Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Wind Shake

Posts

Wind Shake

#1

Wind Shake

Don Stephan

Saw the term in another woodturning forum and made me curious. What is wind shake and how is it manifested?

Re: Wind Shake

#2

Re: Wind Shake

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Google will give you more information than you're ever likely to need on the subject. Basically, separations between growth rings caused by stress on the tree due to high winds and similar pressures. See drawing below.


img

Re: Wind Shake

#3

and that pic can be an exaggeration...

Dick Coers

.....especially when turning wet wood. The rings may even appear tight, but there is no cellular bond in the wood. Whole chunks can just fall out when it has been cut through.

Re: Wind Shake

#4

Wind Shake is not an accurate term.

Keith Newton

It is not caused by the wind. When the wind blows hard enough to do damage, the first thing to go will be the limb being torn off.

I have seen trees with ring-shake running up into the upper branches as small as my wrist, on perfectly full un-damaged shape.

A more accurate term, is Ring-shake.

Re: Wind Shake

#5

Re: Wind Shake

Sgian Dubh

Ring porous and semi-ring porous species are particularly prone to developing tangential shakes, commonly described as ring shakes and cup shakes (or sometimes wind shakes) although diffuse porous species also suffer tangential shakes. If the separation partially encircles the tree it is a cup shake, but where it follows the whole length of a growth ring it is a ring shake. In the ring porous species the softer spring wood separates from the harder summer wood. The causes are varied; it may be due to sever flexing of the stem during high winds or because of old age and, more often than not, the shake forms in the region where sapwood is turning into heartwood. Any weakness between earlywood and latewood can be exacerbated by other factors such as bacterial infection. In this case the bacteria get a foothold by entering through the tree’s root system. The bacterial infection characteristically spans many growth increments either side of the shake. Yet another example of an external factor increasing the likelihood of tangential shakes, particularly in European oaks, is the European oak leaf-roller moth (Tortrix viridána). A heavy infection of the caterpillars of this species in early summer is capable of severely depleting the young leaves of the tree causing a growth check leading to a situation where the wood rings fail to cohere. Slainte.

Re: Wind Shake

#6

wind shake

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The wind shake I usually see is in trees that are subject to a strong wind from a prevailing direction. it is a straight or mostly straight crack running through the pith and is perpendicular to the direction of the prevailing wind. it usually runs from ground level to about 2/3 of the bole. Its hard to say at what size it starts since MY experience is related to milling wood with a chain saw and for me it is most time effective to mill trees over 24" in diameter, preferable over 30".

I see it a lot in elms, ash, Walnut and oak. In Monterey cypress and deodar cedar I see the ring shakes like in Bills picture.

Robin

Re: Wind Shake

#7

Don and Singh are on the right track

Tom Dunlap

As an arborist and amateur woodworker I'd heard the term ring/wood shake for years but didn't know what exactly it meant. When I moved to Asheville the company that I worked for generated a lot of hemlock logs from trees killed by the adelgid. In order to find a better use for the logs a lot of local mills were contacted. While making the calls I found that most sawyers were worried about trees with shake. I learned how to identify the effect by looking at the log butts. While talking with the sawyers I heard many different explanations.

When I did some research I found that shake is rarely cause by wind. Meaning, wind was rarely the primary reason for the cracks.

What I found was that it was really caused by soil born pathogens that were brought up into the tree from its roots. The reason that the cracks or shakes were there can be directly traced down to a specific year or years of infection.

Knowing a little bit about tree physiology and CODIT [google that for a better understanding of Dr. Alex Shigo's work] I could see how the infection, just like decay is walled off by the tree's protection zones.

Wind has little to do with shake. The myth is perpetuated though. When logs from a certain place are found to have shake the logger/sawyer is always able to find a wind to blame for shattering the trees. Wind may be what breaks the tree but if wind were THE reason for shake ALL of the trees in one location would be cracked. The infection weakens the annual growth increments connections to one another.

One sawyer said he was very careful of sawing shake trees because he had seen slabs break off in the cant and come flying off the mill. Or, if the taper is the other way the two pieces act like opposing wedges like we use to square windows and doors. This jams the blade and can lead to mill damage or sawyer injury.

Tom

Re: Wind Shake

#8

Along The Same Track

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I have a friend here who is the disease "pathologist" [we call him "doctor"] for several tree service outfits. In discussion with him he's mentioned that his experience with shake seems to correlate to an combination of a vascular born pathogen and drought stress. He's mentioned that working annular rings back to the occurrence of shake in a log will often (but not always) track with several years of below average rainfall and thinner growth rings. He then surmised that the tree was producing less and weaker lignin making the ring bonds weaker and more subject to attack by the infectious agent.

Re: Wind Shake

#9

A problem for the logger, not the woodworker

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Here in E.TN.I see it in hickory and hemlock, rarely in other species. Logs with shake are typically left in the woods for they have little value. One should never encounter it when buying lumber of a grade typically used in furniture.

Re: Wind Shake

#10

Re: Wind Shake

Don Stephan

Great set of responses everyone, thank you. Very informative and educational, especially the extension to ring shake. This is a marvelous forum.

I've seen some odd cracks in ash bowls, and saw the term used on a wood turning forum, and never thought to search the Internet. Monday I'll have to look at the exact orientation of the cracks on those bowls.

Re: Wind Shake

#11

Re: Wind Shake

Dick Coers

I'm leery to think that cracks in bowls would be from ring shake. If the entire growth ring is involved, the it is definitely ring shake. Maybe if the crack runs partially in the growth ring, maybe. If it runs perpendicular to the growth ring, probably drying stress.

Re: Wind Shake

#12

Re: Don and Singh are on the right track

Keith Newton

Tom, I have read Shigo and all the other stuff I can find, and am certain that it is just wrong. I'm sorry, but it just doesn't match what I find here in my world.

Here in AR, we have experienced several droughts, where the heat was above 100 for several months in a row. I can recall seeing some standing trees during that period which had checked radially, that I was sure would never recover. Some don't, but Mother Nature has had a lot of time to handle these problems.

The ring shake, occurs at the end of a major hot drought, which has been hot enough to dry the tree to the point that shrinkage has occurred. When the rains come after a drought, the sapwood, which is much more absorbent, and also happens to be on the outside, gets the moisture first, causing it to expand and pop away from the heart. Tension perpendicular to the grain being the weakest property of all its other numbers.

Around 1992, a friend called to ask if I wanted a big oak that she was having taken down from her yard. The tree service used a crane, so none of it ever fell, ruling out impact. It had total ring shake from it's base, all the way up into limbs which would have been smaller than my wrist, 50' - 60'up. There was no decay, and was about in middle of a healthy late-wood ring, which in this tree was ~3/8". I peered into the checks with a 10X slide loope, and could see some fibers which were still connected to both sides, and there was no smell, other than what it normal for Water Oak.

She gave me this tree thinking I would use it for turning, but I ended up splitting it all into firewood. That was the easiest tree I've ever split by hand. One swing, and the ~ 8" shell would split to the ring, then around to the opposite side, leaving a perfectly clean core tree within a tree.

As I got on up to where an arborists had properly removed lower branches, which had healed, the shake had already separated, making a perfect male and female mold of the limb scars. Even the big crotches split easily.

As I was splitting, I was dumbfounded by it, trying to make everything I had read fit, but it didn't. I recall thinking ah ha, the Summer of 1980, but when I counted the rings from the cambium, there were about 12 too many. Then as I continued splitting, I had several big log sections set up on end, when it dawned on me. Water in the sapwood, had moved to the surface, and was about 1/8" deep all the way around, while the heartwood looked dryer. The difference in absorbency between the two was the key. When I counted the rings from the sapwood to heartwood transition, it landed on 1980, the worse Summer of my memory.

The people who have done the most recent research went at it with a preconceived notion, and set out to prove that notion. If my tree had lost a limb after the shake occurred, it would have been open to ants and other vermin which starts the decay, so if one comes along after that, there is the answer they were looking for.

Re: Wind Shake

#13

Re: Don and Singh are on the right track

Tom Dunlap

Hi,

Please don't take this as being argumentative.

I'm trying to understand what you have concluded. You're talking about:

Radial checking

Drought

Cracks

Water absorption

Decay

If you're finding radial checking then that's not shake as far as I understand. Shake is concentric and the separation occurs at the growth increment since it infects the tree at a specific year.

ALL decay can be tracked back to a date if the detective is skilled enough. At one of Dr. Shigo's workshops that I attended he shared a story where he was called in as an expert witness in a case where a tree died/was killed [depends on which side of the case you were on ;0] the tree was very near where Alex lived and he knew EXACTLY what was going on in the tree at a cellular level within a day or three. He was able to examine the tree and provide solid evidence that the construction damage happened within a 3-5 day span. He had high res. scanning microscopes to examine samples for his research. Since he could show the dates of the damage based on the phrenology to that narrow a date range his side could then ask when the excavation was done around the tree. Turns out...during that exact time span. Case closed, Alex wins.

All decay starts from a wound. Trees don't heal like biological creatures. Us biologicals create new tissue to replace the wounded tissue. Botanicals 'seal' the wound and cover over the wounds. Each year the tree replicates itself anew. Layer upon layer a whole new tree is created. This is why knots fall out of boards. The limb that the knot came from was dead when the tree died. No connection of tissues. Knots and discoloration are from decay.

Ants don't create wounds or decay. They're actually beneficial to tree wounds. I've removed many trees or limbs that had ant nests/tunnels in them. ALL of them were isolated to the decayed portion of the wood. They do not break the chemical CODIT walls. Sometimes it only takes the tiniest wound to allow a serious decay pocket to form.

One reason that you might be seeing a difference in the wood from outside to inside is that in most trees only a very few outer growth increments are actually 'growing'. In truth, mostly just the current year. A few increments in there is water and starch transport. Further in...a teeeeny bit of water transport but not much. Water is there but it's not really used by the tree to live. Intra vrs inter cellular water.

From 'Modern Arboriculture' by Alex Shigo, p.154:

Ring shake is a term used to describe circumferential seperations in wood. Ring shakes are associated with barrier zones. The barrier zone is a strong protection zone but a weak structural zone. As the shakes propagate beyond the wound, the wound may tear and ragged edges result. Ring and ray shakes are often associated. The primary crack and the secondary cracks are sites that often contain the wetwood pathogens. In a sense, the wetwood 'lubricates' the cracks and benefits the tree because the possibility of the trunk splitting is reduced. It is amazing to see how nature 'corrects' or adjusts problems that could cause death

Re: Wind Shake

#14

Radial cracks

Tom Dunlap

This morning I was reading one of my trade journals. There is an article about skeleton decay. Interesting...to me anyway :\

While I was reading I thought of another possible culprit for the radial cracks. Duh! [Slaps head :b ]

Lightning will do the same thing sometimes. The instant electrical charge can lead to a huge steam explosion in the trunk of a tree. I've removed trees that have the trunks split into 'firewood' already. Just a bundle of splints...scary to be climbing in that!!!

Sometimes trees will survive lightning hits like that too. Not for a lot of years but maybe one or two.

Tom