Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

The desk is in the clamps! Relief

Posts

The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#1

The desk is in the clamps! Relief

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The glue up of this desk is the most stressful glue up I have ever accomplished. Scattered among the following description are some assembly tips others may find of use.


There are 28 mortise and tenon and 4 dovetail joints on fairly frail pieces that will not withstand excessive "coaxing" with a rubber mallet. When assembled the frame is self locked together by the dovetails in the top rails so the order of assembly was to be critical.

Because the pieces are less robust than say for a dining table the joinery must be as strong as possible so I chose to use yellow glue rather than the slower setting liquid hide glue I normally use for complex assemblies. Saving the day is the fact that "yellow" glue has little shear strength until it fully sets. Any joint that didn't come together by hand and gentle mallet tapping could later be pulled into submission by steady clamp pressure.


Step one in a successful glue up is planning. Here the parts and materials are laid out to avoid time-wasting confusion during assembly. The joints are prominently numbered and critical orientations indicated by arrows and text. Clamps are preadjusted and glue spreading devices-spatula and brush- ready. Adding to the stress is that I could not fully dry fit this desk, the reason being the top rail dovetails that lock it all together being too risky to disassemble. However, and this is most important, each joint was dry fit and adjusted so that it slid together by hand pressure only.


This final picture shows the joinery at one corner of the leg. The top rail is a dovetail into the leg. The panel is M&T into the leg as well as the top and bottom rails. The bottom rail is a double M&T into the leg. Below and out of the picture is a stretcher M&T into the shaped leg, a tedious joint to fit well.

The Lee Valley clamps I reviewed recently are best for a glue up like this one. This number of heavier clamps would likely distort the assembly.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#2

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

roger lance

Bill....the desk is looking very good....congratulations on the successful glue-up....that's a well written description of a complex gluing process.....relaxing and taking a deep breath is a good feeling (you earned it).

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#3

not so

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"relaxing and taking a deep breath"

I am painting the back porch. It is not relaxing and taking a deep breath would leave me gasping from paint thinner. :)

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#4

Re: not so

Jesse Cloud

Great looking desk Bill! And excellent advice.

I especially like, and use, the notion that joinery should fit together with hand pressure/gentle mallet tap only. Things will swell when glue is applied and if it took a hard whack with a mallet when dry, you may not have a mallet big enough to bring it home when its wet.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#5

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

William Duffield

To relieve some of the stress, next time, you might want to try using TiteBond Extend, which is a yellow glue with a slow tack, specially formulated for complicated glue-ups.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#6

Re: not so

William Duffield

For complicated glue-ups with tight fitting joints, you might also want to consider using epoxy (e.g., West System), which does not swell the wood.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#7

Couldn't you have glued in stages?

Dick Coers

One end assembly, relax. Second end assembly, relax. Then add the center in a final glue up. Would have reduced the stress a lot!

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#8

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Great work Bill. Looks like its going to be beautiful.

Can you tell me how the drawer dividers are attached and how you are attaching the drawer runners?

I am currently building something similar and I'm curious how you are doing that.

Thanks.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#9

Why sub assembly gluing is not a good idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The goal is to not only get something together but to have it wind up square and its feet in one plane. The only way to ensure this favorable result is to glue the whole assembly at once. Indeed one clamps the sub assemblies as they are assembled to snug them up and hold things together while the rest is attached. It is typical to have to loosen a sub assembly clamp, or reposition it, to get the whole assembly square and flat. In fact it is typical to readjust the tension and position of most of the clamps to get the whole of the assembly positioned properly. This tweaking would not be possible after the glue on the subassemblies had set.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#11

Stress clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The stress is not from the number of joints but their nature and the fact that I was unable to do a complete dry assembly before the real thing.

If you look at the last picture there are several fiddly joints that all must be perfect to look good and in some cases there isn't much material supporting some of them, for example the rail dado for the panel. Without a complete dry run there was risk that something would not be perfect. And, there was risk that some frail part would break handling the parts or pushing them together. Liquid hide glue is like putting grease on a joint. The yellow gets grabby quick. Maybe the slow set Extend is significantly better but I didn't have any and with out some experience with it I would not use it anyway. In any case the glue was not the issue but the complexity, lack of assurance from a successful dry fit, frail parts and exposed joints that had to be perfect.

As far as working time for the glue, that was not an issue. Once the joint is sealed the set time for typical yellow glue is at least 20 min under my current shop conditions.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#12

Have to disagree

Dick Coers

I've done glue up in stages for a long time, and pieces with less structure than yours. Never had an issue with square or twist with my techniques. Using Titebond, I would suggest that by the time you got your last clamp on, the first joint you made up would not budged if it had to.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#13

Thanks


Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#14

Not always possible to glue all at once.

John Pappas

Not always possible, Bill. I built this display unit (for my daughter's tea pot collection) many years ago. Glue up was a real challenge. Can't recall exactly how I did it, but it definately was in several stages. I might add.....being square wasn't an issue. :)


Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#15

Glue

David Yoho

Another choice for a slower setting glue than the yellow is plain old white glue like Elmer's.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#16

Drawer support detail

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The first picture shows the side drawer support. The next the interior supports.


The runners are mortise and tenoned into the drawer dividers/rails with short loose tenons. These runners are tiny because the drawers are not large. I use maple because when waxed it is very slick and the drawers will glide effortlessly.


The vertical dividers are installed with stopped dovetails.(The part shown is not yet pushed into place) The dovetail securely ties the top and bottom rail together. The back of this vertical piece is grooved to accommodate the tongue of the piece which will guide the side of the drawer. It is not necessary to make this part the full height of the drawer.

The stopped dovetails are cut by hand. It is not hard to do and stress-free because nothing about the joint will show except getting the shoulder right. I could describe making these dovetails if there is interest. I use them for lots of things like holding case sides to drawer dividers for example.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#17

additional detail- stopped dovetail divider

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Nomenclature- I was once told that the vertical parts are "dividers" and the horizontal parts "blades".


This divider is not yet pushed into position where its face will line up with the horizontal blades/dividers. The dovetail will be hidden as dovetails should be.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#18

What a delightful "cabinet"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well "cabinet"...... I don't what to label it but it is delightful. I'm smitten. I hope more people open your post to see it. To keep my head from exploding I will simply admire it and not try to fathom how to make it( but a description would be an entertaining post).

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#19

Re: What a delightful "cabinet"

John Pappas

Bill, I built this in 2006 and posted a picture and description at that time. Later, when it was "at home in Philly", I posted another picture. You can do a search of the archives using, "Display for Chinese Teapots" and see if that answers some of your questions. I appreciate your kind words.

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

#20

Re: The desk is in the clamps! Relief

Mike Rubes, Cary, NC

That looks great! I really like the flared bottoms of the legs.

Mike