Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

What solvents to have on hand?

Posts

What solvents to have on hand?

#1

What solvents to have on hand?

Tom Dunlap

Most cooks can list off the basic staples to have on hand for cooking.

What I'm wondering is what basic solvents I should have on the shelf out in the shop?

There are sooo many but I'm guessing that having a pint/gallon of maybe 5-6 would be sufficient.

But...which ones?

Thanks for helping me make my grocery list!

Tom

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#2

Seems to me...

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Tom: I have a few - acetone and ethanol, mineral spirits, and lacquer thinner. But it seems to be me that what I use really shouldn't matter. I treat them like router bits - buy ones you need when you need them. Given that most solvents are reasonably flammable, I try to minimize what I have on hand and only buy the ones I have specific use for.

Henry

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#3

I agree with Henry but don't underestimate

Howard in Toronto

Vodka.

And Irish whiskey.

Two solvents I always have on hand.

My 2C

Howard

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#5

Concur on the list

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

although I use denatured alcohol rather than straight ethanol. But then, I don't use shellac.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#7

JL

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

JL

It depends on what you are doing and what you need to dilute or dissolve.

Acetone - cleaning, thinning, liquifying wood filler

Mineral spirits - cleaning, thinning

Lacquer thinner - cleaning, thinning

Denatured alcohol or ethanol - cleaning thinning

Isopropyl alcohol (90% or greater) - water and alcohol soluble dyes, cleaning

Kerosene - rust cutting, "oiling"

Paint thinner - brush cleaning (cheaper than mineral spirits)

Methylene chloride - "universal solvent" for polyurethane, works to soften cured finish

Store in a grounded metal locker or an old refrigerator (grounded).

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#8

A few additions to Henry's list that I keep..

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I agree with Henry's list. In addition, I usually have the following:

Naphtha - to make home brew wipe-on poly (and fill my coleman lantern in a pinch)

Enamel reducer (for cleaning)

WD-40: yes it's a very good solvent and cleaner. Try it on oil spills on concrete fooors, then final wash with dawn dish detergent. Works great.

Goof Off: MUCH better than Goo Gone for removing adhesive from labels or old tape residue.

Prep-Sol: a Dupont product left over from my car and motorcycle painting days (along with the enamel reducer). An excellent solvent to remove wax, grease, silicone and pinstripe tape residue from metal prior to prep for painting. I use this for solvent cleaning the residue off the top of my contractor saw after cleaning it with scotchbrite and WD40 with the ROS to remove rust and stains. This is usually only available to auto finishers. I would think the naphtha would produce similar results.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#9

Don't forget water


Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#10

a case for naptha

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

As far as I am concerned turpentine, paint thinner, mineral spirits and naptha are equivalent solvents in terms of their ability to dissolve and thin stuff. The significant variables among them are price and boiling point (some might add odor but I like the smell of all of them). Naptha boils (volatilizes) the most readily. I use it to thin in the winter when flashing the solvent would be more difficult in the colder temperatures. I keep a gallon of it and a gallon of paint thinner on hand choosing between them as to how fast I want the stuff to evaporate.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#11

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Naptha is, in my view, the superior diluent for oil finishes. It thins better, flows out and levels way better, and accelerates polymerization. The only problem with it is that you cannot return thinned product to the original container.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#12

Grocery list

Tom Dunlap

Thanks for the great input!

My plan is to go back through the suggestions and make a list. My first shopping spree might be to buy a quart of each. Then, see what I use up first. Next, buy a gallon.

Many years ago I watched Roy Underhill show how to restore an old ax. His first solvent was what he called 'The Universal Solvent'...plain ol' water. I thought of that after making the original post. I don't have running water in the shop but I do have lots of jugs that can be jury-rigged into a gravity flow setup.

Tom

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#13

I use turpentine, I like the smell....

John in NM

I have some naptha around too, for the cases where it works better. I use turpentine more often though.

And paint thinner for lighting the charcoal :D

Alcohol and lacquer thinner. Not much acetone, but sometimes.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#14

What is needed to dissolve stuff- shopping list

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

There are a lot of solvent properties to consider- flammability, volatility, toxicity, cost, etc. But just considering the ability to dissolve what ever it is that needs dissolving here is a generic list of stuff you may be able to readily buy:

1.water

7.at the other end of the solvent dissolving spectrum are the hydrocarbon solvents- paint thinner, mineral spirits, naptha, trupentine

Now, filling in the gaps starting from the water end and working toward the mineral spirits end

2. alcohols -methanol, ethanol, isopropanol

3. ketones- acetone, anything on the store shelf with "ketone in its name

4. lacquer thinner (actually a mix of ketone and aromatic stuff

5. aromatic- toluene, xylene

6. gasoline - mix of hydrocarbon and aromatic

specialty solvents- powerful general purpose solvents that are especially aggressive, disssolve a wide array of stuff, expensive and not readily available- glycol ethers (brake fluid, , Purple Power), methylene chloride

Esters of one kind or another are cheap solvents similar to ketones but not readily available at stores .

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#15

Whatever you choose

Gary Smyth

don't roll the dice with your future -- add gloves and a respirator with organic/ chemical fume attachments -- and USE IT. A dust mask ain't gonna cut it. In my earlier days building model airplanes I stuck my face in close and apparently breathed enough of the toxic fumes from glue and paint dope that it burned the inside of my nose. Since then I'm sensitive to many solvents mentioned here. Acetone can be particularly nasty as it is absorbed through the skin, deposits in critical organs and tolerance is different for each person. Some will poo poo this post, and I hate to write this, like some insurance label, but there are NO safe organic solvents only more or less severe ones. And, like the sun's UV rays, the effects are cumulative. Some of the chemicals above are mutagenic and over time cause nerve damage, infertility, brain and birth defects and stimulate cell growth not normal. Play it safe now. It can't harm. You may be a lucky one to never have a problem, or you may possess a physiology with cells and DNA hanging around waiting for a trigger to change. By the way, lightweight Nitrile gloves are better than latex as they take more time to dissolve with some of the above solvents.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#16

Clarification

John E. in SC

Correct me if I'm wrong, but my understanding is that denatured alcohol IS ethanol (at least mostly), just with other chemicals added to make it undrinkable. Don't think that you can buy "plain" ethanol, except in liquor stores, or maybe the occasional back alley!

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#17

Absolutely Correct!!!!

Bill Howatt

Yes, it is too easy to ignore this risk and unfortunately the effects aren't seen right away. I'm an official senior citizen and I cringe when I think of my exposure to chemicals when younger.

Bill

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#18

Re: Whatever you choose

William Duffield

When considering using naphtha vs. mineral spirits vs. turpentine, consider the relative toxicities. I use mostly odorless mineral spirits, because they remove the benzene and many of the other toxins from it.

When using alcohol (for shellac) I usually use Behcol, because it is denatured with isobutanol instead of as much as 50% methanol, because the methanol is very toxic. Even better is Everclear, if you can find it in your state. Evidently California thinks it is more dangerous than methanol. Go figure.

Toluene is particularly dangerous because it is very easily ignited and it tends to hug the ground, where a spark can set your whole floor on fire. It also can easily suffocate any shop dog or cat that is snoozing on the job. I won't use it in my shop, even though I keep the doors and windows open whenever the weather allows it.

I use acetone for cleaning up after using epoxy and for trying to remove oils from tropical woods (e.g., teak and cocobolo) before gluing them. As Gary correctly points out, every one of the solvents I choose is still bad for you.

A good reference for helping you decide when and how to use any of them is published by NIOSH.

http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npg/

Just enter the name of the chemical in the search box.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#19

Get facts right- consult reliable sources

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

I am not going to question anyone's personal choices for dealing with solvents but if you are going to warn others quote and reference reliable sources, after studying them.

For those that want the most authoritative information based on scientific studies and operational experience look up the MSDS data which is readily found for anything we might use. These solvents are manufactured and used in billion pound quantities and workers are exposed to them daily on the job. Hence, there are a lot of data on their effects at various concentrations and exposure times. We don't need to rely on mega exposure to rats and extrapolated to humans. The two important pieces of data are the safe concentrations for long term continuous exposure ( a value irrelevant for the typical woodworking hobby situation), and short term acute exposure.

The web sites for products usually will link to MSDS data, or the chemicals listed on the label can be searched simply by typing "MSDS for XXXX".

For the solvents we commonly use, in the quantities we use, and frequency of exposure, the overwhelming hazard is flammability. Except in tiny quantities used to dissolve a label adhesive or something similar none should be used in an enclosed space with limited air circulation.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#20

Re: Clarification

William Duffield

Yes, it is ethanol, but maybe not "mostly". Sometimes it is as much as 50% methanol.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#21

Re: Whatever you choose

paul in AZ

So true. Respect solvents.

Inhaling solvent vapors is well known to medical examiners as a cause of "sudden sniffing death". Kids are specially prone to look for highs with these by sniffing large doses of the vapors from plastic bags. The catastrophic result is a sudden cardiac arrhythmia and sudden death.

Use in a well ventilated area.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#22

odorless baloney

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

Some tiny quantities of unstaurated hydrocarbons are the source of odor in paint thinner. Hydrogenate them, which add cost, and it smells less. The benign toxicity remains the same. Once before when this topic came up I submitted a sample of paint thinner to a chemist friend to look for benzene. Couldn't detect any at some sub percent level that I no longer recall. So, until a carbon respirator is used while filling the gas tank (gasoline does contain benzene) worrying about paint thinner is misplaced.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#23

With respect, I rarely post without

Gary Smyth

checking facts.

It may not match your test with your friend, but other science is available.

No pissing contest here, but I'm not wrong.

I started wiith a scanning of: DHHS (NIOSH) Publication Number 81-123

Occupational Health Guidelines for Chemical Hazards

Occupational Health Guidelines for Chemical Hazards summarizes information on permissible exposure limits, chemical and physical properties, and health hazards. It provides recommendations for medical surveillance, respiratory protection, and personal protection and sanitation practices for specific chemicals that have Federal occupational safety and health regulations. These recommendations reflect good industrial hygiene and medical surveillance practices, and their implementation will assist development and maintenance of an effective occupational health program.

I followed with a very quick scan of FDA Mortality and Morbidity report toxic organic chemicals which consists of 585 reports -- including benzine. Benzene toxicity and risk assessment, 1972-1992: implications for future regulation.

D J Paustenbach, R D Bass, and P Price

On the UICs (University of Illinois Chicago) Health and Safety in the Arts website, the safety experts Angela Babin, Michael McCann and Devora Neumark write about the much under-rated solvent hazards:

"Although some solvents are less hazardous than others, all solvents can cause toxic effects. There are no safe organic solvents, only more and less toxic ones. All organic solvents can affect the nervous system, respiratory system, skin, eyes, and internal organs to some degree. Solvents are also implicated in damage to both the male and the female reproductive systems.

Examples of Volatile Organic Solvents:

WHITE SPIRIT

TURPENTINE

NAPHTHA

TOLUOL

MINERAL SPIRIT

BENZENE

LITHOTINE

ACETONE

LACQUER THINNER

GLYCOL ETHER

METHYL ALCOHOL

STYRENE

XYLENE

Examples of safe, non-volatile alternatives:

WATER

SOAPS

DETERGENTS

SODIUM CARBONATE

BAKING SODA

LINSEED OIL

VEGETABLE OIL, OLIVE OIL

BABY OIL (?)

Examples of safer, volatile non-petroleum solvents:

D-LIMONENE (orange oil)

SOYBEAN OIL SOLVENT

CORN OIL SOLVENT

ETHYL ALCOHOL

I was cautioning in a generic sense which is, in my view only common sense. I did do basic review and I stand by my comments. The reader can choose to accept or not.

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#24

Re: odorless baloney

William Duffield

You're using the gasoline outside, and can avoid breathing the vapors by standing upwind, and most gasoline pumps have vapor recovery systems. (I don't use it in the shop.) In woodshop applications, Stoddard solvent is used in enclosed spaces, and skin is often exposed.

Yes, a typical maximum benzene content in Stoddard solvent is 0.1%, which is lower than the average limit for gasoline, 0.62%. Note that the OSHA short term permissible exposure limit is 5 parts per million for benzene.

Are you suggesting that hydrogenation has no effect on reducing the toxicity of any of the double and triple carbon bond chemical components in Stoddard solvent?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_spirit

It's only Wikipedia, but I'll paraphrase the article anyway. Low odor mineral spirits contains less of the highly volatile shorter hydrocarbons. Odorless mineral spirits have been further refined to remove the more toxic aromatic compounds.

By the way, I don't eat baloney, because you never know what they put in it. :D

Re: What solvents to have on hand?

#25

Re: What is needed...is a good chemistry reminder