Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

How would you do this top?

Posts

How would you do this top?

#1

How would you do this top?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


(It has been decades since I did an isometric drawing so I may have the angle of the frame's miter joint draw incorrectly in the isometric view.)

Situation: A desk top. The interior field will be curly rift ash veneered to 3/4" Baltic birch plywood. This field will be framed with a mitered "frame" of solid wood, again rift ash. An 1/8" black band will separate the frame from the field.

Forgetting the band for the moment, can I simply glue the mitered frame to the plywood? Never tried gluing solid wood to ply. Would the addition of a spline be prudent for this joinery?

The banding will be from some African Black Wood I got some long time ago. I could making banding, route out the trough and inlay it. Or I could rabbit out an 1/8 x 1/8 on the edge of the frame and glue the Black Wood into the rabbit, then glue the assembly to the plywood and plane it all smooth.

Re: How would you do this top?

#2

Re: How would you do this top?

Jay St. Peter

Bill, While you are a much more experienced woodworker than me, I have unfortunately done a lot of plywood edging.

You can straight glue the banding to the plywood without any type of spline. But, a spline (or biscuits) does help with alignment, especially if the ply isn't perfectly flat for any reason. I can't tell the size of the band, so not sure if a router bit would do the miter after application, which would make clamping easier. If the miter is large and you want to do it first, a spline might help. I'd glue the black strip to the ash, then miter, then spline. Usually when I edge ply, I make the band slightly proud and use a block plane to even it up. Don't like sanders for that job. But, if you pre-miter you probably want it to align pretty closely, so again a spline might be called for. Ply usually just isn't as "perfectly" flat as wood you've milled yourself.

Jay

Re: How would you do this top?

#3

Re: How would you do this top?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Inlay slightly oversized into the banding stock then retrim the banding for a precise glue surface.

Spline or biscuits are called for, including a partial in the miters. If biscuits, they should be positioned below center of the ply to prevent telegraphing up to the veneer surface.

Re: How would you do this top?

#4

My thoughts

Merle

Bill, since you will use plywood for the substrate, you should be fine gluing to it since it provided long grain to long grain contact. However, I tend to overbuild, so I would likely add a tongue and groove for the added strength/security. You could glue a long sample of the ash to a short scrap of plywood, wait 24 hours, then see how much force is required to break the glue joint. FWIW

Re: How would you do this top?

#5

Re: How would you do this top?

Bob Lang

This may sound like heresy, but I would stay away from plywood and use MDF. Even the best plywood is far from flat, and that will drive you nuts when you try to get the banding both flush and nice and straight. If you're making your own veneer, it might be thick enough to allow you to use plywood so you could plane out the wavy surface. I would also veneer both sides of the sheet material.

You can size the edges first and just use glue, but you'll sleep better if you have spines between the sheet material and the banding/solid edge.

If it were me, and wanted to use a minimal amount of material for the banding, I would make a small rabbet on the inner edge of the trim, glue in the band and get it flush. That you I'd only have to worry about matching the trim to the edges of the sheet material.

Bob Lang

Re: How would you do this top?

#6

Re: How would you do this top?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I have no experience with MDF. Am I understanding that I can edge glue to it with a spline for added strength.

The veneer is resawed in the neighborhood of 1/16". The mitered frame will be 1 1/2" by 3/4+" thick.

Re: How would you do this top?

#7

Re: How would you do this top?

Barry Irby

I am not fond of MDF, but unfortunately I am even less fond of what passes for plywood these days. If you can get some Apple Ply or high quality Baltic Birch and it checks out as flat enough I would go with that. Otherwise I would go with MDF.

I would make the frame up and let the black strip into it, creating a flat interior edge. You can glue it directly to the MDF, but out of an abundance of caution I would use a spline. (I have a biscuit jointer, but I like splines better.) Probably would put a small biscuit in the miter in the frame.

Then I would laminate veneer to the back side and let it over lap the frame and all and then "kill" the edge of the veneer by cutting a small chamfer on the bottom edge.

Anytime you glue to the edge of the mdf you should use a somewhat generous layer of glue. (I use Titebond) I wet the MDF and rub it in and then wet it again and probably have a little more squeeze out than you are used to. All of this may be over kill, but I am sure it would work.

PS, MDF is very dusty, be prepared. Also very heavy. Comes in sheets that are 49 by 97 because the edges are tender and often need trimming.

Re: How would you do this top?

#8

MDF + Glue

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The edges of the substrate must be glu-sized before making the joint. The stuff acts like a sponge to wick glue and moisture away from the joint leaving it weak. The edges should, therefore, have two applications of the same glue, one thinned, the next full strength, at least 2 hours before the final joint is made. What you want is a slight sheen on the edge surface. This seals and reinforces the edge fibers. Dewaxed shellac can also be used to partially seal the edges to control the absorbsion.

If using MDF, do NOT use biscuits as they will telegraph through to the top surface. Rather a 3/16" slot and 1" wide spline should be used.

This is not a good choice if you're in the "put a brad in it 'til the glue dries" club as the nail will easily fracture the edge.

All that said, it does make a very flat substrate for veneering and the top surface takes veneering glue very well. Figure 80+ Lbs. for a 4x8 sheet so wear your sacro-belt. ;)

Re: How would you do this top?

#9

If I had one more Active Brain Cell....

Barry Irby

I would have been able to use the term "glue size".

Re: How would you do this top?

#10

Re: Active Brain Cells

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

That good contact cement gets'em every time :D

Re: How would you do this top?

#11

Re: How would you do this top?

Bob Lang

What they all said about sizing the edge. MDF also tends to swell in thickness, but if you want something flat, and have good support for the panel it's a great substrate.

Bob Lang

Re: How would you do this top?

#12

Re: My thoughts

John Lucas

MDF may be flat but it sucks 20 years down the line. I'm just not a fan of MDF for fine furniture. Apple Ply would be my choice. I don't do much edge gluing on cabinetry but have done quite a few picture frames with various edge glue ups. I prefer splines to biscuits for that purpose.

Re: How would you do this top?

#13

Re: My thoughts

Larry in NW Ohio

John By apple ply, I assume that means apple plywood. If so where would a person get that, I have never seen it. Thank You. Larry

Re: How would you do this top?

#14

Re: My thoughts

Steve Schoene

ApplePly is a brand name for a plywood madeo with 1/16" birch ply. It is high quality, similar to Baltic birch. Search on the name for distributors.

Re: How would you do this top?

#15

Re: My thoughts

John Lucas

It does go by several names, Baltic Birch and Apple Ply are the ones my local dealer sells. Do a search and you will probably find a local source. It is much higher quality than Plywood, stays flat, supports weight better than MDF and is really a joy to work with. It's not cheap and I'm about as cheap as they come but I'm willing to spring for that when a special project needs it.

Re: How would you do this top?

#16

Re: Active Brain Cells

Barry Irby

I have a friend that says, "If it don't stink, it don't work!" He was talking about Kilz at the time, but he applies it to most things. I think he is right. The stinky stuff works better.

Re: How would you do this top?

#17

Re: How would you do this top?

Jason in OC

FWW had an article on something like this in the July 2012 issue, #228, available here: (scroll down for the images.)

http://www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/article/a-better-way-to-add-stringing-and-banding.aspx

Re: How would you do this top?

#18

Re: My thoughts

Barry Irby

Bill, Chippendale did not use ANY MDF :D . I tend to agree with those who are reluctant to use it on fine furniture. You build some really nice stuff and I just don't think I could bring myself to use MDF on anything that fine.

I recently used baseboard made of MDF (or some cheap equivalent) in the utility room of a house I am flipping. The pop off valve on the water heater decided to pee in the floor. Maybe a pint of water. Soaked in under the basebaord and caused it to swell and the color bled through the paint. Some of it got under the bottom plate of a wall and ruined the baseboard in the adjacent bathroom about four feet away. Lesson learned. Never use MDF Baseboard again, Especially in a potentially wet location. I'd hate to see somebody spoil that nice top with a spill.

Re: How would you do this top?

#19

Baltic Birch

Jesse Cloud

"Baltic Birch" used to mean something, but now they sell all kinds of crap under that name.

ApplePly is a trademark owned by a specific manufacturer and you have a better chance of knowing what you will get.

BTW, most of the criticisms of MDF such as how it performs in wet conditions hold true for any plywood. And Chippendale didn't use plywood, either.

Re: How would you do this top?

#20

Re: How would you do this top?

Joseph Prendergast

Bill. I have glued up many tops over the years using a plywood center and hardwood edge,but never with a third element being involved, I.E. Black African wood. Still, don't see much of a problem here. I don't think you need to worry about a spline for this application as today's glues are better than ever. Whatever you do, leave your banding material fat above the top as you glue up. Plywood is never perfect, and besides that fact, it loves to move and it is typically variable on the surface. I used to do splining on pieces but have gotten away from it mostly. Depending on how careful you work will depend on whether you need to inlay or not. The inlay will by far give you the best joint, but will be harder to do and more time consuming. Glue up a practice piece and see how you like it. I like your idea of the 1/8' rabbit cut into the banding but I would glue that to the plywood and then add the inlay after. Best of luck to you.

Re: How would you do this top?

#21

Re: Active Brain Cells

Brad Bransky

Learned a lot from all this. Thanks guys.

Brad

MPMA'57

Re: How would you do this top?

#22

thanks for all the helpful advice-poplar plywood?

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I am going to use Baltic ply. Apple stuff has not made it to the southeast yet.

It would seem to me that a similar product made from cheap poplar would be available. Train cars of poplar logs called "Peelers" leave a yard here bound for ?? They get rotary peeled for some kind of plywood but I have never seen it.

Re: How would you do this top?

#23

Re: thanks for all the helpful advice-poplar plywo

Bob Lang

The poplar ply I have seen (and it's been about ten years) was really crummy. Plywood is really treated as a commodity, with the bottom line of the manufacturer and retailer trumping making a useful product.

Bob Lang

Re: How would you do this top?

#24

Bill, sorry to be so late replying.

Keith Newton

My advice, is to not use plywood for your substrate. Your thick veneer, and your glue-line may be fine, but you will be trusting the face veneer under it to be glued on better than it probably is.

In the industry, there is a fine balancing act between too much, and too little glue. It may only need to be bonded 50% to hold that thin face maybe .020" thick after it is sanded. So when you glue your thick veneer onto that, it will have a lot more tenacity when there is any MC change. After it leaves your shop, you have no control of that, and even if you expect it to find a home with perfect atmosphere control, there are always times when storms knock out the power, or plumbing fails when nobody is home.

You will just have too much time and effort into this project to have the failure due to someone else's shortcoming.

I was just cutting up some plywood which the veneer is virtually falling off due to too little glue. If you choose to go ahead with plywood, I would try to find a way to test the actual plywood you are going to use first. You are good at that, and can even report your findings. My plywood for instance is splintering back from the cut way beyond what I would expect, even after a blade change. If you pressed on the best sticking tape along a fresh cut edge, then peel it back. If the face comes off, that would be a telling sign. Of course parting it with a chisel would show something.

Good luck with your bagging. It is a really good act to add to your bag of tricks.

Besides MDF, industrial PB is another good substrate, which is a bit harder and stiffer, but on the downside, is even heavier. Now that I'm longer of tooth, that becomes a consideration. ha

Re: How would you do this top?

#25

Industrial PB=Peanut Butter ??