I have 3 walnut boards I want to use for a table top.
They are skip planed and need to be brought down to 3/4".
They are too wide for my (6") jointer.
Each is a little over 40" long.
1 board seems to be dead flat.
1 has a slight cup; laying flat across my TS each end is raised about 1/16 to 1/8.
1 has a slight twist; laying across my TS there is about the same amount of lift between the corners as the cupped board.
In the past, I've used a sled with my planer that I read about in FWW where the planer acts like a jointer. Works well, but these boards are too long.
Should I just joint them, rip to width, plane to final thickness and hope the top is reasonably flat, or try to hand plane one side flat first (I've never done that with boards this long before)?
Is the cup/bow and twist enough to worry about?
Thanks for any suggestions.
Joe
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
There is sufficient structure from the framing that the top will sit on to pull and hold a top flat.
What you are calling cup is in fact called something else that I never remember (not bow either). You will be able to squish it flat in the clamps. The twist is only a problem when jointing. A twisted board is hard to get jointed for edge gluing. If the pattern works out ok I would just glue it up one joint at a time with the straightest board in the middle. The result will be flat enough and flexible enough to easily pull down on typical table framing.
If you have lots of thickness to play with you might snip off diagonal corners on the twisted piece with a hand plane and then thickness plane it.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Dead flat isn't really crucial for a table top. Building tables is fun, they are very forgiving of errors and flaws. I might be inclined to correct the twist on the one board if I could.
You can dress boards up to 9" wide quite well with your 6" jointer. Take the blade guard off (yes, I know, but that's how its done). Set the fence all the way out and take a light pass cutting what you can. Flip the board around and do the same - I typically do 1/32" cuts doing this. Repeat this until the twist or whatever is corrected to your satisfaction. You will have a stepped cut in the board face of course - but the steps should be roughly parallel. Plane the other face parallel with the stepped face, and then flip the board over to plane the first face (from the jointer) parallel with the second face (from the planer).
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
This is more relative to say, deck boards or wood flooring, if the center line of the board lifts, then it's called "crowning"--the opposite of "cupping", where the edges lift. Also, arranging boards with the pith side down when laying deck boards is called "crowning the boards".
Cupping usually means the top got wet, crowning usually means there's excessive moisture underneath.
Jason
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Dick Coers
Personally, I prefer getting a table as flat as I can. Trying to do a perfect glueup is tough enough, let alone trying to do it with twist. Then consider what it will look like when finished. A table top has more light reflection on it than any other furniture we make. Having cupped and non flat stock will be magnified when the finish goes on it. You are going to have mismatched grain in the glue up with the 3 boards, I would rip them apart and make them flat. The suggestion for reversing the board on the jointer is okay if the grain isn't too brash or heavily figured. If the grain is at a sharp angle to the surface, reverse jointing will result in chipout.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
the cup is going to get removed when the lumber is thickness planed. However, as you state, if the cup is too severe to be removed when thickness planing then the only solution is to rip and reglue. I am doing just that today with one of the most cupped pieces of oak I have ever seen. However, it is not for a top. I don't like narrow pieces in a top and I will go to extreme effort to avoid reducing the width of a table top piece.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Depends on the joiner as to chip out. Since I have obtained my carbide insert spiral heads on both my joiner and planer I have almost zero chip-out even with some woods that were always an issue with my old units - even after water spray etc. Unless the chip out is extreme the joiner defects would be removed in the later planner operation anyway.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
You said, "Cupping usually means the top got wet, crowning usually means there's excessive moisture underneath." I'm fairly certain that whichever side of a board gets wet, will swell, to become the convex side, and conversely if one side becomes dryer ahead of the remainder of it's thickness, will contract, to become the cupped or concave side.
As for choosing to put the pith side down on all the boards of a deck, causes me to groan. I usually just choose the best face for the top. Lots of #1 deck lumber, may be knot free, but have several feet of wayne down one or more edges. That looks horrible on the top side, so I always put that side down, which is pith side up. Then there may be some boards which have a knot pocket on the pith face, which would hold water after each rain, so I try to put those down.
As for fasteners, I prefer using the screws, and have started using only one per joist, switching back and forth from each side of the center down the length of the board. This has been sufficient to hold the deck boards as flat as when two are used, and I think it may even solve two problems that I have seen from my 40 something years as a professional woodworker.
Back in the sixties and seventies, we were nailing down 2x4's with two 16D hot-dip galvanized casing nails per joist. There were so many nails down the tops of the joist, that they were prone to splitting down the top edge, which would take in and hold water, pollen, dust, and spores, which would lead to decay, even in treated wood.
The other thing that I think it helps, is that it takes off some of the stress between the fasteners. Since most deck lumber is delivered wet, it will dry out when it lays out in the Sun long enough. It will cup on the top since that side gets hottest and dries first. Most treated pine, contracts about 1/16" per inch of width after it goes from it's wet to dry state. If you try to prevent the edges from cupping by putting the fasteners near the edge, say 4" apart, then that means the wood between those fasteners is trying to shrink down to 3.75", or 1/4" less. This can lead to split boards, or "breathing out" or fasteners backing out.
Of course, when the deck boards are cupped, small checks appear in the face due to the surface drying faster than it can come up from the middle, so when the next rain comes, it will get wet faster first, which will cause them to crown. So the process starts over, and goes back and forth over and over with each rain.
Even though I spread this load by using only half the fasteners, I also locate them only about 1.5" off the centerline, and even then angle them inward a little, to reduce the distance a little more where they exit the deck board, and enter the joist.
So far, all that I have done this way are holding up fine, with no call-backs, and if I had gotten any, it would only mean driving a few more screws.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Don Stephan
At my age, being confused happens more often. Sounds like the discussion has combined individual non flat boards and a glued up non flat panel (table top).
I like to have my individual boards as likely as possible to stay flat and straight for decades before gluing together. Towards that end, Iwill sticker new lumber for at least a week or two. Then I'll trim the ends until there are no splits and cut the needed pieces 3-6" longer than final length, joint one side flat and plane the other side parallel. If necessary, I will use a hand plane on boards wider than my Jointer to get one side pretty darn close to flat and straight, and then use my (wider) planer. After this initial flattening and straightening the pieces get stacked and stickered for another week minimum. After this second acclimatization period a series of pencil marks across one face will show how evenly wood was removed with a light pass through the jointer. If the piece was flat then it gets planed to final thickness; if it needed more than a couple light passes to make one face flat after making the other side parallel it goes back to the stickers for another week of acclimatization.
There's no question that even middle weight clamps can force pieces flat and straight, but that's incorporating stresses in the glued panel. My two cents is any incorporated stresses make later splits and other problems more likely, and I think it's disrespectful of the tree that was cut to make the lumber.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Dick Coers
Both Bill's and Larry's response is dependent on the machine. If I feed a cupped board into my 24" Yates American thickness planer, the feed roller and pressure bar will press it flat as it goes through the machine and pops up on the other side with a cup in it still in it. Feed it through a little Dewalt lunchbox planer, and the cup would probably be planed out. If I had a carbide insert head, then maybe no chip out, but I don't.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Chuck in mtl.
an old time woodworker told me the most stable lumber comes is when the internal sap of the wood is replaced with water. He suggested to me this is done with hot water and pressure and over time the sp is forced out and replaced with water. do not know if this true.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
I guess when I mentioned cupping/crowning, I was thinking mainly of wood flooring. I've refinished quite a few now, and when there's an exterior door (like a patio door) and water stains in front of it, the flooring is almost always cupped. I suppose it could be that the water has penetrated the floor and gets the underside wet, which won't dry as quickly. However, I have also noticed that when it rains, my deck boards (treated pine, any finish long gone) seem to cup nicely, as evidenced by the puddles they hold, then flatten back out a bit once they dry--I walk out there barefoot from time to time, and don't feel any cupping. I do hope to someday replace the deck with a 3-season room/deck combo, and on the deck part, I want to screw the boards down from underneath with a Kreg jig. I've always wondered about the 2-screw reasoning; what you've said about that makes total sense to me.
Jason
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
I don't know why your deck boards cup, but the cupping of the wood flooring is probably due to compression shrinkage. That's where the top layer of the boards gets wet and tries to expand but is mechanically restricted from doing so (in this case by the neighboring boards). Because the wet wood can't expand, the cells of the wood are crushed instead. When the wood dries back out, the part that was wet (the top layer), dries to a narrower width than it was previously (because the cells are crushed). The bottom layer of the boards never got wet and so is unaffected. Cupping results.
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
The trick is to be brief, concise, and specific. One beef I have with blogs (no surprise if you've visited the hand tools side lately ) and wiki's is that editing is virtually non-existent. The reason this is important is that the superfluous text distract the reader and encourage him to skim the article, seeking to get to the meat of it, rather than concentrate and work out the author's point if it is not immediately clear. As they go though, that article is better than many, I would guess it could be trimmed by 25%, whereas 50-60% is often more the norm.
I believe he has mixed up some of the pictures or some of the process as well, but I wouldn't know for sure. Looks like he's planing off the jointed face before the untouched face. Trouble is, I'd lost patience and started skimming by then (there I go, being hyperbolic again )
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Mine doesn't either Bill, I joint the face fir
Larry in nw ohio
I don`t know if this will help anyone, but this is what I do with a DeWalt planer DW735 or my Woodmaster sander, I lay the board on a flat surface and put spacers in the open spaces all around the board. Then when I plane it I get a good flat board and use double face tape and tape the board to be planed on the flat one and just run it thru the planner or sander. I like to use the sander, because it does a better job. I get one side fairly flat and then work on the other side. This does a good job for me. Larry
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Re: Mine doesn't either Bill, I joint the face fir
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
I've always just run a rough-sawn board through my lunchbox planer (DW 733) as-is. I set it to take a 1/32" cut off a cupped board without compressing out the cup. After one pass, there will be a smooth stripe down the middle. Then I lower the head 1/32" and flip the board over. The result is two smooth stripes down the outside edge. Rinse and repeat until both sides are flat and smooth.
Jason
Re: Question about table top boards and stock prep
Even if the lumber flexes some on the first few pass on each side (which would result in a series of curved "facets"), that will all get worked out by the last pass or two on each side that end up full width.