Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

What solvents to have on hand?

Posts

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#26

Solvent for epoxy

GolfSteve in Calgary

I used to use acetone to clean up uncured epoxy but recently learned that isopropyl alcohol works just as we'll or better.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#27

Melting brain cells story

Tom Dunlap

When I was in junior high I was making model hot rods. My brother, who is 8.5 years younger, started building along with me. My Mom asked me to talk with him about the effects of glue/paint vapors. Coming from me would make the message more meaningful. I was planning on telling him the next time we got out the kits. A day or so later Mom had some hot drippings for our dog to enjoy. She put them in her, the dog, not Mom ;), bowl but it was still too hot. Mom dropped some ice cubes into the bowl to cool it. The cool water made a 'puddle' in the drippings. My brother was in the kitchen at the same time. I told him to look at what was happening to the ice cubes. I told him that was what would happen to his brain if he got too many vapors from glue/paint. His eyes turned into saucers! No glue sniffing in our house!

Tom

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#28

Re: Solvent for epoxy

William Duffield

That's a good tip. I really don't like using acetone. I guess 70% rubbing alcohol would work OK, unless you're worried about raising the grain on adjoining wood surfaces.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#29

Re: With respect, I rarely post without

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

An art department is not the source of toxicology information that I would rely on.

Stating correctly that some solvents have toxicology concerns and then listing various solvents does not mean that every solvent on that list has the same concerns attributed to some on the list. The solvents on the list vary widely in their toxicological properties. I have no objection if someone chooses to treat all solvents with the same caution, but don't claim it is necessary.

"Acetone can be particularly nasty as it is absorbed through the skin, deposits in critical organs" This statement is in conflict with anything I have ever seen published on this widely used industrial solvent. Mammals naturally make acetone in small quantities. It is readily excreted. It and toluene are considered the most benign of the industrial solvents. Will you reference the source of your claim?

" like the sun's UV rays, the effects are cumulative. " I have never seen solvent exposure treated like the effects are cumulative. Industrial health departments monitor short and long term exposure effects but there is no cumulative exposure guidelines or regulations like there is for radiation, for example. Again, a reference for this claim?

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#30

Re: Solvent for epoxy

GolfSteve in Calgary

I use the 70% isopropyl alochol and it works fine. A bit of google engineering also reveals that denatured alcohol can be used.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#31

Totally unrelated, but you reminded me

John in NM

Once when I was making tortillas, I wanted to melt some fat that had been in the fridge. Since the recipe requires water too, and I didn't want to get the fat super hot, I put the water in with the fat before heating it. Big mistake - fat floats on water, yet boils at a higher temp. End result was water and lard splattered everywhere :D

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#32

Reply

Gary Smyth

Scientists at the UIC art department are at least as good a reference as “I submitted a sample of paint thinner to a chemist friend” as a reliability factor. You can pick whatever source you choose for your own belief but I’ll stick with my sources and my statement. I never stated that all organic solvents have the same dangers. I did imply if not state that anyone working with solvents ought to be careful and not to roll the dice with their health. As to cumulative effects can you seriously challenge that any solvent that is absorbed into the body and causes systemic, nerve, optic and irreversible intellect damage is not by definition a cumulative problem if the exposure is prolonged and/or repeated? I don't need a graph to tell me to be cautious. As to acetone, for some it may be a mild rash, for me it is a cause for more serious breathing problems. Here are additional sources. I’ll not debate this matter on this site further.

TOXICOLOGICAL REVIEWOFACETONE(CAS No. 67-64-1)

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Washington, TOXICOLOGICAL REVIEW OF ACETONE (CAS No. 67-64-1) In Support of Summary Information on the Integrated Risk Information System (IRIS) May 2003 Environmental Protection Agency Washington

Material Safety Data Sheet

Acetone MSDS

Section 1: Chemical Product and Company Identification

Special Remarks on other Toxic Effects on Humans:

Acute Potential Health Effects: Skin: May cause skin irritation. May be harmful if absorbed through the skin. Eyes: Causes

eye irritation, characterized by a burning sensation, redness, tearing, inflammation, and possible corneal injury. Inhalation:

Inhalation at high concentrations affects the sense organs, brain and causes respiratory tract irritation. It also may affect the

Central Nervous System (behavior) characterized by dizzness, drowsiness, confusion, headache, muscle weakeness, and

possibly motor incoordination, speech abnormalities, narcotic effects and coma. Inhalation may also affect the gastrointestinal

tract (nausea, vomiting). Ingestion: May cause irritation of the digestive (gastrointestinal) tract (nausea, vomiting). It may also

affect the Central Nevous System (behavior), characterized by depression, fatigue, excitement, stupor, coma, headache,

altered sleep time, ataxia, tremors as well at the blood, liver, and urinary system (kidney, bladder, ureter) and endocrine

system. May also have musculoskeletal effects. Chronic Potential Health Effects: Skin: May cause dermatitis. Eyes: Eye

irritation

Dangers to Humans

Solvents, and acetone more than most, are easily absorbed through the skin and also de-fat it. This often results in cracked, dry skin, eczema, dermatitis, allergies, and other skin conditions. Within minutes of exposure appreciable amounts of acetone are also found in the blood and from here may cause to damage to many key organs in the body. By crossing the blood-brain barrier it may also affect the central nervous system, causing behavioural disturbances both in the short and long term.

In addition solvents can act as carriers - dissolving chemicals that would otherwise remain outside the body and transporting them across the bodies defence membranes in the skin, mouth, nasal passages, etc.. These effects are often cumulative and therefore may have long-term implications on the health of workers and hence the potential for associated liabilities being incurred by employers.

The human body has developed the skin (epidermis) and other surface tissues of organs such as the lungs, mouth and nasal passages to act as a barrier to external compounds. However these tissues are by their very nature made of organic molecules - proteins, poly-saccharides, fats etc. This means that organic solvents naturally dissolve into these membranes and pass into the body proper. This in itself is a danger, but much more hazardous is the fact that these solvents dissolve and carry through the membranes other potentially toxic compounds that are on the skin and/or in the environment.

Alternative solvents to acetone tend to have higher flash points, meaning they are less flammable, but as a result do not evaporate from the tools that have been cleaned and leave behind greasy, oily residues which can contaminate further work, as well as being a hazard in themselves. They still have toxicity problems associated with all solvents in being easily absorbed through the skin and other membranes.

From an article by US Occupational Safety and Health Administration:

Millions of workers are exposed to solvents on a daily basis. Health hazards associated with solvent exposure include toxicity to the nervous system, reproductive damage, liver and kidney damage, respiratory impairment, cancer, and dermatitis. Solvents share many chemical, physical, and biological properties that warrant national attention be directed to them as a group.

From a publication by the Centre for Disease Control in Atlanta, USA by J. Donald Millar, M.D., D.T.P.H. (Lond.), Assistant Surgeon General, Director, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control.

Epidemiologic studies of various groups of solvent-exposed workers have demonstrated statistically significant chronic changes in peripheral nerve function (sensory and motor nerve conduction velocities and electromyographic abnormalities) that persisted for months to years following cessation of exposure. Epidemiologic studies have also shown statistically significant increases in neurobehavioral effects in workers chronically exposed to organic solvents.

These effects include disorders is characterized by reversible subjective symptoms (fatigability, irritability, and memory impairment), sustained changes in personality or mood (emotional instability and diminished impulse control and motivation), and impaired intellectual function (decreased concentration ability, memory, and learning ability). Among organic solvent abusers, the most severe disorders reported are characterized by irreversible deterioration in intellect and memory (dementia) accompanied by structural CNS damage.

From an article by Capt Mario E. Fajardo M.D., of the US Public Health Service

Organic solvents are a distinct group of substances characterized by their ability to dissolve oils, fats, plastics, rubber and resins.

Amongst those organic solvents commonly used, ketones are chemically stable substances, which include acetone, methyl ethyl ketone, methyl isobutyl ketone, and diisobutyl ketone. Exposure to high concentration of these agents can produce narcosis, headaches, nausea, vomiting, dizziness, loss of coordination, and loss of consciousness. At lower doses they can induce irritation of the eyes and respiratory passages and slow central nervous system activity. Respiratory failure and death have been reported with exposure to these agents.

Most solvents irritate the mucous membranes of the eyes, nose and throat with the eyes being the most sensitive.

The initial manifestation is typically a burning sensation, resulting from stimulation of the trigeminal nerve endings of the nose and eyes, although a cough may also be apparent as a result of stimulation of the laryngeal nerve endings in the throat. Aspiration of solvents into the lung can result in rapid and severe pulmonary damage. Heavy exposures are commonly manifested by cough, chest tightness and loss of breath.

Prolonged exposure and absorption may even cause a chemical burn.

Inhalation of organic solvents may cause a progression of symptoms from an initial euphoria to lethargy, dizziness, staggering gait, coma and death.

From a publication by the Centre for Disease Control in Atlanta, USA by J. Donald Millar, M.D., D.T.P.H. (Lond.), Assistant Surgeon General, Director, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#33

Ellis Walentine

Dres once told me...

Ellis Walentine

After our resident finishing maven, Sam Simpson, passed away from liver cancer several years ago, I mentioned his passing to Michael Dresdner. Mike simply said something to the effect of "yeah, everyone who deals with finishes on a continuing basis ends up that way." Of course he wasn't speaking literally, but I've always respected his anecdotal evidence, since he's spent his entire professional career in the finishing trenches.

Ellis

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#34

Re: Me too

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Depending on the temperature and humidity, I may add turpentine, Naptha, Mineral spirits, or Acetone to oil based finishes, I have used all (sometimes more than one in the mix) just to control drying time etc. I do most of my spraying right outside my shop, then move the item into the shop to dry. When it is hot and Sunny, I have really added a lot of slow thinners to avoid "bubbling", when cold, a lot less thinner - usually Naptha or Acetone for quicker drying. Don't use much Acetone lately due to the major price increase. Acetone will mix with both alcohol and other thinners so it can solve some problems. Of course lacquer thinner will really dry fast when used in cold weather. Many people think you can use only one solvent - actually almost any will work with most Poly's, other urethane, varnishes, Tung oil and BLO.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#35

so as to not confuse the bystanders

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

If you want to know the hazards of using acetone consult the MSDS sheet for it. Ditto for any chemical you use.

While it is arranged to appear his text is from the acetone MSDS sheet most of what is reported by Smyth is from some undisclosed source that has little to do with acetone and offers no evidence to support previous claims of accumulation, etc. The OSHA exposure limit for acetone is one of the largest of any solvent. ( It is regarded by places that use it in mega ton quantities as the safest of the organic solvents in terms of toxicity.) These concentrations at your nose would likely need to come from concentrations at the source that would be well within the explosive limit for acetone. Hence, my caution that in a typical situation you are more likely to explode before achieving a concentration of solvent that would cause a health issue.

I believe that alarmist claims for toxicity unsupported by fact or experience do not promote safe use of solvents, or chemicals in general. On the one had they can drive useful products from the market place to be substituted by materials with inferior performance (green paint stripper comes to mind) or lead others to dismiss any claim of hazard and result in careless use (chromate wood coloring is a good example).

Bottom line- if you use a chemical in quantity consult its MSDS sheet or better yet have it in your woodworking files. Respect, don't overreact.