Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Clamping a bent lamination question

Posts

Clamping a bent lamination question

#1

Clamping a bent lamination question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


One of the stretchers for the desk will be bent. Shown are the strips to be clamped and the form it will be bent about. The clamps are there to hold it all together for the picture and not to suggest this is how it will be clamped. In fact, that is the question.

What do I need to know to be successful clamping.?

1. Do I need a "caul" strip between the lamination and the clamps?

2. How do I keep the clamps from skidding. They skid downhill as I tighten them.

3. How close together do the clamps need to be. (I have lots of clamps)

4. Any other advice?

After bending and trimming a dovetail will be sawed into each end and this stretcher dovetailed into the desk stretchers. the bow bows it away from the feet under the desk. Clever, but not my original idea.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#2

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

Yonak

Bill, my recommendation is to make the jig in two halves. One half is shown. The other half would have a concave curve and an opposing flat edge. Three pairs of blocks could be clamped to the top and bottom to keep the strips from sliding and to keep the assembly from bowing.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#3

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

1. Do I need a "caul" strip between the lamination and the clamps?

1. yup, you need a caul. otherwise, you'll end up with a neat depression where each clamp sits.

2. How do I keep the clamps from skidding. They skid downhill as I tighten them.

If by downhill you mean the clamps slide toward the ends, when I've had this problem, I cut a divot into the form so that the far end of the clamp will stay put and the business end will always be as close to a right angle to the curve as possible.

3. How close together do the clamps need to be. (I have lots of clamps) This will depend on this thickness of your caul and the laminations, but I'd put them about 4" apart.

4. Any other advice?

Get some of that nifty Titebond extended time stuff.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#4

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

Sgian Dubh

1. Do I need a "caul" strip between the lamination and the clamps?

It's a good idea because it saves making indentations in your top lamination. Use an extra strip of laminate or find a piece of 6 mm ply.

2. How do I keep the clamps from skidding. They skid downhill as I tighten them.

In the straight edge opposite the curve cut angled notches roughly parallel with the curved edge so that the length of the clamps are perpendicular between the curve and its matching straight notch.

On much tighter bends than this, and big curves we bore holes in the former so that the ends of F clamps go into them. You don't need that.

3. How close together do the clamps need to be. (I have lots of clamps)

Fit in as many as you can that you are able to get in with your hands and tighten comfortably. About 3" apart should work fine. Apply pressure first at the brow of the curve and work outwards to the extremities, either one direction at a time or work outwards equally from the brow, whichever suits.

4. Any other advice?

Use a non-creeper glue, e.g., epoxy resin, urea formaldehyde, etc. Work fast to get the pressure on, avoid creating voids which is why you should work from the crown outwards. Wax the curved edge of the former, or stick plastic parcel tape down on the curved bit-- in fact, wax, polish or tape off any wooden parts you don't want to stick to your laminations, or to which you don't want your laminations to stick. Make sure you don't allow the laminates to drift out of line-- perhaps attach the wide face of the former to a base with screws so that you can push the edges of the laminates down to the base. Your curve is not at all severe--- it should be a doddle. We eat gentle curves like this for breakfast, lunch and tea. Don't be afraid of it. Slainte.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#5

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

John McGaw

Except for very small laminations such as curved box handles, I've always used male/female forms. The results are pretty much guaranteed to be smooth although it makes the stock preparation a bit more touchy since the overall thickness must be perfect to match the difference between the two forms. Holes in the forms for the clamps to grab keep things from sliding around in the heat of battle. I've used both ordinary yellow wood glue and polyurethane glue for laminations and didn't see a lot of difference although I guess the springback might differ. If everything is perfectly prepared and you are ready to go once everything is slathered in glue and stacked the open time doesn't seem to be a big factor.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#6

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

John Pappas

How do I keep the clamps from skidding?

Cut notches into the back of the form so you're clamping between parallel lines.

Also, I think spacing of 6 or 7 inches whould be adequate.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#7

JL

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

JL

Yes to caul - that way you are clamping parallel edges.

I also cut notches in the form.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#8

like this? 

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


This glue up challenged my large clamp collection. In fact used all but two of my long ones. The notches on the back of the form did the trick.

I learned a glue spreading trip from David Finck, the plane person. I slather glue on with a brush and then scrape off the excess with a credit card that has tiny notches filed in its edge (like a floor tile glue spreader). It spreads quickly this way and there are not thick spots.

Thanks to all for all the tips I employed.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#9

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

Barry Irby

Bill, Looks like you nailed it. I tried to respond an hour or two ago but had to go to the dentist.

I have made many bentwood laminations and it appears you did yours well.

I was going to mention that my experience is that spring back varies with the number of plies and how thick they are, the species, and the glue and the radius. My experience is that if you have the plies thin, about an 1/8" and you have about five or six, you will have minimum spring back. I make the lamination first and see what I get. If it's close (really close) to what I wanted, I use the piece and make the other parts match it, rather than trying to create the perfect curve. (Hope that makes sense) I also make the curve a little long and trim the ends off, maybe two or three inches. I find the ends are usually a little straighter than the sweet part of the curve. I have tried to compensate by clamping the heck out of the very ends, but that just over bends them and it worse than letting them run wild and trimming them. I glued most of mine with Titebond.

I will have to find pictures of the rose arbor I built. 12' diameter circle resting on eight columns with semicircular arches springing to a center octagon. There was a finial that was 40" tall. The arches were redwood with half inch thick lamination glued with Gorilla Glue. (They call it Gorilla Glue because your hands look like the belong to a gorilla when you finish.)

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#10

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A friend told me that he always tries to use at least six laminations and he never has springback. I've tried to follow that guideline and have not had a problem since.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#11

there is a formula to predict spring back

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Somewhere in the archives of Fine WW someone contributed a formula that determines spring back. It depends only on the number of plies. Around 6 and spring back is nil. This part is a stretcher. It will be sprung to fit its space however it winds up. It is dovetailing the ends that may prove interesting.

got it FWW Vol 119 page 10

y = X/n(squared) where y is the spring back in inches(for example) X is the amount of the deflection of the bend and n is the number of plies. So in my case the bend is a total of 5", the plies are 5 so the spring back is 5/25 inches. or some less than a quarter inch.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#12

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

Don Stephan

More than once I've read that clamping pressure spreads out at a 45 deg angle from the clamp pads. I use this idea to determine how close together to position clamps. The thicker the caul, the more the pressure spreads out before reaching the glue, allowing the clamps to be further apart. A rigid glue like epoxy or plastic resin will eliminate springback, but sounds like some flexibility would be desirable in this desk design. Hope it turns out as well as your last project.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#13

The 45 degree myth

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

How much clamp pressure spreads out depends on how stiff the stuff is that is stressed. If the thing is perfectly rigid the spread is 180 degrees. If mushy, 0 degrees. Wood is somewhere in between.

A rigid adhesive will not a rigid assembly make. While the glue might be rigid the wood isn't . It will stretch and relax the bend to some degree.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#14

craigd

Strap clamp?

craigd

I haven't had a chance to try it but wonder if a [ratcheting] strap clamp would work

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#15

Ellis Walentine

Cauls

Ellis Walentine

Whenever I laminated parts using just one form, I cut masonite strips to use around the outside of the lamination as a caul. In keeping with the premise that glue pressure radiates at a 45º angle from the clamp head, I would use enough of these caul strips to create a caul that was as thick as half the space between the clamp heads, e.g., 1" (8 strips of masonite) for clamps spaced 3" on center. It's important to wax your caul strips (and your form) heavily with cheap paste wax to keep the glue squeeze from turning the whole setup into a solid block. Alternately you can use wax paper.

Ellis


img

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#16

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Cauls

Jesper, Denmark

An alternate to waxing - and a bit safer from a sticking problem is visqeene (sp?).

You cannot avoid the slipping, as each strip will be at a different radius. Start the clamps in the middle and ensure the strips are longer than needed for the finished part.

.....and wonderful picture, Ellis.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#18

There is "furniture" in there somewhere?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

And I thought I had a large clamp collection!

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#19

Rick L

Re: Strap clamp is the best option...

Rick L

For the simple curve. I've used them many times. Can't imagine why someone would struggle and take the long way to use so many clamps when the strap clamp is so fast and simple,

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#20

a significant difference band vs screw

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't argue with success so if strap clamps have worked in your situation I am certainly not claiming they won't.

Strap clamps apply but a small fraction of the force that a row of screw clamps will apply. In my case I made thick plies, about 1/8". I had to crank the Acme threads to see glue squeeze out. I could not have gotten this amount of pressure on the plies with any band clamp I own.

For veneer gluing a pressure of at least 15 psi is recommended. For edge gluing the number is at least ten times this amount. I would guess for bent lamination gluing the number is in between.

In my case I had a strip 2" x 48" or about 100 square inches. Even at 15 psi I need a minimum of 1500 pounds of pressure on the assembly, and probably more would be better.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#21

Cool picture Ellis, Timeliine?

Keith Newton

I get a nice chuckle out of seeing old photos of myself from back in "old days". ha. Do you know what year that was taken? I'm guessing late 70ies, or early 80ies.

Now that you have shown that much of a project, you ought to show the finished product.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#22

Re: a significant difference band vs screw

Jesse Cloud

Another option for gentle curves is a vacuum press. Here in the foothills of the Sandia mountains I get about 21 psi in my bag. And no clamps at all!!

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#23

I did a number of those several years ago...

John in NM

Using a form, F clamps, and matching cauls. I made three forms as I recall, all for arched doorways of various sizes and shapes.

My preference for this kind of work is to use plastic resin glue. Spring back is almost non-existent. There is probably some, but I never had to worry about it, it's tiny. Never tried a bent lamination with PVA glue, so I can't compare.

A band clamp might work ok, depending on size and type. I would do a dry run first though, if the band will squash the laminations to the form with no gaps, then it's probably good enough when using plastic resin glue. It does not seem to require the clamping pressure of PVA's.

Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#24

Ellis Walentine

Good guess, Keith

Ellis Walentine

That photo would have been taken around 1977. I made a set of ten laminated chairs and a big rosewood and ash dining table for a customer in Philly. A few years later, I made another set of six of these chairs to go with a tulipwood and ash dining table for a client in San Diego. After that, I threw away the molds. The laminations were really intense: 9' long x .100 thick x 1 1/2" wide x 9 plies, plus about six plies of masonite around the outside. They also had curved wedges inserted between the plies at the ends to create a flared appearance.

Here are the only two shots I could find, as most pictures of my early work burned up in my shop fire in '99. Sorry for the quality; they were scanned from 4 x 6" prints.



Re: Clamping a bent lamination question

#25

Re: Good guess, Keith

Don in Central Illinois

Those are fantastic, Ellis.