Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

Posts

Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#1

Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

Thunderstorms here this morning so I decided to rewatch The Guns of Navarone. In this scene with Anthony Quinn I see a wheel crank with spokes that have mystified me for years.

Maybe one of the mechanical engineer coves here could solve the mystery for me.

A simpler design would be with straight spokes. Having them in the S shape uses more material it seems but there has to be a purpose. There are lots of examples of this type of spoke on a wheel crank or single arm crank.

I've wondered if this configuration puts more torque on the axle than a straight spoke. I dunno???

--------------------

To play a wrong note is insignificant;

To play without passion is inexcusable

-Beethoven


Spokes on a wheel

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#2

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One argument I've read is that the s-shaped or curved spokes are less likely to crack as the metal shrinks in cooling. Probably more significant in larger wheels.

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#3

IIRC

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The curved spokes were thought to make stronger "joint" with less metal where they join the rim at an angle and provide a better grip where the wheel is set in line with (rather than at 90°) the keel to provide the most clearance to the gunnels of a fisherman's boat as in the picture.

Sounds good anyway :D

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#4

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT

Mark Nowicki

I have spent a few years in merchant marine {when I was younger and better looking) including some in the engine room lot.

Curved spokes simply indicate which way the wheel has to be turned to open or close, especially useful in the dark when you can tell by feeling the spoke shape.

Mark

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#5

Way Better Answer

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

for the "mechanical spaces" :D

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#6

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT

basil

I read somewhere in an article about heavy equipment that that was the reason for bulldozer idlers always having an odd number of spokes.

Now the idlers are all built from steel plate and give the appearance of being solid.

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#7

Re: Way Better Answer

Tom du

Hmmm...now that sounds right!

This solution answers the other part of my question...what about single handled cranks?

A person would only have to look, or feel in the dark, to know which way to crank, right or left handed threads

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#8

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT

Clay Foster

Curved spokes just look way cooler, which is very important if you are going to be in a scene with Anthony Quinn.

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#9

another discussion

Tom Dunlap

I'm not the only one who wonders about things like this :b :)

This is an old discussion:

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#10

I'm with Bill, only,

Keith Newton

I would think it would help prevent the wheel from cracking, during the cooling process. At the foundry, they could torch one side or the other of the curved spoke, to slow the cooling of one side, which could relieve some stresses out on the rim.

the improved "hand", would just be a side benefit.

Did any of the scenes show the crew in action on it? What does it do, is it a windlass for the anchor chain?

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#11

a patternmakers explanation

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It actually has to do with the shrinkage and how the linear shrink is translated to a change in diameter. It might be easier to give an example. Let’s say you want to cast an 18” diameter wheel like the one in the picture. Just to have some numbers to toss around well cast it out of brass which has a linear shrinkage of .1875”/foot. The rim is nearly 5’ long and will shrink a bit over 7/8” which will translate to an almost 3/8” change in diameter. Now for the spokes to shrink the same amount and keep the wheel round and with no stress cracks they need to be nearly 12”. It doesn’t take a math wiz to be able to figure out the only way to fit 12” spokes in an 18” wheel is to make them curved.

Most round things like pulleys or solid wheels you use simple linear shrinkage as measured across the diameter. This type of wheel is the only one where you translate the linear shrinkage of the rim and adjust the diameter accordingly.

Robin

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#12

Re: a patternmakers explanation...more ???

Tom Dunlap

Robin,

Thanks for the explanation of the s-shaped spokes. That makes a lot of sense.

Now...what about the same s-shape being applied to crank handles? I've seen, and used, many old cranks and some modern ones with the s-curve. I can't see how the shrinkage explanation would apply to a linear tool like a crank.

When I think of a crank I envision a lever. then I try to remember high school physics and practical applications, and I can't see any mechanical advantage to the s-shape. The load on the end seems like it would be the same no matter how convoluted the crank was shaped.

Re: Spokes on a wheel---OT *LINK*

#13

Your physics is correct

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I suspect the S-shaped crank handles are so for aesthetic reasons only.