Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Posts

Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#1

Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Barry Irby

My fridge is dying. Compressor is going bad according to repair guy. Its about 15 years old.

So I am shopping in the scratch and dent section of Lowe's. They have a Whirlpool, a Samsung, and an Electrolux, any of which would suit my needs. The Electrolux appears to be marked down the largest percentage. Most of them have the damage on the side where it would be hidden and its very slight.

Any opinions on which brand to buy? Any other suggestions? Important features to look for? What about the side by side doors with the divider in between that flips in and out? Good? Trouble down the road?

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#2

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

John McGaw

FWIW, Consumer Reports shows Whirlpool as the most reliable brand in all categories. Samsung appears to be 50% more prone to failures. Electrolux doesn't even make it to the reliability charts, probably because of low sales numbers.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#3

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

paul in AZ

Whatever you do AVOID GE. I had one for only a couple of years and had innumerable troubles. Garbage. Expensive mistake.

Replaced it with LG which is OK but the ice maker and ice dispenser are troublesome.

Consumer products nowdays are built to generate repair bills and die young.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#4

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Chuck in Mtl.

I have an LG fridge and so far its been just ok. all the plastic on the shelves shrank and split so this was replaced under warranty. The compressor is very small and the cooling coils are underneath...a place were dust can collect and block airflow. The repairman told me fridges last an average of 10-13 years...no like the fridges I knew as a child.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#5

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

John McGaw

In their defense, all modern refrigerators have smaller compressors but they also have insulation and seals which are much more efficient than their ancestors. That is the way that the modern units manage to get along with less than half the power consumption of the old ones. The coils underneath are not a problem in most households and cleaning once a year should do the trick unless the house is infested with shedding pets.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#6

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

RobCarr

The operating cost advantage of smaller compressors and better insulation are offset by more frequent replacement cost. Of the last refrigerators I have not had one last more than 16 years. I have a GE that my grandparents had, must be from the early 40s if not earlier, still works! I also have a Hotpoint deep freezer from the early 60s, still works! They sure knew how to build them back then!

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#7

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Larry in NW Ohio

As for the coils under the fridge, I put a charcoal filter behind the front grille and on the right side, to catch some of the pet fur. That has cut some of the cleaning. that needs to be cleaned every few weeks. Larry

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#8

How Can?

Dave's Not Here

I've never understood how Consumer Reports can rate anything as being reliable? Aren't they after all testing the current year models which would mean they haven't had enough time to know if they are reliable or not? They sure do sell a lot of magazines though.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#9

Re: How Can?

JohnT

Consumer Reports sends out a questionaire to its subscribers that asks about what appliances/ automobiles/ lawn mower/etc. you own, how old it is, repair history, overall reliability and satisfaction. As i recall, it was a pretty detailed questionaire (haven't subscribed for several years).

I believe this is where they get their reliability and repair history data.

-John-

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#10

Re: How Can?

Howard Norman

JohnT is correct. CR gets their reliability data from a subscriber survey. I was a subscriber many years ago and hadn't been one until this year again. The jury is still out if I will renew.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The key component is the compressor....

Jesper, Denmark

If you can get to it, look for the manufacturers name on the compressor. The best is a Danfoss compressor.

No, I am not nationally prejudiced 8)

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#12

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Jay St. Peter

Honestly, I read all the CR data and shopped around. But in the end, I chose based on the shelving layout and mounting mechanism. The last fridge I had (Kenmore, so it doesn't help with which brand to buy since it can be any), the way the shelves mounted to the door was flimsy and I wound up buying 3 replacements over 7 years. The ice maker also failed early/often, cracked plastic case. Probably spent $500 over the years on plastic parts.

FWIW, I chose a Samsung. It's about 3 years old. The water dispenser switch has gotten a little tricky to operate, but still works.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#13

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Chad P

I don't have any advice on durability, however I do want to make a point on in-door water dispensers combined with stainless steel. I have a Samsung with in-door water. The insert where water is dispensed is also stainless steel. The inevitable drips from the water dispenser run down the stainless steel insert causing corrosion which is rather unsightly. This fridge is only about 3 years old.

I have seen water dispenser inserts on other stainless steel fridges that are plastic. If I bought a new fridge I would look for one of these or just a fridge without the in-door ice and water.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#14

When is five years old not five years old?

Barry Irby

Went back and looked at the fridges again. Read the label on the Electrolux and notice it was made in 02 of 08. The guy working there claims it does not matter because it has not been running. So, does it matter or not?

Also noticed they have one on the floor that appears to be Identical to the Whirlpool. The one that was reduced claims it was $2500 reduced to $1800. But the new one on the floor appeared to be the same fridge and it was $2100. Does not appear to be as much of a reduction as they claim.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#15

Re: When is five years old not five years old?

Dick Coers

You must be looking at a french door frig. I don't like all that plastic in the drawers and imagine them sagging or cracking in no time. We bought a Whirlpool side by side with all the ice maker hardware on the door. Makes for lots of room in the freezer, and paid around $1,100 at American TV, furniture, and appliance. I just couldn't see paying another $800+ for a drawer freezer. Besides, bending over ain't gettin' easier!

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#16

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

NickinMass

We have a Samsung french door, counter depth model (with the in-door ice/water dispenser - personally I would have rather had the ice maker in the freezer and no water dispenser, but this was the only configuration available in counter depth and we can't do a regular depth fridge because of the kitchen layout). We've had it for several years and it has held up just fine (household of 6, including 3 kids, so it gets a workout) - ice maker got a little wonky last summer but has been fine since then (from what I understand the ice maker is the weak point in many modern fridges). Holds temp well and is pretty effficient with space utilization (the only annoying thing is that you need to open both doors to get at the deli/cheese drawer). It runs quiet, but ice maker is very loud when it drops ice into the bin.

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#17

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Tony - Memphis

We just bought a new Whirlpool. Side by side doors. So far, we like it fine. I'm still not sold on the side by side thing (my first), but no major complaints. Not like its something I use all day. The sliding baskets in teh freezer are nice. Lots of neat features in the fridge - much better lighting, sliding shelves, adjustability, door storage, etc. It makes some funny noises - especialy when defrosting (water gurgling) - had to get used to that. Water and ice dispenser work fine (not a fan of those either, but they work ok). My biggest complaint is the stainless is so hard to keep decent looking. Our old unit was of the same vintage as yours and finally gave up. I would buy this one again. It has the inline filter - maint./expense item. Oh, the controls are easy to use.

Tony

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

#18

Re: Buying new Fridge questions (OT)

Larry in NW Ohio

Tony We have a Whirlpool also, and the filter isn"t much of an expense item. If you don`t use it much, you never really have to change it. The way you can tell is to put a cup under the wateroutlet and time it for how long it takes to fill to a certain level, then take the filter out, and time the filling to that level again, and if it`s very close to the same your OK. Put the filter back in and go with it. I only changed our filter once in the 7 years we had it.Larry