black pipe and Pony clamps
bradkansas
Why is that black pipe which rubs off on everything unless it is sanded and cleaned is used rather than galvanized in Pony clamps?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
black pipe and Pony clamps
bradkansas
Why is that black pipe which rubs off on everything unless it is sanded and cleaned is used rather than galvanized in Pony clamps?
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Dale Lenz
It has been said that galvanized pipe will slip more in the clutches of the pony clamps. Not knowing any better some 35 years ago my first pipe I purchased was galvanized. I can't tell any difference. Black pipe was/is cheaper so most of my pony/pipe clamps are black pipe.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Jack Guzman from Maine
I use both. Never noticed a difference except one thing. Black pipe+white/yellow glue+oak= black stains.I either use tape or waxed paper between the pipe and the wood when using these together.The water in the glue reacts with the iron in the pipe and leaves a black stain on the oak. For this reason only I wish all my pipe clamps had galvy pipe.---Jack
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Keith Newton
Black is cheaper, and the galv has a slightly smaller OD. If they had made it to fit galv, they might not work on black, so they are sized for the larger.
Be careful to always push the slider up against the head, and slightly tighten it when stored. Those things can really hurt your knuckles or toes when they slide down onto hands or off onto toes.
A light coat of spray primer down the length of pipe ought to keep the staining down, but would wear off. I usually try to hold them up a little as I tighten the screw. Actually trying to keep the center of the screw lined up with the center of the panel thickness is best for sending the effort down the middle of the panel. If it is outside a thin panel, or outside, makes the panel bow away to the opposite side, so for 3/4" thickness, it should be held away from the pipe a little.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
William Duffield, in Bozeman
Use oxalic acid (e.g., Barkeeper's Friend) to remove the black stain.
I cut several short lengths of PVC pipe, and slide them over the black pipe, to use as standoffs. They're easier to find than the wax paper or visqueen, if I leave them on the clamps. The only problem I have with them is having to take off the extras if I need to use a long clamp on a narrow glue-up. You'll find out if you have too many during the practice dry assembly.
Black-bluish stain
Dale Lenz
All of my woodworking career folks have complained about the black-bluish stain on wood with tanic acid, oak being the worst. Yes, I get the stain, but a few swipes with a plane removes them, never has been a major problem for me.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Larry in NW Ohio
William This is going to be a stupid question, but how do you put the pvc on the pipe, by taking the end off. Thank you Larry
great tip
Jack Guzman from Maine
What a cool idea. I'm going to outfit my clamps with pvc pieces. You always seem to come with good tips William.---Jack
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
William Duffield, in Bozeman
Well, you can take either end off. One end screws off, but that one is the more difficult, unless you have the thread protector end cap on the other end. It's difficult to get a grip on the cap, and you have to unthread it. I don't use the end caps, so I find it easy enough to push on one end of the gripping plates (whatever you call them) to slide the sliding end off. Putting it back easily on only requires that you push on both ends of aforementioned stack of plates. But, maybe I'm not understanding your question, because my explanation should be obvious to anyone who has made much use of the Pony clamps.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Galen Vetterick
Black steel pipe and galvanized are both made to the same dimensional spec limits and what you usually find is A53. Black steel pipe is just protected by the oxide coating created by the forming process and oiled to prevent rusting. Some black pipe is not oiled but has a thin lacquer coating or an asphaltic varnish ( not to be confused with asphaltic coated pipe for buried service). They hold up better than just oil in warehouse storage till it is sold or used.
Hot dipped or zinc coatings are soft and have greater chance of the clamp slipping. Depending on the design of the clamping mechanism some may hold to galvanized and not slip. You may find that the lacquer or varnish coatings may slip as well. Black is cheaper but it is used to insure a better grip of the clamp over galvanized by most manufactures.
We had to be very specific when we ordered pipe as most we used got sanblasted and painted so any coating cost us more blasting labor. Steel warehouses hated to process our orders cause they did not want rusty black pipe in there warehouse.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
bradkansas
Dale,
I bought two 48" galvanized pipes for the Pony clamps yesterday and they were $3 cheaper than the black pipes at HD.
I used them on a 24 X 48 quarter sawn white oak table today and there was no lack of grip on the Galv. pipe.
Brad
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
bradkansas
Jack, I've started putting the black pipe on the top over a couple thin wood strips thereby holding the pipe above the surface and Bessy's or black pipe underneath where the staining doesn't matter. A benefit is that I don't get the bowing upward as with the clamps all on the bottom.
Now that I've used the galvy and find them acceptable, I will phase out the black pipe.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
bradkansas
William, Aside from your living in my favorite fly fishing hub, your idea of the PVC pipe standoffs is great! Brad
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
bradkansas
I have found if you sand and sand and sand the black pipe one can remove almost all the black from staining your hands and the stock, but not all. So wear gloves already!
HD has 48" galvy for $14.95 and black pipe for $17.95 here in Kansas.
Re: OT - black pipe and Pony clamps
William Duffield, in Bozeman
I don't live here; I'm just here on vacation. As far as I know, there's no fly fishing to speak of back in NJ, on the Cohansey.
Why is anyone buying pipe clamps?
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
If I looked at the correct entry a Pony clamp cost $16 plus the cost of the pipe which must push the cost to $20 or so. For $5 to 10 more one can get the aluminum Universal clamps from Lee Valley in 2 to 4' lengths. Advantages are that they don't flex so panel gluing is easier, they don't stain, they adjust easier, they are lighter. Most that have tried bar clamps or any variety conclude that they are worth the extra cost.
For some reason we all seem to begin with pipe clamps. Once you use a handy bar clamp the pipe clamps are never used again. So take heed and skip over the pipe clamp step and buy bar clamps to begin with.
Re: Why is anyone buying pipe clamps?
Ron in Sterling, CT
Hi Bill
I bought a milk crate full (17) at a garage sale for $15. I cleaned them up, and repainted all of them. I made a deal with a friend who owns a machine shop for the pipe. He had a whole bunch of old black pipe, so I used his horizontal band saw to cut the pipe, and his pipe threader to thread the pipe. I traded him 7 of the clamps for the pipe for my 10 clamps. Now I have 10 pipe clamps, plus a few extra pieces of long (6 ft.) pipe for a total cost of $20.74 ($15 for the pipe, & $5.74 for a can of paint), plus a few hours of my labor. At $2.07 each out of pocket that is why I am using pipe clamps.
Ron
Re: Why is anyone buying pipe clamps?
Bill Tindall, E.TN.
Hey, I asked why people were buying them. "Stealing" them is another issue. 
Re: Why is anyone buying pipe clamps?
Jack Guzman from Maine
I agree but when I got my first set I wasn't aware of an alternative. Since then I have bought more when other people get better clamps. They go real cheap at yard sales and flea markets and you can never have too many clamps.---Jack
Same here...
John in NM
With 10 or so, various lengths of pipe, and some handy threaded couplings, I have most of the clamps I need for most glue ups. If I were starting from scratch now, I would likely buy the LV ones - but only because of your reviews and having worked with some crazy stiff alloys. I suspect there are a lot of consumers who don't know that aluminum doesn't automatically mean cheap and soft.
because I've never seen a 9' long bar clamp
Pipe clamps are a necessity in a custom shop!
Dick Coers
Take them to a pipe fabricator and have them roll the pipe into a curve. Works great for radius panel glue ups. I've even made them up to 16' long with couplings.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Joseph Prendergast
Well. I love my pony clamps and for many reasons would never give them up. I use 3/4" pony clamps and have some 9 feet long. Where are you going to buy a K-Body that long. No, they are not the first clamps I grab for glue up's, but I find I always need them for something.
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Brad Bransky
Joseph, I too have used the ponies for many years and find no fault other than the marking which is easily prevented, as you know. They do a wonderful job of closing my gaps and making my product, mostly arts and crafts tables, appear to reflect a higher skill than I possess. 1260 pounds pressure does wonders (760 lbs. for Bessey's bars).
Brad
MPMA'57
Re: black pipe and Pony clamps
Jim Randolph
I didn't see that anyone addressed the original poster's question about why black pipe is used. I'm pretty sure manufacturers of pipe clamps say that the galvanizing will wear out the clutches faster.