Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

How to read a MSDS

Posts

How to read a MSDS

#1

How to read a MSDS

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

How to read a Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS)

The purpose of these documents is to provide persons working with chemicals the most reliable information on the health and safety risks of the chemical or formulation as well as instructions for first aid, disposal, spill mitigation, etc. If you worked for a responsible company that uses chemicals you would be encouraged/required to review these documents for the chemicals you regularly handled. This practice is to be encouraged in the home shop as well. A MSDS for any chemical can be readily found by searching the Internet, “MSDS XXXX”. Labels often have links to MSDS sheets.

While these documents are designed for ordinary mortals they are filled with incomprehensible jargon which I will attempt to decipher. We will use acetone as an example

Acetone Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS)


Section 1

This section provides common names for the chemical. In this case acetone is always simply called “acetone”.


Section 2

Let the jargon begin. “CAS No.” is the Chemical Abstracts number assigned to this chemical. 67-64.1 is the CAS number name for “acetone”. “ACGIH TLV” is the concentration (“threshold limit value (TLV))” of a chemical that a worker can be exposed to day after day for a working lifetime without adverse health effects. TLV is a reserved term of the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH). These data seem to be falling out of favor to be replaced by the data tabulated below it. “STEL” is the short term exposure limit, or the maximum concentration of the chemical that a worker should not be exposed to for a short time.(translation: workplace concentration must never go above this amount) It is logically higher than the “TWA” Total Workplace Average”. According to OSHA, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, “TWA is the employee's average airborne exposure in any 8-hour work shift of a 40-hour work week which shall not be exceeded."

Concentration for vapors is usually expressed as “ppm” which stands for parts per million which translates to the more comprehensible equivalent of milligrams of the chemical per cubic meter of air. To summarize these data: OSHA has determined that a worker can safely work an 8 hour shift in a concentration of 1 gram of acetone (approximately ¼ teaspoons) per cubic meter of air.

How did OSHA come up with these values? For something like acetone that is widely used in industry there is a vast body of experience with worker exposure from which to set these values. Responsible companies, for example Kodak, DuPont, etc. have measured workplace concentrations of chemicals for decades and monitored worker health to develop internal limits for exposure. These and other data were used by OSHA. For a new chemical the levels would be conservatively set from animal studies.

There follows the “Emergency Overview” which gives worst case hazards for this chemical. For acetone we are informed that it is highly flammable and if you drink or breathe enough of it it will cause the problems listed. It is well to note that this section provides worst case information, what can happen if you spill, drink or breathe enough of it. Salt can show up with alarming properties in this section. This section usually illustrates that enough of anything can be a hazard. More relevant information for typical encounters with the chemical is to be found elsewhere in the MSDS.


I regard the “Hazard Ratings” part of Section 2 as the most useful part of the MSDS for quick reference. Here we have a quick summary of the relative hazard of the chemical. We see that the health hazard for acetone exposure is slight and it is highly flammable. I interpret this summary to mean that the main concern in using acetone is high fire hazard. The other two entries are of most relevance to chemists and hard to summarize so I will skip them.

Section 3 Physical Properties

Much of these data are of little interest to the woodworker. However, “Odor Threshold” combined with the TWA given in Section 2 is relevant. In the case of acetone you can smell it at 62 ppm and 1000 ppm is safe to work in. Be especially wary of chemicals where the TWA is less than the odor threshold for in this case your nose will not provide a warning of an unsafe concentration. In contrast for acetone, and most solvents, being able to detect it by smell doesn’t necessarily mean the concentration is a fire or health hazard. Odor is a poor measure of risk.


Section 4 Fire Data

Flash Point Definition- Flash point is a temperature (probably in degrees F but we don’t know for sure in this case because it doesn’t say). If the liquid is above this temperature a spark will ignite the vapor. We see that a spark or flame will ignite acetone at any temperature that we might be using it. There are lots of ignition sources in a shop- switches and motors- hence, the fire rating of 3 in Section 2. The “Flammable Limits” entry tells us what concentration of acetone in a vapor will ignite/explode. Almost any solvent we use in woodworking will have a similar value. Note the confusing change in concentration units. It takes some chemical gymnastics to convert from ppm to volume percent.

Section 5 is mostly of use to people doing chemistry with the chemical and I will skip it.




Section 6

.

From the Occupational Safety and Health Administration manual-

“LD stands for "Lethal Dose". LD50 is the amount of a material, given all at once, which causes the death of 50% (one half) of a group of test animals. The LD50is one way to measure the short-term poisoning potential (acute toxicity) of a material. LC stands for "Lethal Concentration". LC values usually refer to the concentration of a chemical in air but in environmental studies it can also mean the concentration of a chemical in water.

For inhalation experiments, the concentration of the chemical in air that kills 50% of the test animals in a given time (usually four hours) is the LC50 value.”

In the case of acetone we see that it takes a lot of it to kill rats and rabbits which is why it has a health rating of 1 in Section 2. If the chemical has any special toxicological properties, for example carcinogen, we would find that information here

The rest of the document is self explanatory.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#2

Very Useful, Bill, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

you left out . . . "The State of California has determined that this s*** [insert product, any product] will kill you, cause cancer, give your offspring a third eye and scales, and render you permanently impotent/infertile."

:D

Re: How to read a MSDS

#3

a story on that....

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I was in Wyoming fishing and needed some snap swivels. After purchase wife was scrutinizing the purchase and began to laugh. It was know to the state of CA that my snap swivels would cause cancer, no doubt from the 6 ppm lead that might be in the 3 mils of brass plating. The problem with this crap is that it trains some people to ignore warnings and others to become hysterical about "chemicals" of any stripe.

As good was the label on the milk that warned that the product contained "Milk", a food allergen. Heedless, I drank it anyway.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#4

And

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Just think of what you were doing to those poor fish by throwing that crap in the water!!

"Dude! You gonna really eat THAT now?" :D :D

Re: How to read a MSDS

#5

clock plans warning

Jerry Gibbs

I bought some clock plans made of paper. The paper plans contained a CA warning in case I sanded wood, used stain, varnish etc. after I bought the paper plans. I think the people of CA ignore these warnings completely.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#6

Re: How to read a MSDS

Ed Wozniak-Buffalo, NY

MSDS sheets for paints can be useful in determining what solvent to use for thinning. Paint labels do not always have this information, one reason being that some paints are not supposed to be thinned because then they would violate the VOC rules. The MSDS sheets however list all of the materials that make up the paint and it is usually not too hard to pick out one that will mix properly with the paint. This came up for me when when I tried to spray some Kubota brand paint for my tractor. Paint thinner did mix with the paint but xylene or some other thinner (I forget what) was part of the list of ingredients and I was good to go.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#7

excellent point, thanks

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This post will be added to the Articles section. Your useful addition has been added.

If the MSDS is a mixture, for example a finish as you pointed out, or a cleaner, the chemical constituents will be listed along with at least their approximate amounts in Section 1. If the MSDS is for a product name, again, its chemical constituents will be listed.

As an example of using this information, premetalllized dyes are exceptionally light stable. Other dye types are less so. By searching the MSDS for dye stains one can determine which brands are premetallized and hence more light fast.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#8

Re: And

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

One of the latest safety measures imposed by the state of CA is that no plumbing fixture can contain any lead or any alloy containing lead. What this did was eliminate the use of red brass for hose faucets and other fittings. Sure silicon bronze is a better alloy for corrosion resistance but it is almost double the cost due to being more difficult to machine.

Robin

Re: How to read a MSDS

#9

Re: excellent point, thanks

Howard Acheson

>>>> If the MSDS is for a product name, again, its chemical constituents will be listed.

It should be noted that the MSDS is not a recipe for the compound or product. MSDS is only required to list the constituent chemicals that are hazardous. For example, waterborne finishes are not required to list water--some do however. Nor does the MSDS list the specific quantities of hazardous materials. Frequently they only list a range.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#10

Re: And

R Payne

The no lead isn't a CA thing. It's for all the U.S. (although I don't recall when it takes effect for the whole of the U.S. - so CA may have put in a state law making it earlier).

Re: How to read a MSDS

#11

correction

Bill Tindall, E.TN.


The purpose of the MSDS is to list the known information on the constituents. There is no "hazardous" definition by which to judge what is listed and what is not. Everything is listed and it is left up to the reader to judge hazard from the information.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#12

If you believed half of the warnings -

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I died about 20 years ago! I worked several jobs in my 50+ working years, and am now 72. I used to "Buff" asbestos Brake linings with a wire wheel to clean off the glaze from leaky wheel cylinders at a service station (second job) did this many times. Can't remember how many times I swallowed used motor oil when changing oil lying under a car, or leaded gasoline when siphoning.

The house I was raised in had many lead pipes, lead paint all over (don't think I ate any though. Used to save Mercury - coated pennies with it to make them silver, chased mercury drops around the table and floor etc.

I worked at the steel mills for about 3 years using toulene daily sometimes made me dizzy (er).

Worked as a repairman at a motor repair shop, we all used a bucket of used transformer oil to remove grease & dirt from our hands (heavily laden with PCB's)

then ate lunch. Used to use the Carbon tetrachloride fire extinguishers to clean brush type motors and generator while they were running.

Sprayed a lot of different pesticides - from DDT to Chlordane (sprayed 2 or three of the chlordane "rose dust" cartridges under my current house to kill spiders.

Drank "raw" milk, cream, & used homemade butter for several years. Had an ulcer when I was young and used to eat raw eggs (punched holes in unwashed eggs and sucked the egg out). Used to wash my shirt in 111 Triclorathane (sic) at work then put it on damp.

I could continue this list for hours, but I want to smoke a cigarette -(smoked for over 50 years).

So far the only issues I have had is flat feet, arthritis, gallstones and hip replacements, do have type 2 diabetes (oral medication under control) don't think any of the chemicals had anything to do with these!

I am quite sure I am not going to live forever (doubt I would want to do that), I sure would rather ignore 99% of the "warnings" and live the way I want to while I am here!

Re: How to read a MSDS

#13

Amen.

paul in AZ

Of the things we are told can go wrong, 99% of them never happen.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#14

Re: Amen.

Larry in NW Ohio

Larry Are you sure we aren`t brothers. That sounds about like my life. I also use to clean my hands with laqure thinner, and also drank leaded gas the same way you did. I also drank from a little ditch that was downstream from an elevator. So far there isn`t much wrong with me I could say that my early life caused it. There are so mant more things that I drank and washed my hands with and also breathed in like DDT, that I should be dead by know. We could do with less regulations. I`m not saying we shouldn`t have things the MSDS list, it`s good to know what is in what container. We just need to use some common sense. Something we seemed to have lost some where along the way. Larry

Re: How to read a MSDS

#15

If you believe

Merle

government warnings, you probably wouldn't drink hard water! :D

Re: How to read a MSDS

#16

As in ice cubes?


Re: How to read a MSDS

#17

good genes can sub for good sense

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

But if you are unsure of the quality of your genes for warding off the harmful effects of stuff others have experienced to be harmful, then be prudent. Look at the hazard ratings and for things that have 2's be cautious. For things that have 3's be especially wary or avoid a use or situation that exposes one to a #3 risk.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#19

don't ignore the warnings *LINK*

GolfSteve in Calgary

The problem with understanding warnings like these is that there is not a direct cause and effect.

e.g. you personally used PCB's all your life and you do not have cancer, so you don't believe any warnings.

Most of the warnings are based on statistics. eg. if 100,000 people are exposed to PCB's at a concentration > XX, then 10 will get cancer, which satisfies a criterion that someone set as the goalpost to qualify as hazardous. (*)

Some hazards are immediately apparent - eg. if you breathe hydrogen sulphide (H2S) at a concentration above 1000 ppm you are probably going to die within a few breaths. Everyone understands that type of warning.

MSDSs can be very useful if you want to educate yourself about the hazards you are exposing yourself to. So many hazards are so easy to avoid - eg. wearing rubber gloves, wearing a respirator - that the slight incovenience of using adequate ventilation or wearing a respirator is much lower than the inconvenience of a solvent headache or the small chance of premature death.

Some people are pigheaded and prefer to take their chances (I work with people like that) just so they can think they are tough. Others are educated in the risks and have made the decision that the risk is acceptable. Others are uneducated about the risk (I work with many people like this in China) and they are the ones I feel sorry for.

(*) this is a bad example because PCBs are relatively non-hazardous unless ingested - that is why they were so useful to industry. The problem with PCBs is that if they are inefficiently burned, the combustion products (dioxins/furans) are extrodinarily hazardous. Because of their stability and fat solubility they also bioaccumulate.

I have to admit that some of the California warning labels that I've seen on consumer products are a bit ridiculous, but I do admire the drive to make products safer and to educate consumers.


PCB MSDS

Re: How to read a MSDS

#20

Good and Bad MSDSs

GolfSteve in Calgary

H2S is extremely dangerous.

This, in my opinion, is an example of a MSDS that is not very useful: http://www.mathesongas.com/pdfs/msds/MAT11210.pdf

When I read this MSDS, I learn that H2S is harmful if inhaled, and short term exposure might cause irritation, cough, lack of sense of smell, sensitivity to light, changes in blood pressure, nausea, vomiting, difficulty breathing, headache, drowsiness, dizziness, disorientation, hallucinations, pain in extremities, tremors, visual disturbances, suffocation, lung congestion, internal bleeding, heart disorders, nerve damage, brain damage, convulsions, coma, death.

Note that death is just something that might happen....you have to get to page 6 to learn that the LC50 in rats is 444 ppm. For this MSDS you have to be reasonably technically savvy to understand how hazardous H2S is. The MSDS also does not warn that you cannot rely on your sense of smell to detect the presence of H2S.

Compare that with what I think is a much better MSDS: http://www.keyera.com/titanweb/keyera/webcms.nsf/AllDoc/BDF828E563D095BF8725784D0060D0B1/$File/H2S.pdf

Highlighted on the first page is this text:

This product is extremely toxic and flammable and will be easily ignited by heat, sparks or flames. Explosive mixtures form when vapors mix with air. Vapors may travel to a source of ignition and flash back. May be fatal if inhaled – high concentrations can cause immediate death. Hydrogen Sulfide that is an extremely toxic and flammable gas at low concentrations. Exposures to hydrogen sulfide above 100 ppm are immediately dangerous to life and health (IDLH) and may be fatal.

Now, that, is something an average person can understand.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#21

rebuttal

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

If you read my post I point the reader to what I find the most useful part of the MSDS, the number hazard rating. We see that for the MSDS that you find unhelpful that the number 4 !! is blazingly obvious for both fire and health. A 4 rating is cause for particular concern. 4's are the baddest of bad, reserved for the most hazardous properties. A health rating of 4 is something that only a trained person should deal with.

This MSDS is only unhelpful if you don't look to the number rating as the first place to get an assessment of a chemicals hazards.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Rebutted rebuttal...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

But, one has to understand that number rating first for it to be meaningful. Certainly useful at-a-glance to those in the know, but the average joe is still left in the dark compared to clear, concise, bold text at the top explaining an immediate danger that anyone with basic reading skills can understand.

A complicated MSDS seems anathema to OSHA's goal of protecting the stupid from themselves.

Jason

Re: How to read a MSDS

#23

Re: 2nd issue there

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I also believe that the people that are exposed to childhood disease's, normal bacteria, pollen, and some chemicals etc. develop a resistance to them and strengthens the body.

Many of the issues that children have today did not exist - I don't mean not diagnosed, I mean did not occur. The incidents of allergies are a good example. I went to a country school, and the only allergy I saw in ANYONE in the school was a reaction to poison Oak and Ivy. Zero food allergies, asthma etc, even bee stings. Not saying there were not some children affected then - but it certainly was a lot smaller percentage than today.

I have had friends that kept their children isolated from public to avoid catching illnesses, and didn't even let them play in the dirt. The children had way more health problems than mine and that carried on into adulthood. This is somewhat verified by looking at people traveling to other countries. Drink water or eat fresh food in China or areas of Mexico and see if you have resistance to the bacteria. EVERY person my company routinely sent to China ended up with an Illness that required hospitalization - all survived but one guy was quite ill for several weeks.

Another issue is that much of the "scientific data" is in error for various reasons. The Swordfish Mercury scare a few years ago put a lot of hard working fishermen out of work, then it was proven a year or so later that mercury levels DO go up and down in the human body (samples taken from Smithsonian tissue samples during a mans lifetime). PCBS were declared permanent - until they re-sampled love canal and found it perfectly clear of any pcbs. Even though the temperature hasn't risen one degree in 16 years - the Global warming is still believed. I still believe the "hole in the ozone layer" is bogus - The science is fine but they took a snapshot in time that has no relation to geological time - then declared the findings fact! When it shrunk a couple years later they didn't publicize the fact.

There is just too many scientists and politicians wanting to be in the spotlight and that are willing to distort or ignore certain facts in order to scare the public for me to have any faith in what they say or publish. Yes, I am an educated individual and worked with chemicals for many years as part of my job as an Engineer. No I did not ever expose any other person to dangerous (or above OSHA limits). But I also am certified in several classes of Statistics - including Taguchi so am quite aware how they develop their data.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#24

Duh

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

This is precisely why I made the considerable effort to prepare what I hoped to be an informative, easy to read post on the topic. If you read what I wrote and still can not understand some useful to woodworkers part of the MSDS email me with a description of what needs to be made clearer and I will fix it before it is posted as an Article.

The only essential part of the MSDS is the number rating. One needs to only understand two words, "Fire, Health" , and four numbers whose significance are clearly described next to the number hazard entry.

I would advocate that everyone should be familiar with the "Diamond" hazard label found in the MSDS erroneously labeled deficient. It was the first thing I spotted when the page loaded and I instantly knew this was some bad stuff. While it is not used on consumer products it will be found throughout the workplace that uses chemicals on labels and posted in the vicinity of their use and often on trucks carrying chemicals.

Re: How to read a MSDS

#25

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Duh

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

It's not a rip on what you wrote or your efforts to educate those who peruse the pages of WoodCentral. My issue is with the MSDS--why not base it on training virtually everyone already has (basic reading), particularly when it could be a life-and-death matter instead of a numbering system that requires a legend and/or additional training to be readily understood?

That's not to say the number/diamond system couldn't also be used, but I think a short, clear, highlighted statement at the top of the MSDS would be more universal in its communication of the level of dangers of a given substance.

Jason