Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT - Vodka experts out there???

Posts

OT - Vodka experts out there???

#1

OT - Vodka experts out there???

Joe Pack

No, I'm not looking for a drinking buddy, but I am looking advice from any of the experienced vodka drinkers out there!

I am hoping to make some homemade vanilla extract to give as Christmas gifts. The basic recipe is to soak extract grade vanilla beans in alcohol, either bourbon or, most often, vodka...1# vanilla beans to 1 gallon alcohol. All I know about vodka is that the name Smirnoff is advertised, and that the price ranges from high to low at the WalMart liquor section. What I need to know is whether or not there really is a difference in taste between various brands/prices and what that difference is to your taste buds.

Can you help?

p.s. If you need to experiment in order to weigh in on this one, you have my express permission. :D

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#2

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Can't help you with the vodka question but Bourbon vanilla is not made with bourbon liquor. It is a reference to being made with vanilla beans from the bourbon Islands, the former name of Madagascar.

Robin

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#3

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

Joe Pack

Thanks, Robin. I did run into that when I was researching the vanilla bean thing...bourbon being a type/region of the bean.

The reason I mentioned using actual bourbon alcohol is that I came across a couple of vanilla extract recipes that did use bourbon instead of vodka. With what little I know about booze, though, it would seem to me that using true bourbon would make for some REALLY expensive vanilla extract...maybe better to drink than to cook with!

Thanks again.

Joe

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#4

If I remember correctly...

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Alton Brown, of "Good Eats" posits that any old vodka will do for that task. I think it was an episode on spice, and, of course, vanilla is one of those. He, too, created vanilla extract (and in so doing, taught my wife how). He said any old bar vodka was just fine.

Rod

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT - Cheapest kind.......

Jesper, Denmark

You just need the ethanol to extract the flavor from the Vanilla beans, so the cheapest vodka is as good as the most expensive.

An alternative, which might be both better and cheaper is neutral grain alcohol, the raw material for making vodka by diluting with Water - and other flavored spirits.

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#6

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

Lars Parrington

i done the homemade vanilla extract thing a few times now. the alcohol doesn't seem to matter much, though i'd shy away from the cheapest stuff. i used svedka the first time and that was fine. used white rum last time and that worked great too. now i have some brewing in tanqueray gin, since that is what was in the cupboard.

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Vodka is SUPPOSED to be odorless, colorless and tasteless--I believe that may even be law in the U.S.

However, vodka is distilled from distiller's beers, made with a broad range of recipes, and some of the characteristics of the ingredients do make it through to the final product. Also, the skill of the distiller has an impact, depending on how much of the "heads" and "tails" of the distillation runs they allow into the product. The heads (the first amounts of alcohol out of the distillation) contain some undesirable compounds (including some toxins), and too much of these contribute to hangovers and off flavors.

Personally, we've always used Smirnoff brand vodka (both for consumption and for vanilla extract purposes)--it's relatively inexpensive, and I don't find it to have any off flavors that my untrained palette can detect. McCormick's, on the other hand, is rot-gut vodka. Cheap, but it's nasty. It doesn't taste right to me.

Jason

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#8

JL

+1 on the ethanol

JL

If you use "Everclear" or whatever they call it nowadays (95% alcohol) - you can dilute it to the proper strength easily (about 35% alcohol) after you've finished extracting the beans. You can extract the compounds from the bean more efficiently (and probably more quickly). You won't have anything but pure alcohol - so you don't have to worry about anything but the vanilla flavor.

I would advise using distilled water to do the dilutions.

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#9

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

John McGaw

For your intended purpose you would want the most neutral flavor-free vodka. Some online sources rate Findlandia as tops in this category. I'd guess that the best solvent for vanilla extract would probably be a 50:50 mix of reagent-grade ethanol and distilled water. Personally, I drink Absolut on the rare occasion that I drink vodka, but that is probably just from force of habit now and the bottle in the fridge has probably been in there for four years now (but it never goes bad).

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#10

not what I would recommend

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

If the objective is vanilla extract to use in cooking I don't see why it would be desirable for the flavor to be altered by the alcohol source. To that end use drinking grade ethanol which I am told can be bought at a full service booze store.

This is not an inexpensive experiment and there is opportunity to wind up with something a cook won't use. Personally, I would have no interest in vanilla extract flavored by bourbon. Your procedure sounds like it came from someone that liked alcoholic beverages, not a chef.

There are other variables. The concentration of beans to solvent seems too small. Then there is how long to soak; whether to heat/warm.

The extract I use is 37% ethanol and it says that 1 TBS equals 1 bean equivalent which is 4 grams(bean) to 15 grams solvent. Given this information your procedure is too dilute and adds another question. Do you extract with 95% ethanol and then dilute to 37%, or extract with 37%? The result will be quite different.

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#11

2nd on the Cheapest kind.......

Kevin French

Medicinally plants don't know beans about alcohol so go cheap. GO VODKA

Having said that, where you are making an extract for cooking and taste, you may want to improve the extract by running your vodka through a ZERO WATER FILTER first, it will remove the impurities that separates cheap vodka from the good stuff.

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#12

Everclear

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is 190 proof (95% ethanol, 5% water) (available in 150 as well) but is illegal and cannot be sold in something like 15 States because of a) its potency and b) its lack of flavor or sent.

It ain't cheap either.

:D

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#13

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

james runchey

I don't know if I qualify as an expert. but I certainly have experience. I have a vodka on the rocks every night before dinner, as I have had for 30 or 40 years or so. I started out with premium brands, Absolut, Stoli, etc. went down to Smirnoff. and finally down to Skol (a cheapie) when I realized there was no difference in taste, why spend the extra money? Just my 2 cents.

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

#14

Re: OT - Vodka experts out there???

Joe Pack

And I thought WoodCentral folks were only interested in woodworking! Didn't know we had so many booze experts our there! Many thanks for all your suggestions.

Reading through the many brand recommendations makes me think of one of a friend's lines when somebody asked what he wanted to drink...."Whatcha drinkin'? I dunno...whatever you're buyin' I guess."

Thanks again. I'll try to remember to fill you in on my experiment. Results should be in in about 6 months according to the recipe.