have a uniform luster at this stage.

Once a finish with any sort of build is applied it matters not whether the surface was planed, sanded to 180, or 600. What you see will be the finish surface, and not the wood below.

I get the attraction of a silky smooth planed surface. Nice to run the hand across. But it becomes irrelevant once the finish is applied.

I predict that you will be amazed at the surface defects revealed as dull places when you begin to sand the planed surface. Or, you may be a better planer than I.

Re: Stain before glue up

#18

the problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First, that is the look I like for the side of a drawer. The dark dovetails stand out against the light side. perfect

I make drawers tight and then after assembly I plane them to fit s o they work well and have attractive reveals. Can't prefinsh the pins for this approach to drawer building. And, I can't predict how a drawer will turn out after glue up so I must make the drawer to fit tight and then fit by planing. My goal is to be able to close the drawer by pushing on one corner and not have it bind. It will smoothly close if fit perfect.

PS nice chest of drawers!

Re: Stain before glue up

#19

Re: pre-finished drawers.....

gary peterson

would be nice to finish dts before assembly, never a perfect fit and they do need some fixing. I too use a artist brush, painstakingly applying stain on the drawer and not the drawer side. I used to shellac the sides, but to keep them white, I now apply two coats furniture wax to the outsides and two coats shellac to the insides, back and bottom.

Re: Stain before glue up

#20

Understood - Thank you.