With respect, I rarely post without
Gary Smyth
checking facts.
It may not match your test with your friend, but other science is available.
No pissing contest here, but I'm not wrong.
I started wiith a scanning of: DHHS (NIOSH) Publication Number 81-123
Occupational Health Guidelines for Chemical Hazards
Occupational Health Guidelines for Chemical Hazards summarizes information on permissible exposure limits, chemical and physical properties, and health hazards. It provides recommendations for medical surveillance, respiratory protection, and personal protection and sanitation practices for specific chemicals that have Federal occupational safety and health regulations. These recommendations reflect good industrial hygiene and medical surveillance practices, and their implementation will assist development and maintenance of an effective occupational health program.
I followed with a very quick scan of FDA Mortality and Morbidity report toxic organic chemicals which consists of 585 reports -- including benzine. Benzene toxicity and risk assessment, 1972-1992: implications for future regulation.
D J Paustenbach, R D Bass, and P Price
On the UICs (University of Illinois Chicago) Health and Safety in the Arts website, the safety experts Angela Babin, Michael McCann and Devora Neumark write about the much under-rated solvent hazards:
"Although some solvents are less hazardous than others, all solvents can cause toxic effects. There are no safe organic solvents, only more and less toxic ones. All organic solvents can affect the nervous system, respiratory system, skin, eyes, and internal organs to some degree. Solvents are also implicated in damage to both the male and the female reproductive systems.
Examples of Volatile Organic Solvents:
WHITE SPIRIT
TURPENTINE
NAPHTHA
TOLUOL
MINERAL SPIRIT
BENZENE
LITHOTINE
ACETONE
LACQUER THINNER
GLYCOL ETHER
METHYL ALCOHOL
STYRENE
XYLENE
Examples of safe, non-volatile alternatives:
WATER
SOAPS
DETERGENTS
SODIUM CARBONATE
BAKING SODA
LINSEED OIL
VEGETABLE OIL, OLIVE OIL
BABY OIL (?)
Examples of safer, volatile non-petroleum solvents:
D-LIMONENE (orange oil)
SOYBEAN OIL SOLVENT
CORN OIL SOLVENT
ETHYL ALCOHOL
I was cautioning in a generic sense which is, in my view only common sense. I did do basic review and I stand by my comments. The reader can choose to accept or not.