I cut two 5/8"x15" redwood circle on my bandsaw using a self-made circle cutting jig. I found that there are a lot of saw marks on the cut surface. I would like to find out what causes these marks. Is this caused by improper tensioning or feed rate? There is no play in the centering pin and the jig is secured to the table.
It's caused by harmonic oscillation of the blade. It can be nearly eliminated by switching to a blade with variable tooth spacing and variable tooth set.
Going to need a picture to really help. Lots of guesses since "marks" can be a lot of things. Bent tooth, bad weld, dull blade, low tension, too fast of feed. warped or twisted wood, etc...........
Set: Cheap blades (and, sadly, some expensive ones) may have considerable variation in the set, so the tips of the teeth aren't cutting in the same plane. It is possible to joint the sides of the teeth with a coarse sharpening stone to wear down the excessive set. I've done this with the saw running, but I can't recommend it for safety reasons.
Twist: Twists in the blade, particularly at the weld, produce a pronounced divot or hump on every revolution of the blade. You will usually hear an audible click every time the twisted weld passes through the blade guides.
Number of teeth: More teeth produce smoother cuts. If you're cutting relatively thin material, you can use a blade with a lot more teeth without clogging it.
Style of teeth: For thin work, choose regular crosscut teeth instead of the typical hook or skip teeth that you use for resawing and thicker work.
Pitch: As Robin said, variable pitch teeth cut without harmonic oscillation. The variable pitch blades I have are all carbide-tipped, though, and quite expensive. The carbide tipped blades themselves cut cleaner, because the teeth are all ground on the sides and not set like regular metal blades.
I made a circle cutting jigs several years ago and finally go it to work, but it was a struggle.
What does the statement about the pin being lined up with the teeth mean? Seems simple until my dyslexic twisted brain starts working on it. If you consider the front (leading edge of the teeth to be a "point" and the pin to be a point, and any two points establish a line, something is missing here because they will always be "lined" up. If we introduce a fence (another line) Then perhaps the line established between the leading edge of the blade and the pin should be perpendicular to the lint of the fence. (?) But what happens if the fence has been set to compensate for the drift of the blade?
If you are cutting thin materials, say less than a half inch, and you are using a 3TPI skip tooth blade, you could have brief intervals when no tooth is in the wood. And the teeth have alternate set so each successive tooth would tend to push the blade left or right. This probably the cause of the harmonic vibration. So it would seem like a good idea to use a blade that either has no set or one that is fine enough to have several teeth in the stock all the time. Also, a narrow blade seems to help. Apparently they don't fight the curve as much.
The diameter of the circle has a big effect. Fairly easy to cut a large circle. I tried to cut bowl blanks. It was tough. Needed a blade set up for thick wet stringy wood. Got one. Still found it easier to cut the blanks as polygons rather than circles. (A powerful lathe and a sharp bowl gouge will make quick work of a polygon.)
This is a blade from Highland Hardware. It is a 6TPI Hook Tooth blade. Next time I buy some Timberwolf blades, I will try their 1/4" Positive Claw blade.
I rarely use my bandsaw to cut finish good. I think I have expected too much regarding the cut finish. I sanded these circles on my spindle sander and they are good for utility use.
Woodslicer blades from highland hardware are a variable pitch and they are not carbide but rather impulse hardened steel. About 2x the cost of a standard blade but worth it.
Re: Semi Hijack, and some stupid questions/comment
Lee Schierer in McKean, PA
You are correct that two points always line up, but think of a line starting at the leading edge of the teeth and then making a line perpendicular to the normal line of cut the blade would make if cutting a straight line. The pin must be on that perpendicular line.