Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT Welder Suggestion?

Posts

OT Welder Suggestion?

#1

OT Welder Suggestion?

John M in Mid Mich

Buddy of mine wants a new welder. His wife wants to surprise him on his upcoming birthday, but I don't know what to recommend if it isn't based on glue. He has a small "hobby" farm with a couple small tractors and implements, so something general purpose. I have no idea what kind of welding he wants to do, but probably nothing fancy, in other words I'm sure he does not need inert gas, etc. But, stick or wire feed? What tradeoffs with 120 vs. 240? I see ads for "inverter" types - what about those? Is it at all possible to think we can get something he'll appreciate without him being involved in the selection?

Thanks.

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#2

Don't

markhennebury

Being somewhat fussy about my tool purchases, i usually do quite a bit of comparative research and have something very specific in mind that i want at the end when i am ready to buy.

Based on that i wouldn't want anyone making that purchase for me by trying to guess what i wanted; invariably they would get the wrong item, there are just to many variables to get right by chance.

Also there is the enjoyment of going and picking out your machine and accessories after having put all of the work into finding the right one.

There are many variables in buying a welder and without knowing a lot more of the specifics; type of work, materials, material thickness etc it would be easy to mess up.

Although the sentiment is nice it could easily backfire and end in disappointment.

So in general I would recommend against surprise tool / machine purchases.

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#3

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Wow, this is analogous to having your wife ask a neighbor "my husband wants a woodworking saw", when you don't know if he wants to make furniture, trim trees, or build a barn! I have a 290 amp (AC)/220 input Stick Welder, a 125 amp MIG 120 V input (with inert gas), and an acetylene / Oxygen welder.

There are many variables in welding equipment - cost can run from $100 to $10,000. There is stick welding that will work well for thicker material and is a good general purpose welder - IF you are somewhat experienced. The stick welders can be AC or AC/DC, the AC/DC are more versatile and more expensive - anything under 180 amp output with 240 AC input is IMHO not worth purchasing. These are great for welding heavy material - 1/4 to 3/4 thick - an experienced welder can weld down to a 1/16 material but it is tough.

Then there is the MIG - Metal Inert Gas, these vary in price - a decent one with a output of 140~150 will run $200 ~$400 + tanks (Yes I would add the Argon/Co2 tanks ~ far more versatile). These are very easy to learn and will weld thin stock 1/16" up to about 3/8 inch thick material well.

Third choice is the Acetylene / Oxygen rigs, I have one and use it quite a bit for brazing and some lite welding - I would not recommend it for a beginner.

As has been stated above - real hard to buy something that would make someone happy if you do not know what he is wanting.

If your wife bought you a new CMS when you wanted a table saw you probably would be pretty disapointed.

You might discuss with HIM, what he thinks would be a great welder for you to purchase! May give you some insight as to what he really wants.

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#4

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

basil

Lincoln 225 amp AC cracker box. They used to be cheap, reliable and would burn DC 70-18 LH up to 110-18 LH rods with a little practice.

Makes a good all round general purpose farm stick welder.

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#5

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

If your buddy is wanting a new welder that implies that he has one and wants to upgrade. This would be like someone here with a contractor saw wanting to upgrade. I'm guessing he has a couple of ideas of what he wants so I would suggest feeling him put a bit. Maybe you could come up with something that you need to have him weld for you and while your there you could ask him why he wants a new welder.

Robin

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#6

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

Yonak

Maybe his wife could give him a picture of a welder and a skull cap, the indication being she will buy if for him when he picks out what he wants.

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#7

craigd

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

craigd

I agree with Mark, let him in on the surprise. My farm experience suggests stick or MIG, while my shop has TIG/stick and O/A.

If stick, you want 220V to get the amps needed for bigger pieces of metal (I want to say bigger than sheet metal but don't know that).

Inverters are very cool - instead of a huge iron transformer, they use electronics to do voltage conversion and are hugely more efficient; for example, my 220V/300amp inteverter TIG machine weighs 40# and I run it on a 30amp circuit. The classic Big Blue Miller Syncrowave weighed 600# and needed a 100amp circuit for the same specs. The lunch box inverters that run off of 110/220 are bees knees for most uses. Of course, this tech is pricey.

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#8

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

Larry in NW Ohio

I think Yonok has a good idea, but along with the cap I would put a picture of a welder and clip a check or a couple hundred dollars to the picture. athen in the birthday card I`d put a note that the cap has the present almost bought but didn`t know what to really get. If she is going to buy the whole thing, they could go pick it out together and she would pay the rest. Or something to that effect. Happy Birthday to him, I always wanted a welder. Larry

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

#9

Re: OT Welder Suggestion?

John M in Mid Mich

Thanks everyone. I've relayed the basic response: let him pick.