Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

Posts

Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#1

JL

Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? - long

JL

My wife and I have a friend.

She is not a "handy person". She is not descended from "handy" people. She is one person who knows who has the best takeout - so I wouldn't describe her as someone who really does much in the kitchen. Years ago, she came over to our townhouse when we painted the dining area because she had never really seen anyone paint a room before.

She is in her "old family home" - that is on the order of 40 years old. Needless to say, it needs work. The home has brick facing on the lower portion and wood siding up above.

She doesn't have a corded drill. She did get a small, inexpensive drill/driver a while back - that she has used (but not often).

Does she need a drill? In my opinion - yes. Every house should have a bare minimum of tools. Among others, a pry bar, a hammer, screwdrivers, pliers, an adjustable wrench, a saw and a drill. But if you aren't "handy", which drill? I believe that she should have a 1/2" or 3/8" hammer drill. This would do the vast majority of household tasks that she might need.

The big question is - would it be a waste? Would she ever use the drill after she got it? We're talking 40+ years of not using many tools. A good hammer drill runs $60-$100 for a 1/2" or so if it is corded. Not too much - but would it be a good fit?

How do you help someone into being a "tool user"?

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#2

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Ryan

I also have a 40 year old house and do a lot of my own work around it so I am certainly what you would call "handy" . I own a cheap corded drill and it has done anything I need. I've never felt the need for a hammer drill. I'd make sure she has the hammer, screwdriver, adjustable wrench and the like. If you feel she needs a drill, then buy a simple corded one. The hammer drill would never get used.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#3

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Jesse Cloud

I'm curious. What is the application that needs a hammer drill? I've never had one either and be up to my ears in honey-do work most of my life.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#4

Hammer drill, no need...

John in NM

I've had various hammer drills for years, and lived in a similar house to what you describe. Only time I needed to drill into the brick was when I was putting in an additional hose bib - hardly the type of thing your friend would do herself. So I would say she wouldn't need one.

Regular corded drill perhaps, but I even tend to doubt that. I've found that people who are "handy" are so due to inclination more so than experience or habit. You don't see the inclination in your friend, I would question whether that inclination can be developed where it does not already exist - but there I go getting philosophical.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#5

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Larry in NW Ohio

Wow JL If this isn`t a loaded question, I don`t know what would be. If someone would tell you what drill to buy her, and what else she should have like a hammer, screwdriver, prybar, then a TS, and planner and so on. then she`ll be coming over and asking you to came and look at something in the house that she is working on. You follow her over and get in the house and she has the kitchen tore apart, she wanted to paint the cabinets and thought she had to take them down to do it. Well one thing lead to another. I don`t know JL what to give her first, a drill, I`d be afraid to let her have a drill, that she might come over with a drill bit drilled in her hand and a lawyer in her other hand. Aren`t you kind of afraid that if she would have some tools, that she might work on something and have it taken apart, after all it`s easy to take something apart, than to put it back together, than to fix it and put it back together and when she can`t she`ll be at you`re back door. That could become a habit. Does`t she have family, brothers or maybe sons. Larry

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#6

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Nat Robison

In my opinion, anything more than an average 12V cordless drill is a waste. Only have her buy something that you want to use when she calls you and you don't want to haul yours over there. She probably wouldn't ever take on a task requiring a hammer drill.

Most 40-year old houses hit a maintenance cycle where lots of things need to be updated. Hope she doesn't get in over her head.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#7

JL

Concrete, masonry, etc.

JL

Old concrete gets REALLY hard. Brick and cinder block can be handled by most drills.

I have a 1/2" hammer drill that gets used for all my masonry/concrete projects. Could I do it with a 1/2" drill - possibly - possibly not.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#8

JL

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

JL

IMO, she is already over her head.

This is her family home. The only home she remembers from her childhood on up.

There is a lot of deferred maintenance and a lot of fix-it work. Fortunately she sold her condo - so now she has the $ to fix some things.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#9

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Nat Robison

Hopefully, the money she has to fix things will include the right contractors. I can understand the attachment to a home. I only ever lived in one house growing up and my parents still live there. It's a 1847 farm house in Michigan. The older I get, the more I realize that not just anyone can work on these houses. As my parents approach their 80's, I hope they start to realize they can't keep it going forever, financially or physically. Truth is, if and when they sell, I wouldn't be shocked if the house and barn were knocked down and the lots split up. My hope is that someone with lots of time and money would buy it and restore it properly.

Sounds like you might be "on call" for the next few months. Good luck in whatever your role is.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#10

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Jerry Nicholson

I got along without a hammer drill for many years - even drilled holes in brick. Now that I have one, I have learned it is the ONLY way to go for drilling brick and hard concrete. That said, I doubt that a non-tool person would have a need for one. The non-tool person would probably also not bother to keep the battery on a cordless drill charged, making the cordless drill useless. Now a tool nut might own a couple of 1/2 inch drills, a couple of 1/4 inch drills (one of those is nearly 65 years old, the new one is only about 50), a couple of cordless drills, a hammer drill, a 3/8 drill, and a 3/8 right angle drill (from Harbor Freight, used for a single task).

BTW I bought the hammer drill after bending the shaft of a regular (corded) 3/8 drill. That hammer drill really makes short work of drilling a 1/4 hole in a 45 year old brick.

Jerry

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#11

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Kevin French

Once you figure out if & what she needs in a cordless give her a bar of wax to make the screws drive easier and drop the hammer feature.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#12

Re: Concrete, masonry, etc.

Kevin French

YES, but do you think SHE is going to drill those?

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#13

Re: Should she have a drill?  If so, which one? -

Kevin French

Do you want her to get a Hammer Drill so you can borrow it?

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#14

Sounds like what she needs....

John in NM

Is a good handyman....

Edit - or a good handywoman - I often come home from a week at work and find my wife has finished a number of projects we had going.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Sounds like what she needs....

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I agree.

There are certainly many benefits to being a DIYer, but it's not for everyone. You might have some conversations with her about what her long-term goals for the house are. If she's looking to have it maintain or gain value, then she should seriously consider professional services for repairs/maintenance/upgrades. If she's looking for the catharsis of doing the projects herself, then she may need a mentor as much or more than tools. And, there's always YouTube--which, of course, comes with a caveat emptor clause.

However, if she's never done any of this stuff and no one in her family did either, I would suspect that her interests and hobbies naturally lie elsewhere, and working on one's own home can seriously cut into those, perhaps at the expense of one's balance of life.

Jason

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#16

Jerry Nicholson said it all.... but

Howard in Toronto

seems like there's only one practical reason to suggest this person buy a hammer drill....

so you can borrow it!

just kidding

but a good plan, noentheless

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#17

What I Did

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I got my kids each a cordless combo comprised of a drill and an impact driver. That way they have something to drill holes and such plus a driver that also doubles, quite nicely, as a hammer drill for masonry etc.

I prefer the Rigid brand because they run promotions with free lifetime battery replacement. My kids, therefore, each have an 18v set of compact tools and can buy bits etc. as they need them.

The extra bonus is that it leaves more room in the trunk since I don't have to schlep my own tools along when I'm asked to go help with something.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#18

I'd say Corded

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Ok...so corded are not as "handy"....but they always work. Those who use drills very infrequently will not be good at charging the batteries. Some eith leave the battery on the charger for months or not at all and the battery is dead right when they need it.

A decent "residential" corded will probably cost less too.

My 2 cents.

T.

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#19

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The one downside...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...to corded drills that I've found where they don't substitute well for cordless drills is that their AC motors are lousy at low-speed, high-torque screw driving, unlike a DC-motored cordless.

Jason

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#20

JL

Point taken


Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#21

Yabut......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

....does the person need a drill or a driver? Corded is fine for drilling but not great for screwing. Now don't get all Freudian about that last sentence! ;-)

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

LOL!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I would actually LIKE a good, corded drill/driver that functions as a modern cordless does (I like the look/feel/operation of the Bosch--a corded AC-to-DC converter pack that takes the place of the battery would mean an instant sale to me). I have cordless drills and batteries coming out the wazoo, and every once in a while when I haven't used them for a few weeks, I can't find a charged battery.

Jason

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#23

Wazoo?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jason, yer sa-posed to store'em in a toolbox or on the peg board. You got'em out the wazoo [old or otherwise], a medical visit is seriously in order not to mention more fiber!

:D

Re: Should she have a drill? If so, which one? - long

#24

Long Cord Screw Driving

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Not that there's anything wrong with that. After all, the size of the cord ain't the determining factor.

Of course, it's the conductor, not the baton, that makes the orchastra play. ;)