Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

Posts

Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#1

JL

Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

JL

I'm the tech person at the Playhouse.

I read the lighting board manual and played around with the board. I find it easy to run.

I set up the laptop for playing cues and songs. I played around with the programs and got it setup. I find it easy to run.

I bought walkie talkies for communicating between the light/sound booth and backstage.

Why is it that some people can't seem to comprehend simple instructions on how to operate equipment, programs, etc.? The equipment is NOT hard to operate - a bit futzy, but not hard. Ditto for the programs.

Why are people adverse to exploring the equipment and learning by doing? Why don't they read the manuals??

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#2

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

Larry in nw ohio

Well I`ll try to tell you JL, and I do not want to offend anyone. People`s brains are wired completely different. I`ll start with myself, I was kind of born with a wrench in my hands. All I can remember doing when I was young was constantly taking motors apart all the time. Then maybe try and build a generator that would run itself without fuel, kind of a perpetual thing that had a gas motor on it to get it going and after that the generator and battery would take over. Of course it didn`t work, but I had lots of fun working on that for ever almost. My youngest plays by ear, never a lesson and played a keyboard like he was on it for years, he and 4 other boys made and recorded a bunch of songs and sold them on disk. He also taught himself computer and know works on them at his work along with other things and I`m lucky to type this. So to cut it short, some people just are wired different, one person that can follow instructions very well can not even balance a checkbook. ;) Larry

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#3

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

Terry in Edmonton

It has been my experience after 40 years in the high tech field that some people just find thinking too much work. Some can follow directions and read a manual but give them a new problem and they are lost, even if the solution is staring them in the face. It's almost like they have been fed the answers all their lives and just never learned to work it out for themselves.

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#4

Wanting to learn

Tom Dunlap

I'm with you...amazed!

My confusion comes from co-workers who do the same work as me...an arborist...who have 'learned' how to do something one way...and that's the way they stay. Nothing advances. No way for me to show them any value in doing anything differently.

Then, I get hired to teach a class about tree climbing. The attendees 'want' to learn and advance and they suck me dry! I LOVE that! I'll give away knowledge as often as I can.

My conclusion is that there is some inner desire to learn or to just 'life along'. Too many people just 'lifing along' I think >(

One guy I worked with would insist on doing things the unsafe and wrong way...because 'That's what I was taught/learned'. He could never understand that he might have been taught or learned wrong.

Tom

Tom

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#5

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

Kurt

"People`s brains are wired completely different. "

That sums it up nicely. Some people can't build much of anything without a detailed plan, others "gimme the finished dimensions and I'll figure it out".

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Wanting to learn

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well said, Tom. I'm a painting contractor, and I've been in the business for 17+ years now. I try to keep learning (I can't help myself--sometimes it would be easier to just stick with what I know and skip everything else), but I've met plenty of painters older than I who brag about their 20 or 30 years of experience, but as soon as I see them start painting, I can tell it's one year of experience repeated 30 times.

I'm with you, JL, I don't mind taking a few extra minutes to figure things out, and while I didn't used to read instruction manuals, I often do now because I can quickly find and use features on tools or electronics that may not be readily obvious or discoverable.

Jason

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#7

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

Chuck in mtl.

because, IMHO, some are afraid to mess up or break something. This keeps a lot of people from getting to explorative or curious.

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#8

Taught the wrong way...

John in NM

That reminds me of being taught to drive a forklift many years ago. I saw three pedals and assumed the one on the left was the clutch. The instructor explained that it was like a clutch but there was a braking function at the bottom of the pedal action, and went on to explain that the transmission was like an automatic so you didn't need the clutch anyway.

Years later I came across a good instructor who explained that the third pedal was not a clutch, it was the full brake - for all four wheels. The middle pedal only operated brakes on one axle (I can't remember which now). Man was I embarrassed, but to his credit that instructor had made no fuss or fun over it, just explained it and moved on, a very professional guy.

Then it was driving me a bit crazy, did the first instructor not know or did he just assume I was so dumb that I couldn't follow the simple explanation that contradicted my assumption? Either way, he was not a good instructor.

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#9

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

Jesse Cloud

A few decades ago my job involved manning the customer support line for my company's mainframe computers. The hardest customers to help were those who "knew how it should work" but wouldn't read the manual or felt obliged to argue with my advice. Usually after half an hour on the phone they would say something like "I don't think your way will work, but I'll try it." and I would never hear from them again until they ran up against a different wall.

After the call, I often hung up the phone and vented "Read the f'ing manual you @*@&#&@".

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well, shoot.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Now that's going to bug me for the next 4 months or so. I learned to drive forklifts about 18 years ago, but they were electric, and had only two pedals--brake and accelerator.

However, in the winter now, I moonlight (often literally) as a snowplow truck driver for a friend of mine who owns a landscaping company. The truck I drive is a medium-duty, single-axle dump truck, and has a salt hopper in the bed that holds ~2500 lbs. of salt. The large parking for which I am responsible requires ice melt (it's more enviromentally friendly to the surrounding "bog", but sometimes less effective than bulk rock salt--and way more expensive), which comes in 50-lb bags. So rather than loading bulk salt at the shop with a skidsteer, I get to go down to the masonry supply warehouse, open up (they gave us the code to the lockbox), hop on their forklift (LPG), raise a pallet of the ice melt up to the hopper, and cut open and dump in all those bags (49 to a pallet).

The forklift has 3 pedals, and I'll be darned if that far-left pedal isn't a clutch, center is the brake and the right is the juice. There's a 3-position lever on the steering column for F-N-R, and the clutch has to be in if the forklift is "in gear", otherwise it dies.

Of course, there's nothing like having to figure all this out at 3 AM, in the dark because the overhead lights are metal-halides that take about 10 min to come on when it's 10ºF in the unconditioned warehouse.

Jason

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#11

Do we expect consistency?

John in NM

These forklifts were old Hysters, perhaps some others do have a clutch. Now my question (and it's going to have to wait until plowing season :D ) is whether that forklift comes to a dead stop if you push the left pedal right to the floor.

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#12

Could also be......

John in NM

A safety switch on the brake. I remember driving one that would only start if the shuttle gear were in neutral, and another that wouldn't start unless the seat belt were fastened :D

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

#13

Re: Somewhat OT - learning by doing...

AlMorgan

I've written computer manuals for programs I've written and there are 2 ways to write a manual. Function by function or work flow. Both have there pro's and con's,but the function by function is the typical because after a user learns the work flow of the program,he's more interested in using the manual as a sort of reference - which function by function lends itself to. Workflow is good for the first use, but becomes cumbersome for the writer and user for systems that have multipal workflows or modes that make it the system work differently,depending on settings,etc.