Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Battery Questions

Posts

Battery Questions

#1

Battery Questions

Barry Irby

I have an older set of Makita 12 volt tools. I have had the four batteries rebuilt at a cost of about a $200. Those wore out and I had two more rebuilt again. I have acquired other tools and only use these occasionally. The two rebuilt batteries did not do nearly as well as the first four. Apparently the died from disuse. I called the rebuilder and asked for some help and they said something to the effect of "you failed to pamper them". My tools have always gotten very (VERY) random use. They might sit for several months ignored and then get hard use for two or thee days, or they might get light use for a few weeks. The projects come and go. So I feel like I got blown off. NO, wait, I was blown off.

Day before yesterday I tried one of the batteries and to my amazement it worked. Just as it should, light use for two days and then it went dead. Put it in the charger and it complained the battery was hot. (Not so) I let it sit a while and it still thought it was hot. I put it in the freezer and forgot it and left it in there over night. (Is freezing them a faulty memory on my part or and Internet myth?) The charger is still complaining about its being too hot. (Or does that just mean outside the normal temp range?) Any hope for this battery?

I still like these tools and feel its a shame to throw them away because of the dead batteries. I have three drills and an impact driver. Would you buy a couple of new batteries or have these rebuilt again or just trash the set?

Re: Battery Questions

#2

Re: Battery Questions

Keith Newton

Barry, I have switched to all li ion batteries. They are a lot lighter, and hold their charge much longer than all the older technology. I sure wouldn't be putting money back into those older tools.

Re: Battery Questions

#3

Nope . . .

Steve Mackay

Mom & Dad bought me one of the "Professional" cordless drills awhile back. 300 and some bucks worth. Worked well for about a year. Then, yes . . . batteries. Ordered one. 86 bucks. Well, it's a shame to toss the 300 dollar tool. Got the battery home and it burned up the tool. Forget about it. Cut your loses. It's just throwing away good money after bad. For 86 dollars we could buy a decent "tailed" animal. (And it will last DECADES !)

Re: Battery Questions

#4

Re: Battery Questions

Bill Howatt

I believe there is a sensor in the pack which gives the "too hot" signal and perhaps this has gone bad.

Rechargeable battery care differs a bit with the battery technology but in general they should never be totally run down to dead flat. They all have self-discharge where they run down just by sitting around. The li-ion are probably the best in this regard, ni-cads some, general nimh really bad and the new "permanent or similar worded" nimh very good although more expensive and bit less capacity for a given size.

There are a lot of variables in batteries and I detest them as a general rule but I can't argue with the convenience factor so I keep using them.

The freezer trick has been mentioned as a way to fix ni-cads that don't charge. I don't think it really works - never has for me, anyway.

Bill

Re: Battery Questions

#5

Re: Battery Questions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have "trashed" several sets of drills & batteries. I did some investigation, and for the price of the rebuilt or replacement batteries, normally I can find a "set" of 2 batteries AND a comparable drill or other driver. I I did purchase a Ridged Drill and a Impact screwdriver from HD with the "lifetime warranty" 3 or four years ago, (yeah, I bought them in my sons name as it will be his when I pass and I registered them properly - real hassle) all of the batteries are now failing and I will see how good the warranty is soon. I did see that someone else - can't remember which product - from either Menard's or Lowes were also offering a similar battery warranty. I do like the Li-ion batteries a lot more as they seem to have more power and hold it longer - and are much lighter. I have an 18V Hitachi drill with the LI batteries. I have a set of Dewalt batteries that are gone - with a good drill. I will probably pitch it in the near future. In the shop I normally like to use my tailed equipment - easier to use an extension cord than futz with the batteries.

Re: Battery Questions

#6

Rigid warranty good

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have replaced two sets of batteries on it and my daughter one set.

We typically don't treat our battery tools in a way that results in optimum battery life. Also, the rapid charges are not kind to batteries. Hence, we should expect to not have them last many years.

Batteries can last a long time. The Prius batteries have sophisticated battery management electronics that keeps them charged in a narrow range about 50% with sophisticated current management for charging and discharging. They are expected to last 10 years or so. By comparison if your abused drill battery lasts 3 years it is probably all that can be expected.

Re: Battery Questions

#7

Re: Rigid warranty good

Tom

I bought a campbell Hosfeld drill driver a few years back, 39 dollars soft start. Works just fine for what I need around the shop. I combine it with tailed tools, and I use a brace from time to time, which is far more precise. Obviously not what would work for a contractor, but around the house, shop, and farm, I like it. I bought a similar deal on Black and decker for when this one runs out.

When I have to run a lot of screws, I get out the Milwaukee gun with the cord, and it has a lot more power and runs all day.

Re: Battery Questions

#8

Re: Battery Questions

Justin Szeliga

The overheated battery is a bad thermistor. I use Dewalt cordless & have had batteries rebuilt by 2 different rebuilders. The company that did the last set I had done had some complaints on an internet forum or 2 about the batteries not lasting as long as the new batteries, which turned out to be true. The previous company has a reputation for leaving out the thermistors which keep the battery from over charging. Not sure what I'm going to do next as my 1 year old rebuilts are all loosing charge sitting in the case over the weekend.

The idea behind the rebuilt packs is that you can get a better quality battery that holds more juice than the manufacturer gives you. I'll give it another shot, as it's 1/2 the price of a new battery pack. If I get ambitious I'll order some sub-C cells & rebuild my own & see how that works.

Re: Battery Questions

#9

Re: Battery Questions

Larry in nw ohio

Justin Have you tried Voltman Batteries in Mansfield, Ohio, or is that one that you already tried. I used them once so far and the batteries seem to do well yet. Larry

Re: Battery Questions

#10

Re: Battery Questions

Justin Szeliga

Voltman Batteries was the last company I used. The batteries lose their charge just sitting. I have the same problem that the guy whose complaint I saw had. I'll rebuild them myself before I use Voltman again.